-
Open Access Article
1 - Meta-analysis of customer communication relationships with the satisfaction of users of sports facilities
kazem mehri mehrdad Rahimain alireza taherpourNowadays, in order to stay competitive and survive, organizations must have a correct and accurate knowledge of their external environment, especially customers, who are the main pillar of the external environment, in order to understand their needs and wants. customers MoreNowadays, in order to stay competitive and survive, organizations must have a correct and accurate knowledge of their external environment, especially customers, who are the main pillar of the external environment, in order to understand their needs and wants. customers in order to provide better service and bring more satisfaction and In the end, they take a step towards long-term preservation. This need has caused a change in the approach of organizations and new concepts in the field of customer management and marketing have been introduced by passing the traditional form. The gradual entry of our country into the world trade arena, the advancement of the privatization policy, the increase of customers and the subsequent increase of their expectations and expectations have increased the competition in such a way that the survival of organizations depends on the creation and increase of advantages. It will be competitive. The aim of this research was to investigate the meta-analysis of customer relations with the satisfaction of users of sports facilities, in order to reach this goal and complete the subject literature and theoretical foundations, related information from the field method and the library method such as reading books, articles, magazines, and research projects. Hashi and Internet information banks were collected. The statistical population included all the researches reported in the field of investigating the relationship with the customer and the satisfaction of the users of sports facilities from 1390 to 1402. From among the statistical population, 20 studies that met the criteria for entering the meta-analysis were selected as research samples through the census method. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
2 - A Meta-Analysis of psychological characteristics and driving behavior in order to provide a future roadmap for police in traffic accident prevention
parviz fadakar Gabalou Mehdi Molaei Yasavi seyed moslem moosavi panahBackground: Because policy prioritization is limited by existing capacities. Therefore, it is necessary to conduct a comprehensive study that examines the role of psychological variables in driving behavior. Objective: This research aims to use new research methods, und MoreBackground: Because policy prioritization is limited by existing capacities. Therefore, it is necessary to conduct a comprehensive study that examines the role of psychological variables in driving behavior. Objective: This research aims to use new research methods, under the title of meta-analysis, to analyze and combine the results of research in the field of driving behavior and psychological characteristics in order to provide a roadmap for the prevention of traffic accidents. Methods: The statistical population of this study is the research on driving behavior between the years 89 to 99. Exact information on their number was not available and 25 studies on driving behavior were selected. The research method of this research is meta-analysis method. Findings: All these researches were analyzed in terms of effect size and Pearson r index was used to calculate the effect size. Analysis of the results of the research using a random effects model showed that the total effect size of the psychological variables affecting driving behavior was 0.32. Also, the heterogeneity of the results using Q and I2 indices showed that there is no significant difference between the size of the effects obtained in different studies. Conclusion: It is suggested that in order to prevent traffic accidents, special attention should be paid to the psychological characteristics of drivers and to provide a driving competency along with written tests and driving skills, a tool should be used to assess the psychological characteristics of drivers. Develop scientific programs to improve the psychological characteristics of high-risk drivers. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
3 - Futures Studies of the Goals of the Anti-Daesh Coalition by Using Network Analysis Techniques
MohamadReza Jamshidi Javad Tavasoli Noghabi Sayed Hasan Hoseini Mehran Keshtkar Toraj EskandariAmerica and its allies took steps to form a coalition and attacked the extremist positions after a long time of the violent extremist activities in South-West Asia, with specific goals as the fight against terrorism. However, the objectives of the action announced by th MoreAmerica and its allies took steps to form a coalition and attacked the extremist positions after a long time of the violent extremist activities in South-West Asia, with specific goals as the fight against terrorism. However, the objectives of the action announced by them, but according to the previous records of America, these goals seem unrealistic and need to understand the real goals of the coalition and with the advice of the past through future study. Therefore, it is trying to determine to a large extent behind the main objectives in this study, with reference to the population of which consists of two categories: "Documentation, media interviews," and "experts". The data were extracted and analyzed using content analysis and exploration as the first population. After the data were categorized in several sections, and then send the questionnaire to the population to judge. Finally, it was recognized with a number of 13 important objective judgment of experts, using network analysis techniques and the use of software Super Decision analysis process. So the most important of them are "to weaken the powers of the Middle East"; "Israel's security" and "Re-penetration of America and its allies in the Middle East" Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
4 - Explanation of a Model for sustaining the Role of Bridge as Urban Spaces
Elham NazemiFrom old days, bridges had a role beyond a passage and were considered as public spaces with function of accepting activities. The purpose of this article is to describe a model for studying bridges as an urban space and also studying those types of bridges, which are u MoreFrom old days, bridges had a role beyond a passage and were considered as public spaces with function of accepting activities. The purpose of this article is to describe a model for studying bridges as an urban space and also studying those types of bridges, which are urban spaces. The article seeks the answer for the following research questions focusing on i) which types of the bridges have the qualities to be an urban space, and ii) how to reinforce the role of the bridge as the urban space. Responding to the research questions, we have classified the bridges and introduced the types that have the capability of being an urban space and defined urban space and the factors and indicators affecting it through the descriptive-analytical research method. Data were collected through documentation and survey and information analysis by meta-analysis method, summarization and ANP. The studies carried out in the research indicated that the bridges can be of various uses other than being only a pathway. Therefore, the bridge’s definition and typology will be studied and the elements and criteria affecting the assessment of the urban space quality were introduced. The three characteristics of the bridges were such as pathway to cross the obstacles, and characterized joint through connection between two sides. Thus, a general definition for a bridge can be, “bridge is a structure constructed to cross the physical obstacles and as a joint connects two sides together”. Also, according to the urban development scholars' views, the most prominent components of urban space are physical, functional, semantic, contextual and environmental elements. Subsequently, it can be said that the urban space is a part of the physical space of the cities having a history of being old and active and belongs to the public where social activities are mostly happening. Also, the criteria including visual pleasure ability, diversity of use, public accessibility, physical configuration, richness of sense, sociability, diversity of users, human scale, readability, animation, relation with nature, robustness, environmental control, comfort, safety and health, publicness and proportion with the cultural and historical contexts are, respectively the most applicable of the urban space. Therefore, the role of the bridge as an urban space was reinforced, in addition to their three essential functions, the bridges must possess the criteria of an urban space, too. Therefore, a bridge as an urban space is “a part of the physical space of cities created for crossing the obstacles and connecting two sides together and as a joint has a history of being aged and active and possessed by the public”. Studying the criteria of the urban space regarding the types of the bridges which were more capable of turning into an urban space indicated that the functional factors are more effective in strengthening the bridges’ roles as the urban spaces compared with the other criteria. According to the study constructing bridge-museum, bridge-market and bridge-recreation areas are of the successful samples that can change and reinforce the role of the bridges as an urban space. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
5 - An Analysis of the Trends of Mortality in Iran and the World and the Factors Affecting the Country's Mortality in Research Texts (Course of the Last Decade)
mohsen mohamadi ali Pezhhan majid radfarThe current article was written with the aim of investigating the trends of mortality in the last three decades. The total number of researches and articles reviewed was 79 articles, researches, dissertations and theses, which were analyzed using Cm2 and Maxq software. MoreThe current article was written with the aim of investigating the trends of mortality in the last three decades. The total number of researches and articles reviewed was 79 articles, researches, dissertations and theses, which were analyzed using Cm2 and Maxq software. data was analyzed, and the results of the research showed that the developments related to the reduction of mortality in the reference countries were quite slow and gradual, the process of which took nearly two hundred to two hundred and fifty years, but the process was not uniform in all countries, but the major Western countries have gone through these stages that lead to the formation of population theorists. At the end of this period, due to the transfer of experiences and scientific knowledge in the field of health from reference countries to other countries such as Iran, a much shorter period of time has passed. For example, in our country, Iran, since the beginning of the developments of prevention, treatment and doing things related to mortality control, a period of 60 to 65 years has happened. The findings of the research showed that in Iran, the process of changes from underlying and contagious diseases has alternately aligned with lifestyle changes, and today the most important causes of death are related to diseases, but cardiovascular diseases have the most The percentage that is directly related to the lifestyle and further confirming this analysis, after accidents and accidents is ranked second, and the share of men's deaths in all cases, which causes the difference between the life expectancy of women and men between two Three years have changed in favor of women Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
6 - A Review of Iranian and Australian Management Accounting Researches
حسین اعتمادی رضا حصارزاده آمنه بذرافشانThis paper to classifying objects, statistical populations, theories, methods andanalysis techniques of management accounting researches of Iranian and Australianresearchers, investigates 67 and 199 articles of them in 9 known journals. Findingsindicate, while there is MoreThis paper to classifying objects, statistical populations, theories, methods andanalysis techniques of management accounting researches of Iranian and Australianresearchers, investigates 67 and 199 articles of them in 9 known journals. Findingsindicate, while there is a significant correlation between general approaches of theresearches, but diversity of Iranian sub-classify is smaller than Australian ones. Alsothere are some cases that need to more attention and so, to more advertence and moreresearches in universities. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
7 - Meta-analysis of Audit Committee Independence and Financial Reporting Quality
Ameneh Bazrafshan Rezvan Hejazi Ali Rahmani Susan BastaniThe purpose of this paper is Meta-analysis of audit Committee independence and financial reporting quality. In spite of general expectation for positive relationship between audit committee independence and financial reporting quality, the empirical researches reveal se MoreThe purpose of this paper is Meta-analysis of audit Committee independence and financial reporting quality. In spite of general expectation for positive relationship between audit committee independence and financial reporting quality, the empirical researches reveal several inconsistence conclusions. So, we conduct a meta-analysis of the association between audit independence and financial reporting quality in period of year 2000 to 2013. Although we cannot reliably aggregate results across studies in a statistical sense because of inconsistencies in defining FRQ and the absence of replication studies, quantitative review techniques after considering homogeneity analysis (by within-group Q and between-group Q) yield three conclusions: first the use of different FRQ measures in the AC independence literature explains the variation in results across studies. Second there is no relationship between audit committee independence and “earnings management and quality score”. Third there is positive relationship between audit committee independence and “accrual quality, abnormal return, restatement and fraud”. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
8 - The Effect of Adopting International Financial Reporting Standards on the Financial Reporting Comparability: Meta-Analytic Evidence
vahid ahmadian میثم حامدی رقیه نامورInternational Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) were developed with the aim of increasing the comparability of financial reporting, enabling market participants to make better economic decisions and improving the efficiency of the capital market. But after more than MoreInternational Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) were developed with the aim of increasing the comparability of financial reporting, enabling market participants to make better economic decisions and improving the efficiency of the capital market. But after more than a decade of research on the effects of adopting these standards, there is still no definite conclusion about the extent of achieving this goal, and experimental studies report contradictory results. In order to obtain objective evidence regarding the real effects of adopting International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) based on the experience of countries that have adopted these standards, in this research, a comprehensive analysis of studies that examine the effects of adopting International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) on comparability Financial reporting has been done. Based on the analysis of 243 observations, with an independent sample of 2,544,582 company-years, meta-analysis and meta-regression results indicate that the adoption of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) generally has a positive and significant effect on the comparability of financial reporting. but the size of the effect of adopting these standards depends on several factors such as the method of mandatory or voluntary acceptance, the legal structure of the countries and the executive guarantee of accounting and auditing of the countries under review. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
9 - A meta-analysis of the relationship between conservatism and comparability with earnings management in Iran
zahra Akbary Mohammadreza Mehrabanpour hossein jahangirnia Reza Gholami JamkaraniThere have been numerous studies on the factors related to earnings management that with contradictory results have been published separately. The purpose of the present study is to examine, analyze and combine the results of previous researches on the relationship betw MoreThere have been numerous studies on the factors related to earnings management that with contradictory results have been published separately. The purpose of the present study is to examine, analyze and combine the results of previous researches on the relationship between conservatism and comparability with earnings management in Iran. The research population includes all existing research in the area of relationship between conservatism and comparability with earnings management including, including valid articles from 2013 to 2019. The research method is meta-analysis using CMA2 software. The findings of the study indicate that conservatism has no significant relationship with accrual and cash earnings management, but it has a negative and significant relationship with total earnings management. Comparability has a positive and significant relationship with accrual and has a significant negative relationship with cash earnings management. Contribution of findings enriches the literature on earnings management and its related factors and fill existing research gap. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
10 - Meta-analysis of the relationship between cultural intelligence and cultural competence
Ali oliaee Alireza Ebrahimpour Seyed Morteza MousavianPurpose: the purpose of this study is to conduct a systematic and meta - analysis of the literature on cultural competence and cultural intelligence to gather and evaluate the quantitative findings of cultural intelligence and its relation on cultural competence.researc MorePurpose: the purpose of this study is to conduct a systematic and meta - analysis of the literature on cultural competence and cultural intelligence to gather and evaluate the quantitative findings of cultural intelligence and its relation on cultural competence.research method: the research method in this paper is applied in terms of objective, in terms of quantitative performance, in terms of nature and method of descriptive and statistical society of all articles of the world. in order to identify studies related to cultural intelligence and cultural competence, the review of university information technologies in online magazines Wiley, springer, Elsevier, science direct, web of science, sage, ProQuest, google scholar were systematically investigated. Studies written in Persian were searched in Iran Dock and Elm net databases. Out of 143 selected articles, finally 8 articles have all the necessary conditions according to the prism selection protocol. then, using a random effect model of quality of each study, heterogeneity between studies and bias with CMA2 software was analyzed and evaluated.results: the effect size (Pearson correlation coefficient) is significant in the case of random effects model (r = 0.480) and z - value is statistically significant at the probability level of 99 %.conclusion: aggregation of research results of the world showed that cultural competence has a positive relationship with cultural intelligence, but the intensity of this relationship varies in different societies. furthermore, cultural competence is related to motivational and metacognitive aspects of cultural intelligence. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
11 - Identifying the most important psychological antecedents of Internet addiction based on a meta-analysis approach: evidence from internal studies
houshang garavand Mohammad Reza Nazari Considering the novelty of studies related to Internet addiction in Iran, the investigation andidentification of psychological factors predicting this phenomenon is evident as a research gap; Therefore, thepresent study was conducted with the aimed to identifying More Considering the novelty of studies related to Internet addiction in Iran, the investigation andidentification of psychological factors predicting this phenomenon is evident as a research gap; Therefore, thepresent study was conducted with the aimed to identifying the most important psychological antecedents ofInternet addiction through a meta-analytical research procedure. The method of conducting the research is aquantitative meta-analysis. In the process of systematic review, 195 articles were identified from 2002 to 2022,and by carefully studying the text of Persian articles by university professors and experts, 108 articles wereidentified. Life satisfaction (ES, -0.65), problem-oriented coping (ES, -0.45), difficulty in regulating emotions(ES, 0.45), interpersonal sensitivity (ES, 0.45), sensation seeking (ES, 42 0.0), feeling lonely (ES, 0.41),depression (ES, 0.39), anxiety (ES, 0.38), psychological capital (ES, -0.37), depression (ES, 0.36) , stress (ES,0.35) and emotional intelligence (ES, -0.35) were identified as the strongest antecedents, respectively. Due to theheterogeneity in the studies, studies with validity (ES, -0.15) had a larger effect size than studies withoutvalidation (ES, 0.06). Based on the results, the manner of using internet can be related to psychologicalcharacteristics of the internet users. It is expected that these findings not only improve the knowledge of thisfield, but also support protective factors and removing risky behaviors. Additionally, it can be used as a helpfultool in intervention programs in this field. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
12 - The Meta-Analysis of the Social Participation Studies
Khadijeh Safiri Roghayeh Tamiz -
Open Access Article
13 - The Study of Theoretical Approach of Natural Disaster Management in Iran using Meta-analysis
Mehdi Nojavan Esmail Salehi Babak Omidvar Shahrzad FaryadiBackground and objective: Population growth and unplanned urban development has led to increase the risk of disaster in urban areas. Achievement to knowledge and ways to deal with disasters, have attracted attention of residents and researchers to natural disaster manag MoreBackground and objective: Population growth and unplanned urban development has led to increase the risk of disaster in urban areas. Achievement to knowledge and ways to deal with disasters, have attracted attention of residents and researchers to natural disaster management. The number and variety of published scientific papers in the field of natural disasters is one of the reliable proofs for showing the trend of researchers to this field. The objective of this research is meta-analyzing the published papers in Persian scientific journals. Material and Methodogy: For meta-analyzing of theoretical approach of Natural Disaster Management in Iran, initially 29 journals are selected. Then 454 papers are selected among these journals. These papers have been published from 2002 to 2016. Finally, for analyzing the papers, the analyzing criteria such as research methodology, sampling method and planning model and approach are determined using the expert’s opinion. Findings: The map of studies distribution showed that Tehran, Khorasan-e-Razavi, and Azerbaijan-e-sharghi provinces have been considered in a lot of papers. Results showed that physical approach is the dominant approach in the studies which is a weakness in papers. Also disregarding the scientific principle of research methodology such as absence of sampling, reliability, and validity is the other weakness of studies. Discussion and Conclusion: Considering the dominant approach in the previous studies, studying and using the community-based and organizational approaches in the future researches is proposed. The policies of scientific journals in publishing applied papers is led to aggregation of these papers in the journals. So it is proposed due to importance of theoretical and fundamental studies and identifying indicators in the field of disaster management, scientific journals would have special attention to theoretical papers in this context and providing the condition to presentation of more theoretical and fundamental papers in this subject. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
14 - A Meta Analysis of Rural Tourism Development Evaluation with an Emphasis on Strategic Factors (SWOT)
Mohammad Reza POURJAAFAR Hadi Mahmoodi Nezhad Shaheen Aylka Hamed Aghebat BekheirRural Tourism is considered as a process in rural development which is creating other activities such as agricultural that can increase the financial, economical and environmental development, job creat MoreRural Tourism is considered as a process in rural development which is creating other activities such as agricultural that can increase the financial, economical and environmental development, job creation and permanency that follows by life quality improvement, services and convenience in regional and local development framework. Here, the rural attractions and potentials can be resources and opportunities of this fact. Moreover the rural tourism development causes social, economical and environmental positive and negative effects while interfering in rural regions. In this method which uses a descriptive and Meta analysis, it is tried to choose the best way of interfering in rural regions studying and quality evaluating the rural tourism. This researchs findings show that a strategic way in strategic factors (SWOT) analysis process using a vast and flexible look through variables and facts in rural tourism can provide a maximum in planning, design and performance of rural tourism development which should be evaluated in Iran todays social, economical, environmental and political structure. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
15 - A meta-analysis on the capital asset pricing model
Saeed Fathi Farideh Tavakoli Iman OstadCapital asset pricing model is an equilibrium model to show the relationship between systematic risk and return of capital assets and indicate the pricing of assets due to their systematic risk. Abundance of empirical studies in testing standard and developed CAPM shows MoreCapital asset pricing model is an equilibrium model to show the relationship between systematic risk and return of capital assets and indicate the pricing of assets due to their systematic risk. Abundance of empirical studies in testing standard and developed CAPM shows the importance of CAPM in estimating the price of financial assets. The meta-analytic approach of this paper creates a distinct realization to this context of finance by using of variance analysis, correlation test and means difference. So we use the statistical results of 418 CAPM tests during 1972 to 2016. The results show that time period of the test, type of portfolio ranking, country development grade, type of systematic risk and the type of CAPM test have a significant effect on the price of beta. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
16 - فراتحلیل رابطه تفکر انتقادی با شاخصهای پیشرفت تحصیلی
سالار عبدالملکی جواد مصرآبادی ابوالفضل فرید -
Open Access Article
17 - فراتحلیل عوامل همبسته با تعهد هنجاری معلمان در جمهوری اسلامی ایران
رامین غریب زاده عادل زاهد بابلان مهدی معینی کیا علی خالق خواه -
Open Access Article
18 - فراتحلیل مطالعات پیشگیری از جرم از طریق طراحی محیطی (CPTED) در داخل
یدالله صادقی ابوالفضل مشکینی محسن کلانتری بهمن کارگر عبدالرضا رکن الدین افتخاری -
Open Access Article
19 - Meta-Analysis on Femininity Studies and Development in Iran Considering on economic development
Azadeh ghazanfari khalil Mirzaei Masoume ReshadThe first trainers and preparers of a wise and knowledgeable generation in a society for creating and preparing the contexts of advancement and development in a country and nation, are women. Therefore, this is enough to consider the development and advancement of women MoreThe first trainers and preparers of a wise and knowledgeable generation in a society for creating and preparing the contexts of advancement and development in a country and nation, are women. Therefore, this is enough to consider the development and advancement of women in a society, equal to advancement and development of that country. This paper is performed in order to merge done studies in femininity field and development. Method which is used in this paper, is Meta-analysis. Statistical population were consisted of related and available studies which were accessible in Iran using Persian language, in paper form, from 1385 to 1401. After investigating the criterion of inputs and outputs, 55 effect sizes from 17 studies which have Meta-analysis condition, were obtained. In order to analyze data from sensitivity data, funnel chart, stochastic models and heterogeneity analysis, CMA2 software was used. Analysis of obtained information from research showed that the amount of combined effect in this stochastic model (chosen model for this Meta-analysis), which was significant. Size of obtained effect were calculated averagely according to interpretation of Cohen's scale and results illustrated that women and femininity have effect on development.Also by considering economic development as moderator variable,it is calculated averagely too. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
20 - Meta-Analysis of Effectiveness of Triple P-Positive Parenting Program on reduction of Externalizing Disorders in children and parenting problems
mansoureh bahramipourThe goal of this study is meta-analysis of researches about effectiveness of Triple P-Positive Parenting Program on reduction of Externalizing Disorders in children and parenting problems. This study with meta-analysis or integrating the results of different studies, de MoreThe goal of this study is meta-analysis of researches about effectiveness of Triple P-Positive Parenting Program on reduction of Externalizing Disorders in children and parenting problems. This study with meta-analysis or integrating the results of different studies, determine the effect size of Triple P-Positive Parenting Program on reduction of Externalizing Disorders in children and parenting problems. For this purpose out of 12 studies,11 studies which have proper methodology were selected and meta-analysis conducted on them. The research instrument was meta-analysis checklist. This study includes 306 subjects and 11 effect sizes. The results of meta-analysis indicated high significant effect size for triple p-positive parenting program on reduction of externalizing disorders in children and parenting problems(d= 0/82, p= 0/00001). According to Cohen’s table its high effect size, and it means of intervention have proper effect. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
21 - A meta-analysis of researches on relationship between resilience and life satisfaction
Mirnader Miri abbas hemati Niloofar MikaeiliLife satisfaction is one of the important components of well-being, that its low levels among people have many negative consequences. A lot of research has been done on the factors affecting life satisfaction, which one of this factors is resilience. In this direction, MoreLife satisfaction is one of the important components of well-being, that its low levels among people have many negative consequences. A lot of research has been done on the factors affecting life satisfaction, which one of this factors is resilience. In this direction, the purpose of this study was to collect and integrate the results of the relationship between resilience and life satisfaction and calculate their effectsize by using the meta-analysis model. In order to answer the meta-analysis question, from among all research on the relationship between resilience and life satisfaction in carried outthroughout Iran, 11 research studies which were acceptable in terms of methodology and ex-hibited inclusivecriteria, were sele-cted for the meta –analysis. The period of studies has been from 2006 to 2019.The combination of effect size by Schmitt and Hunts method shows that the average effect size of the relationship between resilience and life satisfaction in Iran is for a fixed effect model 0/411 and for random effect model 0/422, that both of which are significant at level of 0/000. Therefore, the average effect size of current study is 0/422 and this amount is moderate according to the Cohen criterion. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
22 - A Meta-Analysis of Interventions to Reduce Procrastination
hadi keramati Reza Jafariharandi mohammad setayeshiazhari zahra torkzadeThe aim of this study was to do a meta-analysis on interventions conducted on procrastination to determine the most effectiveness intervention for procrastination. This meta-analysis conducted on 17 studies and calculated 17 effect sizes. These studies were published in MoreThe aim of this study was to do a meta-analysis on interventions conducted on procrastination to determine the most effectiveness intervention for procrastination. This meta-analysis conducted on 17 studies and calculated 17 effect sizes. These studies were published in journals and database of Jahad Daneshgahi, Markaz Tahghighat cumputeri, Majalat Iran. Comprehensive meta analysis (CMA V2) were administrated to doing meta-analysis. The result showed that ACT and instruction of cognition and meta-cognition skills have most effectiveness to reduce procrastination. According to results researchers recommend the use of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy )ACT( and cognition and meta-cognition skills to overcoming procrastination. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
23 - A Meta-Analysis of the psychological - educational interventions on progressing the academic effectiveness in high school students (2005-2012)
Sayed Hossein Siadatiian Ahmad YarmohamadianThe aim of the present study is meta-analysis of the psychological - educational interventions on progressing the academic effectiveness in high school students. The statistical population included all theses and published researches in scientific-research journals in t MoreThe aim of the present study is meta-analysis of the psychological - educational interventions on progressing the academic effectiveness in high school students. The statistical population included all theses and published researches in scientific-research journals in the field of high school student’s academic achievements. The research sample included those researches which had methodological conditions. This study has been determined the effect size of psychological - educational interventions on high school student’s academic achievements. Between 47 researches, meta- analysis has done by using 23 researches (acceptable by the methodology). The research instrument was a researcher-made checklist to extracting data based on 1819 cases. Data analysis was done manually. The meta-analysis results indicated that the effect size of psychological - educational interventions on high school student’s academic achievements is d=0.668 (p=0.001). This effect size has moderate effect according to Cohen’s table. At last, psychological - educational interventions have significant effects on high school student’s academic achievements. And the researchers and authorities of education can use the models that have had the moderate or higher effect size on high school student’s academic achievements. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
24 - Qualitative meta-analysis on the conducted researches in the field of MOOC (Massive Open Online Courses)
Esmaeil Jafari Kourosh Fathi vajargah Mahboobeh Arefi Morteza RezaeiZadehSince 2008, MOOC as an educational tool is not only used by educational institutions and also universities and it is interesting subject for many scholars and researchers. The aim of the current research was to provide a comprehensive picture of the conducted researches MoreSince 2008, MOOC as an educational tool is not only used by educational institutions and also universities and it is interesting subject for many scholars and researchers. The aim of the current research was to provide a comprehensive picture of the conducted researches in the field of MOOC. In order to achieve the aim, the qualitative meta-analysis was used to examine and analyze 40 research in the field which each of them had a different perspective and methodology. The results showed that all conducted researches have predominant features both structurally, methodologically and contextually. Theoretical orientation of more than half the researches were based on connectivist paradigm which indicated that if Iranian educational institutions and universities want to implement MOOC, it need to transform structuralism paradigm to connectivist paradigm. Namely, education and higher education policies should move towards an approach which is based on dialogue, interaction, knowledge creation and emergent learning Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
25 - Investigating the learning transfer as a major concern for the workplace
Maryam Hassanpour Roodbaraki Mojgan Abdollahi Alireza Araghieeh Fatemeh Parasteh GhambovaniThe purpose of this study was to identify and predict the factors affecting learning transfer to the workplace. The research method is descriptive-analytical carried out by exploring studies which were related to learning transfer based on meta-analysis method. Document MoreThe purpose of this study was to identify and predict the factors affecting learning transfer to the workplace. The research method is descriptive-analytical carried out by exploring studies which were related to learning transfer based on meta-analysis method. Documentation included 85 scientific articles and research projects from 1390 to1397 solar and from 1988 to 2018, of which 27 documents were selected through a checklist of research with intrinsic criteria owing to their conformity with the main purpose of the study and the indicators were selected through purposeful sampling.Data analysis was performed using Comprehensive Meta-Analysis Software (CMA-2) and results were interpreted using Cohen's interpretive system. The results of measuring the effect of factors affecting learning transfer showed that "Individual factor (ES = 0.578)", "Educational factor (ES = 0.520)" and "Organizational factor (ES = 0.448)" had the most effect on learning transfer.Also, individual talent, transfer design and performance feedback components were reported with the most effect size were noticed as the most important.However, performance self-efficacy, training contents and resistance to change showed least effect size, and revealed the least important effect on the learning transfer to the workplace. The results showed that attention to individual and educational factors would have a positive and strong effect on increasing learning transfer to the workplace. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
26 - Meta-Analysis of the Effectiveness of Constructivist Approach-Based Education on Academic Performance in the Experimental science course
yaser garavand Morteza Omidian Hamid Farhadirad Seyed Abbas Razavi gholamhossin maktabiThe present applied research with meta-analysis method sought to combine research on the effect of constructivism-based education on students' academic performance in experimental sciences course. The field of research of the study consisted of available studies that ha MoreThe present applied research with meta-analysis method sought to combine research on the effect of constructivism-based education on students' academic performance in experimental sciences course. The field of research of the study consisted of available studies that have been disseminated in Iran and abroad for the past 15 years in the form of theses, scientific research articles, and scientific conferences at Iran research Institute for Information Science and Technology (Irandoc), The Scientific Information databases (Sid), Database of Iranian Publications (Magiran), Sivilica and scientific-research journals in the field of Educational Sciences and Psychology, Science Direct, ERICT, Psych info, Scopus, and Google Scholar. According to inclusion and exclusion criteria, 14 effect sizes were evaluated among 109 studies.Initial studies were used to analyze the combined effect size with two fixed and random effects models and to investigate Publication Bias by sensitivity analysis using Funnel plotand and statistical index of Safe of fail statistic and Q Cochran test and I-square to investigate heterogeneity were used and Fisher's Z-factor was used to convert the effect size. Combined effect size results were obtained for the random effects model (2.64). The results also showed that the variables of the type of tools and the type of interventions used are moderating the effectiveness of constructivist-based education on students' academic performance in experimental science course. The findings of this meta-analysis have strong theoretical and empirical support and warrant the necessity to review and apply constructivist-based education in the country's education system. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
27 - Meta-analysis of researches on relationship between coaches’ democratic leadership style with athletes’ satisfaction
Ali Zamani Nokaabadi mehrdad AfkhamiObjective: Coach leadership style can be defined as the process of influencing the individual and group trying to achieve goals. Democratic styles are behaviors that allow the athlete to participate in group decisions. The authoritarian style, on the other hand, involve MoreObjective: Coach leadership style can be defined as the process of influencing the individual and group trying to achieve goals. Democratic styles are behaviors that allow the athlete to participate in group decisions. The authoritarian style, on the other hand, involves the coach making independent decisions based on his personal authority. Athlete satisfaction is considered as a consequence or achievement of the coach's work in leadership research. The present study aims to quantitatively combine the results of research conducted in this field in the country.Methodology: The statistical population of the present study includes all articles on the relationship between democratic leadership style and athlete satisfaction and in order to collect the data needed for meta-analysis, a coding form was used. Using meta-analysis method and comprehensive meta-analysis software (CMA2), 7 articles were selected and reviewed. This study was performed using the effect size calculation technique. In this way, the statistical tests used in the hypotheses were analyzed after becoming the effect size. The statistical population of the present study included all articles on the relationship between democratic leadership style and athlete satisfaction. In this meta-analysis, the results of researches that have met the necessary conditions in terms of methodology have been studied. That is, articles and criteria within the treasure have been used. These criteria in the research are: 1 research has been done in Iran. 2 In the relevant research, leadership style and athletes' satisfaction have been used as an independent or dependent variable. 3 The research must have provided the necessary information for the practical extraction of the effect size (relationship strength). Therefore, the number of researches selected for meta-analysis is seven.Results: The results of meta-analysis showed that in all studies, democratic leadership style and satisfaction were effective, which software output with an average effect size of 0.25 confirms this issue and this amount of effect size is less than average. The funnel diagram also showed that there is a publication bias in the studies, which indicates that some studies have not been published or researchers do not have access to some articles or study results. The relationship between democratic leadership style and athlete satisfaction is below average. About 25% of the calculated effects are in the lower middle class (with an average effect size of 0.25).Conclusion: The findings of this meta-analysis showed that democratic leadership style and athlete satisfaction have an effect with an average effect size of 0.25. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
28 - Qualitative Meta-Analysis of Conducted Research on Verse 34 of Surah An-Nisa
Fatemeh Hajiakbari Sayed Mahdi RahmatiThe purpose of this research was the qualitative meta-analysis of the conducted researches on the verse 34 of Surah Nisa (chapter of women in the Holy Qur'an). The research universe included the scientific research articles published in the mentioned verse from 2001 to MoreThe purpose of this research was the qualitative meta-analysis of the conducted researches on the verse 34 of Surah Nisa (chapter of women in the Holy Qur'an). The research universe included the scientific research articles published in the mentioned verse from 2001 to 2018. The under investigation sample subsumed thirty-three selected research papers from different journals. The research was designed as descriptive- analytical qualitative meta-analysis. To collect data, first, the scientific research articles in the keywords related subject concerning the verse 34 of Surah Nisa , such as striking the women and the men ascendancy were searched and selected in Normagz, Alamnet, and Jama'i Enssani websites. Then the data were extracted. The results showed that most of the selected articles focused on the meaning of the male ascendancy. The most important components of the studies in the scope of verse 34 of Surah Nisa were in terms of the general principles regarding the meaning of striking, the conditions and way of doing it and its necessity or permissibility, the meaning and scope of the “neshuz”, the cultural and social conditions of the commentators in the perception of the verse and or the social historical contexts of the coming down from high on the Holy Qur'an mentioned verse era. The dispersion of the studies also showed that in the years 2015 and 2018 five articles were published apartly concerning the verse 34 of Nisa Sureh; which was the most frequent compared to other years in the statistical universe of the research. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
29 - a monolithic model for identifying innovation drivers among knowledge-based organizations.
mani shojaie Davoud Samari Roohalla Samiee zahra alipour darvishThe need for product innovation is necessary to compete in the domestic and global markets. On the other hand, the importance of new product development, as one of the revenues generating areas for companies and the country as well as identification of the necessary fac MoreThe need for product innovation is necessary to compete in the domestic and global markets. On the other hand, the importance of new product development, as one of the revenues generating areas for companies and the country as well as identification of the necessary factors and contexts for creating innovation capabilities has become a strategic requirement in the knowledge-based industries. In this article, we strived to identify the factors affecting the creation and strengthening of product innovation capabilities, while the relationship model between these factors is evaluated and proposed, which are the drivers of product innovation. For this purpose, we first investigated meta-analysis model among 52 effective international researches in the field of product innovation, among which 15 researches were selected. Then, the identified drivers were classified into six factors. The status of research variables was assessed through distribution of a carefully designed questionnaire among 250 people of the knowledge-based companies include employees, senior managers and middle managers. Their responses were analysed using structural equation modeling, confirmatory factor analysis and regression correlation test to prove the proposed research model. The Findings showed that three components of innovation culture, intra-organizational communication and knowledge management have an effect on product innovation in knowledge-based organizations, while three components of external communication, organizational structure, and intellectual capital have no effect. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
30 - Meta-Analysis of the Effect of Mental and Real Games on Mental Functions
هادی قاضی زادهIntroduction: Play is a part of human life from birth to death. Man needs thinking for his mental and social development and play is the basis of thinking. Therefore, purposeful planning of the game can be used to increase the functions of the mind. In fact, researchers MoreIntroduction: Play is a part of human life from birth to death. Man needs thinking for his mental and social development and play is the basis of thinking. Therefore, purposeful planning of the game can be used to increase the functions of the mind. In fact, researchers have discovered the potential cause of games to support learning, and have found that games have a positive effect on learning and mind function. The aim of this study was to integrate the research conducted in the field of the effect of games on mental functions and also to achieve a general result based on scattered results using statistical methods. Methods: The present study was conducted by meta-analysis method and with a systematic review of research conducted in this field. The statistical population includes 23 studies on the effect of games on mental functions that have been conducted over the past two decades. The total statistical sample size of the studies conducted in this meta-analysis is 1631 people, 100% of which included both sexes. In this study, the data was analyzed using a meta-analysis method and CMA software. Results: The findings of this meta-analysis indicated that the effect size of mental and real games on the mental function of consciousness and creativity has the greatest effect with the value of 0.653 and other mental functions are respectively language and memory with an effect size of 0.409 and thoughts, perceptions and imaginations with an effect size of 0.345, which get the least effect from mental and real games. Conclusion: The results of the present study indicated that both mental and real games are effective in increasing the mental functions of the citizens. Therefore, considering the importance of this issue, it seems that by playing these games, you can influence mental functions and provide success and increase these functions. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
31 - Identifying the antecedent elements of job satisfaction among the employees of sports and youth departments in the country with a meta-analysis approach
Arman Allahveisi Rasool Moradi hezari behzad izadiThe current research was conducted with the meta-analysis method and with the aim of integrating the researches of the factors affecting the job satisfaction of the employees of the sports and youth departments of the country. The statistical population of this research MoreThe current research was conducted with the meta-analysis method and with the aim of integrating the researches of the factors affecting the job satisfaction of the employees of the sports and youth departments of the country. The statistical population of this research is made up of existing researches that have been accessible in the form of articles in all text databases and university libraries between 2011 and 2022. These studies were selected purposefully and based on inclusion and exclusion criteria and sensitivity analysis, 32 effect sizes from 15 studies were examined. Based on CMA2 software the results of the combined effect size were obtained for the random effects model (0.32) and for the fixed effects model (0.26). Also, the highest significant effect size was equal to 0.72 related to the internal marketing variable and the lowest significant effect size was equal to 0.11 related to the leadership style variable. According to the findings obtained in this meta-analysis, it is suggested to strengthen the mentioned variables, especially internal marketing, human resources growth, reward system, appropriate moral atmosphere in programs to strengthen job satisfaction among sports and youth departments of the country. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
32 - Drivers and Barriers of creativity in the organization: Meta-analysis of Iranian studies
Fateme Motavalli Ali Yazkasti Zahra SadeqiaraniObjective: The aim of this study is investigation the individual factors affecting creativity in Iranian organizations by meta-analysis.Method: The present study is a meta-analysis. CAM2 software has been used for this purpose. In the initial search with the inclusion c MoreObjective: The aim of this study is investigation the individual factors affecting creativity in Iranian organizations by meta-analysis.Method: The present study is a meta-analysis. CAM2 software has been used for this purpose. In the initial search with the inclusion criteria of the research year and the language, 1687 related documents were found from the studied databases. After that, 77 researches were selected and entered into the meta-analysis process.Findings: The findings show that at the 95% confidence level, individual factors have a significant effect on organizational creativity and have been able to explain 0.467% of changes in organizational creativity. Also, the results of the heterogeneity test indicate that there is a heterogeneity between the studies, which is why the random effect size has been used. The funnel diagram also indicates that the standard error is low and the bias is relatively low, in fact, it indicates a normal and random distribution, and the observed error is due to possible oblique types. Conclusion: According to the research findings, among the individual factors affecting creativity in Organization Independence with effect size (0.714), feeling of effectiveness with effect size (0.660), significant feeling with effect size (0.647) And constructive thinking strategies with effect size (0.749) had the highest effect size and a significant relationship with organizational creativity. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
33 - The Meta-Analysis of Variables Associated with Creativity
Kamran Ganji Saeideh Taghavi fataneh AzimiAim: The aim of this research was to study the variables associated with creativity in Iran. Method: The research method chosen was meta-analysis in which all research reports were collected by using internal and external information data bank. Some twelve studies from MoreAim: The aim of this research was to study the variables associated with creativity in Iran. Method: The research method chosen was meta-analysis in which all research reports were collected by using internal and external information data bank. Some twelve studies from throughout of Iran (2004-2013) involving some 3015 participants were used in this meta-analysis. Data were analyzed using Pearson coefficient effect size method for fixed effect model. All statistical operations accomplished by Comprehensive Meta-Analysis, Version 2.0. Results: results showed that the mean of mixed- model of effect size was 0/496 for fixed effect model and 0/497 for random effect model in which both were significant in 0/001 level. The mean of mixed- model of effect size (0/496) in this research showed the moderate to high on creativity. Conclusions: Also the results showed that there is significant effect size between cognitive styles, internal and external motivation, gender, emotional intelligence, epistemological believes, dimensions of goal direction, mental well-being, personality characters, teacher’s activity and characteristics, intelligence, age, parent’s marital satisfaction, critical thinking, happiness, thinking styles, and direction goal with creativity. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
34 - Meta-analysis of Creativity Fostering Techniques
Touraj hashemi shahram vahedi Ghafour ahrariBackground: Creativity has an important role in everybody’s life. Progress and change has no meaning without creativity. Creative skills in today’s rapid changing world are not retractable. Purpose: Many of researchers tried to foster creat MoreBackground: Creativity has an important role in everybody’s life. Progress and change has no meaning without creativity. Creative skills in today’s rapid changing world are not retractable. Purpose: Many of researchers tried to foster creativity and gained different results. The total effect size of these findings and subcategories of creativity, and other variables are examined in this paper. In another way, this article is going to meta-analyze creativity promoting techniques. Method: To achieve these purposes, the researchers searched informational banks on the net, magazines, and theses, based on special criterion. A total number of 28 articles had been analyzed with CMV.2 software. Result(s): The total effect size of 0.789 based on random model, according to Cohn’s scale, shows a large effect size. The statistic of Q (df=,27) = 221.481, (p<0.0001), indicates that there should be some moderator variables. So, age, gender, time, technique and instrumental of scales were examined by ANOVA and regression tests. Conclusion: Based on these results, we can confide the effectiveness of these techniques, but there was no significant effect of moderator variables. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
35 - فراتحلیل عوامل موثر بر کارآفرینی در سازمان های ورزشیایران
فریده شریفی فر فریبا محمدیان فروزان شریفی فر -
Open Access Article
36 - A Meta-Analysis of the Influential Factors in Job Stress among Islamic Azad University Staff
لیلا Bakhashi-sorshjaniUndoubtedly, job stress plays a key role in the decline and burnout of the human resources in organizations. One problem associated with our contemporary modern life is the appearance of job stress in terms of the work environment. Meta-analysis creates a better underst MoreUndoubtedly, job stress plays a key role in the decline and burnout of the human resources in organizations. One problem associated with our contemporary modern life is the appearance of job stress in terms of the work environment. Meta-analysis creates a better understanding of the similarities and dissimilarities of the previous studies conducted in this field and hence allows for a more comprehensive perspective on the research subject. In the present study, the previous studies on the job stress have been classified in terms of such criteria as statistical society, the involved variables, and type of job, and finally 12 studies have been selected as the statistical society of the research. In our proposed meta-analysis, for investigation of the magnitude of the effect of the independent variables on the job stress, the criteria for the effect size of coefficients r and d of Cohen have been used. Our findings show that the variables for age (d = 0.49), gender (d = 0.56), and job experience (d = 0.35) have an intermediate importance in the amount of job stress. Besides, variables for organizational atmosphere (d = 0.62), organizational justice (d = 0.98), work ethic (d = 0.95), and job satisfaction (d = 0.8), each of which used in a separate study, have great importance in determination of the amount of job stress. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
37 - Meta-analysis of the relevance between quality of work life and Job Satisfaction on Iran‘s organizations
Seyed Mehdi Veyse Jafar Abbaspour Heydar AbbaspourQuality of work life has an important impact on the job satisfaction. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to provide a meta-analytic examination of the relationships between Quality of work life and job satisfaction. For this purpose, nine of which were acceptable i MoreQuality of work life has an important impact on the job satisfaction. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to provide a meta-analytic examination of the relationships between Quality of work life and job satisfaction. For this purpose, nine of which were acceptable in terms of methodological choice and meta-analysis was performed on them. This paper, using meta-analysis method and Comprehensive Meta-Analysis Software (CMA2), aggregated the findings of articles. Results, based on 1940 participants, indicated that Quality of work life and job satisfaction is above averageThis paper, using meta-analysis method and Comprehensive Meta-Analysis Software (CMA2), aggregated the findings of articles. Results, based on 1940 participants, indicated that Quality of work life and job satisfaction is above average (mean effect size 0/57). Among the dimensions of quality of work life, quality of work life was strongly correlated with the social cohesion (0/507), the development of human capabilities (0/495), overall living space (0/484), but the correlation of safe working environment with the job satisfaction (0/337) was less. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
38 - Qualitative meta-analysis of research on the context and factors of changes in the Iranian family
Hamed Nazari Mohammad Ganji Assadollah Babaei FardThe Iranian family has undergone many changes in recent decades. These changes have occurred in different aspects of the family including household size, marriage and divorce rates, the purpose of marriage, and so on. The aim of this study is to investigate the factors MoreThe Iranian family has undergone many changes in recent decades. These changes have occurred in different aspects of the family including household size, marriage and divorce rates, the purpose of marriage, and so on. The aim of this study is to investigate the factors affecting family changes based on existing research in this area. The methodology of this study includes qualitative meta-analysis and systematic review. The target group is all research that has been published in the form of thesis and research papers. Data coding and analysis is done using MAXQDA software. In order to achieve the purpose of the present research, 57 studies in Iran from 2001 onwards were studied. Besides descriptive analysis, the reviewed documents were evaluated in different aspects. The findings of this study indicate that there are three main factors led to changes in the Iranian family: 1. The education and employment of women has promoted their status in the family power hierarchy; 2. Modernization processes have caused changes in the value system of the Iranian family. ; 3. The socio-economic status of the family affects the values of its members. At the end of the study, a critical conclusion and evaluation of the existing knowledge in the field of family studies in Iran have been presented and the weak points in this area that require further research are identified. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
39 - Me-analysis of the studies conducted about collective conflicts
Samad Abedini Jafar Ebrahimi Parvin GolizadeConflict in the society is a type of damage which disrupts social relations and creates a space filled with hatred and enmity among people. This will pave the ground for future conflicts and tensions and damage the society materially and spiritually. The present meta-an MoreConflict in the society is a type of damage which disrupts social relations and creates a space filled with hatred and enmity among people. This will pave the ground for future conflicts and tensions and damage the society materially and spiritually. The present meta-analysis is an attempt to reanalyze a series of pathological studies in the field of affecting factors in collective conflict. This study is a meta-analysis and correlative, and the method of the study is descriptive. Seven conducted studies about collective conflict have been used in this study. Study of the primary sources on the subject, is the main tool of gathering information in this study. After changing the variables and estimating the effect size, Hedges method was used. The effect sizes have interpreted on the base of Cohen's study (1977). Findings of the study show that the effect of age, gender, socio-economic situation and different factors such as (aggression, deprivation, anomie, cultural differences, property disputes, ethnic and tribal belongings) and education are different in tending to collective conflict. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
40 - Metatheorizing in social sciences
Abbas Lotfizadeh Reza Ebrahimi Islam EbrahimiThe concept of metatheory in the social sciences literature has emerged under various labels such as meta-sociology, reflexive sociology, and sociology of sociology. The purpose of this paper is to introduce and analyze sociological metatheory. This paper is based on th MoreThe concept of metatheory in the social sciences literature has emerged under various labels such as meta-sociology, reflexive sociology, and sociology of sociology. The purpose of this paper is to introduce and analyze sociological metatheory. This paper is based on the study of the major works of metatheory proponents and critical discussions of its opponents. The paper reviews meta-theory definitions and provides a clear definition of it. Also, the relationship of metatheory with the concept of reflexivity is considered and the benefits of metatheory and criticisms against it are raised. Many sociologists and theorists have stressed the need for the development of social theory. Since metatheory is an effective step in enriching theories, more attention should be devoted to this area. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
41 - A Meta-Analysis of the Relationship between Social Support and Academic Performance
Emad Aldin Ahrari Javad Mesrabadi Seysd Qasem MoslehSocial support as a relevant and effective variable on academic performance has been investigated in many studies, and the different and sometimes contradictory results of these studies highlight the necessity of a meta-analytical study. This study aimed to combine the MoreSocial support as a relevant and effective variable on academic performance has been investigated in many studies, and the different and sometimes contradictory results of these studies highlight the necessity of a meta-analytical study. This study aimed to combine the findings of 12 years of Iranian and international investigations which had studied the relationship between social support and academic performance. The statistical population included Iranian and internationally published and available studies related to the subject from 2009-2021. Based on the inclusion and exclusion criteria, 55 studies and 101 effect sizes were selected. Finally, after sensitivity analysis and removal of extreme effect sizes, 79 effect sizes were analyzed. The results showed that the combined effect size was 0.189 for the fixed model and 0.220 for the random model. In this study, gender and age were studied as qualitative and quantitative moderator variables, respectively. The results showed that there was no significant difference in the effect sizes of the relationship between social support and academic performance based on gender. The meta-regression results also showed that by increasing the age mean, the effect size decreases to a very small significant amount and a small part of the total heterogeneity is explained by the age mean of the initial studies. As a result, based on obtained effect size, social support is effective in increasing students' academic performance. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
42 - Meta-Analysis of the Relationship between Learning Styles and Students' Academic Achievement
negar ostovarResearch shows that one of the individual characteristics of learners that affects the educational interventions effectiveness is the learning style of learners. Learning styles is one of the interesting research fields in behavioral sciences; Therefore, due to the incr MoreResearch shows that one of the individual characteristics of learners that affects the educational interventions effectiveness is the learning style of learners. Learning styles is one of the interesting research fields in behavioral sciences; Therefore, due to the increasing amount of research in the learning styles field, it is necessary to conduct combined research in this field. This research was carried out by the meta-analysis method with the aim of numerically combining the quantitative results of researches in this field. The research population is all post-graduate theses and articles in the field of the relationship between learning styles and academic achievement indicators in the country between 1371 and 1401 years. From the initial 189 studies, 98 cases were included in the meta-analysis based on the inclusion and exclusion criteria, and 384 effect sizes were obtained from these studies. The results showed that the summary effect size of learning styles with academic achievement was .19, although subsequent analyzes showed that the effect size is different in learning styles various. The largest effect size is related to Jackson's style profile and the smallest effect size is related to Fleming's styles with academic achievement indicators. The implications of this meta-analysis show the relatively low impact of learning styles on academic achievement and emphasize the need to investigate the role of mediating variables in the relationship between these two variables. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
43 - A Meta-analysis of Gender Interaction on the Effectiveness of Cooperative and Group Discussion Methods
Ayoub Feyzi Javad Mesr AbadiThe population of this meta-analysis were the available related studies done between 1370-1392 in the country, including full-text articles, theses and research projects in the databases and libraries, universities or government agencies. Based on the inclusion exclusio MoreThe population of this meta-analysis were the available related studies done between 1370-1392 in the country, including full-text articles, theses and research projects in the databases and libraries, universities or government agencies. Based on the inclusion exclusion criteria as well as sensitivity analysis, almost 323 effect size from about researches were investigated. The results of the combined effects of gender differences on the effectiveness of cooperative and discussion methods in random model for girls and boys was 0.665 and 0.589, respectively, which were both statistically significant effect sizes. Based on Cohen's criteria, we can say that the effectiveness of these methods for male and female students is average and desirable. Also, the independent t-test results showed that there is no statistically significant difference between the effect size means of boys and girls although the effect size for girls was greater. So, as suggested by the theoretical foundations of these teaching methods, these methods are not limited to a particular ability level or sex but all who are engaged in can benefit from these methods Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
44 - A comparison between male and female students in self-efficacy meta-analysis
Masoomeh Ghaedrahmati Masoud Asadi Asghar ShiralipourThis research using one of the new research methods namely meta-analysis tealt with analyzing and combining the results of researches were done in connection with self-efficacy in research centers in Iran. The statistical population was 25 researches. These researches w MoreThis research using one of the new research methods namely meta-analysis tealt with analyzing and combining the results of researches were done in connection with self-efficacy in research centers in Iran. The statistical population was 25 researches. These researches were chosen based on research methodology components such as questions, hypotheses, aims, statistical population, sampling method, research method, validity, reliability and questionnaires. Statistical analysis was done through comprehensive meta-analysis software. Using Schmidt and Hunter method for combining the effect of size on self-efficacy, the results showed that there was a significant difference between male and female students. The male's effect of size was more than those of female ones. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
45 - A Meta-Analysis of the Relationship between Emotional Intelligence and Academic Achievement in Persian Speakers Databases
Seyyed Mohammad Seyyed Kalan Sadegh Maleki Avarsin Hosien NajafiGiven the importance of emotional intelligence in academic achievement, the purpose of this study is a meta-analysis of the studies which were conducted on the relationship between emotional intelligence and academic achievement. Through meta-analysis method, this study MoreGiven the importance of emotional intelligence in academic achievement, the purpose of this study is a meta-analysis of the studies which were conducted on the relationship between emotional intelligence and academic achievement. Through meta-analysis method, this study integrates the results of various studies and then determines the effect size of the relationship between emotional intelligence and academic achievement. The population composed of all the research done up to 1392/4/20. Through the non-probabilistic targeted sampling method, 16 research documents were selected as the research samples. The research tool for the study was meta-analysis checklist. Meta-analysis method used in this study was bead on the Hunter and Schmidtʼs approach to model-based interpretation of the Cohen model. The results showed a significant relationship between emotional intelligence and academic achievement since the effect size of the relationship between emotional intelligence and academic achievement, (432.0), was above average, interpreted according to Cohen. It can be concluded that higher emotional intelligence has a significant correlation with academic achievement. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
46 - The Relationship between Intellectual Capital and Human Resource Productivity: A Meta-Analysis Study
Forouzan Safari Ojgaz Hassan RangrizThis applied qualitative meta-analysis study explored the relationship between intellectual capital and human resource productivity. The research population comprised 50 dissertations, thesis and articles out of which a sample of 13 was purposefully selected to be analy MoreThis applied qualitative meta-analysis study explored the relationship between intellectual capital and human resource productivity. The research population comprised 50 dissertations, thesis and articles out of which a sample of 13 was purposefully selected to be analyzed. Expert consensus was employed to verify the identification reliability of the selection, categorization of the research data and the reliability of the coding system used. The significance and effect size reliability was checked via expert agreement of two meta-analyzers on effect size calculation. The results of the met-analysis revealed that intellectual capital was correlated with human resource productivity as a moderator variable. It was also found that among the 26 effect size figures calculated, 15 were high (< 0.5), four were low (from 0.1 to 0.3) and 7 were medium (from 0.3 to 0.5). Also, the results indicated that structural and human dimensions had respectively the greatest effect size with regard to their relationship with human resource productivity. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
47 - A Meta-Analysis of Human Resource Productivity Antecedents
Yousef Vakili Hamed KhamehchiThe present study set out to identify the human resource productivity antecedents conducting a meta- analysis. This applied study employed a quantitative descriptive research design. The study corpus consisted of articles published in scientific journals in the fi MoreThe present study set out to identify the human resource productivity antecedents conducting a meta- analysis. This applied study employed a quantitative descriptive research design. The study corpus consisted of articles published in scientific journals in the field of human resource productivity within the period from 2011 to 2019, among which 48 articles were recruited through a non- random purposive sampling procedure and underwent the meta-analysis. The selected studies were analyzed using CMA2 (Comprehensive Meta-Analysis Software) software. The reliability of the selection procedure and categorization of the studies as well as the reliability of using specific concepts for coding the variables were both confirmed by the examiners. Moreover, the reliability of the significance level and effect size were obtained through the agreement in measuring the effect size by two analysts. The findings revealed that among the antecedents of human resource productivity, emotional intelligence (0.767), organizational entrepreneurship (0.761), talent management (0.728), self-discipline (0.720), job motivation (0.705), organizational health (0.691), career advancement (0.652), effective leadership (0.635), quality of work life (0.632), job autonomy (0.623), employee creativity (0.618), organizational agility (0.618), information and communication technology (0.585), organizational trust (0.581), knowledge management (0.563), social responsibility (0.548), and social capital (0.523) had high effect sizes (above 0.5), respectively. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
48 - A Meta-analysis of the Pathological Perspective in Regional Documentary Studies Based on the Area Level
maryam Sejodi keramatollah ziari majid yasoori ahmad PourahmadPathological view of controversial issues such as the regional sphere in which different sciences and attitudes are involved in its conceptual, functional, and executive foundations is very important. For this purpose, the present study aims to have a meta-analysis of t MorePathological view of controversial issues such as the regional sphere in which different sciences and attitudes are involved in its conceptual, functional, and executive foundations is very important. For this purpose, the present study aims to have a meta-analysis of the pathological view in internal documentary studies based on the level of the region. Work process at the level of documents such as upstream documents and reports, some published and unpublished drafts, provincial cover projects, among doctoral dissertations and master theses and articles (scientific research, extension science, and journal conference) relied on two phases; The first stage is based on the method of documentary methods and collection of primary and secondary sources and documents (categorized damages) and the second stage is based on meta-analysis methods, content analysis, and grounded theory (obvious and hidden case damages). The obtained results show that in the first stage, the most important results of categorized damages have an emphasis on document approach, method and procedure, area management, economic issues, concepts and ideas, practical field and implementation, and in the second stage among the 54 types of research in the field of the nature of research with the highest frequency with 42 cases with applied research, in the field of research method with the highest frequency with 25 cases with survey-field, in the field of data collection techniques with the highest frequency equal to 27 cases were resulted based on a questionnaire. Also, 31 cases had the reliability of measuring instruments, of which 27 cases had an average between 0.7 and 0.9. Also, 43 of them had research hypotheses or questions, and finally, considering the use of the majority of research from an analytical framework, the application of the nature of research in the use of theories shows that most research studies, or 48 of them, are only based on theory testing and the rest of them have been a kind of theory testing supported by providing models and suggestions. Thus they can be included in the theory-based research; however, they did not fully have the policy and principles of fundamental and theoretical research. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
49 - A meta-analysis of women's political and social participation in the last 4 decades
reza fazel sara ebrahimi hamid ansariThe purpose of this study is to meta-analyze the political and social participation of women in the last 4 decades. The aim of this study was to quantitatively and qualitatively combine the results of research conducted in socio-political participation to determine the MoreThe purpose of this study is to meta-analyze the political and social participation of women in the last 4 decades. The aim of this study was to quantitatively and qualitatively combine the results of research conducted in socio-political participation to determine the factors affecting political and social participation and the intensity of the impact of each of them on these variables through the intensity coefficient. The impact should be calculated and the most effective factors on participation should be identified. Therefore, this study has been carried out using the documentary research method, by taking notes from the published study in this field. Findings indicated that the variables of political effectiveness, feeling of legal inequality, political awareness, social and economic status, self-confidence, age, mass media, stereotypes, women's employment, marital status, feeling of gender inequality, sociability, Traditional beliefs and literacy levels are considered as more effective barriers to women's social and political participation, respectively. As a result, these barriers have led to the low presence of women in limited cases, and by removing these barriers and changing misconceptions and the proper education and socialization of women and girls from an early age, they must be promoted to high political positions and Socially prepared. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
50 - Meta-analysis of voluntary and mandatory disclosure of financial and non-financial information on market reaction
shiva zamani majid zanjirdar ali lalbarThe present research aims to conduct meta-analysis of the effect of information disclosure on market reaction. In order to integrate the results of different researches and identify the determinants of relations between information disclosure and market reaction, we use MoreThe present research aims to conduct meta-analysis of the effect of information disclosure on market reaction. In order to integrate the results of different researches and identify the determinants of relations between information disclosure and market reaction, we used meta-analysis methodology as a quantitative statistical method. In order to implement the meta-analysis method, from the website of foreign journals (published articles related to research variables from 1990 to 2020 and the website of domestic scientific research journals (published articles related to research variables from 1370 to 1399) to They were identified and collected as a statistical population of the research and finally 86 studies have been analyzed by systematic elimination method; The results of studies conducted in the mentioned period and around this relationship, using I2 and Q tests indicate that most of these studies are heterogeneous. In order to identify the cause of this heterogeneity, by dividing the research based on different criteria for measuring information disclosure and market reaction and calculating statistics within the group, we found that these different measurement criteria used in research is one of the contradictory factors in research results. In the following study, observation of mandatory disclosure of financial and non-financial information as well as voluntary disclosure of financial information has a significant and positive relationship with market reaction. Information that voluntary disclosure of non-financial information has no effect on the capital market.. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
51 - Meta-analysis of the effect of virtual networks and professional development )Case study of student-teachers of Farhangian University of Hamadan)
zohreh roghanian fatemeh moradiThe purpose of this study is to meta-analyze the research conducted on the effect of social networks on the professional development of students of Farhangian University of Hamadan. The method of this research is meta-analysis. Statistical community, all articles in sci MoreThe purpose of this study is to meta-analyze the research conducted on the effect of social networks on the professional development of students of Farhangian University of Hamadan. The method of this research is meta-analysis. Statistical community, all articles in scientific databases, Civilica; Normagz, S.I.D., humanities and articles indexed in journals, between 1300-1400, which were selected from among the works done 34 and after studies, 21 studies were selected due to having the necessary information. . In order to collect the required data, no diffusion bias, heterogeneity, effect size were investigated. Sensitivity and effect size were evaluated using CMA software. The results showed that the size of the virtual network effect is at three levels: high, medium and low. The highest effect size (0.597 and 0.562) is the average effect size (0.329,0.393,0.422) and the lowest effect size (0.195,0.148). Accordingly, there is a significant relationship between virtual networks and the development of the student-teacher profession. And this confirms the impact of virtual networks on the development of student-teacher careers in universities. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
52 - Examine the Meta-analysis Effect of Violent and Non-violent Games on Aggressive Feelings and Behaviours
Ahmad Ali Jadidian Hassan Pasha Sharifi Hamzeh GanjiMany researches had done regarding the effects of video and computer games on aggressive feelings and behaviours which showed disparate results. Therefore, the purpose of the present research is to examine the meta-analysis effect of violent and non-violent games on agg MoreMany researches had done regarding the effects of video and computer games on aggressive feelings and behaviours which showed disparate results. Therefore, the purpose of the present research is to examine the meta-analysis effect of violent and non-violent games on aggressive feelings and behaviours. The statistical population included all researches related publish in English and Persian done from 2002 up to 2012. The sampling method was a targeted one to make the required comparisons possible for answering research questions. That is, the comparison of the degree of effect between experimental and non-experimental researches, between violent and non-violent games and to study the effect of increasing the amount of time of computer games on the degree of aggression. Having evaluated the accuracy and strength of researches by consulting three judges, 30 researches were selected for final study. Researches were classified into experimental and non-experimental ones, and the games were also divided into violent and non-violent ones. The results showed that the degree of effect for three variables was 0/21 for aggressive behaviour, 0/23 for aggressive feelings, and 0/29 for biological arousal. By comparing experimental with non-experimental researches, the obtained degree of effect was meaningful. That is, experimental researches showed more effect degree. By increasing the duration of game, the effect degree reduced in all three mentioned dependent variable, and the amount of effect degree was more in violent games than non-violent ones. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
53 - Meta-Analysis on the Impact of ICT on Teachers' Professional Development
Ali Khalkhali Zohreh Shakibaei Mehdi AndeshThe purpose of this research was a meta-analysis of the previously done researches on the impact of ICT on the status of teachers in order to estimate the actual effect size of the ICT on professional development of teachers. The population was all the researches on the MoreThe purpose of this research was a meta-analysis of the previously done researches on the impact of ICT on the status of teachers in order to estimate the actual effect size of the ICT on professional development of teachers. The population was all the researches on the impact of ICT on teachers in Iran, by the end of 2010. Among the researches done, nine of them having suitable characteristics for the application of meta-analysis were selected through purposeful sampling method. The research instrument was a check list for the selection of researches from technical and methodological aspects. The preferential meta-analysis model consists of the mixed approach of Hunter and Smith. Also, Cohen’s approach was used for the interpretation of research findings. The findings showed that the use of ICT had significant impact on the professional development of teachers. In addition, the degree of effect of the ICT on professional development of teachers was 0/387 which is above average based on the interpretation indexes. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
54 - Factors Related to Immigrants’ Social and Cultural Adjustment in Urban Environments: Accomplished Research using Meta-analysis Method
mohsen safarian Ali moradiThe aim of this study was to investigate the immigrants’ social and cultural adjustment factors in urban environments of Iran using meta-analysis method. The document research method is text-content analysis. The statistical population of the study is research pu MoreThe aim of this study was to investigate the immigrants’ social and cultural adjustment factors in urban environments of Iran using meta-analysis method. The document research method is text-content analysis. The statistical population of the study is research published in scientific journals in Iran for a period of 22 years from 1999 to 2022, related to the social and cultural adjustment of immigrants; among them, 25 studies were analyzed from the indexed scientific databases of Jihad Daneshgahi, specialized journals of NoorMags and the database of the country's publications. In the analytical part, first, the statistical presuppositions of expectation bias and homogeneity of the studies were evaluated and then the hypotheses were examined. The results show that five sets of factors including social, economic, cultural, demographic, and psychological were identified in this study, each of which has been studied using several variables. The confidence interval reported by this set of factors ranges from the confidence interval (-0.039 and 0.215) which is related to economic factors rather than the high confidence interval, scope (0.275 to 0.614) as well as the positive value of Z2 number. It can be concluded that demographic factors with an impact factor of 0.510 have the highest adaptability and psychological factors with a minimum level of impact factor with a value of 0.293 have the least impact on the process of social and cultural adjustment of immigrants. Besides, all factors with at least 95% Confidence Interval have a positive effect on immigrants’ social and cultural adjustment. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
55 - Meta-analysis of the relationship between cultural capital and leisure time: based on a systematic review
Ehsan Sanatkar Mohsen Niazi Ayoub SakhaeiSo far, several researches have been conducted on the relationship between cultural capital and leisure time, especially in the theoretical framework of Bourdieu. For this purpose, all the researches that were published in the 90s in reliable quarterly journals were ext MoreSo far, several researches have been conducted on the relationship between cultural capital and leisure time, especially in the theoretical framework of Bourdieu. For this purpose, all the researches that were published in the 90s in reliable quarterly journals were extracted and analyzed in 5 levels with the system review method. Mend was examined and finally, based on the specified criteria, 11 works were selected and used in the meta-analysis process. In the initial stage, the assumptions of homogeneity and publication bias were checked, and after the tests, the heterogeneity and lack of publication bias were confirmed, and then the data were evaluated by CMA software. The findings of the current research show that the effect size of cultural capital and leisure time is 0.470, which is in the medium range based on Cohen's effect size interpretation system. Also, audience and education variables were considered as moderating variables and it was determined that the effect size coefficient in citizens (0.497) is more than youth (0.413) and in non-students (0.535) more than those studying (0.270). In fact, the findings show that the relationship of two variables with the adjustment of citizens and non-productive people can have different effects on each other. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
56 - A Meta-analysis of the relationship between cultural capital and leisure time: based on a systematic review
Mohsen Niazi Ehsan Sanatkar Ayoub SakhaeiSo far, much research has been conducted on the relationship between cultural capital and leisure time, especially in the theoretical framework of Bourdieu. For this purpose, all the researches that were published in the 90s in reliable quarterly journals were extracted MoreSo far, much research has been conducted on the relationship between cultural capital and leisure time, especially in the theoretical framework of Bourdieu. For this purpose, all the researches that were published in the 90s in reliable quarterly journals were extracted and analyzed in 5 levels with a systematic review method and finally, on the basis of the specified criteria, 11 works were selected and used in the meta-analysis process. In the initial stage, the assumptions of homogeneity and publication bias were checked, and after the tests, the heterogeneity and lack of publication bias were confirmed, and then the data were evaluated by CMA software. The findings of the current research showed that the effect size of cultural capital and leisure time is 0.470, which on the basis of Cohen's effect size interpretation system, is in the medium range. Also, audience and education variables were considered as moderating variables and it was determined that the coefficient of effect size among residents (0.497) was more than that of youth (0.413) and among non-students (0.535) was more than that of students (0.270). In fact, the findings showed that the relationship of the two variables with the adjustment of citizens and non- students can have different effects on each other. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
57 - A Meta-analysis Method of Factors Related to Immigrants’ Social and Cultural Adjustment in Urban Environments
Mohsen Safarian Ali MoradiOne of the main subjects that immigrants in metropolitan areas are involved with is the social and cultural adjustment to the target country and how they come along with their culture. Many studies have been done in this field. The aim of this study was to investigate w MoreOne of the main subjects that immigrants in metropolitan areas are involved with is the social and cultural adjustment to the target country and how they come along with their culture. Many studies have been done in this field. The aim of this study was to investigate what factors influence immigrants’ social and cultural adjustment in urban environments of Iran using a meta-analysis method. The theoretical framework of the research was provided through an integration of views concerning socio-cultural and psychological adjustment. Text-content analysis of documentary research method was used to collect that data. The research population of the study consisted of research papers published in scientific journals in Iran for a period of 22 years from 1999 to 2022, which were related to the social and cultural adjustment of immigrants; of which 25 studies were analyzed from the indexed scientific databases of Jihad Daneshgahi, specialized journals of NoorMags and the database of the country's publications. The data collection technique was a reverse questionnaire and the evaluators’ questions in the questionnaire. Statistical analysis were performed using CMA2 statistical software. To analyze the obtained data, a brief description of the studies and their characteristics was elaborated at first. In the analytical part, first, the statistical presuppositions of expectation bias and homogeneity of the studies were evaluated and then the hypotheses were examined. The results showed that five sets of factors including social, economic, cultural, demographic, and psychological were identified, each of which was studied using several variables. The confidence interval reported by this set of factors ranged from the confidence interval (-0.039 and 0.215) which is related to economic factors to the high confidence interval, scope (0.275 to 0.614) as well as the positive value of Z2 number. There is a direct and positive relationship between the components of various factors and the socio-cultural adaptation of immigrants. It can be concluded that demographic factors with an impact factor of 0.510 have the highest impact and psychological factors with a minimum level of impact factor with a value of 0.293 have the least impact on the process of social and cultural adjustment of immigrants. Besides, all factors with at least 95% Confidence Interval have a positive effect on immigrants’ social and cultural adjustment. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
58 - فراتحلیل مطالعات پیشگیری از جرم از طریق طراحی محیطی (CPTED) در داخل
یدالله صادقی ابوالفضل مشکینی محسن کلانتری بهمن کارگر عبدالرضا رکن الدین افتخاری -
Open Access Article
59 - The Meta-Analysis of the Relationship between the Internet and social loneliness
Mohsen niazi Mahdi Karsanji Ayyoub sakhaei seyyed saied hoseynizade araniBackground and Objectives: Several studies have been conducted on the relationship between the Internet and social loneliness among different groups based on different methods. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to use a meta-analysis method to analyze and combine MoreBackground and Objectives: Several studies have been conducted on the relationship between the Internet and social loneliness among different groups based on different methods. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to use a meta-analysis method to analyze and combine the results of face studies about the connection between the Internet and social isolation. Methodology: In order to carry out the current meta-analysis, 12 related studies were conducted in the years 1380 to 1395 with the aim of assessing the relationship between the Internet and social isolation and published in prestigious quarterly papers. Were chosen. Selected research by survey method and application of survey tools in society various surveys have been conducted on the basis of putative measures. In the first step, the evaluation of selected studies of homogeneity assumptions and dissemination errors was investigated, which resulted in the heterogeneity of the size of the effect and the non-bias of the published studies. At the stage second, the coefficient of effect size and the role of moderating variable of gender were evaluated using the second version of CMA software. Results: The findings showed that the effect size or Internet impact factor on social isolation was equivalent (0.214), which, according to Cohen's interpretation system, has a low impact. Also, considering the gender as a moderating variable, this coefficient was evaluated for men (0. 539) higher than women (0.246). Conclusion: Overall, the results of the research showed that the Internet is affecting social isolation. Although this is more than men in men. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
60 - Investigating organizational transparency studies in scientific articles of the last 10 years with meta-analysis method
fuad makvandi Maryam IsvandAbstractBackground and purpose: Today, sharing organizational information with employees in order to create transparency, trust and responsibility means organizational transparency. The aim of this research is to investigate organizational transparency studies in scient MoreAbstractBackground and purpose: Today, sharing organizational information with employees in order to create transparency, trust and responsibility means organizational transparency. The aim of this research is to investigate organizational transparency studies in scientific articles of the last 10 years using meta-analysis method.Research method: This research is practical in terms of purpose. The statistical sample of 30 articles is completely matched and suitable for meta-analysis of the research topic, 10 Latin articles and 20 Persian articles were used. In this regard, the research results were analyzed using the meta-analysis method with the help of software (CAM).Findings: The findings showed the most important variables affecting organizational transparency that had a high intensity of effect, including response to crisis and interactive efforts, organizational culture, authentic leadership and organizational accountability, and the most important variables influencing organizational transparency that had a medium or high intensity of effect, including prevention Financial administrative corruption, job satisfaction and intention to quit, organizational strength, job adaptability, organizational trauma management, organizational paranoid, employee trust, and employee moral behavior were among them.Conclusion: The effective factors identified to promote organizational transparency should be taken into consideration by managers of organizations so that they can achieve the effective factors of organizational transparency in their organization. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
61 - Meta-analysis of the studies done on job satisfaction of university staff
omidali hosinzadeh nasser hagirianThe purpose of the present study was to investigate the extent to which studies were done on job satisfaction of university staff. The method of research is meta-analysis and the statistical population includes studies conducted in the period from 2011 to 2016 internall MoreThe purpose of the present study was to investigate the extent to which studies were done on job satisfaction of university staff. The method of research is meta-analysis and the statistical population includes studies conducted in the period from 2011 to 2016 internally and from 2010 to 2016 abroad as a full text article in internal databases (Noormags, Magiran and SID), and foreign (Pub-Med) were available. In order to collect information, a checklist of the characteristics of research projects was used. After analyzing the criteria for entering and leaving and also analyzing the sensitivity of 20, the effect size of the study with meta-analysis conditions was obtained. In order to analyze the data, sensitivity analysis, Funnel analysis, fixed and random models and heterogeneity analysis using CMA software were used. Data analysis of the research showed that the job satisfaction of the university staff varies from year to year. So, after removing the six size effects of the effect, the amount of combined effect size for the random effects model (the model selected for this meta-analysis) was 0.67, which was statistically significant. Also, job satisfaction of employees varies according to sampling methods, but there is no difference in gender. Regarding the results of meta-analysis, it can be said that job satisfaction of university staff is very important and attention can be made by the authorities in this regard. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
62 - Meta-analysis of the relationship between Social Capital and Knowledge Management
hajar ZareiObjective: The purpose of this research is to determine the relationship between social capital and knowledge management in Iran. Methods: The present study is applied in a quantitative and survey method. The target community of research is the articles published in sci MoreObjective: The purpose of this research is to determine the relationship between social capital and knowledge management in Iran. Methods: The present study is applied in a quantitative and survey method. The target community of research is the articles published in scientific publications and international and national conferences in Persian language. Articles that include methodologically, hypotheses and research questions, and the method of analyzing the assumptions of the criteria in the meta-analysis were chosen. So, 27 articles with the desired characteristics comprise the statistical population of the study. Data analysis is meta-analysis using CMA2 software to measure the effect size of the assumptions. Results: Findings in the size of the effect of 15 hypotheses show that in the dimension of social capital, cognitive dimension is 0.644, communication dimension is 0.493, and structural dimension with 0.416, respectively, in knowledge management. In the dimension of knowledge management, knowledge acquisition with 0.287 is the least and the later cultural factor with 0.935 more with social capital and accepts most of the work. In total, the size of the effect of social capital on knowledge management is 0.645. Conclusion: The results of this study indicate that all aspects of social capital affect knowledge management, the effect of each of the components of social capital on knowledge management, and the amount of social capital effect in each aspect of knowledge management is also different. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
63 - Meta analysis of information and comminiucation technology acceptace studies in ISI and Scopus citation databases
abas dolani nadjla haririAbstract Objective: The main goal of this study is to determine effective variables in technology acceptance, and account the variables effect sizes in the technology acceptance field in ISI and Scopus citation databases. Methodology: The research method was meta- ana MoreAbstract Objective: The main goal of this study is to determine effective variables in technology acceptance, and account the variables effect sizes in the technology acceptance field in ISI and Scopus citation databases. Methodology: The research method was meta- analysis. In the study all of researchs done in technology acceptance field in two citation databases (ISI and Scopus) were gathered. So appropriate data for meta-analysis like means, standard errors, samples, information technology acceptance fields and ultimate degree of the statistical test were gathered and analysed by STATA and Equal softwares. Findings: results showed, precived usefulness, precived ease of use, attitude and usage were in most studies and were very effective in technology acceptance by users’ overviews. Also in subgroups, public subgroup, enjoyment, in electronic government, trust, in staff subgroup, skill and social inffulence, and in electronic education subgroup, enjoyment were important factors. Conclusion: so many effective variables are in technology acceptance field. The variables that were in current technology acceptance models had the most role in the subject. Some models in technology acceptance like Davis have the most usge among researchers. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
64 - The Meta-Analysis of the Effectiveness of Life Skills Training on Mental Health
Haidar Ali Hooman Kamran Ganji Ahmad Omidifarthe aim of the present research was to conduct a meta-analysis examining the effectiveness of life skills training on the mental health of school children and university students. Twenty seven Iranian studies from 2001 to 2012 comprising of 3089 participants were used i Morethe aim of the present research was to conduct a meta-analysis examining the effectiveness of life skills training on the mental health of school children and university students. Twenty seven Iranian studies from 2001 to 2012 comprising of 3089 participants were used in the meta-analysis. Data was analyzed using standardized mean difference effect size method or Cohen’s d (1988) for fixed effect model. Findings indicated that the mean of mixed-model of effect size for fixed effect model and for random effect model were significant, respectively 1.834 and 3.117(P<0.001). Since the effect sizes were heterogeneous, moderating variables were searched. The results indicated that in terms of research designs and gender there were no significant differences between effect sizes across the studies. However, in terms of age and number of life skills training there were significant differences between effect sizes across the studies. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
65 - The Meta-Analysis of the Effectiveness of Psychological Interventions on the Iranians’ Feeling of Happiness
Seyed Hossein Siadatian Amir Ghamarani Fatemeh Yaghobianthis study aimed to undertake a meta-analysis examining the effectiveness of psychological interventions on Iranian happiness. The sample consisted of 16 studies and 770 participants. The data were analyzed using the Khun’s metaanalysis check-list. The results ind Morethis study aimed to undertake a meta-analysis examining the effectiveness of psychological interventions on Iranian happiness. The sample consisted of 16 studies and 770 participants. The data were analyzed using the Khun’s metaanalysis check-list. The results indicated a high effect size of the effectiveness of psychological interventions on happiness (d = 1.3; p<0.001). The Fordyce therapy approach had the highest effect size and the gratitude strategy training had the lowest effect size on promoting happiness. The final finding of the present study indicated the effectiveness of psychological interventions on promoting Iranian happiness Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
66 - Meta-analysis of Effectiveness of Group Interventions in Social Anxiety Disorder
HamidReza Oreizi Saeedeh Daneshmandi Ahmad Abedi،The aim of this study was to investigate the efficacy of group interventions and compare the efficacy of behavioral group therapy, cognitive group therapy and cognitive-behavioral group therapy in social anxiety disorder by using meta-analysis method based on the Hunte More،The aim of this study was to investigate the efficacy of group interventions and compare the efficacy of behavioral group therapy, cognitive group therapy and cognitive-behavioral group therapy in social anxiety disorder by using meta-analysis method based on the Hunter and Schmidt approach. Forty seven studies which were accepted methodologically and conducted within the last 20 years in Iran were included in the meta-analysis. The checklist of meta-analysis with 1743 participants and 51 effect sizes were used. The results indicated that the effect size of the group interventions on social anxiety disorder was 0.62, and this was true of children, adolescents and adults groups. The effect size of behavioral group therapy, cognitive group therapy, and cognitive-behavioral group therapy were 0.59, 0.69, and 0.68, respectively. This study suggested that the effect size of group interventions on social anxiety disorder was large, and this was true of all age groups. Although all group therapies were effective, the efficacy of cognitive group therapy and cognitive-behavioral group therapy were more than behavioral group therapy. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
67 - A Meta-Analysis of the Relationship Between Self-Regulation Learning Strategies and Academic Procrastination
Javad Mesrabadi Ebrahim Gazidarihe aim of this study is to combine the results of studies that had been conducted about the effectiveness of self-regulated learning strategies on students'''' academic procrastination. All published studies in Iran from 1990 to 2017 were collected. Based on the quantit Morehe aim of this study is to combine the results of studies that had been conducted about the effectiveness of self-regulated learning strategies on students'''' academic procrastination. All published studies in Iran from 1990 to 2017 were collected. Based on the quantitative findings of 21 selected studies, 48 effect size were obtained according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria. The findings indicated that the mean of the total effect of the studies were -0.78 for the fixed effects model and -0.85for the random effects, both significant at 0.001. As the effect sizes were heterogeneous, gender and research method and education were examined as the mediating variables. The results of two independent t test indicated that the effect size of gender difference was not significant, but the effect size for experimental research was significantly higher than the effect size for correlational research. Also, the effect size for meta-cognitive strategies was more than the effect size for cognitive strategies and resource management. The findings suggest that self-regulated learning strategies significantly reduce students’ procrastination Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
68 - The Meta-Analysis of Epidemiological Studies of Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder
Haidar Ali Hooman Kamran Ganjihe aim of the present research was the meta-analysis of the epidemiological studies of Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) in Iranian adults. Data collected from 10 studies conducted from 2001-2011, included 5028 participants and was analyzed using binomial Morehe aim of the present research was the meta-analysis of the epidemiological studies of Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) in Iranian adults. Data collected from 10 studies conducted from 2001-2011, included 5028 participants and was analyzed using binomial effect size display and inverse variance for fixed effect model (Wolf, 1986; Hooman, 2008). Findings revealed that the mixed model of the effect was 0.029, which was reduced to 0.028 by omitting two of the research studies. The general prevalence of ADHD after eliminating two of the studies and using sensitivity analysis was 6.76%. The prevalence rate of ADHD in males and females after excluding one of the research studies and using sensitivity analysis were 3.94% and 1.93%, respectively. Further meta-analysis showed that the prevalence of attention deficit, hyperactivity – impulsivity and combined types of ADHD were 4.72%, 3.54% and 3.84%, respectively. It can be concluded that the proportion of ADHD in females and males and the prevalence of ADHD types in Iranian adults are in accordance with many other research studies. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
69 - A Meta-Analysis of The Effectiveness of Psychological Interventions on Students’ Self-Concept
Mohammadreza MoradipoorThe aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of psychological interventions on students’ self-concept based on studies in Iran from 1390-1397. The method of this study was meta-analysis. The statistical population included all related studies in th MoreThe aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of psychological interventions on students’ self-concept based on studies in Iran from 1390-1397. The method of this study was meta-analysis. The statistical population included all related studies in the country from 1390-1397 which were available in Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies, Noormags, SID, Magiran, and Irandocs databases. For collecting data, a checklist was used. After checking the inclusion and exclusion criteria, 20 effect sizes were computed from 18 studies. The comprehensive meta-analysis software (CMA-2) was used to analyze the collected data. In this regard, a Funnel plot, Egger's linear regression method, Rosenthal's fail-safe N and Q test were used to investigate the meta-analysis assumptions. The calculated combined effect size based on the random model was 1.526, which indicates the positive effect of interventions. According to the findings, it can be concluded that psychological interventions have improving effects on students' self-concept Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
70 - Meta-analysis of social capital research and crime prevention
sayyad DarvishiField and Aims: Many researches on the relationship between social capital and prevention of social crimes have been conducted between different groups and based on different methods. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to use a meta-analytical research model to com MoreField and Aims: Many researches on the relationship between social capital and prevention of social crimes have been conducted between different groups and based on different methods. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to use a meta-analytical research model to combine and integrate the results of studies on the relationship between social capital and crime prevention.Method: In order to perform the present meta-analysis, by examining the background of all the researches related to the relationship between social capital and crime prevention that were published in prestigious scientific journals between 1390 and 1399, 17 studies that It was methodologically acceptable, selection and meta-analysis were performed on them. The research tool was a meta-analysis checklist and Cohen's effect size method was used to achieve the overall correlation value.Finding and Conclusion: The results showed that the effect size or coefficient of effect of social capital on crime prevention is equal to 0.48 which by converting the mean d to the value of z in a normal distribution curve according to Cohen's interpretive system, this amount is considered a high effect. Be. In general, the results showed that social capital has a significant effect on crime prevention at the level of (P <0.001). Also, the magnitude of the effects of social capital variables can indicate their importance in crime prevention and guide future research and policy-making in this area. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
71 - The Effect of Cryptocurrency on Stock Market Using Meta-Analysis Method
Seyed Keivan Khatami Mohammad Khodaei Valahzaghard Seyed Mohammad Abdollahi KeivaniAbstract The present study aims to systematically review the effect of cryptocurrencies on stock market using meta-analysis. In this regard, the researcher evaluated the studies conducted during 2011-2020. The results of the present study, which were conducted using me MoreAbstract The present study aims to systematically review the effect of cryptocurrencies on stock market using meta-analysis. In this regard, the researcher evaluated the studies conducted during 2011-2020. The results of the present study, which were conducted using meta-analysis method and statistically combined the results of studies on the effect of cryptocurrencies on the stock market, indicated that the discovered effect size is significant for most studies. Since the measurement error of the homogeneity test is less than 0.05, the studies are homogeneous and confirm the fixed effects model. In addition, the effect size of the fixed effects model was evaluated based on Rosenthal table. The measurement error of the fixed effects model was less than 0.05, confirming the research hypothesis. Therefore, cryptocurrencies affect the stock market. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
72 - علل توسعه نیافتگی ایران (بر اساس تحلیل محتوا آثار منتشر شده در این زمینه)
اسدالله نقدی محمد جواد حصاری -
Open Access Article
73 - شکل گیری اعتماد اجتماعی و فراتحلیل عوامل موثر در آن
مهرداد جواهری پور محمد رحیمی رضا مؤمن پور -
Open Access Article
74 - فراتحلیل اثربخشی مداخلات روان شناختی _آموزشی بر عملکرد تحصیلی دانش آموزان حساب نارسا
سیدحسین سیادتیان امیر قمرانی -
Open Access Article
75 - فراتحلیلی بر مطالعات سبک زندگی در ایران با تأکید بر مطالعه زنان و جوانان
mohsen niyazi milad norouzi asma asghari kaveri -
Open Access Article
76 - َفراتحلیل مطالعات حوزه ی دین و ارزشهای اجتماعی در ایران
mohamad hossein poriani -
Open Access Article
77 - A meta-analysis of studies on factors affecting emotional divorce in Iran society
mohsen niyazi somayeh miri hadi afraEmotional divorce is one of the most important social issues affecting families in contemporary societies. In a way that has sparked a lot of studies. Therefore, it is essential to conduct research that can get the existing research main extract. The purpose of the pres MoreEmotional divorce is one of the most important social issues affecting families in contemporary societies. In a way that has sparked a lot of studies. Therefore, it is essential to conduct research that can get the existing research main extract. The purpose of the present study is to apply meta-analysis to analyze and combine the results of studies on factors affecting emotional divorce. The statistical population consists of all articles on emotional divorce among Iranian families between the years of 1390 and 1396. According to the meta-analysis criteria, 5 articles on emotional divorce were selected from the 60 articles published in databases and reviewed by meta-analysis software. Initial investigations indicate the heterogeneity of effect size and lack of bias in publication studies. Also, the effect sizes of the variables of the religiosity of the couples are 0.316, the families’ involvement 0.303, the power structure in the family 0.387, which is evaluated in terms of the average to top from Cohen interpretive system. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
78 - Meta-analysis of Iranian society's tendency to manage the body
Tahereh Jahanparvar طاها عشایریThe body is a social category and a bio-cultural thing. In proportion to the culture and norm of society, the body also changes. In today's world, the body has become an important thing in social relations, social health and a cheerful lifestyle, as well as gaining soci MoreThe body is a social category and a bio-cultural thing. In proportion to the culture and norm of society, the body also changes. In today's world, the body has become an important thing in social relations, social health and a cheerful lifestyle, as well as gaining social status and approval. Social, the body has become more the focus of society, the current study using meta-analysis method seeks to investigate the reasons for the tendency of Iranian society to manage the body. The statistical population is 68 documents, of which 39 researches were selected by deliberate-judgmental method in the period of 1387 to 1400. Findings in the descriptive section show that in 1392, the most study (23%) was done in this period and was performed in Tehran (23%). Women were the main target of the study (69%) and the research method was cluster type (41%). The tendency to change in the body (body management) is high (35%), medium (29%) and low (36%). The effect size of studies from 39 studies indicates that media resources, cultural capital, social capital, capital, structural resources, consumption style, psychological factors, differentiation, socialization and underlying factors have a significant effect on Iranians' tendency to manage the body. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
79 - Meta-Analysis on Women’s Studies and Development in Iran Considering on political development
azadeh ghazanfari khalil Mirzaei masoume ReshadThe first trainers and preparers of a wise and knowledgeable generation in a society for creating and preparing the contexts of advancement and development in a country and nation, are women. Therefore, this is enough to consider the development and advancement of women MoreThe first trainers and preparers of a wise and knowledgeable generation in a society for creating and preparing the contexts of advancement and development in a country and nation, are women. Therefore, this is enough to consider the development and advancement of women in a society, equal to advancement and development of that country. This paper is performed in order to merge done studies in femininity field and development. Method which is used in this paper, is Meta-analysis. Statistical population were consisted of related and available studies which were accessible in Iran using Persian language, in paper form, from 1385 to 1401. After investigating the criterion of inputs and outputs, 55 effect sizes from 17 studies which have Meta-analysis condition, were obtained. In order to analyze data from sensitivity data, funnel chart, stochastic models and heterogeneity analysis, CMA2 software was used. Analysis of obtained information from research showed that the amount of combined effect in this stochastic model (chosen model for this Meta-analysis) was obtained equally to 0/472, which was significant. Size of obtained effect from studies(p<0/001) were calculated averagely according to interpretation of Cohen's scale and results illustrated that women and femininity have effect on development.Also by considering social development as moderator variable,this coefficient was calculated as social development 0/645respectively.that in level of p<0/001 are significant Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
80 - Meta-analysis of the effect of information disclosure on market reaction
Shiva Zamani Majid Zanjirdar Ali LalbarPurpose: The present research aims to conduct meta-analysis of the effect of information disclosure on market reaction. In order to integrate the results of different researches and identify the determinants of relations between information disclosure and market reactio MorePurpose: The present research aims to conduct meta-analysis of the effect of information disclosure on market reaction. In order to integrate the results of different researches and identify the determinants of relations between information disclosure and market reaction, we used meta-analysis methodology as a quantitative statistical method.Methodology: In order to implement the meta-analysis method, using software CMA from the website of foreign journals (published articles related to research variables from 1990 to 2020) and the website of domestic scientific research journals (published articles related to research variables from 1990 to 2020) to They were identified and collected as a statistical population of the research and finally 86 studies have been analyzed by systematic elimination method.Findings: The results of studies conducted in the mentioned period and around this relationship, using I2 and Q tests indicate that most of these studies are heterogeneous. In order to identify the cause of this heterogeneity, by dividing the research based on different criteria for measuring information disclosure and market reaction and calculating statistics within the group, we found that these different measurement criteria used in research is one of the contradictory factors in research results. In the following study, it was observed that there is no significant relationship between audit components and market reaction, while in contrast, between the types of voluntary and mandatory disclosure, and corporate governance components with market reaction, a significant relationship was observed.Originality / Value: Based on the findings of the present research, financial market activists and investors should pay more serious attention to the way of information disclosure and mandatory disclosure tools and composition of shareholders in their analysis, but audit components are a special guide for choosing the best capital option. It does not offer financial market participants. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
81 - Meta-Analysis o Factors Affecting Customers' Preferences in Selecting a Bank
naser Ghabouli ALIREZA Bafandeh Zendeh Samad AaliThe aim of this study is to analyze the literature of factors affecting customers' preferences in selecting banks and determining variables as well as determining the effect size of influencing variables on customer preferences in selecting banks. Banks are required to MoreThe aim of this study is to analyze the literature of factors affecting customers' preferences in selecting banks and determining variables as well as determining the effect size of influencing variables on customer preferences in selecting banks. Banks are required to know the behavior and needs of consumers in order to retain customers and gain more market share, and given that numerous studies have been conducted in this regard, and since in these studies the ability to control the research environment, examples and Methods, measuring tools are different from one research to another, the results of research are different and sometimes conflicting, so it is very important to conduct combined research that brings the extract of research in this field in a systematic and scientific way to researchers. A total of 15 studies were selected and examined with CMA2 software. The results indicate that the following factors have contributed to the preferences of customers in choosing banks: 1. Financial facilities 2. Bank confidence 3. Method of dealing with employees 4. Providing banking services 5. Physical and spatial conditions 6. New and advanced technology 7 -Reputation and validity of bank 8- Security and information preservation 9.The cost of providing services 10 - Quick access to the Bank 11. Marketing. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
82 - Meta-Analysis of E-Government Studies in Promoting Good Governance Indicators
Seyed Anoshiravan Majdzadeh sanjar salajeghe Amin Nikpour Mohammad Jalal KamaliThe present article aims to analyze the theoretical field of research conducted in the field of e-government in promoting good governance indicators, and meta-analyze the studies conducted in this regard. Considering that good governance in different societies can have MoreThe present article aims to analyze the theoretical field of research conducted in the field of e-government in promoting good governance indicators, and meta-analyze the studies conducted in this regard. Considering that good governance in different societies can have different meanings and types of factors, therefore, in this article, an attempt has been made to make a theoretical summary in the field of factors in the analysis. The statistical population is 59 articles (25 domestic articles and 34 foreign articles) during the period from 1390 to 1402. The collection of data from the articles was based on the Prisma protocol, which was adapted to the opinion of experts. After a systematic review of the articles, meta-analysis method and CMA2 software were used to analyze the data. Also, after the inferential analysis of the data using linear regression and multivariate regression methods, the degree of relationship between each independent variable and then all independent variables in different dimensions with the dependent variable, i.e. good governance, was evaluated. The findings of the research show that among all the variables in the studies, accountability is the most effective variable on good governance, followed by transparency, supervision of government institutions, efficiency of government institutions and access to Public services have the greatest impact on good governance Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
83 - Meta-Analysis of Articles in the Quarterly Journal of Intercultural Studies (Volumes 10-14)
ali akbar saberi hasan bashirGiven the growth in the humanities and social sciences, researchers have come to the conclusion that mastering all aspects of any problems is not possible to some extent. They have conducted combined research to provide them with the essence of research on a partic MoreGiven the growth in the humanities and social sciences, researchers have come to the conclusion that mastering all aspects of any problems is not possible to some extent. They have conducted combined research to provide them with the essence of research on a particular topic in a systematic way. This article seeks to address the practical framework of quarterly articles in research, sampling, methodology and data collection methods. The aim of the present study was to quantitatively combine the results of the researches and the course of the research stages and using meta-analysis method. 43 articles related to the period 10 to 14 of the Quarterly Journal of Intercultural Studies and with the opinion of experts in the field of culture. The results of meta-analysis show that the approach of quarterly articles is to meet the goals and objectives of the quarterly and more than 80% of them have dealt with cultural aspects. Of course, there are some shortcomings in this direction that need to be addressed. Including: Adopting more combined research methods, using interview methods and similar methods in social research, limiting and determining validity and reliability Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
84 - Studying the Theoretical Traditions of Communication Sciences in Iran (A Meta-Analysis of Doctoral Theses in the Field of Communication Sciences at Allameh Tabatabai University, During the Last Decade )
mohammad javad Badinfekr hasan bashirFrom the beginning of the development of communication knowledge, the interdisciplinarity and fragmentation of this science has been the central issue of thinkers in this field, and so far, many efforts have been made to explain the interdisciplinary or even post-discip MoreFrom the beginning of the development of communication knowledge, the interdisciplinarity and fragmentation of this science has been the central issue of thinkers in this field, and so far, many efforts have been made to explain the interdisciplinary or even post-disciplinary nature of this science. The basic subject of this article is the study of the theoretical traditions of communication in Iran. The main question of this article is: What are the most and most important theoretical traditions used in doctoral dissertations in the field of communication sciences at Allameh Tabatabai University during the last decade?To answer this question, the theoretical framework of the "seven theoretical traditions of communication" from the perspective of Robert Craig (2007) was used. Also, using the meta-analysis method, 56 doctoral theses (all theses) have been examined. One of the important results of this research is that the most used theoretical traditions in Iran include: 1- socio-cultural tradition (30%) 2- critical tradition (25%) 3- social psychology tradition (24%) 4- tradition Semiotics (14%) - phenomenological tradition (3%) 6- cybernetic tradition (3%) and 7- rhetorical tradition (1%). Also, another result of this research is that 47% of doctoral theses of this university have made direct reference to theories, 5% have used theories as a research framework, and 48% have moved towards combining or building a new theory. As a result, it can be said that in the doctoral theses of Allameh University communication theoretical traditions are rarely mentioned. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
85 - A study on the meta-analysis of cultural intelligence research in the organization
mehdi kheirandish salimeh latifi jalisehThis study deals with the identification of cultural intelligence consequences using meta-analysis approach . The purpose of this study based on goal is descriptive and type of use is applied. The study population included 70 dissertations, Thesis and cultural intellige MoreThis study deals with the identification of cultural intelligence consequences using meta-analysis approach . The purpose of this study based on goal is descriptive and type of use is applied. The study population included 70 dissertations, Thesis and cultural intelligence research that 23 sample selected using non-random purposefully method for meta-analysis. The identification reliability via the agreement of the Referees in selecting the researches and Their categorization, The Coding Reliability was obtained via The agreement of the Referee on the use of specific concepts to variables Coding and significance and Effect size Reliability was obtained via an Agreement on effect size calculation between two meta-analyzer. Findings showed that among 18 variables, 8 variable has a high effect size (more than 0/5), 4 variable has a low effect size (between 0/1 – 0/3) and 10 variable average effect size(0/3 – 0/5). The results showed that the variable of productivity, quality of work life and social capital had the greatest effect size. And problem solving, transformational leadership and emotional intelligence had the lowest effect size. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
86 - Study of Factors Affecting the Political Culture of Citizens: Meta-Analysis of Research From 2001 to 2021
seyed ali mirlohi Taha Ashayeri Tahereh ـJahanparvar Elham HoseinzadehPolitical culture refers to the political knowledge, political awareness, knowledge, tactics, tastes or political attitudes of citizens. In Iran, the issue of politics, participation in elections, presence in various socio-political arenas and citizens' political awaren MorePolitical culture refers to the political knowledge, political awareness, knowledge, tactics, tastes or political attitudes of citizens. In Iran, the issue of politics, participation in elections, presence in various socio-political arenas and citizens' political awareness of parties and candidates show the growth of their political culture. The main purpose of this study is to study the factors affecting the political culture of citizens in the period 2001 to 2021. The research method was meta-analysis (quantitative), the statistical population was 45 documents in which 23 studies (survey, correlation coefficients, significance level and sample size) were selected by non-probability method. The results show that there is a significant relationship between political capital, mass media, social capital, economic capital, cultural factors, psychological factors and national issues with political culture. Due to the heterogeneity between the above studies, modifier variables have been used. The results show that among the ethnic groups of Turks (0.23), Fars (0.21), Turkmen (0.20) and Kurds (0.18) have an effect on political culture as mediating variables and their overall effect is equal to 0.18%. Among the statistical population, university professors with a value of 0.34 and students with a value of 0.29 and academic elites with a value of 0.26% had the most impact as a mediating variable on political culture Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
87 - Generational distance in Iran: meta-analysis and criticism of previous research
mohamadhosain panahi seyyed hadi alavyyun The main purpose of this research is to review and critique research on generation gap. In this research, after initial refinement of the articles, 40 scientific-research papers related to the topic of generation and gap generation through the Marigans Scientific More The main purpose of this research is to review and critique research on generation gap. In this research, after initial refinement of the articles, 40 scientific-research papers related to the topic of generation and gap generation through the Marigans Scientific Database and the Noormags database were selected and reviewed in the areas of theoretical framework, research methodology and findings and were compared. The results of this study show that in these studies, the poverty of native theorizing, the prevalence of survey methods and the absence of combinatorial methods, scattering and inconsistency in the indexing of generational distance types, are different from the concepts of distance, gap and generational discontinuity. In addition, the lack of precise operational definitions for these concepts, and the lack of accurate measurement of variables, and the lack of separation of the value and normative dimensions of generational distance, have confounded their findings. The research also suffers from the generalization of the results obtained without considering the dimensions and domains under study, the lack of a common age criterion in the separation of first, second and third generation generations, and the lack of attention to the validity of the tools used. In general, significant differences and inconsistencies in the results can confuse future researchers and misinterpretations of results by policymakers Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
88 - Methodological Discussion in International Relations Theories from the Philosophy of Science Aspect
Reza Kaviyani Shide Shadlou This paper studies theories of international relations from the philosophy of science perspective based on two types of evaluation. The first type is through meta-analysis, that is, how international relations are evaluated through ontology, epistemology and met More This paper studies theories of international relations from the philosophy of science perspective based on two types of evaluation. The first type is through meta-analysis, that is, how international relations are evaluated through ontology, epistemology and methodology. In fact, the “whyness” and “howness” of the emergence and retrieval of thoughts in the field of international relations are at the center of this meta-analysis. The second type is based on the theoretical foundations which include questions such as “What are the peculiarities of international relations in these theories? What are the components of international relations based on different theories of the field? What is the implied discourse in different theories of international relations? What relation is between theory and action? What are the impacts and consequences of theories of international relations in terms of methodology?” Accordingly, this paper utilizes a descriptive-analytical method within the interdisciplinary topics of international relations and philosophy of science to explore the above mentioned issues. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
89 - Obstacles affecting students' participation in sports activities, meta-composite and meta-analysis approach
fahimeh rivandi مهوش نوربخش مهدی کهندل پریوش نوربخشThere is a large amount of studies about students' participation in sports activities, the results of which are somewhat ambiguous and ambiguous, therefore, the present research was conducted with the aim of meta-synthesis and meta-analysis of the barriers affecting stu MoreThere is a large amount of studies about students' participation in sports activities, the results of which are somewhat ambiguous and ambiguous, therefore, the present research was conducted with the aim of meta-synthesis and meta-analysis of the barriers affecting students' participation in sports activities. The method of this research is a systematic review with the aim of combining quantitative and qualitative research. The statistical population of this research is the qualitative and quantitative studies that are available within the country between 1385 and 1400, which were examined based on the inclusion and exclusion criteria in the meta-combination of 12 studies and in the meta-analysis of 22 studies. In the meta-combination section, thematic synthesis method was used to analyze the results of primary research. The findings of the meta-composite section showed that there are three general environmental barriers in the explanation of barriers affecting students' participation in sports, namely public environment barriers, operational environment barriers, and internal environment barriers. Students participate in sports activities. In the meta-analysis, the results of the combined effect size for both the random effects model and the fixed effects model were equal to 0.35. The effective barriers of parents' attitude towards girls' sports are among the most important variables and in most cases the findings of past researches were confirmed and in some cases they were violated. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
90 - Meta-analysis of Researches on Work Life Quality of Higher Education Institutions Faculty Members
Zohreh shakibayi Abstract: This study aims to conduct meta-analysis on investigating about faculty members’ working life quality in higher education organizations. The statistical community includes all conducted researches on faculty members’ working life quality in More Abstract: This study aims to conduct meta-analysis on investigating about faculty members’ working life quality in higher education organizations. The statistical community includes all conducted researches on faculty members’ working life quality in higher education organizations of Iran, by the end of 2014. 24 researches were chosen as being suitable to do meta-analysis through purposeful sampling. The research instrument was a checklist for selecting researches from technical and methodological aspects. The preferential meta-analysis model contained the mixed approach of Hunter and Smith. In addition, Cohen’s approach was used for interpreting research findings. The findings showed that the effectiveness of faculty members’ working life quality in higher education organizations is 0.456, which is higher than average according to interpreting indexes. The dimensions of faculty members’ working life quality in higher education organizations include fair payment, safe working environment, providing the opportunity to grow, legal positivism in labor organization, social dependence to working life, social integration and human capabilities development, which were significant in 0.001 levels. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
91 - فراتحلیل مطالعات سلامت اجتماعی و کیفیّت زندگی دانشجویان ورزشکار و غیر ورزشکار
Zahra Gafari poursakich Ali Manteghi Fasaiiدر این مقاله با استفاده از روش فراتحلیل به تحلیل و ترکیب نتیجه مقاله ها و پایان نامه های مربوط به سلامت اجتماعی و کیفیّت زندگی و نیز بررسی نظریّه های اجتماعی موجود در این زمینه پرداخته شده است که از بین مطالعات بسیار انجام گرفته در باره موضوع مورد پژوهش تعدا Moreدر این مقاله با استفاده از روش فراتحلیل به تحلیل و ترکیب نتیجه مقاله ها و پایان نامه های مربوط به سلامت اجتماعی و کیفیّت زندگی و نیز بررسی نظریّه های اجتماعی موجود در این زمینه پرداخته شده است که از بین مطالعات بسیار انجام گرفته در باره موضوع مورد پژوهش تعداد 43 تحقیق انجام شده در این خصوص با بهره گیری از چک لیست فراتحلیل به عنوان ابزار اندازه گیری پژوهش برگزیده شدند. بر اساس یافته های به دست آمده در بیش تر مطالعات انجام شده، واحد تحلیل فرد بوده است و در همه ی آن ها برای گردآوری داده ها از روش پیمایشی – نظری استفاده شده است. همچنین نظریّه ی سلامت اجتماعی کییز و پرسشنامه ی وی در این زمینه راهنمای بیش تر پژوهش ها بوده است. علاوه بر این، در بیش تر مطالعات یادشده، تأثیر عامل های گوناگون بر سلامت اجتماعی شناسایی شده اند که از میان این عامل ها؛ کیفیّت زندگی و شاخص های آن و همچنین میزان تحصیلات تأثیری چشم گیر بر سلامت اجتماعی داشته اند. Manuscript profile
Sanad
Sanad is a platform for managing Azad University publications
Links
Related Centers
Technical Support
Official pages
The rights to this website are owned by the Raimag Press Management System.
Copyright © 2021-2024