• Home
  • Systematic Review
    • List of Articles Systematic Review

      • Open Access Article

        1 - Review on the Entrepreneurship in the Internet of Things (IoT) Ecosystem
        Roya Shahabi Ehsaneh Nejad Mohammad Nameghi
        The new developments of the digital age have brought smart devices and equipment around us and a smart lifestyle in general, and the amount of this intelligence has been added to the level of intelligence with time. The intelligent growth of the devices and equipment ar More
        The new developments of the digital age have brought smart devices and equipment around us and a smart lifestyle in general, and the amount of this intelligence has been added to the level of intelligence with time. The intelligent growth of the devices and equipment around us in the Internet of Things and the increase in the communication and processing capabilities of its network infrastructures make there is an intelligent ecosystem of the Internet of Things in human life with two-way and mutual communication. In this sense, entrepreneurship and value creation and preservation are important in the fields related to the new Internet of Things technology and play an important role in its progress and development. This article systematically review entrepreneurship in the Internet of Things, using reliable website of the Internet of Things, in all years and the important issues related to entrepreneurship in the Internet, such as the applications and entrepreneurial opportunities in the Internet of Things. Technological business models in this field, new values and their preservation, Internet of Things challenges, legal and legal issues of entrepreneurship in the Internet of Things, are discussed and analyzed. Also, practical and successful examples of entrepreneurship in the Internet of Things and its ecosystems, along with the use of academic capacities for the further development of the Internet of Things, the role of the Internet of Things in organizational transformation and the strategic orientation required for entrepreneurship in the field. The Internet of Things is reviewed in this review article. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        2 - Critical Evaluation of the Media Effect Studies: A Systematic Review
        Majid Mohammad zamani Seyyed Mojtaba Emami
        The effect of media content on individuals, institutions and the general public can be measured and identified. Media effect studies have been the focus of communication and media scholars around the world since the beginning of the twentieth century; And The number of More
        The effect of media content on individuals, institutions and the general public can be measured and identified. Media effect studies have been the focus of communication and media scholars around the world since the beginning of the twentieth century; And The number of domestic studies has also been growing in recent years, but the qualitative evaluation of this trend can make researchers aware of the criticisms and gaps in existing research to pave the way to improve the quality and improve the research process in this area. Therefore, after presenting the model of media content effects, this study examines 39 selected articles using a systematic review method. The findings of this study show; Despite the quantitative growth of media effect studies in recent years, these studies have often focused on the tangible cognitive and behavioral effects of the individual and have ignored the intangible effects of emotion, attitude, belief on institutions and the public. Ignoring the active role of the audience in the effects of the media, the dominance of quantitative methodology, ignoring the macro public and institutional effects, short-term studies of media effect studies and inaccuracy of metrics are among the criticisms of most of these studies. In the continuation of this article, while presenting a proposal to address these criticisms the existing gaps of each field of cognitive, belief, attitude, emotional and behavioral effects are presented as a guide for the qualitative development of this field of study. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        3 - A Systematic Review of Treatment and Quality of Diagnostic Coding and its Influencing Factors in Iran
        طلعت مدنی مریم احمدی
        Introduction: One of the perennial challenges associated with coding diagnoses and treatment, quality data encryption is. Accuracy, reliability, completeness timed and all the components are coding quality. The aim of this study was to evaluate studies on the quality of More
        Introduction: One of the perennial challenges associated with coding diagnoses and treatment, quality data encryption is. Accuracy, reliability, completeness timed and all the components are coding quality. The aim of this study was to evaluate studies on the quality of diagnostic coding and medical care and its determinants in Iran, respectively. Methods: This study is a systematic review, in which all articles published on the topic in the lower period 1380 to the end of March 1394 (March 2001 to March 2015) were studied. Internet search to find articles in the internal data base Magiran, BarakatKnowladege Network System, Irandoc, SID and external databases, Google scholar, Science Direct and PubMed and was Persian and English keywords. 200 articles published in Farsi and English were retrieved and finally 14 articles were identified and evaluated. Results: Four paper specifically examines the components of quality of coding, six paper examines the factors affecting coding quality, and the four paper also common for both components and factorsaffecting coding quality were examined. Component coding quality, most studies (seven cases) were examined coding accuracy. The factors affecting coding quality, most studies (five cases) to investigate the role of documentation and diagnosis recording among, respectively. Conclusion: The results of the study showed that among the components of quality timeliness of coding properties is not desirable. Findings of the study on factors affecting coding quality is the importance of observing principles of documentation on coding quality. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        4 - A Systematic Reviews of Healthcare Complaints in the Hospital of Iran Since 2006 to 2016
        damon Gorji Ali Vafaee Najjar Roghya Staji ٍElahe Hooshmande
        Introduction: The health complaint is an expression of dissatisfaction by patient or its family that is required to responding. This research is done to achieve the Portrait of country medical complaints in the last decade. Methods: In this systematic review by searchin More
        Introduction: The health complaint is an expression of dissatisfaction by patient or its family that is required to responding. This research is done to achieve the Portrait of country medical complaints in the last decade. Methods: In this systematic review by searching keywords in 6 knowledge base and to get help from Google search engine, articles in the field of health complaints in the period 1385 to 1395, were searched. The outcome of this search was 1270 Persian and English articles. Then the research team studied the title and abstracts and they removed 1120 irrelevant articles or without full text. In the next step, after the study of full texts, removed 131 duplicates or irrelevant with the issue. Eventually, research team achieved to the 19 articles that were completely relevant with the issue. Results: Generally, according to a specified pattern, highest percentage of the complaints were related to inappropriate behavior of medical staff and the lowest was related to costs. More than 60 percent of complaints were related to period 1390 to 1392. All complaints and registered articles were related to medical centers and hospitals affiliated to the Ministry of Health and medical education. Conclusions: Serious determination of health authorities about application of complaints as a tool to quality improve, can play a role in taking advantage of this great and valuable source of information to promotion health society. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        5 - Development a model of Human Resource Risks in The Field of Health and Treatment Using Systematic Review and Delphi Method
        Sareh Noorian Zavare zahra sadeqi-arani
        Introduction: Today, the important asset of organizations and their competitive advantage is capable and quality human resources. Despite, the risks of human resources have not been addressed especially in the health sector, and there is a significant research and pract More
        Introduction: Today, the important asset of organizations and their competitive advantage is capable and quality human resources. Despite, the risks of human resources have not been addressed especially in the health sector, and there is a significant research and practical gap in this area. Therefore, the present study aims to identify the risks of human capital in the health sector and provide a comprehensive model of this Risks. Methods: For this purpose, in the first step, the dimensions and indicators of the human resources risk model were extracted from the theoretical literature using the systematic review method. The Delphi technique is then used to validate the final model of human resource risks in the healthcare sector. Results: In the first phase and systematic review of scientific documents, 1050 documents were obtained in the initial search, which were found after refining 67 related documents. Which by examining these documents, 271 risks of human resources were identified. After eliminating duplicates and merging similar these, the number of human resources risks was reduced to 139 risks, which was validated in the second phase by Delphi method. After 2 rounds of Delphi, 4 main themes, 14 sub-themes 1, 4 sub-themes 2 and 134 concepts (risks) related to human resource risks in the field of health were identified and validated. Conclusion: According to the identification and validation of human resources risks in the healthcare, the critical risks include human capital risks, operational risk of human resources, risk of attitude on the human resources unit and individual risks of employees of the human resources unit. The comprehensive model of human resource risks in the field of health that is presented in this study can be a tool for assessing and prioritizing of human resource risks in the organizations under this section and its results can be the basis for human resource risk management action in these organizations. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        6 - Conceptualizing Social Health through Viral Advertising
        shima shahhosseini bideh sayyed hasan hataminasab shahnaz nayebzadeh Mohammadreza dehghani ashkezari sayyed majid mirhosseini
        Introduction: Advertisements play an important role as an efficient strategy in improving the level of social health of the society. The aim of the current research is to qualitatively analyze articles in the field of viral advertising and to identify and determine the More
        Introduction: Advertisements play an important role as an efficient strategy in improving the level of social health of the society. The aim of the current research is to qualitatively analyze articles in the field of viral advertising and to identify and determine the ranking of indicators in the field of social health. Methods: In this study, with a systematic review and according to the PRISMA guidelines, the articles published in the field of viral marketing during the period from 2001 to 2022 were investigated in the Wos database, and the data were guided by using qualitative content analysis. Then, using fuzzy screening, the effective indicators were identified and prioritized using the fuzzy method. Results: By analyzing the qualitative content of the selected articles, 26 indicators were extracted and using the fuzzy screening method, 17 indicators were identified as effective indicators and prioritized by the fuzzy method. Conclusion: The social health field is constantly looking for ways to adapt to new technologies. Therefore, the principled and correct use of viral advertisements can be considered as a new perspective in the field of social health. The results of the research showed that among the 17 confirmed indicators, information, creativity, source reliability, innovation in the message, and accessibility are more in order than capacity and indicators of message specialization, fantasy, social stimulus, interactivity, and perceived intention. The source of the least capacity can have significant improvement and growth of social health. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        7 - Meta-analysis of the relationship between cultural intelligence and cultural competence
        Ali oliaee Alireza Ebrahimpour Seyed Morteza Mousavian
        Purpose: the purpose of this study is to conduct a systematic and meta - analysis of the literature on cultural competence and cultural intelligence to gather and evaluate the quantitative findings of cultural intelligence and its relation on cultural competence.researc More
        Purpose: the purpose of this study is to conduct a systematic and meta - analysis of the literature on cultural competence and cultural intelligence to gather and evaluate the quantitative findings of cultural intelligence and its relation on cultural competence.research method: the research method in this paper is applied in terms of objective, in terms of quantitative performance, in terms of nature and method of descriptive and statistical society of all articles of the world. in order to identify studies related to cultural intelligence and cultural competence, the review of university information technologies in online magazines Wiley, springer, Elsevier, science direct, web of science, sage, ProQuest, google scholar were systematically investigated. Studies written in Persian were searched in Iran Dock and Elm net databases. Out of 143 selected articles, finally 8 articles have all the necessary conditions according to the prism selection protocol. then, using a random effect model of quality of each study, heterogeneity between studies and bias with CMA2 software was analyzed and evaluated.results: the effect size (Pearson correlation coefficient) is significant in the case of random effects model (r = 0.480) and z - value is statistically significant at the probability level of 99 %.conclusion: aggregation of research results of the world showed that cultural competence has a positive relationship with cultural intelligence, but the intensity of this relationship varies in different societies. furthermore, cultural competence is related to motivational and metacognitive aspects of cultural intelligence. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        8 - Systematic Review of Higher Education Institutions Cultural Policy Making Evaluation Indicators
        Ali Reza Nasiri Firuz REZA عقیلی
        Introduction and purpose: In the last two decades, despite the emphasis on the importance of higher education institutions cultural policy making, less attention has been paid to appropriateness of policy formulation, efficiency of programs implementation, and effective More
        Introduction and purpose: In the last two decades, despite the emphasis on the importance of higher education institutions cultural policy making, less attention has been paid to appropriateness of policy formulation, efficiency of programs implementation, and effectiveness of cultural activities. This study was done with the purpose of identifying cultural policy making evaluation indicators of higher education institutions. Designing cultural policy making evaluation conceptual model was another purpose of the study. Method: This research was done with qualitative method and reviewing previous researches. Articles were selected through studies related to cultural policy making evaluation between 1997 and 2020. Through 191 searched articles, finally 50 articles were chosen and investigated systematically. Findings: Based on reviewing researches and related articles, cultural policy making evaluation indicators in higher education system were classified in three main categories: evaluation of policy formulation, evaluation of program implementation, evaluation of activities and outcomes. Sub-categories were classified as: problem finding, formulating solutions and legitimization. Conclusion: Identifying evaluation indicators of cultural policy making in higher education system, weak and strength points in formulation, implementation and evaluation stages were realized. In addition to being a guideline for policy makers, the necessary context for reformatory actions, amendation and promotion of quality in higher education cultural policy making were brought together. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        9 - The role of librarians and Librarianship in the meta-analysis and meta-analysis studies
        Maliheh Dalili Saleh Soraya Ziaee
        Purpose: Systematic review is detailed and gives a comprehensive overview of studies in a specific area to researchers. Meta-analysis is a statistical procedure to combine information obtained from a systematic review investigated. Because of librarians expertise and sk More
        Purpose: Systematic review is detailed and gives a comprehensive overview of studies in a specific area to researchers. Meta-analysis is a statistical procedure to combine information obtained from a systematic review investigated. Because of librarians expertise and skills for working and participating in these studies their association seem to be necessary. On the one hand we decided to deal with the role of librarians in the research team of meta-analysis on the other hand to the meta-analysis studies in the field of information by them. Methodology: This study is a librarian research with available study in these area. Findings: In this study we deal with the expressed process of systematic review and meta-analysis research as well as meta-analysis research by the librarians. Conclusion: These studies began in 1966 and since 1999 librarians joined the research team of meta-analysis, as researcher. Librarians with knowledge of the techniques of meta-analysis and ability to use of it and as a objective observer can actively participate in a meta-analysis project. Also in the field of information began in 1992, which were more focused on "information system". Conclusion: Understanding of the role of meta-analysis approach will be useful for future researches in the field of information. The meta-analysis studies on other topics, demonstrating the benefits of this approach in the investigation, so use of loads to improvement of the position of information and knowledge. Researchers in iran have done less to meta-analysis approach in the field of information, the reason for this lack of orientation can be no full and free access to full-text sources. Advances in knowledge analysis and reporting guidelines to improve the quality, scope and application of the results are the meta-analysis benefits and using this approach can be taken for the promotion of information science and knowledge. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        10 - Systematic research review of bank mergers in Iran and the world
        amir ehsani mehrzad minooei zadalah fathi
        Merger in banks or in other words, merger policy is one of the major issues in the banking sector that has been undertaken successfully worldwide with the aim of preventing bankruptcy, improving profitability and so on. A merger is a combination of two or more firms and More
        Merger in banks or in other words, merger policy is one of the major issues in the banking sector that has been undertaken successfully worldwide with the aim of preventing bankruptcy, improving profitability and so on. A merger is a combination of two or more firms and, like an acquisition, is such that the acquiring firm assumes responsibility for the assets and liabilities of the acquired firm or firms, furthermore, a departmental overlap may arise with the acquisition of a firm or bank. Since this issue is of great importance and sensitivity, it is very important to understand this process, its dimensions and types, and to use a new and efficient approach to implement this policy in the best way possible. Therefore, an attempt has been made in this study to provide suitable suggestions and solutions for banking mergers and then present a new and innovative method in this field, which is accompanied by a review of all relevant aspects, using the systematic review method to address this issue. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        11 - مروری نظام مند بر روش های مکاشفه ای ترکیب سرویس در محیط محاسبات ابری
        محمدباقر کریمی
        در دهه حاضر، مفهوم سرویس و ارائه نرم افزار به صورت سرویس بر روی معماری سیستم های ابری به عنوان دو تحول مهم، دنیای سیستم های اطلاعاتی را متحول کرده است. این تغییر، چرخه حیات تولید نرم افزار را با یک دگرگونی پارادیمی مواجه کرده است که در آن تولید نرم افزار از طریق ترکیب س More
        در دهه حاضر، مفهوم سرویس و ارائه نرم افزار به صورت سرویس بر روی معماری سیستم های ابری به عنوان دو تحول مهم، دنیای سیستم های اطلاعاتی را متحول کرده است. این تغییر، چرخه حیات تولید نرم افزار را با یک دگرگونی پارادیمی مواجه کرده است که در آن تولید نرم افزار از طریق ترکیب سرویس های آماده در بستر ابر انجام میگیرد. یکی از الزامات ترکیب سرویس در محیط ابر این است که باید به صورت on-the-fly انجام گیرد که تحقق آن نیاز به یک مصالحه بین بهینه بودن سرویس مرکب و زمان ترکیب سرویس دارد. مسئله ترکیب سرویس با اطلاع از QoS، مسئله‌ای است که برای آن چندین راه حل بالقوه وجود دارد که معمولاً چند تا از آنها بهینه محسوب می‌شوند، بر این اساس این مسئله، یک مسئله بهینه سازی و در زمره مسائل NP-Hard به شمار می‌آید. با توجه به این واقعیت که به دلیل افزایش روزافزون تعداد سرویس‌ها که منجر به بزرگ‌تر شدن فضای جستجوی مسئله می‌شوند، در سال های گذشته محققان زیادی به تحقیق بر روی ارائه روش های مبتنی بر الگوریتم های ترکیباتی و مکاشفه ای برای حل مسئله ترکیب سرویس در محیط ابر، علاقه نشان داده اند و این اقبال ادامه دارد. در این مقاله، بر اساس مروری نظام مند بر ادبیات تحقیق، پرسش های مهمی که می توان در حوزه تحقیقاتی ترکیب سرویس به روش مکاشفه ای می توان مطرح کرد، استخراج شده اند. سپس با طبقه بندی پژوهش ها بر اساس رویکردهای حل مسئله، اهداف و اولویت های مورد نظر محققین، نتایج و آمارهای مفیدی ارائه شده که می تواند به تحقیقات آینده کمک کند. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        12 - Interactions between Soil Organisms and Global Climate Change and Application of Meta-Analysis in its Interpretation: A Systematic Review
        Zahed Sharifi Ali Akbar Safari Sinegani
        Soil microorganisms have important role at production and consumption of greenhouse gases,such as carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), nitrous oxide (N2O), and nitric oxide (NO). On theother hand, there are valid reasons that climate changes can directly or indirectly a More
        Soil microorganisms have important role at production and consumption of greenhouse gases,such as carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), nitrous oxide (N2O), and nitric oxide (NO). On theother hand, there are valid reasons that climate changes can directly or indirectly alter the compositionand abundance of soil microbial communities. So that, the results of the systematic review showed thatthe main direct effects of climate changes on soil microbial communities are likely to be caused bychanges in temperature and moisture content. Howevr, the effects of increased CO2 levels onmicrobial communities are often indirect, as they are mediated by positive effects of the gas on plantphotosynthesis, which in turn changes in quantity and quality of soil C inputs. Any way, depending onthe taxonomy, body size, feeding habits, ecosystem type, local climate, treatment magnitude andduration, the patterns respons of the soil organisms in against of climate change parameters are differ.So that, the results of meta-analysis has show that the response of soil biota to elevated CO2, is dependon the trophic group, body size, and experimental approaches (field or greenhouse). Whereas, theresponse of soil biota to warming and altered precipitation are depend on local climate and ecosystemtype. Furthermore, the effects of increase CO2 on soil organism abundance diminished with time,however the effects of warming and altered precipitation intensified with time Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        13 - Meta-Synthesis of Factors and Barriers Influencing the Participation of Iranian Students in Sports Activities
        fahimeh rivandi مهوش نوربخش مهدی کهندل پریوش نوربخش
        The existence of a large volume of studies on the participation of students in sports activities, with somewhat ambiguous and contradictory results, has posed challenges in planning and policymaking in this field. Therefore, it is necessary to integrate and consolidate More
        The existence of a large volume of studies on the participation of students in sports activities, with somewhat ambiguous and contradictory results, has posed challenges in planning and policymaking in this field. Therefore, it is necessary to integrate and consolidate the findings of previous research. This present study aims to go meta-synthesis of factors and barriers influencing the participation of students in sports activities. The research methodology employed is a systematic review that aims to synthesize qualitative studies. The statistical population of this study consists of qualitative studies (articles and theses) published between the years 2006 and 2021, which were accessible as full-text in the databases and university libraries. Based on inclusion and exclusion criteria, 12 studies were reviewed. In this study, a designed checklist was used for data collection. To ensure quality control, the validity and reliability of the extraction codes were assessed, and the validity of the codes was evaluated using the Glynn’s agreement coefficient. The findings indicate that in explaining the factors and barriers influencing student participation in sports, three general environmental factors and barriers can be identified: general environmental factors and barriers, operational environmental factors and barriers, and internal environmental factors and barriers. Among these, the environmental factors and barriers are considered the most significant variables in predicting student participation in sports activities. Based on these results, it is necessary to focus on environmental factors and barriers when explaining student sports participation. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        14 - Systematic review of multigrade classrooms studies
        sara ebrahimi
        The purpose of this study was to systematic review the studies of multigrade classrooms in Iran in order to classify and provide an overview of the challenges and the solutions identified and to analyze them. The present study was conducted by a qualitative method of sy More
        The purpose of this study was to systematic review the studies of multigrade classrooms in Iran in order to classify and provide an overview of the challenges and the solutions identified and to analyze them. The present study was conducted by a qualitative method of systematic review. Reliable research were conducted by electronic search keywords of multigrade classroom, multigrade education and multigrade teaching in the databases of SID, Noormags, Google Scholar, Irandoc, Magiran, Comprehensive Portal of Humanities and The University of Tehran’s Scientific Journals Database the period of 1396-1386. The process of identification, screening, qualification, and inclusion in the sample study was performed based on the PRISMA statement. In the searches, 204 studies were identified for systematic review. After eliminating duplicates and screening, finally, 35 studies that met the inclusion criteria were selected & analyzed. The selected documents were reviewed based on qualitative meta-analysis. In the analysis of  multigrade classrooms challenges, findings indicated 5 main categories of challenges including challenges related to teachers, students, society and environment, curriculum elements and multigrade system which were examined separately or in combination. Also, in reviewing the research, the main solution to address each of these challenges was to design and develop a curriculum consistent with the characteristics of the local community. A program that is faithful to the national curriculum on the one hand and to the realities of the multigrade classrooms and the local community on the other. Accordingly, it is suggested that the national curriculum be modified in collaboration with teachers and multigrade experts, so that the curriculum of single-grade classrooms can be adapted and integrated based on the multigrade curriculum. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        15 - A systematic review of the mobile learning components in Iranian higher education
        Mohammad Reza Keramati Fatemeh Narenji Thani Yasaman Mobin Rahni
        The purpose of this study is to identify and determine the related components to mobile learning within the Iranian higher education system. The research method was applied in terms of objective and by using a qualitative approach, has been used systematic review method More
        The purpose of this study is to identify and determine the related components to mobile learning within the Iranian higher education system. The research method was applied in terms of objective and by using a qualitative approach, has been used systematic review method for data collection. To achieve the purpose of the research, a regular and extensive review of the research background (between 2010-2021) was searched in internal scientific databases. After reviewing based on criteria such as; research topic, abstract, and content of documents, among 543 research, 32 items were selected and analyzed. In addition, the Critical Appraisal Skills Program (Glynn,2006) has been used to determine the validity, and the reliability was assessed by agreement between two raters (Researcher and specialist in the field of e-learning and mobile learning in higher education system) with a Cohen's kappa coefficient of (73%). Results from the systematic review extracted 17 concepts and 5 components. Findings showed which related components to the teacher (knowledge, attitude, and required skills), learner (knowledge, attitude, and required skills), classroom leadership (interaction, learning methods, teaching methods, evaluation, content), organization and management (resources Finance, information resources, organizational culture) and technology (software, hardware, and infrastructure) have been received more attention in these studies. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        16 - Systematic review of components supporting formation PCK among novice teachers
        maryam khodarahmi mostfa ghaderi mahboobeh khosravi mahmoud mehrmohammadi
        Because PCK is considered as one of the dimensions of teacher knowledge, understanding how to support it has been considered. This study is a systematic review of 11 years of research (2021-2010) on the components supporting PCK formation. The aim of this study is to cl More
        Because PCK is considered as one of the dimensions of teacher knowledge, understanding how to support it has been considered. This study is a systematic review of 11 years of research (2021-2010) on the components supporting PCK formation. The aim of this study is to classify the components and factors supporting PCK formation. 39 articles were selected from 6 major academic databases using search disciplines and manual screening protocols. Literature analysis focused on twelve components and 9 groups of actors. "The role of teacher training programs in PCK development", "PCK based on personal experience" and "Growth of teachers' reflection in line with PCK development" are recognized as the main components of supporting PCK formation. In this study, several actors from the relevant literature were identified, and categorized into nine categories based on percentage, including: mentors, new teachers, school principals, university administrators, students, colleagues, Supervisor, researchers, and parents; And among them "mentors", "new teachers", "school principals" and "university course organizers" are known as the top actors in the formation of PCK. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        17 - A Systematic Review of E-Learning in the Context of Iran: Where Does English Language Teaching Stand?
        Peyman Nouraey Mohammad Bavali Fatemeh Behjat
      • Open Access Article

        18 - Central Bank Transparency and Capital Market Reaction: A Systematic Review
        Mehdi Moazzami Mohsen Rasoulian Mohammad Hossein Vadiei Nowghabi Meysam Arabzadeh Esmail Mazroui Nasrabadi
        In an expansive test of nations over distinctive geographic districts and over a long period of time, we discover restricted nation and variable-specific impacts of central bank straightforwardness on figure exactness and their scattering among an expansive set of profi More
        In an expansive test of nations over distinctive geographic districts and over a long period of time, we discover restricted nation and variable-specific impacts of central bank straightforwardness on figure exactness and their scattering among an expansive set of proficient figures of monetary and macroeconomic factors. More communication indeed increments estimate mistakes and scattering. So the aim at this study is a systematic review of central bank transparency and capital market reaction. This study was conducted using a systematic review. At first all papers (n=165) related to keywords (capital market reaction and central bank transparency) searched for Persian and English databases; Google, Google scholar, PubMed covering the period from 2012 through 2022 was performed. Then all qualitative and quantitative papers related to central bank transparency selected and analyzed (n=28). As a result to inclusion and exclusion criteria, papers related to central bank transparency were found and analyzed (n=28). Predefined inclusion and exclusion criteria were: papers related to central bank transparency, papers were Persian and English, types of papers were original and all the papers were free full text. In the initial search, 165 papers were found that after reviewing the titles and abstract articles and removing repetitive and non-related, 54 possible related articles were investigated. Of these, 31 papers were omitted from the abstract because of lack of access to the original article and lack of sufficient information. Finally, 28 papers were included in the study. There are very few studies that have examined the effect of central bank transparency on capital market turmoil. The effect of central bank transpar-ency on the domestic capital market has not been studied. There is no agreement in the literature on theoretical discussions on whether increasing central bank transparency affects capital market turmoil. In foreign research, we can also refer to the study of Dinser and Eichngreen (2007) who have studied this effect empirically using the main transparency index. The pre-sent systematic review shows that almost whole of papers on central bank transparency and capital market reaction highlighted similar findings con-cerning monetary policy decisions. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        19 - Designing the Model of International Networking Capability
        Mohamadreza Hallajyosefi Samad Aali Naser Sanoubar Hakame Niki Esfahlan
      • Open Access Article

        20 - Identifying the Dimensions and Components of the Health-oriented Urban Form with An Emphasis on the Epidemic Disease: A systematic scoping review
        Helia Sareminia Fatemeh Mohammadniay Gharaei sanaz saeidi mofrad Sulmaz Ghahramani
      • Open Access Article

        21 - Analyzing the components of brand positioning in the minds of Muslim consumers
        moslem rezaie Seyyed Hassan Hataminasab shahnaz nayebzadeh
        Purpose: The increasing number of Muslims and the need to adapt and match the products with the preferences of Muslim consumers, requires the identification of brand positioning components for this type of consumers, which has not been studied in this important issue by More
        Purpose: The increasing number of Muslims and the need to adapt and match the products with the preferences of Muslim consumers, requires the identification of brand positioning components for this type of consumers, which has not been studied in this important issue by reviewing the literature. Therefore, the purpose of this research is to identify the components of brand positioning in the minds of Muslim consumers. Methodology: This research is based on the purpose of applied and descriptive research, and according to the implementation method for searching and selecting scientific articles, a systematic review of the research literature was considered and the components were extracted with the technique of qualitative content analysis. All articles related to brand positioning and branding for Muslim consumers were searched, collected and qualitatively evaluated from the Scopus citation database and Google Scholar. Finally, 17 articles were qualitatively analyzed using Max Qda software. Findings: The findings of this research show that the components of price, quality, service, consumer preferences, distribution channel and sources of competitive advantage of the company have been studied as components of brand positioning in the minds of Muslim consumers in the research literature. Conclusion: The components of brand positioning should be adapted and appropriate according to the level of commitment and dependence of Muslim consumers of each country and region to Islam. be more focused. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        22 - Systematic Review of Effectiveness Studies Conducted Regarding Women Cosmetic Surgery in Iran
        Ahmad Parsaei Elham khajavi
        Purpose: The aim of the current study was to systematically review the effectiveness studies conducted on women's cosmetic surgery in the last 5 years (2018-2023). Methodology: This study is a type of secondary research and is considered a systematic review according t More
        Purpose: The aim of the current study was to systematically review the effectiveness studies conducted on women's cosmetic surgery in the last 5 years (2018-2023). Methodology: This study is a type of secondary research and is considered a systematic review according to the implementation method. Document analysis method was used to collect data, which included all published effectiveness studies (2018-2023) and a total of 16 studies were examined. The information obtained was made by the researcher's checklist tool and the summary of the contents was presented in the form of a table. Findings: What emerged from the review of articles published in the last 5 years was that the treatments that were targeted include positive psychotherapy; schema therapy; cognitive-behavioral therapeutic approach; interpersonal psychotherapy; self-belief based on choice theory; metacognitive therapy; emotion regulation skills; Acceptance and Commitment Therapy; body appreciation training; Self-healing training and cognitive therapy are based on mindfulness, and among them, therapy based on acceptance and commitment has received more attention. Conclusion: Despite the steep trend toward cosmetic surgery and the proof of the existence of psychological disorders and problems in people applying for cosmetic surgery, few researches have been recorded in the field of applying effective psychological treatments; Therefore, it is necessary for future researchers to pay special attention to this category. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        23 - Systematic Review of Iranian Researches with a Focus on the Effectiveness of Researches Conducted Regarding Working Women
        Mehrnaz Azadyekta
        The aim of the present study was to systematically review Iranian researches with a focus on effectiveness researches conducted on working women in the period of 2018-2023. This study is a type of secondary research and is considered a systematic review according to the More
        The aim of the present study was to systematically review Iranian researches with a focus on effectiveness researches conducted on working women in the period of 2018-2023. This study is a type of secondary research and is considered a systematic review according to the implementation method. Document analysis method was used to collect data, which included all published effectiveness studies (2018-2023) and a total of 45 studies were examined. The information obtained was made by the researcher's checklist tool and the summary of the contents was presented in the form of tables. What emerged from the review of the articles published in the last 5 years was that researchers are looking for positive organizational behavior, which is followed by an increase in the strengthening of employees' psychological resources, and this is while working women, due to the connection with the environment outside the home and On the other hand, they are under a lot of stress due to their maternal responsibility. Therefore, considering the role of women, in society, work-family conflict has negative consequences for the psychosocial health of working women and their families, and it also affects the optimal performance of organizations, hence it is suggested that researches on the effectiveness of work-conflict be carried out in the future. Target the family by emphasizing the role of women and try to improve the psychological condition of working women.  Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        24 - Elements and Indicators of Urban Form: A Meta-Synthesis Study
        zeinab kheirkhah Marjan A. Nemati Mehr
      • Open Access Article

        25 - Content Analysis of the Roots of Corruption in the Public Sector of the Developing Societies
        Mina Alavi Abolhasan Faghihi Morteza Moosakhani Reza Najafbeigi
        Administrative corruption as an old injury to the organs of public organizations in developmental societies has become a national crisis today, and the continual evolution of this phenomenon leads to a risk of people's trust. Therefore, the present study aimed to answer More
        Administrative corruption as an old injury to the organs of public organizations in developmental societies has become a national crisis today, and the continual evolution of this phenomenon leads to a risk of people's trust. Therefore, the present study aimed to answer the question "What are the roots of corruption in government organizations in developing countries?". Despite the prevalence of corruption, a comprehensive study has not been carried out in this area. Using the content analysis method, the researcher analyzed the results and findings of previous researchers and, by performing 7 steps, classified the roots into 29 concepts and 8 categories. The CASP checklist was used to control the qualitative researches and the Holsty reliability coefficient was used to confirm the findings. The results of the research showed that all factors in the levels of reason (individual motives and organizational conditions), middle (state) and macro (society and sovereignty) as the causes of corruption seem probable. However, in different societies in the developing world, agreement on the causes of corruption is more than expected. In all these poor or rich societies, corruption is associated with several factors: at macro level, threats and weaknesses of governance, unfamiliar civil society, middle level, weak rule of law, government capacity reduction, lack of economic development, weakness and Micro level, organizational behavior management and weak organizational behavior management. Finally, based on research findings, suggestions for future research are presented. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        26 - Storage Zone Functions Optimization in Warehouses: A Systematic Review of Class-Based Storage
        Nur Iftitah Qurtubi Qurtubi Muchamad Sugarindra
      • Open Access Article

        27 - A Model for Organizational Resilience
        Maghsood Amiri laya olfat Kamran Feizi Mohammad Ali Salehi Abarquee
        Research findings have indicated that the crisis management capacity of social organizations significantly influences the extent to which various communities can adequately which has been defined as an organization's capacity in anticipating crises, minimizing their imp More
        Research findings have indicated that the crisis management capacity of social organizations significantly influences the extent to which various communities can adequately which has been defined as an organization's capacity in anticipating crises, minimizing their impacts, resisting resultant damages and effectively responding to and tackling challenging situations, has become a major concern in organizational research. Hence, the purpose of the present study was to identify various facets and indicators of organizational resilience, design a Resilience Model, and thereby, to help organizations to promote their resilience. The Resilient Model was designed employing a qualitative research methodology and using systematic review and interviewing experts as data collection instruments. The Model was validated via confirmatory factor analysis and was employed in evaluating resilience of three leather industrial firms. Results revealed that the firms were not resilient and significantly needed further investigation of organizational resilience indicators and reform planning. This Model can vividly identify strengths and weaknesses of organizational resilience and offer implications for overcoming weaknesses. Encounter crises and rise to challenges. Social organizations play a key role in accelerating the process of restoring social order by offering efficient emergency services. Therefore, organizational resilience Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        28 - A systematic review of research related to the blended teaching-learning approach in Iranian universities
        fatemeh narenji thani Mohammad Ali Shahhoseini Atefeh Ghofrani
        The purpose of this research is to investigate researches relatedto the blended teaching-learning approach in Iranian universities. The research method is applied, and data collection was conducted using a qualitative approach through a systematic review method. For thi More
        The purpose of this research is to investigate researches relatedto the blended teaching-learning approach in Iranian universities. The research method is applied, and data collection was conducted using a qualitative approach through a systematic review method. For this purpose, resources were searched from databases(sid, noormags, magiran, civilica, ganj.irandoc) by using related keywords.Then the found documens were analyzed based on Sandlowski and Barroso seven-step model.Based on a comprehensive and systematic view, the research results indicate that the previous researches on the subject of the blended teaching-learning system in Iranian universities have examined the three dimensions of the input(competencies related to students with 5 subdimensions, competencies related to instructors with 2subdimensions), the process(teaching-learning process with 3subdimensions) and the ouput(student-related output with 3subdimensions, instructor-related output with 2subdimensions) as the main dimensions of this approach.Based on the findings, the role of university management and leadership has been neglecte in the studied researches,while it is one of the main dimentions of the teaching-learning system.The results of the present research can be a model for university managers and instructors to effectively implement a blended approach in the teaching-learning system,and a guide for researchers to conduct further research in order to eliminate research deficiencies in this field. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        29 - Review of Anisakiasis Disease in Iran from 1970-2019
        Seyed Reza Hosseini Saeed Dadkhah Tehrani
        Anisakiasis is a zoonotic disease caused by the nematode Anisakis caused by eating infected and uncooked fish. Due to the fact that this disease is zoonotic, the necessary health advice should be given to people who tend to eat raw and especially raw foods of different More
        Anisakiasis is a zoonotic disease caused by the nematode Anisakis caused by eating infected and uncooked fish. Due to the fact that this disease is zoonotic, the necessary health advice should be given to people who tend to eat raw and especially raw foods of different types of seafood. Based on the search results with the keywords, Iran and Anisakis in information sources and search engines, 24 studies conducted in Iran on Anisakiasis disease were found. This parasite has been reported in Iran to a greater extent than the shores of the Caspian Sea, Persian Gulf and Oman since 1349, which according to the results obtained in regular reviews, this amount has been higher in the southern regions of the country (Persian Gulf and Oman). Due to the high percentage of contamination in some of the fish studied, up to 97% of the need to pay attention to this parasite for food preparation is more evident. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        30 - بررسی بالینی اثربخشی داروهای یونانی بر بیماری های پوستی
        موشیر انصاری نسرین جهان عبید علی تنزیل احمد
        Background & Aim: Throughout the past three decades, scientific attention has been increased in examining Unani drugs for a potential therapeutic or preventive agent in the management of a number of health disorders in general and skin disorder in particular. T More
        Background & Aim: Throughout the past three decades, scientific attention has been increased in examining Unani drugs for a potential therapeutic or preventive agent in the management of a number of health disorders in general and skin disorder in particular. The purpose of this systematic review is to analyze and categorize the current state of scientific evidence from clinical studies regarding the efficacy of Unani drugs in skin diseases. Experimental: Electronic and non-electronic systematic searches were carried out to identify all relevant clinical research on Unani drugs. Reference lists of articles that met the inclusion criteria were searched. Only studies reported in English were reviewed. Studies on single Unani drugs and compound formulations in various skin diseases were included, in accordance with the PRISMA statement that included studies must measure a physiological and/or a behavioral outcome. Results: The studies that met our inclusion criteria are effects of Unani drugs on Acne (n=5), Melasma (n=2), Pityriasis (n=1), Vitiligo (n=2), Urticaria (n=2), Ring worm (n=2), Psoriasis (n= 3), Eczema (n = 2), and Scabies (n = 1). The data from these studies support the efficacy of Unani drugs as compared to placebo and standard drugs in improving Acne, Melasma, Pityriasis, Vitiligo, Urticaria, Ring worm, Psoriasis, Eczema and Scabies. Recommended applications/industries: Findings from initial clinical trials suggest that Unani drugs may improve the clinical manifestations of skin diseases. However, larger multi-site clinical trials are needed to extend these preliminary findings. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        31 - Meta-analysis of the relationship between cultural capital and leisure time: based on a systematic review
        Ehsan Sanatkar Mohsen Niazi Ayoub Sakhaei
        So far, several researches have been conducted on the relationship between cultural capital and leisure time, especially in the theoretical framework of Bourdieu. For this purpose, all the researches that were published in the 90s in reliable quarterly journals were ext More
        So far, several researches have been conducted on the relationship between cultural capital and leisure time, especially in the theoretical framework of Bourdieu. For this purpose, all the researches that were published in the 90s in reliable quarterly journals were extracted and analyzed in 5 levels with the system review method. Mend was examined and finally, based on the specified criteria, 11 works were selected and used in the meta-analysis process. In the initial stage, the assumptions of homogeneity and publication bias were checked, and after the tests, the heterogeneity and lack of publication bias were confirmed, and then the data were evaluated by CMA software. The findings of the current research show that the effect size of cultural capital and leisure time is 0.470, which is in the medium range based on Cohen's effect size interpretation system. Also, audience and education variables were considered as moderating variables and it was determined that the effect size coefficient in citizens (0.497) is more than youth (0.413) and in non-students (0.535) more than those studying (0.270). In fact, the findings show that the relationship of two variables with the adjustment of citizens and non-productive people can have different effects on each other. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        32 - A Meta-analysis of the relationship between cultural capital and leisure time: based on a systematic review
        Mohsen Niazi Ehsan Sanatkar Ayoub Sakhaei
        So far, much research has been conducted on the relationship between cultural capital and leisure time, especially in the theoretical framework of Bourdieu. For this purpose, all the researches that were published in the 90s in reliable quarterly journals were extracted More
        So far, much research has been conducted on the relationship between cultural capital and leisure time, especially in the theoretical framework of Bourdieu. For this purpose, all the researches that were published in the 90s in reliable quarterly journals were extracted and analyzed in 5 levels with a systematic review method and finally, on the basis of the specified criteria, 11 works were selected and used in the meta-analysis process. In the initial stage, the assumptions of homogeneity and publication bias were checked, and after the tests, the heterogeneity and lack of publication bias were confirmed, and then the data were evaluated by CMA software. The findings of the current research showed that the effect size of cultural capital and leisure time is 0.470, which on the basis of Cohen's effect size interpretation system, is in the medium range. Also, audience and education variables were considered as moderating variables and it was determined that the coefficient of effect size among residents (0.497) was more than that of youth (0.413) and among non-students (0.535) was more than that of students (0.270). In fact, the findings showed that the relationship of the two variables with the adjustment of citizens and non- students can have different effects on each other.   Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        33 - Task Scheduling in Fog Computing: A Survey
        Abbas Najafizadeh Afshin Salajegheh Amir Masoud Rahmani Amir Sahafi
      • Open Access Article

        34 - Investigating individual factors affecting behavioral ambivalence: a systematic review
        malikeh beheshtifar khadigeh Shekhasadi
        Abstract Background and purpose: The concern of many organizations today is that they cannot create the ability to perform another activity at the same time that they are engaged in one activity. Achieving such a transformation is difficult and requires serious attenti More
        Abstract Background and purpose: The concern of many organizations today is that they cannot create the ability to perform another activity at the same time that they are engaged in one activity. Achieving such a transformation is difficult and requires serious attention to create the capacity of behavioral ambivalence in the organization. Therefore, it is important to identify the factors that promote ambivalence among employees. The present study was conducted with the aim of identifying individual factors affecting behavioral ambivalence. Review method: In this research, which was conducted as a systematic review, studies related to the subject were retrieved using defined search terms and using specific databases. Based on the compliance with the entry and exit criteria, the articles were extracted from them and entered into Excel version 2010. Findings: Among 123 articles, 9 articles were selected. These studies had studied the factors affecting behavioral ambivalence. The results of the research showed that factors such as personality traits, flexibility of human resources, internal motivation, self-efficacy, innovative behavior, and managers' support are effective on behavioral ambivalence. Conclusion: In order to optimally use the capacity of intelligence, knowledge and existing skills of employees and behaviors such as searching for new products or services and innovation in the process, it is necessary for managers to pay attention to individual factors on behavioral ambivalence in organizations.   Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        35 - Designing a talent management model in the country's electricity industry using interpretive structural modeling
        maryam hesami roohalla samiee fereydoon azma mahmoodreza mostaghimi
        The aim of this study was to design an interpretive structural model of talent management in the country's electricity industry. Therefore, this research is based on the purpose of development-applied type and based on the method, descriptive-correlation. The present re More
        The aim of this study was to design an interpretive structural model of talent management in the country's electricity industry. Therefore, this research is based on the purpose of development-applied type and based on the method, descriptive-correlation. The present research is based on the purpose of development-applied type and based on the method, descriptive-correlation. The research team consists of 10 theoretical and experimental experts who have been selected by purposeful method and snowball technique. For this purpose, in the first step, the constituent elements of the talent management model were identified from the theoretical literature (by systematic review method) and interviews with experts (content analysis). The output of this step was to identify 36 components in the form of six main dimensions. In the next step, in order to establish the relationship and sequence between the dimensions and present their structural model, the interpretive structural modeling method was used. In this method, based on the opinions of experts and analyzes, the talent management model was calculated. The results indicate that the dimensions of talent acquisition, talent development, talent retention, talent discovery and development of internal capacities of individuals were in the first level and talent assessment were in the second level. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        36 - Prevalence of Medicinal Herbs Use during Pregnancy in the World: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
        Fatemeh Heydarpour Sousan Heydarpour Fatemeh Dehghan Masoud Mohammadi Mohammad Hosein Farzaei
      • Open Access Article

        37 - The Effect of ANGIPARS™ on Wound Healing in Patients with Diabetes: A Systematic Review
        Mohamad Karimian Ali Gholami Mohammad Hosein Farzaei Azzurra Stefanucci Adriano Mollica Yosof Mahmoudi sana shahrabady asma tarjoman Milad Borji
      • Open Access Article

        38 - The Risk of Exposure To Pesticides on Autism Disorder: a Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
        Zahra Moradpour Ali akbar Shafikhani Neda Izady Rezvan Zendehdel Ali Omidi
      • Open Access Article

        39 - A Comprehensive Review on Determinants of Poor Treatment Adherence among Type 2 Diabetes Patients and Low Health Literacy
        Helen Williams Srinivasan Ranganathan
        Both preventive and therapeutic interventions are necessary for good diabetes management and the prevention of complications. There are serious therapeutic and financial repercussions when patients don't follow their doctors' orders about medicine, nutrition, and health More
        Both preventive and therapeutic interventions are necessary for good diabetes management and the prevention of complications. There are serious therapeutic and financial repercussions when patients don't follow their doctors' orders about medicine, nutrition, and healthcare procedures. The current comprehensive review aims to determine factors that have been observed in patients with type 2 diabetes and low health literacy, contribute to poor treatment adherence in 2022. Five steps were taken to complete this review: creating a research question, looking for and extracting relevant papers, choosing relevant studies, tabulating data, and reporting findings. Using the terms "Type 2 diabetes", "obstacles", "determinants", "factors", "barriers", "treatment", "medication", "therapy" "adherence", "non-adherence", "poor adherence", and "low health literacy" was gathered from six electronic databases (Scopus, Web of Science, Embase, Science Direct, PubMed and Google Scholar) from January 2018 to January 2022. Twelve were able to be reviewed from the initial 140 articles. In this review, ten studies have been selected involving 1497 patients with type 2 diabetes. The range of nonadherence prevalence was from 42% to 74.3%. Economic difficulties, inadequate communication with the medical staff, an absence of family support, ignorance, misinterpretation, and low health literacy were major barriers to treatment adherence in the publications. The findings of this study identified both modifiable and non-modifiable factors influencing medication adherence in type 2 diabetes patients. Modifiable factors must be addressed by suitable interventions carried out with the target population and healthcare experts. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        40 - Systematic review of bankruptcy prediction models
        Jaber Zahmatkesh Akram Taftiyan Mahmoud Moeinadin Amin Nezarat
        Objective: The current research aims to systematically examine bankruptcy prediction models with the goal of developing a model that serves as a guide for selecting the most suitable tools. These tools should ideally align with the existing data and quality criteria of More
        Objective: The current research aims to systematically examine bankruptcy prediction models with the goal of developing a model that serves as a guide for selecting the most suitable tools. These tools should ideally align with the existing data and quality criteria of bankruptcy prediction models.Research Methodology: To conduct this research, a systematic search was performed on the Web of Science database using keywords such as Bankruptcy, Default, Distress, Failure, Forecasting, Predicting, Prediction, and Insolvency, spanning the years 2015 to 2023. Based on defined inclusion and exclusion criteria, this search yielded 1000 articles, out of which 49 were ultimately selected and analyzed. The findings from these articles were then summarized in tables. Subsequently, major bankruptcy prediction models were compared based on nine key criteria, and final conclusions were drawn.Findings: Artificial neural networks and support vector machines were found to have the highest accuracy, while multiple personality analysis showed the lowest accuracy. Additionally, artificial neural networks, multiple personality analysis, decision trees, and logistic regression require a large training sample to logically identify and precisely classify patterns. However, case-based reasoning, rough sets, and support vector machines can work with smaller sample sizes.Originality/ Value: The outcomes of this research contribute to a comprehensive understanding of the characteristics of tools used in developing bankruptcy prediction models and the shortcomings associated with them. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        41 - Investigating the Systematic Mapping of Strategic Management in Selected Scientific -Research Journals: Identifying the Research Gaps and Implications for Future Research
        Reza Baniasad Mahdi Bagheri Maibodi SeyedMostafa Baladyan
            Given the expansion of strategic management field of study in Iran at the master and PhD level of education, numerous articles, theses and books have been written in this field of study. Therefore, it is necessary to perform a systematic review of these More
            Given the expansion of strategic management field of study in Iran at the master and PhD level of education, numerous articles, theses and books have been written in this field of study. Therefore, it is necessary to perform a systematic review of these studies in the current situation, to determine the procedure of research and the research gaps. In line with research area of ​​professors, the need of the country and, of course, the problem-centered of the researchers, studies have been published on strategic management and its sub-areas in scientific journals. The objective of this paper is identifying the subjects studied in selected journals, analyzing the the dispersion and frequency of studies, identifying research methodologies, and finally identifying the research gaps in the field of strategic management literature in the country. For this purpose, this study analyzes 9 selected scientific-research journals and 1757 papers by analyzing the secondary data and systematic review of current knowledge of strategic management using the systematic mapping study strategy. Finally, 343 related papers and 333 subjects were identified.  The results of the research show that thematic coverage of the strategic management in these journals is 24.5%, the level of using quantitative method is 59.2%, the level of using qualitative method is 36.4%, and the level of using the mixed methods is 4.4%.  In addition, major parts of the studies were conducted on strategic management process and its sub-areas with 95.1% and in there are a few studies (less than 5%) in the areas of theory building, strategy schools, quantitative foundations, philosophical foundations, interdisciplinary studies with other sciences and Islamic strategic management Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        42 - Investigating the factors affecting on collective protest actions in Iran (2017 and 2009)
        saeedeh esmaeelzadeh ashini
        The present research aims to provide a relatively accurate picture of the causes, topics, characteristics, achievements and problems by systematically reviewing the studies related to mass protests in Iran in 2018 and 2018 and by aggregating the results of scattered res More
        The present research aims to provide a relatively accurate picture of the causes, topics, characteristics, achievements and problems by systematically reviewing the studies related to mass protests in Iran in 2018 and 2018 and by aggregating the results of scattered researches and by achieving a new perspective. These researches give. For this purpose, in this research, taking into account practical possibilities and time limitations, 60 cases (30 studies related to the protests of 1988 and 30 studies related to the protests of 1996) of the existing works between 1388 and 1400 were examined and the necessary information, extracted and analyzed. The obtained results show that in the collection of scientific works related to the protests of 2018, political causes have been given more attention than other causes, and the economic factor has been given less attention than other factors. In general, most of the authors have paid more attention to internal variables and socio-political factors. In the collection of scientific works related to the protests of 2016, social causes have received more attention than other causes, and the cultural factor has received less attention than other factors, and most of the analysts have paid more attention to internal variables and socio-economic factors. In the studies related to collective protest action in 1996 compared to 1988, we see a shift from socio-political factors to socio-economic factors. Manuscript profile