Analysis of place attachment in high-rise buildings (case study: Aseman residential complex in Tabriz city)

Subject Areas : Urban planning

Farhad NematiAzar ¹ , yashar aslanian ² , zoherh Torabi ³

1 - Department of Architecture, Zanjan branch, Islamic Azad University, Zanjan, Iran
2 - Ph. D, Assistant Professor, Department of Architecture, Zanjan branch, Islamic Azad University, Zanjan, Iran
3 - Ph. D, Assistant Professor, Department of Architecture, Zanjan branch, Islamic Azad University, Zanjan, Iran

Received: 2023-02-13 Accepted : 2023-04-27 Published : 2024-04-29

Keywords: satisfaction, sense of belonging, Place attachment, Residential Complex, High-Rise Building,

Abstract :

High-rise construction is one of the methods of providing urban housing, and nowadays, the examination of their responsiveness in providing the quality of life for residents has been more and more noticed by designers and researchers. The current research, which is of a descriptive-analytical type and was prepared using a survey method, while identifying the effective factors in spatial attachment including "form-physical", "perceptual-emotional" and "activity-functional" and ranking them It deals with the level of residential satisfaction. These components in the formal-physical index include the components of "presence ability", "desired quality", "suitable density", "collective spaces" and "indicative places", in the perceptual-emotional index including the components of "duration of residence". "marital status", "personal income", "gender" and "occupation". The components of "memorable local events", "social interactions", "special activities", "suitability of activity to needs" and "cooperation" are also included in the sub-components of the activity-functional factor. The case study of this research is the Aseman residential complex in Tabriz, and its statistical population consists of the residents of this complex. The results of the surveys show that the perceptual-emotional factor with an average score of (3.610) and the formal-physical factor with an average score of (2.932) had the greatest and least impact on creating attachment to a place, respectively. The components of "presence" (3.02) from the formal-physical factor, "duration of residence" (3.73) from the perceptual-emotional factor and "memorable local events" (3.62) from the activity-functional factor have the highest score. among the relevant sub-components. Also, the findings show that there is a significant relationship between the effective factors in creating attachment and people's satisfaction with living in high-rise buildings. This means that the higher the quality of these components and the higher the level of people's understanding of them, the greater the attachment to the place. In proportion to this promotion of the sense of belonging in people, their level of satisfaction with living in high-rise buildings increases. According to the findings of the research, it is suggested that architects, designers and urban planners in the design of residential complexes, all the effective indicators on creating spatial attachment, including physical (form and composition, natural elements, lighting, visibility and access and ...), activities (social welfare, commercial, recreational and transportation services, diversity of activities, etc.) should be taken into consideration more in advance and provide the basis for the positive impact of individual and social indicators in order to achieve satisfaction. Residents will increase from living in high-rise residential complexes Extended Abstract Introduction:       As one of the important indicators of sustainable urban development, the housing category, if unhealthy, endangers the health and quality of life of a wide range of people in the society and consequently the health of the city. Regarding high-rise buildings and their level of satisfaction, many researchers believe that one of the effects of living in complexes with high population density and unfavorable environmental quality is the weakening of social ties between residents, which itself is the basis for reducing stable communication, non-participation, decreasing the sense of belonging and gradual deterioration of these collections. High-rise construction is one of the methods of providing urban housing, and nowadays, the examination of their responsiveness in providing the quality of life for residents has been more and more noticed by designers and researchers. In Iran, residential complexes in different forms are used as a solution to provide housing, but the examination of the response rate of these complexes to ensure the quality of life for the residents has not been given much attention. Measuring housing satisfaction is complex and depends on many factors. Regarding high-rise buildings and their level of satisfaction, many researchers believe that one of the effects of living in complexes with high population density and unfavorable environmental quality is the weakening of social ties between residents, which itself is the basis for reducing stable communication, non-participation, decreasing the sense of belonging and gradual deterioration of these collections. Given that satisfaction, like human nature, is a complex phenomenon with diverse and different indicators, in the present research, the effective factors in place dependence and satisfaction of citizens from living in high-rise buildings were investigated. The factors influencing the creation of a sense of belonging to a place can be considered to be caused by the person and the surrounding environment (with all its characteristics). This is the case with the factors of the "environmental" and the factors that are affected by the social factors, and the social factors. Local cooperation and local visas create memories, etc., and personal factors include mental images and personal characteristics, etc. Such as mental images, satisfaction, security, relationships, expectations and previous belongings, and personal characteristics have the factors of job, type of residence, reference culture and length of stay. Methodology: The current research, which is of a descriptive-analytical type and was prepared using a survey method, while identifying the effective factors in spatial attachment including "form-physical", "perceptual-emotional" and "activity-functional" and ranking them It deals with the level of residential satisfaction. These components in the formal-physical index include the components of "presence ability", "desired quality", "suitable density", "collective spaces" and "indicative places", in the perceptual-emotional index including the components of "duration of residence". "marital status", "personal income", "gender" and "occupation". The components of "memorable local events", "social interactions", "special activities", "suitability of activity to needs" and "cooperation" are also included in the sub-components of the activity-functional factor. The case study of this research is the Aseman residential complex in Tabriz, and its statistical population consists of the residents of this complex. The questions raised around each indicator were prepared and completed by the statistical community based on the five-point Likert scale. In order to determine the validity of the questionnaire, the content validity method was used qualitatively. The reliability of the questionnaires was also evaluated using Cronbach's alpha calculation method equal to (0.876). Finally, the collected data were processed with SPSS software at two levels of descriptive and inferential statistics and analyzed with Pearson's correlation coefficient test.   Results and discussion: The results of the surveys show that the perceptual-emotional factor with an average score of (3.610) and the formal-physical factor with an average score of (2.932) had the greatest and least impact on creating attachment to a place, respectively. The components of "presence" (3.02) from the formal-physical factor, "duration of residence" (3.73) from the perceptual-emotional factor and "memorable local events" (3.62) from the activity-functional factor have the highest score. among the relevant sub-components. Also, the findings show that there is a significant relationship between the effective factors in creating attachment and people's satisfaction with living in high-rise buildings. This means that the higher the quality of these components and the higher the level of people's understanding of them, the greater the attachment to the place. In proportion to this promotion of the sense of belonging in people, their level of satisfaction with living in high-rise buildings increases. In the interpretation of these findings, it can be pointed out that the satisfaction of citizens has a deep relationship with a person's understanding and feeling about an object, subject, place, etc. Events, images, people and belongings in an environment create a memory and mentality in a person and cause feelings such as happiness, enthusiasm, sadness, sadness and memories in a person, which is associated with the creation of attachment. Form-physical factors as well as activity-functional factors, although each of them has some kind of effect in creating a memory and place attachment, but considering that the form-physical factors undergo changes over time, such as additions, colors and lighting, etc. and the activity-functional factors also cause the removal and addition of some activities by changing the use and converting some spaces into future needed spaces to other factors. Conclusion:      In a general summary and according to the findings of the research, it can be concluded that all three mentioned factors had a positive effect in creating a sense of belonging and place attachment, but the effect of perceptual-emotional factors was better. So, It is suggested that architects, designers and urban planners in the design of residential complexes, all the effective indicators on creating spatial attachment, including physical (form and composition, natural elements, lighting, visibility and access and ...), activities (social welfare, commercial, recreational and transportation services, diversity of activities, etc.) should be taken into consideration more in advance and provide the basis for the positive impact of individual and social indicators in order to achieve satisfaction residents will increase from living in high-rise residential complexes.

References:

• Altman, I & Low, S. M (Eds.) (1992), Place Attachment (Vol. 12, Plenum Press), New York.


• Annamoradnejad, R., & Arvin, M. (2021). Investigation Effect Components Individual and Social Context On Place Attachment (Case Study: Qaemshahr City). Journal of Research and Urban Planning, 12(46), 52-67. (In Persian)


• Arghiani M, Mirhashemi S M. (2022). Evaluation of The Components Affecting the Promotion of Attachment to The Place in The Open Spaces of Residential Complexes. Journal of Restoration and Architecture of Iran, 12 (29). (In Persian)


• Bahrampour, A., & Modiri, A. (2015). Study of Relationship Between Residents Satisfaction from Living Environment and Their Attachment Sense in Kowsar High-Rise Residential Complex. Honar-Ha-Ye-Ziba: Memary Va Shahrsazi, 20(3), 85-94. (In Persian)


• Behroozi, M., Majedi, H., & Saeedeh Zarabadi, Z. S. (2022). Identifying The Factors Affecting the Promotion of a Sense of Attachment to The Place with Emphasis On Design -Led Planning Approach. Geography, Regional Planning, 12(4), 108-124. (In Persian)


• Behzadfar, M., & Ghazizdeh, N. (2011). Residential Open Space Satisfaction Case Studied: Selected Residential Complexes in Tehran. Honar-Ha-Ye-Ziba: Memary Va Shahrsazi, 3(45), 15-24. (In Persian)


• Bonaiuto, M; Fornara, Ferdinando & Mirilia, Bonnes (2003), Perceived Residential Environment Quality in Middle- And Low-Extension Italian Cities, Revue Européenne De Psychologie Appliquée 56(1), P, P 23-34.


• Charkhchian, M. (2014). The Study of the Role of Individual Characteristics On the Users' Devotion to Urban Spaces (The Case Study of Khayyam Avenue of Qazvin City). Geography and Planning, 18(47), 55-69. (In Persian)


• Daviran, E. (2023). Evaluation of The Design Components of Children's Living and Leisure Space (Case Study: Playground of District Parks in 4 Regions of Zanjan City). Urban Environmental Planning and Development, In Press. (In Persian)


• Galster, G., C. & Hesser, G., W. (1981). Residential Satisfaction Composition and Contextual Correlates, Environment and Behavior. 13 (6), P.P: 735-758.


• Ghafourian, M. G., Afshin Mehr, V., & Norouzi Zadeh, Z. (2017). Recognition of The Components of Social Sustainability and Their Impact On Increasing Social Interactions in Housing (Case Study: Abazar Neighborhood, Tehran). Hoviatshahr, 11(2), 31-42. (In Persian)


• Ghazi Zadeh, (2011), The Effect of the Open Space of the Residential Complex in Creating Envy of the Place (Case Example: Residential Complexes Chosen by Tehran City), College of Fine Arts, Faculty of Architecture, Ph.D. Thesis. (In Persian)


• Gheimati, M., Etesam, I., & Alaie, A. (2020). Investigating The Role of Place Attachment in The Formation of a New Spatial Identity, Based On Surveying the Adaptive Capacity of Citizens from Modern Urban Residential Views in Region One Area of Tehran. Islamic Art Studies, 17(39), 308-321. (In Persian)


• Gifford, R. (1991). Welcome to The Neighborhood. In R. Gifford (Ed.). Applied Psychology: Variety and Opportonity. Boston: Allyn and Bacon, P.P: 1-19.


• Habibi, K., Hoseini, S. M., Dehshti, M., Khanian, M., & Mosavi, A. (2020). The Impact of Natural Elements On Environmental Comfort in The Iranian-Islamic Historical City of Isfahan. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(16), 5776. (In Persian)


• Haghayegh, M., Keshmiri, H., Movahed, K., & Taghipour, M. (2022). Analysis of Citizens' Health from A Physiological Approach to A Community- Based Strategy in Shiraz Urban Housing. Urban Environmental Planning and Development, In Press. (In Persian)


• Haji Aghabozorg, A., Charkhchian, M., & Ghobadian, V. (2022). An Approach in Evaluating the Factors Affecting the Sense of Attachment in The Middle Spaces of Residential Complexes in Tehran. Comprehansive Studies in Urban Management, 2(8), 37-50. (In Persian)


• Heidari, A. A., & Tarfiee, M. (2021). Evaluation of Urban Space Based On the Adaptation of Physical, Mental and Social Space (Case Study: Chamran Park, Shiraz). Urban Environmental Planning and Development, 1(3), 75-90. (In Persian)


• Heidari,A; Motalebi,Gh; Moradian, S. (2018). Investigation of Place Attachment to Three Scales of Home, Neighborhood and City, (Case Study: Shiraz City). Honar-Ha-Ye-Ziba: Memary Va Shahrsazi, 23(3), 95-106. (In Persian)


• Hidalgo, Carmona & Hernandez, Bernard (2001), Place Attachment: Conceptual and Empirical Questions, Journal of Environmental Psychology, 21, 273-281.


• Javan Forouzande, A., & Motalebi, G. (2012). The Concept of Place Attachment and Its Elements. Hoviatshahr, 5(8), 27-37. (In Persian)


• Lang, J. (1978), Creating Architectural Theory: The Role of Behavioral Sciences in Environmental Design, New York, Van Nostard Reinhold.


• Lynch, K. (1960). The Image of the City. Mit Press.


• Masoomi, M, Mirkhatib, A. (2017). The Impact of Open Spaces Designing to Create Place Attachment in Residential Complexes (Case Study: Sheshsad Dastgah Residential Complexes in Mashhad City). Geores; 32 (3): 52-73. (In Persian)


• Norberg Schultz, Ch. (2013). Existence, Space and Architecture (Vida Norouz Barazjani, Translator). Tehran: Parham Naqsh.


• Peyvastehgar, Y., & Akbari, Z. (2021). Investigating The Effect and Relationship Between Attachment to Place and Spatial Identity in Indigenous and Non-Indigenous People in Three Scales: City, Neighborhood and Home. Urban Environmental Planning and Development, 1(3), 45-62. (In Persian)


• Pourjafar, M., Izadi, M. S., & Khabiri, S. (2016). Place Attachment; Conceptualization, Principals and Criteria. Hoviatshahr, 9(24), 43-54. (In Persian)


• Rahimi, L., Rafieian, M., & Bagheri, M. (2017). Evaluation The Impacts of Spatial Scale On the Residents’ Attachment to Place in Central Neighborhoods (Tabriz City). Journal of Architecture and Urban Planning, 9(18), 43-58. (In Persian)


• Rashid Kolvir, H., Hassanzadeh, P., & Akbari, H. (2021). Comparison of Place Attachment, Psychological Reactance, And Social Well-Being in Residents of Private Homes and Apartments in Rasht City. Quarterly Social Psychology Research, 11(41), 79-102. (In Persian)


• Relph, E, (1976), Place and Placelessness. London: Pion.


• Sajjadzadeh, H, Sharifi, A, Asadi, M.A, & Sharifi, N. (2014). Place Attachment and Perception of Environmental Quality On the Level of Satisfaction in A Traditional Neighborhood (Case Example: Haji Hamadan Neighborhood). Research and Urban Planning Journal, 6(22), 139-152. (In Persian)


• Sajjadzadeh, H. (2013). Role of Place Attachment in Making Identity for Urban Squares (A Case Study: Avicenna Square, Hamedan). The Monthly Scientific Journal of Bagh-E Nazar, 10(25), 69-78. (In Persian)


• Scannell, L; Gifford, R (2010), Defining Place Attachment: A Tripartite Organizing Framework, Journal of Environmental Psychology, 30,1-10.


• Steel, F. (1981). The Sense of Place. Boston: Cbi Publishing Company.


• J. (2001). Interpersonal Communication, Translated by Mehrdad Firozbakht. Shahr-E- Ketab Press.


• Van Poll, R. (1997). The Perceived Quality of the Urban Residential Envirinment. A Multi Attribute Evaluation.


• Yousefzad Farrokhi, S., & Moosavi, M. S. (2018). An Analysis On Social Factors Influencing the Quality of Life in Residential Complexes (Aftab Complex and Taban Tower in Tabriz). Sociological Studies, 11(40), 101-117. (In Persian)