• List of Articles MCDM

      • Open Access Article

        1 - Identification Challenges for fitting out of Government Structure Using Multi-criteria Decision-Making Approaches (MCDM)
        masoud bastami reza najafbagy kramallah Daneshfard Adel Fatmi
        the structure of organization of states is shaped by the purposes, necessities, needs and necessities of every era. With this aim, the main purpose of this research is to present a model of the challenges of fitting the structure of the government in implementing a comp More
        the structure of organization of states is shaped by the purposes, necessities, needs and necessities of every era. With this aim, the main purpose of this research is to present a model of the challenges of fitting the structure of the government in implementing a comprehensive reform of the administrative system. This research in terms of collecting data is a descriptive-survey research,, and in terms of research purposes is an applied research. The statistical population of the research has been scientific and executive experts in the academic environment and governmental organizations. A researcher-made questionnaire was used to collect data, and to analysis the data multi-criteria decision-making approaches (MCDM) was used. In this research, by examining the literature of research and interviewing with experts, 66 indicators were identified and extracted. After judging the experts, using Fuzzy Delphi test, 29 indicators were approved and organized in 5 main components. The results of the Dematel test (studying the effectiveness and impact of variables) showed that the variables of privatization, decentralization and proportionalization, effectiveness variables, and the state structure and bureaucracy are impact variables. Interpretative structural modeling analysis also showed that variables were classified in two levels. At the highest level, the component of bureaucracy and at the lowest level are the components of government structure, adjustment, privatization and decentralization. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        2 - Designing a model for measuring information technology level in organization by fuzzy set
        Abbas Toloie Ashlaghi Reza Radfar Shabnam Pasandideh
        One of the difficult tasks in management is decision making. To accomplish all phases of decision makingprocess, all criteria must be measurable and quantitatively available. Because information technology, accordingto its intangible nature, has a broad range of definit More
        One of the difficult tasks in management is decision making. To accomplish all phases of decision makingprocess, all criteria must be measurable and quantitatively available. Because information technology, accordingto its intangible nature, has a broad range of definitions and generally undetermined indicators some of which arequalitative, there is no certain criterion to measure it. This paper aimed to consider all aspects of informationtechnology. Indicators of information technology have been set in four main groups and in each of them, themain criteria and related sub-criteria are defined. As qualitative and quantitative criteria cannot be measuredcertainly and accurately, the fuzzy systems (FS) are utilized to assess the magnitude of any indicator. To do so,after creating the matrix of decision-making, weights assessment techniques in multi-criteria-decision making(MCDM) have been used and then a model for measuring in order to gain points for a unique level ofinformation technology is provided. The method used to assess the weights is “grouping” that is one of thedecision-making techniques and the method of measurement is fuzzy simple addition weight (FSAW). Pointsearned, indicate the level of information technology in the organization. According to the implementation of themodel and examination by experts in this field, designed model was approved and is applicable in allorganizations that have IT units Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        3 - Application of Topsis Method for Ranking Research Centers in Order to Resource Allocating in Fuzzy Phase
        Ali Reza Ali Ahmadi Mohammad Reza Khosh Lafz
        In this article Topsis method in fuzzy phase was used to determine strategic priorities of research centers for resource allocation. First, the importance score of indices were determined through Study and interview with experts then according to defensive researches in More
        In this article Topsis method in fuzzy phase was used to determine strategic priorities of research centers for resource allocation. First, the importance score of indices were determined through Study and interview with experts then according to defensive researches in the country and related centers which are considered as references indices were chosen. Next we determined to which centers, it is better, to assign the most budyet and facilities according to “TOPSIS” method and related and tables (they are described in the text) also we suggested the best choice. Through this process qualitative and quantitative indices can be used and consequently fuzzy method is sued to conver comprehensive and qualitative indices in to measurable quantitative and indices. This method of decision along with multiple qualitative indices can be used to determine the priority for allocating Rial and foreign currencies budjet to government research centers under the supervision of the ministry culture and advance education. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        4 - Designing an Assessment Model of Leadership EFQM Using MCDM
        A. Taghavi alidash H. Mehrmanesh
        Today, our country's economic firms face countless challenges in globalization. EFQM excellence is astrong tool to help organizations surmount these challenges. This model has two major parts: enablersand results. Enablers include five areas: leadership, people, policy More
        Today, our country's economic firms face countless challenges in globalization. EFQM excellence is astrong tool to help organizations surmount these challenges. This model has two major parts: enablersand results. Enablers include five areas: leadership, people, policy and strategy, partnership andresources, and processes. Results include four areas: people, customer, society, and key performance.This model has been used in organization assessment by people who are responsible for our country’sindustries. However, this model has also been criticized. Assessment is done using an evidentialreasoning approach. The evidential reasoning approach is one of the MCDM techniques. Theimprovable areas must be recognized and divided into two classes: simple and important. Next, theimportant improvable areas must to be prioritized by one of the MADM techniques. To achieve morerapid excellence, the important improvable areas must be conducted by priority. According to theresearch findings, the sub-criteria and bolt points are not equal, in spite of the fact that they areconsidered equal in EFQM excellence. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        5 - A New Multi-Criteria Decision Making Based on Fuzzy- Topsis Theory
        Leila Yahyaie Sohrab Khanmohammadi
      • Open Access Article

        6 - Using Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) for Selecting and Prioritizing of Existing Water Resources as Irragation Water (Case study: Green Area of Boienzahra City)
        Ali SAFARI Madjid Abbaspour Amirhosein Javid Dordaneh Aghajani
        Background and Aim: One of the key factors in the conservation and development of urban green space is use of available water resource in each region according to the characteristics of green space in this paper providing of water for boeen-zahra's green space irrigatio More
        Background and Aim: One of the key factors in the conservation and development of urban green space is use of available water resource in each region according to the characteristics of green space in this paper providing of water for boeen-zahra's green space irrigation has been studied.Method: First available water resources were determined then questionnaires completed by experts, and the effective criteria in the decision-making process of water resources selection were weighed using AHP (Analytical Hierarchy Process) method. Finally, the best option was selected using the preferential prioritization method to enrich the evaluations (Promethee).Findings: The results of AHP method in Expert Choice software indicated that the weight of technical, practical and managerial criteria were higher than other options and water resources of municipal garden wells with miscellaneous wells were selected as the best option. In the second stage, the weights and scores obtained from the criteria and options of the first part, were selected and ranked as input to the Decision Lab 2000 software, and in this stage, the result obtained was confirmed in the first stage.Discussion and Conclusion: The present study indicates that technical, practical, managerial and environmental criteria are the most important factors in choosing the type of water source for irrigation of green space. In other words, in choosing the right water resources, achieving standards, hydraulic shock resistance, no need for advanced technology to control, system efficiency, are the parameters that are most considered.  Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        7 - Site Suitability Evaluation for Ecotourism Using GIS & AHP: A Case Study of Hamedan Township
        Zahra Parvar Behnaz Heshmat nia Kamran Shayesteh
        Background and Objective: Today, tourism is a major source of income for many countries, and it affects the economy of both source and host countries, and in some countries this way of income is a vital importance. Hamedan Township is one of the most popular and importa More
        Background and Objective: Today, tourism is a major source of income for many countries, and it affects the economy of both source and host countries, and in some countries this way of income is a vital importance. Hamedan Township is one of the most popular and important tourism areas of Iran. It is rich in nature, history and culture which make a favorite destination for various tourists. There are so many tourist attractions in Hamedan Township include historical, cultural and natural sites such as waterfall and mountain. Due to rapid growth of ecotourism, a challenge for the decision makers is the way of managing ecotourism in order to minimize the negative impacts for sustainable development of tourism. Method: The main objective of this study is to identify and prioritize the potential ecotourism site in Hamadan County, Iran, using Geographic Information System (GIS) and Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). Seven criteria including slope, aspect, distance from water, distance from road, land use, vegetation were used in this study. Criteria's and sub-criteria's were selected according to the professional expert's opinions. The final map of suitable areas for study area prepared using Weighted Linear Combination (WLC) and Ordered Weighted Averaging (OWA) technique in GIS environment. Findings: The results showed that 15049 ha (5/5%) of study area has first class potential (high suitable), 114919 ha (41%) has second class potential (high), 122589 ha (44%) has third class potential (low) and 26292 ha (9/9%) has four class potential (very low suitable) based on WLC method, but in both models most suitable area is located in west and southwest of township. Discussion and Conclusion: Suitable management for ecotourism development is essential in order to conserve and maintain the biological richness of the area. The results of this site selection models can be a useful reference to the ecotourism planning and development for manager and decision makers. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        8 - Prediction of Urban Physical Expansion Using Multi-Criteria Decision Making Model (Case study: Rasht City)
        Hamide Aliani Hamed Aliani mohadeseh ghanbari motlagh Kamran Rahimi
        Background and Objective: The unplanned expansion of cities is one of the most important issues of urban management in developing countries. Because the increasing development of urban society and unplanned constructions have created many changes in their spatial constr More
        Background and Objective: The unplanned expansion of cities is one of the most important issues of urban management in developing countries. Because the increasing development of urban society and unplanned constructions have created many changes in their spatial construction, which has led to the need for conscious guidance and design of suitable living space for cities. The purpose of this study is to find a set of suitable spatial zones for urban physical development. Method: Rasht city, as the center of Gilan County, has undergone many demographic and urban changes. In order to plan optimally and appropriately for the future urban development of the studied city, 14 ecological and socio-economic criteria were selected based on the opinions of experts and the Delphi method in 2018. Then the weighted linear composition method and network analysis process were used to zoning the ecological potential of the area for urban development. Findings: The results of the implementation of the multi-criteria evaluation method showed that the total area of the region is about 16.12% with very high capability. 29.54% of the region is unsuitable due to ecological conditions and unsustainable social tissue. Discussion and Conclusions: The results of this research can provide more study opportunities for planners and decision-makers to take preventive and controlling factors into strategic decisions.   Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        9 - Environmental and Sanitary Risk Assessment of the waste water treatment plant in west of Ahwaz Using AHP and TOPSIS methods
        hamidreza pourkhabbaz azin azizi saeide javanmardi Ali Reza Pourkhabbaz
        Background and Objective: Employed workers in wastewater treatment plants are always exposed to threats of risk factors in the workplace such as harmful physical, chemical and biological factors. Therefore, the present study assesses the safety, health and environmental More
        Background and Objective: Employed workers in wastewater treatment plants are always exposed to threats of risk factors in the workplace such as harmful physical, chemical and biological factors. Therefore, the present study assesses the safety, health and environmental risks in the wastewater treatment plant in west of Ahwaz city to investigate these risks and provide the necessary solutions. Material and Methodology: After the field visits, interviews to experts and staffs of treatment plant and internet researches (2018), a list of the most important risks was identified and given to the experts and staffs. In order to analyze and prioritize the risks, it was used from AHP and TOPSIS, which are multi-criteria decision-making methods (MCDM) and as well as the entropy technique to calculate the weight of the indicators. In Continuation to prioritizing strategies of factors, in order to removing the conflict between TOPSIS and AHP results, it was used the ranks mean.Findings: According to the results of AHP and TOPSIS, the most important safety and environmental risks that were identified, are impact to rotating parts of systems, entry of toxic materials and impermissible industrial wastewater and the dispersion of biogas from sludge digestion reservoirs. Also, according to the results of the ranks mean method, among the safety and health risks, it was Assigned impact to rotating parts of systems to score 1/5 the first priority, the electric shock and the dispersion of bad gas from wastewater to score of 3 and 3/5 were the second and third priority respectively. Among the environmental risks, it was Assigned entry of toxic materials and impermissible industrial waste water, the dispersion of biogas from sludge digestion reservoirs to score of 2 first priority, fire and explosion score of 3 second priority and fluctuations of waste wate discharge score of 3/5 the third priority.Disscotion & Conclusion: Given that the performance of wastewater treatment plants is a function of various human, natural, equipment and functional factors at the exploitation stage, therefore, management of these factors will help to improve the process of exploitation. In the present study, one of the most important management actions to reduce the level of risks identified, can pointed to apply of work safety guidelines, establishing of facilities and necessary equipment to burn additional gases and prevent their dangerous accumulation in the treatment plant environment, perform pre- treatment of industrial wastewater and continuous monitoring of effluent wastes to match with environmental standards.  Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        10 - Plant Type Selection for Sungun Copper Mine Environment Reclamation by Fuzzy TOPSIS Method
        Iraj Alavi Naser pirooznia
        Introduction: all steps of a mining project generally disturb the environment’s original condition during execution. Therefore from exploration until end of the exploitation and after mining closure, there should be an exhaustive applied reclamation plan of the mi More
        Introduction: all steps of a mining project generally disturb the environment’s original condition during execution. Therefore from exploration until end of the exploitation and after mining closure, there should be an exhaustive applied reclamation plan of the mined land. Planting the suitable plant species in each step of any reclamation plan in this area is the goal of this research. In all type of post mining land use such as Agriculture, Pasture, Forestry, Tourist attraction, Wild life creation, selection and planting the appropriate plant species are the most essential requirements to implement a successful mined land reclamation plan. Material and Method: The Research methodology is selecting the plant species that is carried out on the basis of the primary factors which include type of Post mining land use, Climate, Nature­ of soil. The priority is defined between the selected species, based on of the secondary factors (Perspective of the region, resistance against disease and insects, strength and method of growth, availability to plant Species, Economic efficiency, Protection of soil and storing water, prevention from pollution) by a MCDM model. This model is implemented by FUZZY TOPSIS method. The mentioned procedure was applied in the Sungun Copper Mine in Iran. Decision making was executed on the basis of oral judgments and experts group opinions in the case study. Risults and Discution: The results have been consisted of maple, Ash, Barberry, Paliurus Spina –Christi, Oak, and Sloe respectively. All species are native. In parts that ground is damaged and also waste dump sites, are used Maple and Paliurus Spina –Christi and Sloe are stabilizers and compatible till field is prepared for planting residuary of plants.   Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        11 - presentation of new method for investment strategy in private section
        Hosseyn Mombeyni Abdolreza Yazdani Chamzini
        Selection of the investment strategy is a bothersome and sophisticated process because of taking into consideration a large number of quantitative and qualitative parameters like benefits, opportunities, costs, and risks. However, the parameters may have a significant i More
        Selection of the investment strategy is a bothersome and sophisticated process because of taking into consideration a large number of quantitative and qualitative parameters like benefits, opportunities, costs, and risks. However, the parameters may have a significant influence on each other. A decision-making trial and evaluation laboratory (DEMATEL) can be used to construct a network relationship map. On the other hand, according to the information is incomplete, uncertainty is an inseparable part of making decision in solving the MCDM problems. Therefore, this paper proposes a new hybrid model based on analytic hierarchical process (AHP), DEMATEL, and Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) techniques under fuzzy environment to evaluate the problem of the selection of the investment strategy. For achieving the aim, a three-step process is presented to formulate the problem under consideration. First, the structure of the investment problem is broken into a simple hierarchy structure by using the AHP method to simply model the problem and calculate the importance weights of criteria by using a pairwise comparison process. Second, the interdependent relationships are identified by applying the DEMATEL technique. This technique is employed for computing the global weights of benefit, opportunities, cost, and risk (BOCR) factors. Finally, the fuzzy TOPSIS methodology is used for prioritizing the alternatives. To show the effectiveness of the proposed model, a case study is investigated. The results demonstrate that the proposed model is capable of prioritizing the investment strategies. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        12 - Combination of MCDM and GIS for study of the gypsum mineral mines spatial distribution with emphasis on environmental considerations (Case Study: Hablehrud catchment-Semnan province (
        Mohammad Reza Delghandi Mir Masood Kheirkhah Zarkesh
        In spite of human knowledge and technology development, unfortunately, the situation of the environment at national, regional and international levels is critical and complex. We can no longer expect that with economic and industrial development the environment remains More
        In spite of human knowledge and technology development, unfortunately, the situation of the environment at national, regional and international levels is critical and complex. We can no longer expect that with economic and industrial development the environment remains intact, but the reduction of pollution and its harmful effects using high technology can ensure the health, growth and excellence of present and future life on Earth. Multi-criteria decision-making System (MCDM) has been used to improve decision-making and management process. The spatial information systems are suitable for spatial data analysis. Also, Geographic information systems have been used to properly determine suitable areas for industrial and mining activities and its impacts assessment on the environment. In this study, using ecological, economic and social criteria and their integration with MCDM and GIS, the study area based on its sensitivity to mining activities were mapped. Also Environmental considerations consists of impact of mining activities on the urban settlements, rural settlements, surface water, groundwater, wildlife habitat, agriculture, tourism and vegetation were analyzed. Based on zoning map of the sensitivity of the active area of ​​the mineral gypsum, range, interference within the mining and production zones were identified. The results showed that 15% of the mineral sector with a range of prohibited activities, 6% in the zone of extreme sensitivity, 11% in the zone of high sensitivity, and 58% moderate and 10% is located in the zone of low sensitivity. Which implies the fact that 26 of the total 52 mining operations across the range of prohibited activities that should be stopped. It has been elaborated that the priority for planning must be related to the management of this moderate sensitive zone. The survey also shown that two criteria consists of the agriculture area and surface water had the most interaction with the unsafe mineral activities.   Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        13 - Site selection of Emergency Accommodation in district 19 of Tehran by using MCDM
        afrasyab kheirdast seyed ali jozi Sahar Rezaian Mahnaz Mirza Ebrahim Tehrani
        Background and Objective: The purpose of this research is providing a suitable model for locating emergency accommodation caused by natural and unnatural disasters in the 19th district of Tehran. Material and Methodology: The research method is descriptive-analytical a More
        Background and Objective: The purpose of this research is providing a suitable model for locating emergency accommodation caused by natural and unnatural disasters in the 19th district of Tehran. Material and Methodology: The research method is descriptive-analytical and data analysis is done using MCDM and Arc GIS and Excel system. The statistical population was selected from among the variables of emergency accommodation location and the sampling method was simple and the sampling volume was obtained using Morgan's table (n = 19). The research tool was a questionnaire that was quantitatively designed and its questions were extracted using emergency accommodation standards and distributed among experts. The validity of the questionnaire was confirmed by experts and its value was 0.421. The reliability of the questionnaire was also calculated using SPSS20 software with Cronbach's alpha coefficient of 0.827. Findings: finding of the present research was considered from 3 main criteria (desirability, compatibility and capacity) and 18 sub-criteria to determine accommodation. In the process of locating emergency accommodation, first, information layers were prepared, then standardization and AHP coefficients were applied to them, and finally, after weighting them, layers were overlapped. Discussion and Conclusions: After the final production of the settlement map and according to the results of this research, 28 zones with a value of 7-9 were accepted for settlement. Also, 17 areas with a value of 7 (relatively good), 7 areas with a value of 8 (good) and 4 areas with a value of 9 (ideal) were identified in the study area for emergency accommodation. In total, 1,321,8725 square meters, equivalent to 1,321 hectares, were habitable in District 19 of Tehran. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        14 - Ecotourism site selection of Kiamaky wildlife refuge using multicriteria decision making
        Omid Rafieyan Seyed Ali AKbar Mirrazi Najibeh Abdolalipour Elham Golabi
        Identifying and locating suitable areas for eco-tourism development, is one of the important issues of tourism planners. But the wide variety of options and parameters, variables uncertainty and long terms in environmental planning, causes the     &n More
        Identifying and locating suitable areas for eco-tourism development, is one of the important issues of tourism planners. But the wide variety of options and parameters, variables uncertainty and long terms in environmental planning, causes the          decision-making becomes more complex. So multi-criteria decision-making methods can meet these challenges. Thus the aim of this study is to identify suitable areas for         eco-tourism in Kiamaky wildlife refuge using MCDM method Based on fuzzy logic in GIS. According to the effective criteria on the eco-tourism in this area; obtained from previous research and expert opinions, 15 criteria maps (climate, lithology, height from sea level, slope, aspect, land use and distance maps from residential area, road, river, police station, environmental guard station, sensitive habitats, shrine, spring and waterfall) are produced and classified as input. To determine the weights of criteria, opinions of experts in the form of Delphi Method were applied. The criteria matrix formed and the relative importance of all criteria was defined using the AHP method and pairwise comparison. Finally eco-tourism appropriate priority map was produced using Weighted Linear Combination (WLC) method and applying the index of the importance of each criterion to corresponding classified map. According to mentioned map, 15% and 34% of the area eligible for perfect and good for eco-tourism respectively, and 4% of the area are medium for this purpose. In this study, besides confirming previous studies, power and usefulness of GIS in locating and combining different ecological criteria were shown. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        15 - Extension of VIKOR Method to Find an Optimal Layout for Fixture's Supporting Points in Order to Reduce Work Piece Deformation
        M Ehsanifar M Hemesy
      • Open Access Article

        16 - Development of a New SWOT-MCDM Model to Create Marketing and Financial Strategies in Conditions of Uncertainty (Case Study of Iralco Company)
        Farshad Motallebi Peyman Ghafari Ashtiani Mohammad Ehsanifar
        The most basic step in managing an organization is to develop appropriate and practical strategies. Developing a detailed and complete plan that will determine the long-term direction of the organization and guarantee the prof-itability and survival of the organizatio More
        The most basic step in managing an organization is to develop appropriate and practical strategies. Developing a detailed and complete plan that will determine the long-term direction of the organization and guarantee the prof-itability and survival of the organization. In this research, using multi-criteria decision-making techniques, a new SWOT model has been created to formulate organizational strategies (financial, commercial, production and similar). The upcoming research method is of a mixed type (qualitative-quantitative) which will be used in the qualitative part of the method (de-scriptive-survey) and in the quantitative part of the fuzzy Delphi technique and multi-criteria decision making. In order to target more the results of this research and its output model, Iralco Company (Iran Aluminium) has been selected as a strategic and widely used global product manufacturer to study and implement the mentioned models and techniques. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        17 - Using Multi Criteria Decision Making Methods for Evaluation the Entrepreneurship and Innovation Indicators
        Mehdi karimi Farshid Namamian Farhad Vafaei Alireza Moradi
      • Open Access Article

        18 - Project Manager Competency Model Based on ANP Method in Construction Projects
        Ali Maleki Kaveh-Mohammad Cyrus
      • Open Access Article

        19 - Project Manager Competency Model based on ANP Method in Construction Projects
        Ali Maleki Maleki Kaveh Mohammad Cyrus
      • Open Access Article

        20 - Ranking the Methods of Technology Cross-Border Acquisition, Combining TOPSIS and ANP Approaches for Model Development
        Mehrdad Hoseini Shakib Somayeh Sahebi Arash Radmehr
      • Open Access Article

        21 - Performance Evaluation of IT Industries Using SERVQUAL, DEA and FMCDM
        Alireza Alinezhad Ramin Hakimian
      • Open Access Article

        22 - Providing an practical model of contractor selection and prioritization in project - based companies (Case Study: MAPNACompany)
        HOSEIN KARBAKHSH RAVARI sanjar salajegheh ayyub Sheikhi
        Accurate decision making for selecting contractors in order to manage a project is one of the most important factors of success and enhancing productivity of a project. So, extracting a practical model from the set of factors affecting the selection of contractors can p More
        Accurate decision making for selecting contractors in order to manage a project is one of the most important factors of success and enhancing productivity of a project. So, extracting a practical model from the set of factors affecting the selection of contractors can play an important role in improving the project performance, therefore, providing the proposed model is the main objective of this fundamental-applied research. The approach of this research is the integration of the qualitative and quantitative research and the statistical community are the experts of project management. At first, the model structure has been explained by analysis of data collected from the fundamental data theory approach. In the next step to test the conceptual model of research and hypothesis, the method of confirmatory factor analysis and structural equations based on variance was used using partial least squares method and data processing was performed using SMART PLS software. In the last step, to improve and applicability of the model, fuzzy analytic hierarchy technique, the weight of the criteria has been measured and prioritized .Finally, using fuzzy TOPSIS technique, an applied sample of contractor selection has been implemented. The results show that for the efficient selection of a contractor, by using a proposed model based on the determined coefficients and prioritize the sub-criteria of behavioral and technical capability, the company's capabilities and outsourcing goals, the achieving of optimal decision-making conditions is possible. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        23 - Ranking of Performance Evaluation Criteria in Participatory Urban Management Macro Projects by BSC and FANP
        Mojtaba Salehi Atena Mozaffari
        The public-private partnership means providing financial resources to the private sector to assist the government in carrying out large-scale infrastructure projects. Usually, participatory projects of urban management that need high investment and have a great complexi More
        The public-private partnership means providing financial resources to the private sector to assist the government in carrying out large-scale infrastructure projects. Usually, participatory projects of urban management that need high investment and have a great complexity in terms of technology and design are considered as participatory macro projects. So the performance evaluation of this kind of projects according to their regional influence is necessary. This study identifies and ranks the performance evaluation criteria of participatory urban management projects to use these criteria for creating a comprehensive approach for performance evaluation. The performance evaluation criteria are obtained for two major projects of Tehran urban management namely neighborhood house and cultural-sports complex by questionnaire with Cronbach’s Alpha = 0.97% coefficient. Then, these criteria are grouped based on the aspects of the Balanced Scorecard including financial, clients, internal processes and learning and growth. Then, using the fuzzy analysis network process, the network structure was designed to display and measure the weight of relationships between criteria and sub-criteria. Finally, two projects are evaluated and ranked by TOPSIS and VIKOR and SAW methods. In the financial, clients, internal processes aspects, neighborhood house project showed a better performance than cultural-sport complex, but in the growth and learning aspect, the result for two projects was almost identical. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        24 - Assessment and Prioritization of Sazehgostar Saipa's Information Technology Processes' Gaps Based on COBIT Framework
        Hessam Zandhessami Mohammad Hasan Kargar
        Control Objectives for information and related technology (COBIT) has become one of the most important guidelines for ITG, which provides organizations with a useful tool to start evaluating their own ITG systems. Since COBIT is a generic framework for any organization, More
        Control Objectives for information and related technology (COBIT) has become one of the most important guidelines for ITG, which provides organizations with a useful tool to start evaluating their own ITG systems. Since COBIT is a generic framework for any organization, it is crucial to prioritize the domains and processes of the framework based on the organization requirements.The COBIT framework was used to verify if IT processes are correctly managed in Sazehgostar Saipa Co. This research aims at identifying the situation of IT processes through evaluation of processes gap into an optimum level based on COBIT Framework. Research questions were as follows: 1.what is the levels of COBIT processes maturity and domains maturity? 2. The processes gap into the optimum level. 3. The weights of COBIT processes and domains based on IT strategies. 4. The prioritization of processes gap. The research steps were done based on research model using IT experts’ view and MCDM methods. The results of the research show that the corporation is powerful in “Acquire and Implement” and “Delivery and Support” domains more than other domains and the overall maturity level is 1.66. Besides, the results of gaps and prioritization of them in domains show that the most gaps are in “Manage Quality”, “Enable Operation and Use”, “Manage Problems” and “Provide IT Governance” Processes.   Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        25 - Optimum supplier selection based on a hybrid MCDM approach: AHP-VIKOR
        Armin Cheraghalipour Mohammad Mahdi Paydar Mostafa Hajiaghaei-Keshteli
        In recent decades, the selection of suitable suppliers as one of the important issues in the field of supply chain management is considered. The evaluation and selection of the best suppliers need to make decisions based on different criteria. In this study, a hybrid MC More
        In recent decades, the selection of suitable suppliers as one of the important issues in the field of supply chain management is considered. The evaluation and selection of the best suppliers need to make decisions based on different criteria. In this study, a hybrid MCDM approach consists of AHP and VIKOR methods has been proposed that at first paid to identify the most important criteria in the supplier selection based on previous studies and interviews with company executives. Then by using questionnaires, the paired comparisons of criteria and paired comparisons matrix of groups according to the views of managers and based on Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is performed. Next, using a multi-criteria optimization technique (VIKOR), firm's suppliers are ranked. Furthermore, a case study in the automotive industry is applied to accumulate data for proposed framework. Finally, by identifying effective criteria, appropriate suppliers, and similarity of obtained results with other studies, the efficiency of the proposed model is proved. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        26 - Locate Automated Teller Machines in Mehr Iran Bank by Using a Combination of Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Techniques in Fuzzy Environment
        Mehdi Ebrahimi Nejhad Rafsanjani Seyed Mohammad Moosavi Nadooshan Marjan Tavasoli Fard
        In the recent years, using information technology in Iran industries, mostly in banking, has been increased. Selecting the best site location for Automated Teller Machines (ATM) is also an important Subject for the banking industry. Site locating Sciences have always be More
        In the recent years, using information technology in Iran industries, mostly in banking, has been increased. Selecting the best site location for Automated Teller Machines (ATM) is also an important Subject for the banking industry. Site locating Sciences have always been searching for new optimization methods to find the best location of their case studies. Using Multi-Criteria Decision-Making methods can be expected that the candidate places satisfy the criteria by their weight ratio. Also, the use of fuzzy logic in decision making has been solved the problem of uncertainty and imprecision in assigning the weight of the criteria. So, the applied research study has been using a combined approach of MCDM in a fuzzy environment to provide a new method in Gharzolhasane Mehr Iran Bank ATMs site locating. Regarding the high costs of locating ATMs, the purpose of this study is to provide a method for selecting the best range of these devices Location to increase efficiency and services. Based on the similar studies, a decision criterion was extracted and weighted with FPM Procedure by using QMB and Banking industry expert’s opinions. Then the Location candidates points were ranked by Fuzzy Graph theory and matrix approach method. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        27 - A Comparative Analysis of Approaches to Multi-criteria Decision Gray Prioritize Suppliers (Case Study: Isfahan Mobarakeh Steel Company)
        Ahmad Reza Ghasemi Hashem Mozzez Fatemeh Abedi Jebeli
        The supply chain has recently attracted the attention of many researchers. The purpose of this paper is to identify Suppliers that have the highest potential capacity to meet the needs companies, with reasonable cost and also reduce the risk and maximize the total value More
        The supply chain has recently attracted the attention of many researchers. The purpose of this paper is to identify Suppliers that have the highest potential capacity to meet the needs companies, with reasonable cost and also reduce the risk and maximize the total value of purchaser. Since suppliers are different in terms of products strengths and weaknesses and general conditions, requires a careful evaluation by the purchaser. In order to do this activity in the Companies, there are many problems; one of those problems is to determine the appropriate criteria for assessing supplier. This is because often need to be expressed in the form of qualitative concepts, while they must be evaluated quantitatively. In addition, in terms of decision makers, importance and priorities of each criterion are different, and this is one of the main reasons that authors are seeking to present a model to select suppliers based on appropriate criteria with emphasis on the importance degree of them in the decision-making process. So at first with reviewing the literature, criteria influencing the choice of suppliers were identified, then using a questionnaire that was completed by a Team of experts to screening criteria was discussed. The qualitative and quantitative data were collected and the importance of effective criteria in supplier selection determined by AHP method and finally suppliers of this company ranked using Grey COPRAS method. The most important criteria for evaluation supplier were assets and infrastructure (0.275) and Behran supplier was identified as the best supplier. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        28 - Proper quarry mining method selection in Iran using fuzzy-Topsis approach (Case study: Granite quarry of Gazik in Birjand)
        Arash Ebrahim Abadi Iraj Alavi Sara Kahrobay Monfared
        There are several quarry mining methods which are phased out due to lots of difficulties to use and lack oftechnologies. Selecting the proper quarry mining method is a kind of Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM)problem which needs to be managed appropriately. Selectio More
        There are several quarry mining methods which are phased out due to lots of difficulties to use and lack oftechnologies. Selecting the proper quarry mining method is a kind of Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM)problem which needs to be managed appropriately. Selection Process deals with some factors affecting onselection approach such as revenue, safety, environmental issues, losses, mining period, etc. The aim of thisresearch is to choose the proper quarry mining method in Iranian quarry mines using Fuzzy-Topsis approach.There are some conventional quarry mining methods in Iran including Plug and Feather, Controlled BlastingTechnique, Expanded Powder, Diamond Cut Wire methods. Achieved results from analysis and investigationsshowed that the Diamond Cut Wire method is the most proper quarry mining method for Iranian quarry mines. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        29 - Management of Environmental Impacts due to Mining Operations Using Fuzzy Multiple Criteria Decision Making Techniques (Case Study: Chadormaloo Mining Complex)
        arash ebrahimabadi
        Destruction of area and changes in local ecosystem are viewed as the most important environmental impacts of mining operations in a region. Extents of disturbance area particularly waste dumps are also being increased as mining continues. Hence, environmental management More
        Destruction of area and changes in local ecosystem are viewed as the most important environmental impacts of mining operations in a region. Extents of disturbance area particularly waste dumps are also being increased as mining continues. Hence, environmental management and reclamation of mined lands play a major role in environmental protection in a specified mining region. With this respect, this paper describes optimum plant selection for reclamation process of mining in Chadormaloo mining complex as a case study. In all type of post mining land use such as Agriculture, Pasture, Forestry, Tourist attraction, Wild life creation, selection and planting the appropriate plant species is one the most essential requirements to successful implement the mine reclamation plan. The Research methodology is, Selecting of plant species that is on the basis of the primary factors that are: type of post mining land use, Climate, Nature­ of soil. Then priority is defined between the selected species, based on of the secondary factors by two Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) models that criteria are perspective of the region, resistance against disease and insects,­ strength and method of growth, availability of plant type, economic efficiency, protection of soil and storing water, prevention from pollution. These models are implemented by FUZZY AHP and FUZZY TOPSIS methods. The mentioned procedure was applied to Chadormaloo iron mine in Iran. Decision making was executed on the basis of oral judgments and experts’ opinions in the case study. Results showed that among candidate plants, Artemisia sieberi, Salsola yazdiana, Halophytes types, and Zygophyllum, respectively, are ranked and prioritized as optimum plants for reclamation process using two methods. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        30 - ANP         TOPSIS .),-**) , **)  +)) ( !'!&&"#$$%! !
        دکتربهمن حاجی پور دکترمنصور مومنی زهرا قاسمی
      • Open Access Article

        31 -      
        دکترامیر محمدزاده یونس اسکندری
      • Open Access Article

        32 - A New Model for Best Customer Segment Selection Using Fuzzy TOPSIS Based on Shannon Entropy
        Naime Ranjbar Kermany Sasan H. Alizadeh
      • Open Access Article

        33 - A Novel Method for Selecting the Supplier Based on Association Rule Mining
        Ali Molaali Mohammad Jafar Tarokh
      • Open Access Article

        34 - A New Approach in Fuzzy Multi Attribute Group Decision Making
        Akbar Alam Tabriz Naser Hamidi Farzad Pooyanfar
        In today’s modern organizations, group decision making is inevitable, and it is in wide use for facilitating participation of managers and personnel. Meanwhile we can’t easily ignore the role of conflict between decision makers. This conflict overshadows key More
        In today’s modern organizations, group decision making is inevitable, and it is in wide use for facilitating participation of managers and personnel. Meanwhile we can’t easily ignore the role of conflict between decision makers. This conflict overshadows key elements of decision. In fuzzy group multi criteria decision making, it is possible to see conflict in each criteria. So it will be a new Approach in multi criteria decision makings. Conflicts Classifying and facing each level in every criterion makes the base of method which is proposed in this research. Typically, this Approach  in the environment would be no crisp, and will need to use reasoning which controls fuzzy environment. This classifying is able to help decision makers in their committee to screen criteria and alternatives on one hand and Third-party intervention on the other hand. At the end of the paper a numeric example from selecting technology for the proposal approach is being mentioned Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        35 - Promoting a Hierarchical Model of Decision-Making in Business Process Outsourcing Utilizing MCDM Approach
        mahmoud modiri ali ansari farshad
        Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) is a critical issue in management of organizations, and IT outsourcing is an advanced type of outsourcing. An Organization that decides to outsource part of its activities will initially raise the question of what activities to outsour More
        Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) is a critical issue in management of organizations, and IT outsourcing is an advanced type of outsourcing. An Organization that decides to outsource part of its activities will initially raise the question of what activities to outsource. However, given the absence of a solid scientific and systematic framework and processes for strategic decision-making of outsourcing services, organizations face diverse problems. The Purpose of this article was to utilize Decision tools with multiple criteria in order to identify and rank the indicators that may affect the business process outsourcing. Also, we used the techniques of Analytic Hierarchical Process in order to calculate the weight of these factors and options raised in the business process outsourcing. Also the magnitude of relationships between the indicators of outsourcing (IT) was examined using DEMATEL technique. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        36 - A Desirable Model for Optimizing the Policy of Service to Customers with Simulation Queue and MCDM Approach
        Mahmud Modiri Nooredin Anvari
        Todays, Post Corporation is played an important role to decrease the traffic mass, air pollution and speedup the works. These organizations are classified as a service organization dealing with costumers and staffs. Every days, these organization is faced with large amo More
        Todays, Post Corporation is played an important role to decrease the traffic mass, air pollution and speedup the works. These organizations are classified as a service organization dealing with costumers and staffs. Every days, these organization is faced with large amount of people which standed in queues.  Analysis of queuing systems and decrease the UNFAVORABLE effects of expect is, one of the most noticeable subjects in practical mathematic and operation research. This research is followed above trend. Moreover it is helped to post corporation to decrease their problem providing reasonable services to costumers. First, the problem is defined. Next, system of office queuing is recognized. Finally the total office is chosen in Alborz province for starting special study and determining the way of giving service presentation to costumers as well. As a result, a mathematic model is exhibited based on queuing system structure. The results are shown with Enterprise Dynamic simulation software. The most important advantage of this software is, helped to optimize the system and to predict the function. At the end of study, 4 patterns are also proposed based on experts view. Moreover, three indexes are chosen for evaluation. After all, sequence of models is done based on Topsis Procedure. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        37 - Identify and Prioritize the Assessment Indicators of Organizational Performance According to ‎Stable Balanced Score Card and MCDM by Using Linguistic Variables
        Ali Reza Irajpour Morteza Hajilo
        Sustainability balanced scorecard based on the parameters of sustainable development is a useful and ‎powerful method for evaluating the sustainability performance of the organization or company. This issue was noted in literature review of this paper. The issue of More
        Sustainability balanced scorecard based on the parameters of sustainable development is a useful and ‎powerful method for evaluating the sustainability performance of the organization or company. This issue was noted in literature review of this paper. The issue of this paper covers the aspects of ‎identify and prioritizes of organization performance assessment indicators. In this study, we examine the approach of sustainability balanced scorecard with fuzzy analysis ‎network process for ranking indicators of performance evaluation in poutine plastic industry Co. At first, for designing a model, the lists of related indicators by using the existent literature review ‎were extracted and then the model was reviewed by experts of the company and the exponential ‎model was proposed. The results show that cash flow is in first priority and air pollution and increase of ‎labor/work force skills are next priorities respectively.The proposed model has shown that performance indicators can merge with various aspects of ‎sustainable balanced scorecard by using of fuzzy analysis network technique.‎ Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        38 - Investigating the Causal Relationships Between Critical Factors in Tax Fraud in Iran Using Group Anp and Fuzzy Dematel
        Mohammad Khalilzadeh Davod Sedighezadeh Morteza Vassie Mohammad Reza Pashapour Hedeyeh Shakeri
        Tax fraud essentially entails cheating on a tax return in an attempt to avoid paying the entire tax obligation. Tax fraud is one of the most important issues in each economic system which can be difficultly analyzed. The aim of this research paper is to identify the cau More
        Tax fraud essentially entails cheating on a tax return in an attempt to avoid paying the entire tax obligation. Tax fraud is one of the most important issues in each economic system which can be difficultly analyzed. The aim of this research paper is to identify the causal relationships and prioritize the main effective factors in tax fraud in Iran. In this paper, we use Decision Making Trial and Evaluation (DEMATEL) technique together with Group Analytic Network Process (ANP) method in fuzzy environment. Also, we propose an experimental example to show that the fuzzy Multi Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) model can measure and evaluate the tax fraud issue in real world problems. The findings and results can be presented to the decision makers to select the best solution in order to prevent and confront the tax fraud problem. Finally, five principal factors and twenty secondary factors in tax fraud problem are identified and analyzed by the proposed model and interviewing with experts. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        39 - A note on "An interval type-2 fuzzy extension of the TOPSIS method using alpha cuts"
        Amir Mohamadghasemi
      • Open Access Article

        40 - Vendor Selection: An Enhanced Hybrid Fuzzy MCDM Model
        Behnam Vahdani Akbar Alem-Tabriz Mostafa Zandieh
      • Open Access Article

        41 - A Compromise Decision-making Model for Multi-objective Large-scale Programming Problems with a Block Angular Structure under Uncertainty
        behnam vahdani meghdad Salimi behrouz Afshar najafi
      • Open Access Article

        42 - Evaluation and Comparison of LEED, BREEAM, and the 19th issue of National Building Regulations of Iran (NBRI) in Perspective of Sustainability by (MCDM) TOPSIS Method
        Mohammad Javad Mahdavinejad Mohammad Mehranrad Nasim Eslamirad
      • Open Access Article

        43 - Possibility of establishing the solar panels in the East Azerbaijan province With assessment Incoming radiation and climate parameters
        Shahram Roostaei Mojtaba Pirnazar Arash Zandkarimi Bakhtiar Feizizadeh Neda Moosavi
        The present study focused on feasibility assessment of establishing solar panels sites within the East Azerbaijan. The research’s methodology was established based on GIS spatial decision making systems. It should be mentioned that decreasing nonrenewable sources' More
        The present study focused on feasibility assessment of establishing solar panels sites within the East Azerbaijan. The research’s methodology was established based on GIS spatial decision making systems. It should be mentioned that decreasing nonrenewable sources' process has been considered as one of the serious challenges. Thus, using solar energy is a solution to deal with this challenge. The high topoclimatic and physical properties of the East Azerbaijan tends to establish solar panels for producing electricity. In order to evaluate the possibility of establishing solar systems, within this research we aim to apply GIS-multi criteria decision making models for integrating the data and selecting to potential sites for solar panels. To achieve this, the prior options from different options of analyses network model (ANP) was applied for analyzing the criteria. As part of methodology, the Landsat satellite was used for extracting land use/cover. The SRTM dataset also employed for exploring the elevation, slope, aspect and solar shining. The climate dataset were used for monitoring climatological parameters such as raining, temperature, humidity, number of dusty days, number of cloudy days and sunny hours within the period of 1986 to 2014. Finally the solar panel suitability maps achieved by compounding the informative layers and multiplying those criteria were accessed from executing the model. The results indicated that 48.61% of the study area has very high suitability for solar panels programs. While the northern parts of East Azerbaijan province includes very low potentiality for producing solar based energy. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        44 - Entrepreneurship policy and innovative indicators of industrial companies: Evaluation by MCDM and ANN Methods
        mehdi karimi farshid namamian farhad vafaei Alireza Moradi
      • Open Access Article

        45 - A non-additive fuzzy hybrid model for supplier evaluation and prioritization: A case study of automotive brake system manufacturer
        Naser Hamidi Parvaneh Samouei
      • Open Access Article

        46 - رتبه بندی و مدیریت سهام در بازار بورس با استفاده از تحلیل بنیادی و تکنیکی (مطالعه موردی: بورس تهران)
        علیرضا علی نژاد ابوالفضل کاظمی کیوان صراف ها
        یکی از دلایل اصلی انجام این پژوهش، عدم اطمینان دست اندرکاران اوراق بهادار در زمینه صحت رتبه بندی سهام بورس بالخص صنعت مالی که یکی از ارکان اصلی بورس می‌باشد است. در این پژوهش سعی شده است تا با استخراج شاخص‌های مورد نیاز جهت رتبه بندی دقیق شرکت‌ها در بازار سرمایه تهران د More
        یکی از دلایل اصلی انجام این پژوهش، عدم اطمینان دست اندرکاران اوراق بهادار در زمینه صحت رتبه بندی سهام بورس بالخص صنعت مالی که یکی از ارکان اصلی بورس می‌باشد است. در این پژوهش سعی شده است تا با استخراج شاخص‌های مورد نیاز جهت رتبه بندی دقیق شرکت‌ها در بازار سرمایه تهران در پروسه خرید سهام کمک نموده و به عنوان راهنمای کلی مدنظر قرار گیرد. از دیگر اهداف اصلی این پژوهش، بکارگیری ترکیبی دو دیدگاه مهم در مسیر یافتن مطلوبترین سهام یعنی تحلیل بنیادی و تحلیل تکنیکی است. لذا در این تحقیق ابتدا پس از تعیین گروه تصمیم گیری(خبرگان بورس) و استخراج شاخص‌های اولیه از ادبیات موضوع، با استفاده از روش‌های آماری ناپارامتریک به تعیین شاخص‌های نهایی پرداخته شده است. سپس با استفاده از تکنیک مقایسات زوجی(بهبود در AHP) جهت تصمیم گیری گروهی به تعیین وزن معیارها با استفاده از تأثیرات متقابل آنها بر یکدیگر اقدام شد. سپس با استفاده از روش PROMETHEE و استخراج اطلاعات مربوط به صنایع مالی خدماتی، ابتدا به رتبه بندی این صنایع و پس از آن به رتبه بندی شرکت­های فعال در صنایع برتر شناخته شده پرداخته شده است. پس از انجام تحلیل بنیادی، با مطالعه ادبیات تحقیق و آنچه که در حال حاضر در شرکت‌های کارگزاری به کار گرفته می‌شود، سه شاخص از مهم ترین و پرکاربردترین شاخص­های تکنیکی را جهت تحلیل تکنیکی شرکت­های برتر شناخته شده انتخاب و در انتها زمان مناسب جهت معامله در بازه زمانی سال 1390 تعیین گردید.  Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        47 - Modeling and Ranking the Criteria in Providing Favorable Financing for Public Sector by Using MCDM: Case study of Mashhad Metropolis
        rasool ghorbani mitra azimi
        Abstract This study is to use a library and comparative analysis method for ranking the criteria affecting the optimal model in Mashhad municipal finance and then providing a scheme for the model developed. To get the goal, 23 people are selected in Mashhad Municipalit More
        Abstract This study is to use a library and comparative analysis method for ranking the criteria affecting the optimal model in Mashhad municipal finance and then providing a scheme for the model developed. To get the goal, 23 people are selected in Mashhad Municipality officials and economic experts to complete the questionnaire. The data are analyzed based on Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and Expert Choice software. Finally, after weighting and ranking the criteria and decision options, a funding desired pattern is provided for Municipality of Mashhad in three Macro, medial and local levels. The results represent that   renovation tax, building and land tax (except municipal consolidation taxes), value- added tax and the costs of utilities, are respectively the most important policy priorities on the stabilization of municipal revenues. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        48 - Ranking 7Ms Effective Factors in Iranian Production Systems Using Fuzzy AHP
        Amir Amini Alireza Alinezhad
      • Open Access Article

        49 - The Reference Ideal Method and the Pythagorean Fuzzy Numbers
        Elio Cables María Teresa Lamata Jose Luis Verdegay
      • Open Access Article

        50 - Comparison of Distance-Based Fuzzy MCDM Techniques to Evaluate Marketing Strategies for Tourism-Pilgrimage Hotels During a Pandemic
        Milad Khajiyan Sheini Pour Mohammad Hemati
      • Open Access Article

        51 - رویکرد DEA-TOPSIS برای تجزیه و تحلیل عملکرد مالی بانک های بخش دولتی هند
        hari Tata vijaya nimmagadda
        توسعه سریع اینترنت و تجارت الکترونیکی، بخش بانکی  را به سمت تشویق مشتریان به بانکداری اینترنتی (IB) را تحریک کرده است، با این حال، شواهد نشان دهنده عدم علاقه در استفاده از خدمات IB است. بنابراین، هدف این مقاله شناسایی عوامل موثر بر پذیرش مشتری ازطریق IB و سنجش تاثی More
        توسعه سریع اینترنت و تجارت الکترونیکی، بخش بانکی  را به سمت تشویق مشتریان به بانکداری اینترنتی (IB) را تحریک کرده است، با این حال، شواهد نشان دهنده عدم علاقه در استفاده از خدمات IB است. بنابراین، هدف این مقاله شناسایی عوامل موثر بر پذیرش مشتری ازطریق IB و سنجش تاثیر هر یک از عوامل در پذیرش  IBاست. بر اساس یک بررسی آثار گذشته تحقیقاتی، تعدادی از عوامل به عنوان عوامل  موثر در پذیرش مشتری از طریق IB در نظر گرفته شدند. سپس، این عوامل به یک نمونه از مشتریان IB در قالب یک پرسشنامه ارسال شدند. پس از جمع آوری پرسشنامه ها ی پر شده و بر اساس آزمون آماری، مهمترین عامل در میان آنها مورد تحقیق قرار گرفت. از این رو، بسیاری از این عوامل با یکدیگرمرتبط هستند؛ روش مبتنی نظریه گراف (DEMATEL) با ساختار بازخورد استفاده شده است تا اثرات مستقیم و غیر مستقیم عوامل موثر بر عوامل دیگر و کل سیستم را بررسی کند. نتایج نشان داد که: پاسخدهی (بررسی موثر مشکلات)، دسترسی به خدمات IB (نیازهای سخت افزاری)، سرعت شبکه، سهولت استفاده و بدون نیاز به حضور فیزیکی در شعبه بانک، به ترتیب، مهمترین عوامل بحرانی هستند.   Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        52 - روش ارزیابی ترکیبی برای رتبه های چندگانه بر اساس VIKOR و DEA با ساختار BELIEF تحت عدم قطعیت
        امیر امینی علیرضا علینژاد
        در این مقاله یک روش ترکیبی براساس بر اساس VIKOR و تحلیل پوششی داده ها (DEA) برای انتخاب واحدهای دارای بیشترین کارآیی ارائه شده است. ما از VIKOR به عنوان یک روش حل مصالحه آمیز استفاده می کنیم. این تحقیق یک مدل دو مرحله است که برای رتبه بندی کامل گزینه های جایگزین طراحی ش More
        در این مقاله یک روش ترکیبی براساس بر اساس VIKOR و تحلیل پوششی داده ها (DEA) برای انتخاب واحدهای دارای بیشترین کارآیی ارائه شده است. ما از VIKOR به عنوان یک روش حل مصالحه آمیز استفاده می کنیم. این تحقیق یک مدل دو مرحله است که برای رتبه بندی کامل گزینه های جایگزین طراحی شده و در آن هر جایگزین دارای ورودی ها و خروجی های متعدد است. این مسئله شامل پارامترهای باور در روش راه حل است. ابتدا، مشکل ارزیابی جایگزین بوسیله تحلیل پوششی داده ها (DEA) تدوین شده و در مرحله دوم ما از نظر متخصصان با پارامتر باور در یک مدل تصمیم گیری گروهی (DM) به نام ماتریس تصمیم گیری باور فازی جمع شده استفاده می کنیم. در این روش وزن کارآیی به دست آمده از VIKOR با وزن مدل CCR تحلیل پوششی داده ها ضرب می شود. در نهایت، برای نشان دادن روش پیشنهادی، یک مثال ارائه شده است.   Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        53 - تجزیه و تحلیل عوامل موثر بر پذیرش مشتریان از خدمات بانکداری اینترنتی با استفاده از نظریه گراف
        Ali Sharifi Mahdi Homayounfar
        توسعه سریع اینترنت و تجارت الکترونیکی، بخش بانکی  را به سمت تشویق مشتریان به بانکداری اینترنتی (IB) را تحریک کرده است، با این حال، شواهد نشان دهنده عدم علاقه در استفاده از خدمات IB است. بنابراین، هدف این مقاله شناسایی عوامل موثر بر پذیرش مشتری ازطریق IB و سنجش تاثی More
        توسعه سریع اینترنت و تجارت الکترونیکی، بخش بانکی  را به سمت تشویق مشتریان به بانکداری اینترنتی (IB) را تحریک کرده است، با این حال، شواهد نشان دهنده عدم علاقه در استفاده از خدمات IB است. بنابراین، هدف این مقاله شناسایی عوامل موثر بر پذیرش مشتری ازطریق IB و سنجش تاثیر هر یک از عوامل در پذیرش  IBاست. بر اساس یک بررسی آثار گذشته تحقیقاتی، تعدادی از عوامل به عنوان عوامل  موثر در پذیرش مشتری از طریق IB در نظر گرفته شدند. سپس، این عوامل به یک نمونه از مشتریان IB در قالب یک پرسشنامه ارسال شدند. پس از جمع آوری پرسشنامه ها ی پر شده و بر اساس آزمون آماری، مهمترین عامل در میان آنها مورد تحقیق قرار گرفت. از این رو، بسیاری از این عوامل با یکدیگرمرتبط هستند؛ روش مبتنی نظریه گراف (DEMATEL) با ساختار بازخورد استفاده شده است تا اثرات مستقیم و غیر مستقیم عوامل موثر بر عوامل دیگر و کل سیستم را بررسی کند. نتایج نشان داد که: پاسخدهی (بررسی موثر مشکلات)، دسترسی به خدمات IB (نیازهای سخت افزاری)، سرعت شبکه، سهولت استفاده و بدون نیاز به حضور فیزیکی در شعبه بانک، به ترتیب، مهمترین عوامل بحرانی هستند. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        54 - تصمیم‌سازی ورود و توسعه دو نوع فناوری HVDC و EHVAC برای ایران با استفاده از الگوریتم تصمیم‌سازی MULTIMOORA
        Ali Aranizadeh Mehrzad Kazemi Homayoun Barahmandpour mirpouya mirmozaffari
        امروزه جمعیت در مناطق شهری روزبه‌روز در حال افزایش است و نیاز مصرف نیز به همان شدت افزایش می‌یابد. این حجم از مصرف، نیاز به مراکز تولید توان با حجم انبوه را نیز طلب می‌کند که این دو عامل خود موجب گرایش تکنولوژی به سمت سیستم‌های انتقال توان با ظرفیت بالا خواهد شد. در این More
        امروزه جمعیت در مناطق شهری روزبه‌روز در حال افزایش است و نیاز مصرف نیز به همان شدت افزایش می‌یابد. این حجم از مصرف، نیاز به مراکز تولید توان با حجم انبوه را نیز طلب می‌کند که این دو عامل خود موجب گرایش تکنولوژی به سمت سیستم‌های انتقال توان با ظرفیت بالا خواهد شد. در این میان دو نوع فناوری انتقال توان الکتریکی HVDC و EHVAC قابل بررسی خواهد بود. منتهی هر یک از این دو نوع فناوری همچنان در کشور ایران استفاده نشده است و برهمین اساس می‌بایست تصمیمی جهت ورود و توسعه هر یک از این فناوری‌ها گرفته شود. همچنین ورود هردوی این فناوری‌ها نیز به-صرفه نخواهد بود. در نتیجه در این مقاله به تصمیم‌گیری در مورد انتخاب ورود و توسعه یکی از دو نوع فناوری HVDC و EHVAC خواهیم پرداخت. برای این منظور ابتدا معیارهای این انتخاب را به تفصیل بیان کرده و سپس با استفاده از الگوریتم تصمیم‌سازی مالتی-مورا، به تصمیم‌گیری نهایی خواهیم رسید. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        55 - بررسی مداخلات موثر بر توسعه تولید کشاورزی حساس به تغذیه توسط فرایند تحلیل شبکه ای
        مریم مورج حسین شعبانعلی فمی ژیلا دانشور عامری علی اسدی
        تغذیه  هم به­عنوان ورودی و هم نتیجه توسعه پایدار شناخته می­شود،  جایی که تولید کشاورزی نیز نقش غیرقابل انکاری ایفا می­کند. استان البرز به عنوان یکی از استان‌های بزرگ ایران، با مشکلات متعددی مواجه می­باشد که طی سال‌های گذشته بر امنیت غذایی آن تأ More
        تغذیه  هم به­عنوان ورودی و هم نتیجه توسعه پایدار شناخته می­شود،  جایی که تولید کشاورزی نیز نقش غیرقابل انکاری ایفا می­کند. استان البرز به عنوان یکی از استان‌های بزرگ ایران، با مشکلات متعددی مواجه می­باشد که طی سال‌های گذشته بر امنیت غذایی آن تأثیر منفی گذاشته است،.به­طوری که اجرای کشاورزی حساس به تغذیه برای رفع این مشکلات ضروری تلقی می­شود. پژوهش حاضر به بررسی مداخلات مؤثر بر اجرای تولید محصولات کشاورزی حساس به تغذیه در استان البرز بر اساس تحلیل تصمیم‌گیری چندمعیاره (MCDM) برای اولویت‌بندی این مداخلات و همچنین شناسایی بهترین استراتژی اجرایی برای پیگیری در منطقه پرداخته است. به منظور دستیابی به این اهداف، با استفاده از فرآیند شبکه تحلیلی (ANP)بر اساس مطالعات کتابخانه­ای و اسنادی و مصاحبه با کارشناسان و مراجع، ساختار مدل ANP تدوین شده و مقایسه­های زوجی صورت گرفته است. نتایج نشان می‌دهد که مهم‌ترین عامل مداخله گر، در ابتدا "تولید درآمد برای تغذیه" و پس از آن "جابجایی، ذخیره‌سازی و فرآوری حساس به تغذیه پس از برداشت" ، می­باشد. تصمیم­گیران و مسئولان این استان، باید در اجرای کشاورزی حساس به تغذیه، به این جنبه­ها توجه بیشتری داشته باشند. همچنین، استراتژی پیاده­سازی بلندمدت (6 تا 20 سال) جایگزین بهتری برای هدف­گذاری و برنامه­ریزی تصمیم­گیران و مقامات است. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        56 - A fuzzy MCDM model with objective and subjective weights for evaluating service quality in hotel industries
        Nima Zoraghi Maghsoud Amiri Golnaz Talebi Mahdi Zowghi
      • Open Access Article

        57 - JIT single machine scheduling problem with periodic preventive maintenance
        Mohammadreza Shahriari Naghi Shoja Amir Ebrahimi Zade Sasan Barak Mani Sharifi
      • Open Access Article

        58 - Multi-factor failure mode critically analysis using TOPSIS
        a Sachdeva D Kumar P Kumar
      • Open Access Article

        59 - An MCDM-DEA approach for technology selection
        A Alinezhad A Makui R Kiani Mavi M Zohrehbandian
      • Open Access Article

        60 - Investigating the Factors Affecting the Success of SME'S Innovation Ecosystem Using Fuzzy AHP
        هنگامه معینی پور مریم مصلح ماه منیر بیاناتی
        In severe market conditions, innovation is the creation, development, andimplementation of new ideas or improvement in current products, processes, andstrategies, consequently leading to successful trading and market leadership,providing values for beneficiaries, bringi More
        In severe market conditions, innovation is the creation, development, andimplementation of new ideas or improvement in current products, processes, andstrategies, consequently leading to successful trading and market leadership,providing values for beneficiaries, bringing economic growth, and improving theliving standards. An innovation ecosystem is described as a physical environmentthat refers to a network or cluster of entrepreneurs, inventors, enterprises,universities, research laboratories, governmental agencies, and other institutions andresources aiming at achieving a new process or product development. Therefore, thisresearch mainly aims to identify and prioritize the factors affecting the success of theinnovation ecosystem in enhancing small businesses. In this research, afteridentifying the effective factors using library study and interviews with managers atscience and technology parks, a Delphi survey was applied to recognize main factorsfor the statistical population, including companies located in Tehran, Pardis, andQom Science and Technology Parks. Then, the AHP questionnaire was used toprioritize the factors. The results can be helpful to innovation ecosystems to find andapply their critical success factors, foster small businesses and startups, and survivein the competition ground. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        61 - Providing the Optimal Economic Model of Investment in the Agricultural Sector of Mazandaran Province Using Multi-Criteria Decision Making Models
        مجید قربانی ابوالفضل محمودی محسن شوکت فدایی محمد خالدی
        Economic development requires investment in various sectors of the economy. The agricultural sector has a major share of Iran's GDP, employment and food security. The main objectives of this study are to identify and prioritize investment potentials in the agricultural More
        Economic development requires investment in various sectors of the economy. The agricultural sector has a major share of Iran's GDP, employment and food security. The main objectives of this study are to identify and prioritize investment potentials in the agricultural sector of Mazandaran province using multi-criteria decision making (MCDM) models. For this purpose, 8 investment options of the province, including: pressurized irrigation, construction of gardens and pastures, electrification of wells, poultry farming, watershed management, conversion industries, fisheries and greenhouses were selected. Increasing production capacity was compared and prioritized. The results showed that in the criterion of the return on investment period and the rate of return on capital, activities that do not require group work and have fewer employees are a priority. Also, according to the final calculations, the processing industry has the first priority in the investment of the province's agricultural sector, and watershed management, construction of gardens and pastures, poultry farming, pressurized irrigation, fisheries and aquaculture, electrification of wells and finally greenhouses in the second to eighth priority were placed.Based on the research results, it was suggested that facilitating the inflow of funds into the agricultural sector and the impact of government fiscal policies on private sector activities should be considered by policy makers and the policy of reform and development of the financial sector should be a priority in the country. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        62 - Prediction of Land Use Management Scenarios Impact on Water Erosion Risk in Kashidar Watershed, Azadshahr, Golestan Province
        Davoud Akhzari Samaneh Eftekhari Ahandani Behnaz Attaeian Alireza Ildoromi
      • Open Access Article

        63 - An Application of Fuzzy TOPSIS Method for Plant Selection in Rangeland Improvement (Case Study: Boroujerd Rangeland, Lorestan Province, Iran)
        Ali Ariapour Farzad Veisanloo Marzieh Asgari
      • Open Access Article

        64 - تبیین الگوی ارزیابی عملکرد مالی در بنگاه‌های کسب و کار
        فریدون رهنمای رودپشتی قدرت الله طالب نیا محمدرضا براتی
      • Open Access Article

        65 - Optimization portfolio selection model with financial and ethical considerations
        elham fallahi ganzagh Farimah Mokhatab Rafiei
        The moral investment movement that began in the 1960s in the United States has recently led to a massive move around the world. Growing cases of corporate scams and scandals have pushed investors to consider the quality of corporate governance and the ethics of their be More
        The moral investment movement that began in the 1960s in the United States has recently led to a massive move around the world. Growing cases of corporate scams and scandals have pushed investors to consider the quality of corporate governance and the ethics of their behavior. Also, investors are becoming aware of the desirability of moral aberration of assets.The growing influence of institutional investors has strengthened this awareness. Hence, in order to research in this field, there should be an understanding of the progress made in constructing models that are consistent with financially ethical considerations. We use multiple methodologies to achieve this goal. To obtain the ethical performance scores of each asset, based on the investor's preferences, a hierarchical process approach has been used. A multi-faceted decision-making method is used to obtain the rating of each asset based on the investor's rate on the financial benchmark. Model of portfolio optimization is available to obtain diverse, reliable, and well-matched portfolio portfolios. The purpose of this model is to maximize the financial purpose as the primary purpose and maximize the ethical goal adopted by the investor. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        66 - Optimal Strategy Selection by Using a Combination of SWOT and Fuzzy ANP Techniques
        morad kordi ziynab ghasabzadeh langari
        Survival and life of an organization depend on correct decisions when facing opportunities and threats in the external environment of the organization. Since no organization can have infinite resources, strategists must decide on which strategy among various ones can le More
        Survival and life of an organization depend on correct decisions when facing opportunities and threats in the external environment of the organization. Since no organization can have infinite resources, strategists must decide on which strategy among various ones can lead to maximum profit. SWOT analysis enables managers to discover and identify internal and external factors affecting strategies of the organization. Therefore, the above-mentioned analysis is an appropriate tool to formulate strategies; however, it does not have the capability to evaluate the dependency of identified factors. In this study, a Fuzzy-ANP model is used to support SWOT process. This model considers not only the internal dependency of factors but also the ambiguity that appears in the opinions of decision makers by the application of the model in the fuzzy environment; although that the current techniques such as AHP consider factors independently. The network model presented here to analyze SWOT consists of four levels: the goal (best strategy) is in the first level; SWOT criteria, 4 main criteria and 24 sub-criteria are in the second and third level respectively; and finally alternatives (4 strategy). To calculate weights of SWOT factors, based on ANP method, a questionnaire in the form of paired comparison is designed and then given to the experts of the company studied. Afterwards, the geometric mean is applied, and finally based on ANP model, SO strategy with maximum weight is selected for the company. Manuscript profile
      • Open Access Article

        67 - Optimizing the Risk of Building Environments Using Multi-Criteria Decision Making
        Eghbal Sekhavati Reza jalilzadeh
      • Open Access Article

        68 - Appraisal of Industrial Plans with Expected Monetary Value Approach Using FAHP in the Ceramic and Tile Industry
        Masoud Merati
        One of the essential issues existing in the industry section and long term investments is the procedure of evaluation and selection of industrial projects. Since selection of the optimum and appropriate project, is followed by economic efficiency and conversely the fail More
        One of the essential issues existing in the industry section and long term investments is the procedure of evaluation and selection of industrial projects. Since selection of the optimum and appropriate project, is followed by economic efficiency and conversely the failure of a project causes time and cost wastage and will be followed by huge adverse consequences. Hence, decision making in this field is complicated and various tangible, intangible, qualitative and quantitative factors are involved in it and for this reason identification, study and analysis of them is necessary. In order to evaluate the projects in this article, initially technical and financial studies are considered and analyzed and its results are posed. Technical studies include estimation of investment constant costs, estimation of the plan income, costs before usage, capital turnover and production charges and financial studies include estimation of net current value indices, internal output rate, profitability index, capital return period, break – even analysis and other factors which contribute to economic evaluation of the project. The case study in this research is construction of a tile factory which five plans which in fact involve the research options are considered with indices and various technical and economic factors which through Fuzzy Hierarchical Analysis Technique which is Fuzzy Multivariate Decision Making Methods, have been compared so that the best option is selected and the projects are ranked. The ‌considered indices involve four financial indices including net current value, capital return period, investment output, sales output and the ratio of numerical break – even. The research result indicates that the projects ranking results is very close to the ranking on the basis of internal output rate. Manuscript profile