بررسی رابطه متقابل میان کاهش عمر ساختمان و افزایش ارزش منطقه ای آن در کلان شهر تبریز (مطالعه موردی: شهرک زعفرانیه)

محورهای موضوعی : برنامه ریزی شهری

اکبر اصغری زمانی ¹ , سمیه علیزاده ²

1 - دانشیار گروه جغرافیا و برنامه ریزی شهری، دانشکده برنامه‌ریزی و علوم محیطی، دانشگاه تبریز، تبریز، ایران
2 - کارشناسی ارشد جغرافیا و برنامه ریزی شهری، دانشکده علوم انسانی، دانشگاه زنجان، زنجان، ایران

تاریخ دریافت : 1400/08/23 تاریخ پذیرش : 1400/09/27 تاریخ انتشار : 1400/10/01

کلید واژه: ارزش منطقه‌ای, تراکم ساختمانی, عمر بنا,

چکیده مقاله :

امروزه رشد شتابان و بی رویه شهرها به ویژه در کلانشهرها نیاز به مسکن را در سطح وسیع، به یک چالش اساسی در مباحث برنامه ریزی شهری و جغرافیای انسانی تبدیل کرده است. به همین منظور وقوع پدیده حرکت سلولی که بیشتر در مناطقی با ارزش منطقه‌ای بالا مشاهده می شود. در پژوهش حاضر برآنیم با هدف ارزیابی ارتباط متقابل میان طول عمر ساختمان و افزایش تراکم در منطقه 2 کلانشهر تبریز ( شهرک زعفرانیه) به بررسی اصول و شاخص های حاکم بر میزان ساخت وساز متراکم در محدوده مورد مطالعه بپردازیم. از لحاظ هدف، کاربردی و از نظر ماهیت جز تحقیقات توصیفی – تحلیلی محسوب می گردد. جهت جمع آوری داده ها و اطلاعات پس از بررسی مبانی نظری پژوهش، جهت استخراج قیمت زمین های مسکونی کوی زعفرانیه (قیمت زمین و پروانه های ساختمانی صادر شده) طی بازه زمانی 1398– 1388 از طریق مراجعه به بنگاه‌های ملکی و شهرداری به صورت محله ای تهیه شد. به منظور تجزیه وتحلیل اثرات افزایش ارزش منطقه‌ای وکاهش عمر مفید ساختمان‌ها با افزایش تراکم ساختمانی، از مدل هایی شامل درون یابی کریجینگ، کرنل، کراس تب، فازی سازی، آنتروپی شانون و پیرسون در محیط نرم افزاری GIS، IDRISI، SPSS و EXCEL بهره گرفته شد. نتایج پژوهش حاکی از وجود همبستگی بالا بین افزایش ارزش منطقه ای و افزایش تراکم ساختمانی در کوی زعفرانیه با میزانی برابر 863/0 می باشد. درواقع از آنجاییکه شهرک زعفرانیه جزوه مناطق با ارزش بالای شهر تبریز محسوب می شود و عمر قطعات و سلولهای تغییر یافته همگی کمتر از سی سال بوده، این موضوع نشان دهنده همبستگی بین افزایش ارزش منطقه ای و کاهش عمر مفید ساختمان ها خواهد بود.

چکیده انگلیسی:

      Today, the rapid growth of cities and the consequent need for large-scale housing have made the issue of dealing with widespread change in metropolitan areas a major challenge in urban planning and human geography. Therefore, the occurrence of the phenomenon of cell movement, which is mostly observed in areas with high regional values. in the present study, with the aim of evaluating the correlation between the life of the building and the increase in density in Region 2 of Tabriz metropolis (Zafaranieh town) to investigate the principles and indicators governing the amount of dense construction in the study area. In terms of purpose, it is applied in terms of purpose and descriptive-analytical research in terms of nature. In order to collect data and information, two main methods of field libraries have been used. Thus, after reviewing the theoretical foundations of the research, to extract the price of residential land in Zafaranieh alley (land price and issued building permits) during the period 2009-2019 by referring to real estate agencies and municipalities as neighborhood it was prepared. In order to analyze the effects of increasing the regional value and reducing the useful life of buildings by increasing building density, models including kriging interpolation, kernel, cross-writing, fuzzy, Shannon and Pearson entropy in GIS, IDRISI software environment , SPSS and EXCEL were used. There is a high correlation between increasing the value of the area and increasing the building density in the area, which is equal to 0.863. In fact, since Zafaranieh town with average land value is one of the high value areas of Tabriz and the life of altered parts and cells is less than thirty years, this shows the correlation between increasing the regional value and reducing the useful life of the building.Extended AbstractIntroduction:      Today, the rapid growth of cities, especially in metropolitan areas, has made the need for housing on a large scale a major challenge in the field of urban planning and human geography. To solve this problem, some countries have adopted high-ranking, so that the phenomenon of cell movement occurs, which is more common in areas with high regional values. due to the novelty of the issue of density sales in all these plans and urban studies, the sources that have described the issue of density, less the existence of its relationship with the most important dimension of density, namely valuation Regional and its impact on building life have been mentioned both globally and nationally, and this issue has been somewhat neglected, so the main feature of this study is to contribute to specialized progress and add to the scientific literature on building density and effects. Resulting in a useful life; In this way, using the common point of both axes, it moved towards achieving sustainable development and sustainable architecture in the coming years. Therefore, in the present study, with the aim of evaluating the interrelationship between the life of the building and the increase in density in Tabriz 2 metropolitan area (Zafaranieh town) to investigate the principles and indicators governing the amount of dense construction in the study area.Methodology:       According to its purpose, this research is an applied research and has a descriptive-analytical nature. Data and information were collected in two main ways; Thus, first the theoretical foundations and existing experiences related to building density and building life were examined using the library method and literature review, and then according to the main research problem based on the case study of the research to collect data. , Field harvesting method was used. In the second part, first the initial data were collected by library documentary method by referring to the general census of population and housing (2016) and the detailed urban planning criteria (2013) and then to extract the price of residential land in Zafaranieh alley as Secondary data (land prices and issued building permits) during the years 1388 to 1398 were prepared by referring to real estate agencies and municipalities as neighborhoods. In the next step, considering that the present study tries to study the building density by emphasizing the density changes in a 10-year period, so the data and information collected through the GIS database is organized and according to the needs of the class. They are classified and adjusted and then the map of the study area is extracted through GIS and IDRISI software. Finally, graphical data outputs are provided through GIS, IDRISI, SPSS and EXCEL software. To provide graphic outputs and analyze the mentioned data, research study tools based on IDW method and density kernel in software (Arc GIS), orthogonal and fuzzy tables method in software (IDRISI), Pearson model in software (SPSS) and also for some analyzes in software (EXCEL)Results and discussion:       housing quality alone. For this purpose, instead of the building age index, the building life index has been used. Due to the fact that the useful life of the building in Iran is considered 30 years. Examination of the life of buildings that have changed during ten years (2009-2010) in Zafaranieh town showed that all of them were less than thirty years old and about 38% of our parts were between 16-20 years old and the distribution of these parts in all parts Is a town. In fact, this number of years is not only less than the average building life in Iran, but also differs significantly from the average building life in European countries, which is between 100-1000 years.       The result of the analysis of the life of the building in Zafaranieh town indicates the citizenship of the useful life of the building from the price of urban land. In other words, economic reasons have reduced the useful life of the building to less than thirty years in this area. Based on the building permits studied in which the density changes have taken place, the useful life of any building has not reached thirty years, and considering that Saffron town in general has a high regional value, it can be claimed that the increase in the value of one region It is one of the main causes of the destruction of buildings. The factor of land and housing prices is usually directly related to density. In other words, the higher the price of land and housing, the higher the urban density. The increase in land prices is due to its limitation and the inelasticity of supply to demand, and the need to use it optimally increases the density (building density and consequently population density). The relationship between density and land and housing prices is the main axis of the criteria and criteria governing urban density. Analysis of the results of density changes in the study area, shows the high density of altered parts in the northern and northeastern parts, which is due to the increase in density in these parts due to proximity to residential areas. In the southern parts, due to the proximity to the highway and in the western parts, due to the proximity to the barren areas, the density of changed sections is not significant. The results of this analysis indicate the density nationality of land prices, in other words, exactly in places where land prices are high, we have encountered the phenomenon of increasing density.Conclusion:       Due to the high price of land in Zafaranieh town; It is considered as one of the prosperous areas of Tabriz and according to what was shown in the table of life of moving parts and cells, all of these cells were less than thirty years old. This shows the correlation between reducing the life of the building and increasing the value of land areas. Which decreases with increasing value of building life zones.

منابع و مأخذ:

1. Abu Nouri, Abbas Ali; Mohammadi, Hadi; Nowruz Nejad, Maryam. (2010). Sabzevar agricultural land price analysis by Hednik method. Economic Modeling Quarterly, 3 (2), 122-95.


2. Literary, Mustafa; Pourjafar, Mohammad Reza; Taqvaee, Ali Akbar. (2002). Investigating the situation of building density and presenting the proposed model for determining the F.A.R according to the network of passages (Case study: Elahieh neighborhood of Tehran), Fine Arts Council, 13: 31 - 16.


3. Asghari Zamani, Akbar. (2007) Evaluation and Prediction of Spatial-Physical Expansion of Iranian Cities, Case Study of Zanjan, PhD Thesis in Geography and Urban Planning, University of Tabriz, 2007.


4. Akbari, Nematullah; Tavassoli, Nahid. (2008). Analysis of the Impact of Municipal Tolls on Housing Prices) A ​​Case Study of Isfahan( .A Spatial Econometric Approach, Quarterly Journal of Economic Studies, 5 (1), 64-47.


5. Ariafar, Ali Reza (2002). "Study of the role of building density in controlling population density of cities: A case study of districts 2 and 17 of Tehran", Master Thesis in Urban Planning, Iran University of Science and Technology, 2002.


6. Pour Mohammadi, Mohammad Reza; Hakimi, Hadi; Mirzaei, Ali (2017). Investigating the relationship between building density and land occupancy Case study: Tabriz metropolitan area 1, Journal of Geography and Urban Space Development, 2 (7): 188-169.


7. Jalaei, Farzad; Hamedirad, Mohammad Amin, Hamedirad; Shirzadi Javid, Ali Akbar. (2020). Presenting a method for estimating the life cycle costs of a building in the conceptual design stage based on building information modeling using the National Price List of Iran, Amirkabir Civil Engineering Journal, 52 (7), 23-2.


8. Hesamian, Farrokh (1999). The Problem of Housing, City Monthly, No. 3, 35-20.


9. Hosseini, Farzaneh. (2015). The role of architectural design in increasing the useful length of the building, International Conference on Civil Engineering, Architecture and Urban Infrastructure, 13-1.


10. Khakpour, Barat Ali; Samadi, Reza (2014). Analysis and evaluation of factors affecting land and housing prices in District 3 of Mashhad, Journal of Geography and Urban Planning - Regional, 4 (13), 38 - 21.


11. Rezazadeh, Razia. (2010). Using the concept of perceptual density in establishing the studied environmental utility: Espe Kola neighborhood of Amol city, space planning and planning, 10 (3).


12. Rezairad, Hadi. (2011) Evaluation of high-rise construction policies in a detailed plan with emphasis on the functional space organization of Tehran, Master Thesis in Urban and Regional Planning, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Tarbiat Modares University, 2011.


13. Rahnama, Mohammad Reza; Gholizadeh Sarabi, Shiva. (2012). The role of municipal taxes on housing prices in Mashhad. Journal of Urban Studies, 1 (3), 49-44.


14. Dana's boss, Fariborz. (1999). Residential land pricing mechanisms in Iranian cities, Land and Urban Development Conference, Ministry of Housing and Urban Development. 189-177.


15. Shoaib, Abbas, (2002). Excessive supply density policy of a sample building: Tehran, Sefeh Magazine, Year 11, No. 34


16. Azizi, Mohammad Mehdi, (2009). Density in Urban Planning (Principles and Criteria for Determining Density), Tehran: University of Tehran Press, Fourth Edition.


17. Azizi, Mohammad Mehdi (2003). Density in urban planning, principles and criteria for determining urban density, University of Tehran Press.


18. Azizi, Mohammad Mehdi (2003). The role and place of building density in the development of the city, Proceedings of the first construction seminar in the capital, University of Tehran.


19. Azizi, Mohammad Mehdi (2014). Density in Urban Planning, University of Tehran Press, Tehran.


20. The life of structures in our country does not reach more than 30 years, the 24th of Azar 2014, Khorasan, No. 18858


21. Imrani, Monira; Masoumi, Mohammad Taghi; Nazmafar, Hussein (2019). Investigating the compaction capacity of Urmia city by analyzing the spatial distribution of urban densities and using multi-criteria decision making technique, Urban Structure and Function Studies, 6 (21): 37-7.


22. ghorbani, rasol; Rasoolzadeh, Zahra. (2018). Feasibility study of increasing building density according to the capacity of the network Case study: Bahar neighborhood of Tabriz metropolis. Urban Planning Knowledge, 2 (4): 109 - 95.


23. Legzian, Ehsan. (2006). Economic Effectiveness of Implementing Criteria for Increasing Building Density in Tehran, Region 1, Second Construction Seminar in the Capital, 1-18.


24. Mujtahedzadeh, Ghulam Hussein. (1386). Urban planning in Iran. Tehran: Payame Noor Publications.


25. Mashoodi, Sohrab. (2010). Population and construction density in cities, Tehran, Mazinai Publications, first edition.


26. Mahdia, Mohammad Hadi. (2003) Criteria for recognizing the optimal location in high-rise construction, a case study: District 1 of Tehran Municipality, Master Thesis in Urban Planning, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Tarbiat Modares University, 2003.


27. Consulting Engineers The Role of the Environment. (2013). Comprehensive development plan of Tabriz city. East Azerbaijan Province Housing and Urban Development Organization. IRAN.


28. Consulting Engineers The Role of the Environment. (2015). Comprehensive development plan of Tabriz city. East Azerbaijan Province Housing and Urban Development Organization. IRAN


29. nematolahi. simindokht. (1395). Investigation and analysis of construction surplus sales Case study: Valiasr alley, Tabriz, Journal of Urban Planning and Planning, 7 (24): 42-23.


30. Clapp, John M & Salavei,  Katsiaryna. (2009). Building Age, Depreciation and the Value of Redeveloping Property Characteristics, Hedonic pricing with options value, 1 – 50.


31. Costello, Greg (2012). BUILDING AGE, DEPRECIATION AND REAL OPTION VALUE – AN AUSTRALIAN CASE STUDY. 18^TH ANNUAL PACIFIC-RIM REAL ESTATE SOCIETY CONFERENCE ADELAIDE, AUSTRALIA, 15-18 JANUARY 2012.


32. Coulson, E., McMillen, D.( 2008). Simultaneous estimation of cohort, age, and time effects in housing prices. Journal of Housing Economics 17, 138–151.


33. Debin, D., Jiangang, X. (1998). An analysis on location factors affecting the spatial distribution of Shanghai land values. Chinesse Geographical Science, 8(4), 335-342.


34. English House Condition Survey, Department for Communities and Local Government;2013


35. Goodman, A.C., Thibodeau, T.G. (1995). Age-related heteroskedasticity in hedonic house price equations. Journal of Housing Research 6, 25–42.


36. Kurvinen, Antti & Saari, Arto. (2020). Urban Housing Density and Infrastructure Costs, Sustainability (2), 2 - 24; doi:10.3390/su12020497.


37. Lee, B., Chung, B.C., Kim, Y., (2004). Building age, redevelopment, and housing prices: the case of apartment complexes in Seoul. The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 30, 55-80.


38. O’Connor J,( 2004). Survey on actual service lives for North American buildings , Presented at Woodframe Housing Durability and Disaster Issues conference, Las Vegas.


39. Yashiro T. (2009). Stock Management for Sustainable Urban Regeneration: Overview of Building Stock Management in Japan.


40. Zhao, Pengiun. (2011). managing urban growth in transforming China: Evidene From Beiging, Land use policy,V 24: 96-109.