سنتز پژوهی شایستگی‌های مدیران دانشگاهی: طراحی یک الگو
محورهای موضوعی : مدیریت آموزشی
1 - استادیار گروه آموزش معارف اسلامی، دانشگاه فرهنگیان، تهران، ایران.
2 - دانشیار گروه مدیریت آموزشی، دانشگاه فرهنگیان، تهران، ایران.
کلید واژه: آموزش عالی, الگو, سنتز پژوهی, شایستگی مدیران,
چکیده مقاله :
یکی از اساسی‌ترین مشکل دانشگاه‌ها، فقدان الگوی مناسب برای انتخاب شایسته‌ترین افراد در پست‌های مدیریتی است. پژوهش حاضر باهدف طراحی الگوی شایستگی مدیران دانشگاهی انجام‌شده است. رویکرد پژوهش کیفی و از نوع سنتز پژوهی است.جامعه آماری پژوهش شامل کلیه مطالعات داخلی و خارجی چاپ‌شده در حوزه شایستگی مدیران دانشگاهی در بین سال‌های 1392 تا 1402 به تعداد 80 مقاله بوده است. در این راستا کلیدواژه‌های مرتبط با اهداف پژوهش مورد جستجو قرار گرفت و با در نظر گرفتن معیارهای ورود به مطالعه و حذف پژوهش‌های نامرتبط ازلحاظ عنوان و کلیدواژه، چکیده و نتیجه‌گیری و بررسی تفصیلی مقالات بر اساس مرتبط بودن با سؤالات و کیفیت پژوهش ها ازنظر اعتبار ابزارها و روش‌های تحلیل مورداستفاده، درنهایت تعداد 31 مقاله جهت بررسی و تحلیل انتخاب شدد. پس از پالایش چندمرحله‌ای و تحلیل و ترکیب دادهها، درنهایت الگوی شایستگی مدیران دانشگاهی با 4 مضمون فراگیر و 8 مضمون سازمان دهنده و 102 مضمون پایه ترسیم که مضامین فراگیر شامل شایستگی‌های آستانه‌ای (شخصیتی و اخلاقی)، شایستگی‌های متمایز (رهبری و تفکر نظام‌مند) و شایستگی‌های کانونی (اجتماعی، اجرایی) و شایستگی حرفه‌ای (دانشی، مهارتی) بودند.
Abstract:
One of the most fundamental problems of universities is the lack of a suitable model for choosing the most qualified individuals for management positions.Hence, the present study sought to design a competency model for university managers.The research is qualitative in method and synthetic in type, and is conducted through content analysis while following practical aim.The scope of the current research includes scientific and research articles published in domestic and foreign valid journals from 2013 to 2023 in the field of academic administration competency.The statistical sample of the study was selected using a purposive method, which included 31 items were selected from among 80 articles. After multi-step refinement, data analysis and synthesis, the competency model of university managers with four overarching themes, eight organizing themes and 102 basic themes were drawn, with inclusive themes containing threshold competencies (personality and ethical), distinctive competencies (leadership and systematic thinking),core competencies (social, executive) and professional competencies (knowledge, skills). The results of this study offer important insights into the competencies required for university managers and can serve as a valuable resource for universities seeking to improve their selection process for management positions.
Key Words:
research synthesis, competence, managers, higher education
1.Introduction
The selection and appointment of competent managers is one of the most important and sensitive issue in the work process of any organization, which has received a lot of attention in recent years (Pour Faraj et al., 2023). Organizations need managers who can make correct decisions and provide creative solutions to problems and be accountable for their work and responsibilities (Vakilzadeh et al.,2023). Certainly, to become better managers, having a framework or a model to identify the required competencies will be a guide, and undoubtedly, having such qualifications is not only the distinguishing feature of the manager from other employees, but also provides the basis for the university's success in a scientific and dynamic environment. Hence, the current research tries to answer the following questions:
What are the dimensions and components of academic managers' competencies?
What is the competency model of academic managers?
- Literature Review
Nowadays, if managers of organizations and universities want to achieve their goals, they should prioritize meritocracy and programs to improve their competencies. Research shows that competent management can influence the development and evolution of the university and implement the planned changes effectively (Shimoni, 2017). Management thinkers believe that developing the competence of managers is the key to the development of countries to such a degree that many successful countries in the world admit that if you train a manager, success in everything will follow (Davodi et al., 2021). Sheshpari and Momeni Mehmoui (2023) investigated the dimensions of managers' competence. They came to the point that the competence of managers is influenced by various factors such as their beliefs and values, personal, managerial and professional characteristics. The competency model of the American Association of Public Universities and Colleges (2016) consists of five competencies: managerial, interpersonal, personal, leadership and surplus characteristics. Szczepańska and Dacko (2014) also defined six criteria of scientific ability, analytical ability, personal characteristics, interpersonal skills, management skills and attitude for the university president. Erfani Khanghahi et al. (2021) have conducted a research entitled “presenting the competence model of managers of Islamic Azad University”. The findings of this research have classified the competence of Islamic Azad University administrators in seven dimensions of human communication competence, perceptual, managerial, professional, belief and value, individual and organizational. The current research experiences show that although each of the researches has a proper depth and precision in their work, there is no particular coherence between the researches. Additionally, the results are completely scattered, or the research done on the competence model of managers is not sufficient and comprehensive. Thus, it is concluded that one of the most significant perceived gaps is the lack of an integrated model for the competencies of university managers.
- Methodology
The current research serves a functional purpose, employing a qualitative approach. It utilizes a research synthesis strategy through meta-synthesis, which is associated with inductive content analysis followed by a meta-synthesis of the analyzes conducted. What is considered in the current research is the use of thematic synthesis with the strategy of Sandelovski and Baros (2007). In exploring research related to the competencies of managers, the internal and external databases of Eric, Science Direct, Springer, Scopus, Al-Ziyur, Academic Jihad Scientific Information Database, Humanities and Cultural Studies Research Institute Portal, National Conference Publication Database, Noor and Samaneh Specialized Magazines Database Publications of the country, and keywords such as research synthesis, competence of managers, higher education, university and competence model have been utilized, covering the period from 1392 to 1402. The articles were thoroughly reviewed, and open coding was conducted using the line-by-line method. This process resulted in the identification of 102 codes that had a semantic connection.
Basic themes were extracted and considered as codes, which were then classified into similar organizing themes according to the meaning. Finally, the the analysis yielded 102 basic themes, 8 organizing themes and 4 comprehensive themes. Triangulation method was used to ensure the validity of the findings. The technique of triangulation refers to the use of multiple sources of data to draw conclusions. Using multiple approaches in a study can lead to increasing the credibility of information. So, in order to increase the accuracy and reliability of the findings, the procedure proposed by King et al. (2018), the formula of the Holstein coefficient was also used. In this formula, M is the number of agreement in two stages of coding, n1 is the number of units coded in the first stage and n2 is the number of units coded in the second stage. The value of the Holstein index also fluctuates between zero and one. In this study, coding was done in two stages, in the first stage, 102 codes were identified and in the second stage, coding was done by another expert and 90 codes were extracted. The total number of agreeable codes in two stages was 174. Using the formula, the Holstein coefficient was calculated to be 0.91. Since this value exceeds 0.7, it indicates that the research findings possess good reliability. In the final step, using the obtained thematic network, the conceptual model of university managers' competencies was drawn in the form of 4 comprehensive themes, 8 organizing themes and 102 basic themes.
- Result
The most important competitive advantage of today's universities is their human capital. In other words, in the present era, the competitive advantage will be given to universities that have competent managers, and entrepreneurs who are intellectual and cultural, creative, risk-taking, position makers and opportunity creators in the competition market. Those who put talent and competency management in the priority of their work plans, and based on the competencies, they attract and keep the most brilliant human talents so that they can maintain the territory of competition and create a competitive advantage in the competition scene. The findings of the research indicate that the developed model includes 4 comprehensive themes, 8 organizing themes and 102 basic themes. The overarching themes of this model are threshold competence, distinctive competence, core competence and professional competence. Research methodology provides a comprehensive and systematic view to managers' competencies for designing job analysis systems, human resource planning, selection, appointment, training, recruitment, evaluation and psychological and structural empowerment of university managers. It emphasizes that the managers of the country's universities should have personality, ethical, leadership, systematic thinking, social, executive, knowledge and skill competencies.
- Discussion
The compiled model can be used as a strategic, analytical and operational management dashboard in policy making and decision making. In order to take advantage of the mentioned model, it is suggested that executive committees be formed in order to plan a competency-based system in the selection and appointment of university managers in the agenda of the Ministry of Science, Research and Technology. The innovation and the most important feature of this model is to pay attention to the combination of homogeneous, common and distinct concepts and cover all dimensions, components and indicators of competency models of previous researches.
American Association of State Colleges and Universities. (2016). Competencies for State College and University Presidents. New York: NW. https :// aascu.org/ resources/competencies-for-state-college-and-university-presidents/
Arai,M,Ghazi,H., & Shamami,N.(2023). Designing the competence model of AJA managers (case study: Dafos graduate students). Scientific Quarterly Journal of Iranian Islamic Development Model Studies,11(4). 9-31 . [In Persian].dor: 20.1001.1.23225580.1402.13.1.8.0
Asbati,A.H.Abedi,A., & Haydari,Y.(2013).Investigating the professional competences of Iranian state university managers, Journal of Management and Development Process, 25(1). 69-92. [In Persian].
Aslan, M., & Pamukcu, A. (2017). Managerial competencies and impact on management levels. International Journal of Advanced Research in Management and Social Sciences, 6 (9), 1_15.Retrieved from http://www.garph.co.uk/IJARMSS/Sep20 17/1.pdf
Asumeng,M.(2014).Managerial competency models: A critical review and proposed holistic-domain model. Journal of Management Research, 6(4), 1-21. doi:10.5296/jmr.v6i4.5596
Bach, T., & Veit, S. (2018).The determinants of promotion to high public office in Germany: Partisan loyalty, political craft, or managerial competencies? Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 28(2), 254-269.doi: https://doi.org/10.5296/jmr.v6i4.5596.
Bagshahi, F., Rasouli, R., & Daraei, M.R.(2020).Designing a model for assessing the key competencies of human resources (human resource managers of executive organizations of Yazd province), Journal of Training & Development of Human, 6, (4)-44: 61.[In Persian].
Balyer, A.,& Özcan, K.(2017).Higher Education Administrators' Managerial Competency in Turkey. International Online Journal of Educational Sciences, 9(4), 917-929.doi: https://DOI.org/10.15345/iojes.2017.04. 002.
Black, A.(2015).Qualities of effective leadership in higher education. Open Journal of Leadership, 4, 54-66. doi:10.4236/ojl.2015.42006.
Chalmers, I., Hedges, L. V., & Cooper, H. (2002). A brief history of research synthesis. Evaluation & the health professions,25(1), 12-37. doi:10.1177/0163278702025001003
Chekani,A.S.(2019).Presenting a model to improve the professional competencies of managers of technical and vocational universities of the country. PhD Thesis, Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Unit. [In Persian]. doi:10.22118/edc.2020.235632.1409
Dastani,M.,& Mantezhar,G.(2022).Designing a competency assessment model for managers of scientific institutions: a meta-combination approach, Journal of Academic Management Quarterly, first year, 1(3), 1-26. [In Persian].
Davoodi E, Vedadi A, rezaeiyan A, gholamzadeh D.(2021).Designing a Competency Model for Senior Managers of Gas Refineries in South Pars Gas Complex (S.P.G.C.).Journal of Process Devlopment Management ; 33 (4) :71-96 . doi:10.52547/jmdp.33.4.71
Devali,M.M., Zamahni,M,. Darwish,H., & Azar, A.(2016).Designing a merit model for the selection of heads of centers and units of Payam Noor University. Journal of Human Resource Management Research, 9(3), 97-123. [In Persian].
EmamiMeybodi, A, A., Rahimian,H,. Abbaspour, A., & Ghiathi Nadushan, S.(2018). Designing a model of leadership competencies in public universities in Tehran. Journal of Human resource management research 11(2).137-166. [In Persian]. http://ensani.ir/fa/article/ download/410818].
Erfani,K, M., Saidi, H., & Bahramzadeh, H.(2021).Presenting a competency model for managers of Khorasan Razavi Islamic Azad University, Sociology of Education Quarterly, 7(1). 319-33[In Persian]. doi:10.22034/ ijes.2021 .527866.1033
Farahani,S.,Ghorbanizadeh,V.,Taqvifard, Moha., & Rangriz,H.(2019). Competency model of human resource managers in Iran's top universities, Public Management Research Quarterly,13(50).93-116. [InPersian].https:/ doi:10.22111/JMR.2021.34473.5099
Gudarzi, M. R.,Soltani,I.(2017).Presentation of competency model of managers in educational organizations of Payam Noor University. Journal of Educational Sociology, 3(7). 131-109.[In Persian].
Gurbannejad, P., & IssaKhani, A. (2015). Designing the competence model of academic managers based on Islamic patterns: a comparative study. Irainian Journal of Management in the Islamic University, 5 (11), 37-48. [In Persian].
Habibi, S. F., Amirianzadeh, M., Zarei,R., & Ahmadi, E.(2019).Presenting the model of factors affecting the leadership competence of Islamic Azad University managers, Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human, 7(26). 67-39.[In Persian].
Harkins, K. A. (2017). Leadership competency perceptions of rural community college presidents in the coastal southeast region. Old Dominion University.
Khalili, E., KhorSandi, A., Tanahei, A., &Bagheri, M. (2019). Leadership competencies of university presidents in Iran's higher education system. Journal of Human Resource Studies, 10(4).165-146.[In Persian]. doi:10.22034/JHRS.2020.128832.
Khorshidi,A.,Nasrollahi,M., & Khosravi, A.(2015).Identifying the components of professional competencies of managers and employees of Islamic Azad University, South Tehran branch.Journal of Quantitative reasearchs in Management 7(24), 171-192.[In Persian].
Liikamaa, K. (2015). Developing a Project Manager’s Competencies: A Collective View of the Most Important Competencies. University of Turku, 6th International Conference on Applied Human Factors and Ergonomics and the Affiliated Conferences, 3, 681-687. doi:10.1016/j.promfg.2015.07.305.
Lusi,S., Nurhizrah,G., Yasri & Hadiyanto(2020).Administrative Leadership Managerial Competencies in Higher Educations (Study on Planning Aspect), Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 504 Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference Innovation in Education, 1-5. doi:10.2991/assehr.k.201209.240.
Malekinejad,P., & Ziaian,M.(2019).Designing a new framework for the professional competency model of higher education managers with the integrated approach of ISM and SEM.Quality & Standard Management Journal,10(1).101-125.[In Persian]. doi:10.22034/JSQM.2020.111421.
MezaRios, M. M., Herremans, I. M., Wallace, J. E., Althouse, N., Lansdale, D., & Preusser, M. (2018). Strengthening sustainability leadership competencies through university internships. International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 19(4),739-755.doi:10.1108/IJSHE-06-2017-0097.
Mikła,A.(2021).Managerial Competencies Manage ment–A Practical Approach. Education Excellence and Innovation Management: A, 2025, 17909-17915.
Mohamed Jais, I. R., Yahaya, N., & Ghani, E. K. (2021). Talent Management in Higher Education Institutions: Developing Leadership Competencies. Journal of Education and e-Learning Research, 8(1),8-15. doi:10.20448/ journal. 509. 2021. 81.8.15.
Mohd Noor, B., & Dola.K.(2009). Job Competencies for Malaysian Managers in Higher Education Institution, Asian Journal of Management and Humanity Sciences, Vol.4, No.4, pp.226-240.doi:10.6413/AJMHS.200910.0226.
Mousavi,S.A., Mohammadi, Me., & Safian, M. (2019).Designing a competency model for managers of organizational universities (case study: a university affiliated to a military organization). . Irainian Journal of Management in the Islamic University, 9(2), 217-240.[In Persian].
Porfaraj,B.,Jabari.,A,S & Hassanzadeh,S.(2023).Designing a model of the consequences of managers' competence based on emotional intelligence: a Meta synthesis approachScientific, Journal of Applied Educational Leadership, 4(3), 196-213.[In Persian]. doi:10.22098/AEL.2023.13080.1289
Olwan A.A, Irtaimeh H.J, Al_Lozi M. (2019). Strategic Leadership Competencies and its Impact on Achieving Organizational Excellence via the Mediating Role of Organizational Commitment: A Case Study in National Center for Security and Crisis Management (NCSCM). Journal of Social Sciences,8(1):106_138.doi: 10.25255/jss.2019.8.1. 106.
Qolipour, R, SayyedJavadin, S., & Rozbehan., M.(2017).Designing the competence model of academic managers based on the document of Islamic University. Journal of Resource Management in Police, 6(2),1-34. [In Persian].
Rahimian,H.,Abbaspour,A.,Ghiathi Nadushan,S.,Akbari,M.N.(2018).Designing and validating the competency model of presidents of public universities in Kabul.New Approaches in Educational Administration, 10(40). 29-1.[In Persian].dor: 20.1001.1.20086369.1398.10.40.1.1.
Ruenb,B.D.(2019).An overview of the leadership competency framework. Competencies Leadership: for Effective A Framework for assessment, education, and Research, 19-28. doi:10.1108/978-1-78973-255-920191001.
Saini, M., & Shlonsky, A. (2012). Systematic synthesis of qualitative research. OUP USA.
Salee-on, S., & Laksana, S. (2018). Development Model of Administrators’ Leadership Competencies for Effective Job Performance in Private Higher Education Institutions. Scholar: Human Sciences, 9(2), 173-185. Retrieved from http://www.assumptionjournal.au.edu/index.php/ Scholar/article/view/2995
Sandelowski, M., and J. Barroso. (2007), Handbook for synthesizing qualitative research. New York Springer, 1-284.
Seefeld,S.J.(2016).Leadership Competencies at Concordia University System Institutions. UNLV Theses, Dissertations, Professional Papers, and Capstones. 2735. https://digitalscholarship.unlv.edu/ thesesdissertations/2735
Shabani, Razieh, Sohri, Abbas, Abbasi, Lotf Elah, and Fathi Vajargah, Koresh. (2017). Presenting a model of competence for the managers of elementary education in Tehran. Education and School Studies, 7(19), 145-176. [in Persian]
Shafizadeh,A.,Azaiz,M., & Akbarzadeh.,N.(2012).Identifying entrepreneurial skills needed by university managers, journal of Entrepreneurship Development, 6(2). 27-53.doi:10.22059/jed.2013.36258.[In Persian].
Shawran,S.H.,Parori,A., & Siadat, S.A.(2021).Compilation of the ideal model of university president selection criteria for use in Iranian universities. Iranian Higher Education Research Quarterly, (3).23-1.[InPersian]. dor:20.1001.1 .20088000.1400.13.3.3.1
Sheshperi, L.,& Momeni Mehmoi, H.(2023).Synthesis of the research on the dimensions of managers' competence with an emphasis on Islamic management, Journal of Educational Management Innovations, 18(2). 27-1.[In Persian].
Shimoni, B. (2017). A sociological perspective to organization development. Organizational Dynamics, Elsevier Inc 46(3),165-170. doi:10.1016/j. orgdyn.2016 .11.002
Szczepańska,K.,& Dacko,Z.(2014).Managerial competencies and innovations in the company–the case of enterprises in Poland. Business, Management and Economics Engineering, 12(2), 266-282. doi:10.3846/bme. 2014.240.
Tabassi,A.A.,Roufechaei,K.M.,Ramli,M., Abu Bakar, A. H., & Ismail, R. P.(2016). Leadership Competences of Sustainable Construction Project Managers. Journal of cleaner production, 124, 339-349. doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.02.076.
Talaa'ee, E, Bozorg H.(2015).The Necessity of Paying Attention to the Developmental and Educational Significance of Pre-School Years, as Indicated by Contemporary Research. Education Quarterly,31(122).92-116.[In Persian]. dor: 20.1001.1.10174133.1394.31.2.4.5.
Tomason,B.(2015).Temperament and competence in the managerial roles of nursing education administrators in the North Caroliva community college system. Unpublished doctoral Dissertation, North Caroliva State University, 66-90.
Vakilzade,I.,Manzari,T,A, Porrashidi,R.,&Nikpour,A.(2023).Designing a competency model for health managers of the Ministry of Health and Medical Education. Journal of Green Management, Vol.3, No.3, 80-103. [In Persian].
Virtanen,T.(2000).Changing competences of public sector managers: tensions in commitment. The International Journal of Public Sector Management, 13 (4), 333-341. doi:10.1108/09513550010350300.
Weng S S., Liu Y., Dai J., & Chuang Y C. (2020). A Novel Improvement Strategy of Competency for Education for Sustainable Development (ESD) of University Teachers Based on Data Mining. Sustainability, 12(7): 26-79. doi:10.3390/su12072679.
Wisniewski, M. (2004). Leadership in higher education: Implications for leadership development programs. Academic Leadership: The Online Journal, 2(1), 7. doi:10.58809/ALJ20040101/OJKN1467.
Wisniewski,M.A.(2019). Leadership development for academic chairs: Programs for promoting competence in higher education. The Journal of Continuing Higher Education, 67(1), 48-51dor:20.1001.1.25884395. 2022.4.4.2.8.
