Comparative study of design disciplines to promote the identity of historic urban cores in Iran

محورهای موضوعی : Space Ontology International Journal

Noella Yaghoub Nejad ¹ , Toofan Haghani ² , Alireza Bandar Abad ³

1 - Department of urban Planning, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
2 - Department of urban Planning, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
3 - Department of urban Planning, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

تاریخ دریافت : 1404/02/08 تاریخ پذیرش : 1404/06/13

کلید واژه: Urban conservation, Morphological identity, Historic fabric, Planning regulation, Historic zones,

چکیده مقاله :

Historic zones are vital components of urban structures, linking past and present within the process of morphological evolution. In Iran, many such areas have experienced significant physical and functional decline over the last century. Revitalizing them requires innovative approaches, as prevailing planning strategies tend toward extremes—either strict conservationism or aggressive interventionism. Conservationists aim to preserve historic identity, whereas interventionists priorities modernization at the cost of historical character. This study critiques Iranian urban planning regulations concerning historic urban fabrics, using a comparative approach with successful international cases from England, France, and Spain. Key challenges in Iran include fragmented management and the lack of comprehensive standards—such as colour, style, material, and proportion—to assess new urban and building designs during approval and implementation. The research follows three steps: first, employing a descriptive-analytical method alongside comparative study; second, conducting qualitative analysis through review, description, and interpretation of conservation policies in the three European countries and Iran; third, formulating an urban design guideline and strategy to safeguard the historical identity of Iranian urban fabrics. Findings highlight the necessity of revising planning and design regulations, incorporating criteria that preserve historic identity while encouraging creativity and urban vitality. This study contributes to the discourse on heritage conservation by offering insights for more effective, balanced approaches to sustaining the identity of Iran’s historic zones.

چکیده انگلیسی:

Historic zones are vital components of urban structures, linking past and present within the process of morphological evolution. In Iran, many such areas have experienced significant physical and functional decline over the last century. Revitalizing them requires innovative approaches, as prevailing planning strategies tend toward extremes—either strict conservationism or aggressive interventionism. Conservationists aim to preserve historic identity, whereas interventionists priorities modernization at the cost of historical character. This study critiques Iranian urban planning regulations concerning historic urban fabrics, using a comparative approach with successful international cases from England, France, and Spain. Key challenges in Iran include fragmented management and the lack of comprehensive standards—such as colour, style, material, and proportion—to assess new urban and building designs during approval and implementation. The research follows three steps: first, employing a descriptive-analytical method alongside comparative study; second, conducting qualitative analysis through review, description, and interpretation of conservation policies in the three European countries and Iran; third, formulating an urban design guideline and strategy to safeguard the historical identity of Iranian urban fabrics. Findings highlight the necessity of revising planning and design regulations, incorporating criteria that preserve historic identity while encouraging creativity and urban vitality. This study contributes to the discourse on heritage conservation by offering insights for more effective, balanced approaches to sustaining the identity of Iran’s historic zones.

منابع و مأخذ:

Abuie, R. & Jafari Qavamabadi, N. (2014). Facade, appearance of historical context and urban landscape in national laws, local rules and regulations and urban management duties, Journal of Iranian scientific Association of Architecture & urbanism, (8): 1-16.
Bandarabad, A. & Shahcheraghi, A. (2017). Surrounded by the Environment: Application of Environmental Psychology in Architecture and Urban Planning, 3rd Edition, Jahad Daneshgahi of Tehran Publishing house.
Bellet Sanfeliu, C. (2021). The Evolution of Urban Planning in Medium-Sized Catalan Cities (1979–2019), Urban Science, 5 (36): 1-16.
Bonyadi, N. (2011). Investigation of Specialized Vocabulary and Methods of Conserving Historical Fabrics, Soffeh Journal, (55): 125-140.
Cultural Policies of Spain (undated) Universitat Autónoma de Barcelona, Bellaterra, Spain
D. K. Ching, F. (2009). Architecture: Form, Space, Order, Translated by Dr. Alireza Taghaboni and Seyyedeh Sedigheh Ghavidel, 6th Edition, Arad Books, Tehran.
Daviran, E. & Meshkini, A. & Kazemian, Gh. & Aliabadi, Z. (2011). Intervention Study in Organizing Worn-out and Inefficient Urban Fabrics with a Combined Approach: The Case Study of Zeynabieh District in Zanjan, Journal of Urban Research and Planning, 2(7): 1-11.
Dehghan Rikabadi, K. & Farahani, M. (2021). Evaluating the Consequences of Large-Scale Urban Interventions in Historical Fabric with Emphasis on Economic Effects (Case Study: Sahebolamr Complex of Tabriz), Islamic Architecture and Urbanism, 6(1): 114-137.
Farahnaki, M. (2019). Land use planning for urban river margins based on the green city approach (Case study: Abshooran River of Kermanshah). Space Ontology International Journal, 8(1):15-33.
Feizi Najafi, N. & Majedi, H. (2012). Review of the Intervention Limits of Urban Design in Iranian Architectural Structures for Interaction with Architectural Innovation, Arman Shahr Architecture and Urbanism Journal, (9): 259-269.
Fielden, B. & Jokilehto, J. (2007). Management Guidelines for World Heritage Sites, Translated by Pirouz Hanachi, 1st Edition, University of Tehran Press, Tehran.
Ghaderi, E. & Zamani Moghaddam, A. & Jalali Kenari, H. (2012). Development of Social Management Strategies for the Revitalization, Development, and Conservation of Historical Fabrics: A Case Study of Region 12 of Tehran Municipality, Journal of Iranian Social Development Studies, 5(1): 97-113.
Hanachi, P. & Pour Sarrajian, M. (2014). Revitalization of Historic Urban Fabric, Armanshahr Architecture & Urban Development,6(10).
Habibi, M. & Maqsoudi, M. (2009). Urban Conservation, University of Tehran Press.
Heydari Shooli, F. & Jalali, M. (2021). A Comparative Study of Protection of Privately Owned Historic Buildings in the England and Iran Legal System; From Permission to Objection, Comparative Law Review, 12(1): 61-82.
Hosseini, S. & Alinejad Majidi, S. & Moradinasab, H. (2024) Presentation of the principles of design parameters and regulations of urban facades and body, emphasizing cultural components, case study: Kamyab street, Kerman), Space Ontology International Journal, 13 (3): 67-82
Jamalpour, B. (2006). Intervention Planning in Historic Urban Fabrics, Shahr-e Bartar Conference, Tarh Bartar.
Jokilehto, J. (2015). A History of Architectural Conservation, Translated by Mohammad Hassan Talebian and Khashayar Bahadori, Rozaneh Publication.
Kalantari Khalilabad, H. & Sadeghi, S. & Haqqi, M. (2016). Conservation Strategies in Historical Urban Fabrics with Emphasis on Earthquake Crisis Management: Case Study of Cyrus District, Tehran, Journal of Iranian-Islamic Urban Studies, (23): 61-74.
Kargar, H. & Hosseini Nejad, Zh. & Askandari, M. & Nekooei, M. (2021). An overview of the experiences of large-scale urban regeneration interventions and lessons learned to reduce vulnerabilitie, Disaster Prevention and Management Knowledge, Quarterly, 11(3): 221-237.
Keshani Hamdani, M. (2022). A review of restoration and improvement of street elevations, case study: Isfahan, Alam El Hodi Street and Askarieh Street, Journal of Urban Studies on Space and Place, 6(3): 69-92.
Khatibi, S .M. R, Haji Najafi, V, (2016), An Analysis of Space Distribution and Applied Site Selection of Urban Lands with an Emphasis on Access to Civil Services Based on AHP Model in GIS Environment (Case Study: Qazvin Institutes of Higher Education) , Space Ontology International Journal, 5(1):55-67.

Masuod, M. & Beigzadeh Shahraki, H. (2012). Filler buildings in historical contexts (Design basics and evaluation criteria), Azarakhsh Press, Tehran.
Mashhoudi, S. (2023). urban planning in Iran, its role, characteristics, deterioration and evolution principles, first edition, Azarakhsh publication, Tehran
Meijer, F. & Visscher, H. & Sheridan, L. (2014). Building regulations in Europe Part I: A comparison of the systems of building control in eight European countries, Housing and Urban Policy Studies, Delft University Press
Moradi, M. & Kabirian, A. & Abdi, H. (2017). Revitalization of Old Urban Fabrics (A Review of Experiences), University of Tehran, commissioned by the Deputy of Architecture and Urban Planning, Ministry of Roads and Urban Development, 1st Edition, Tehran.

Nofel, A. & Kalbadi, P. & Poorjafar, M. (2009). Study and Evaluation of Effective Indices in Urban Identity: Case Study of Jolfa Neighbourhood in Isfahan, Arman Shahr Journal, 2(3): 57-69.

Pourbahador, P. & Fadaei Nezhad Bahramjerdi, S. (2018). Review of the Theoretical Framework of the Protective Approach in Historical Urban Landscape, Journal of Iranian-Islamic Urban Studies, 8(31): 63-74.
Riahi Moghaddam, S. & Talebian, M. & Moradi, A.(2021). Exploring the Effective Components on the Classification of Architectural Heritage Based on Conservation Approaches and Policies in European Countries, Journal of Iranian Architectural Studies,10(20): 213-237.
Shah Timouri, Y. & Mazaherian, H. (2012). Design Guidelines for New Structures in Historical Fabrics, Fine Arts Journal, 17(4): 29-40.
Shateri Vaighan, O. & Dabdabeh, M. & Kahyazadeh, V. (2020). Foundations of Conservation in Historical Urban Fabrics, Shabak Scientific Journal, 6(1): 183-192.
Tehran Municipality (2012) Regulations and Detailed Design Guidelines for the New Plan of Tehran, Urban Planning and Architecture Deputy.
Torkzaban, Sh. & Moradi, A. (2011). Design Regulations in Historical Fabrics, Native Architecture and Urbanism Journal, 1(1): 53-66.
Worthington, J. (1998). Managing and Moderating Change. IN WARREN, J., Worthington, J. & TAYLOR, S. (Eds.) Fabric: new buildings in historic settings. York, Architectural Press.

Website References

IFP Ltd (undated) Plan Local d’Urbanisme, https://www.french-property.com/guides/france/building/planning/local-plans/plan-local-urbanisme/ (Accessed October 18, 2024).
IFP Ltd (undated) Conservation areas in France, https://www.french-property.com/guides/france/building/planning/local-plans/conservation-areas/ (Accessed October 18, 2024).
Lovell, D. (2017) ‘Enriching the List.70th Anniversary of the 1947 Town and Country Planning Act’. Historic England, Heritage Online Debate, (3). https://historicengland.org.uk/whats-new/debate/recent/town-and-country-planning-act-70th-anniversary/enriching-the-list (Accessed April 22, 2020).

Mays, D. (2017) ‘The Mother of All Planning Acts. 70th Anniversary of the 1947 Town and Country Planning Act’. Historic England, Heritage Online Debate, (3). https://historicengland.org.uk/whats-new/debate/recent/town-and-country-planning-act-70th-anniversary/mother-of-all-planning-acts (Accessed April 22, 2020).
Stevens, J. ( 2017) ‘The 1947 Act: Winners and Losers, 70th Anniversary of the 1947 Town and Country Planning Act’. Historic England, Heritage Online Debate, (3). https://historicengland.org.uk/whats-new/debate/recent/town-and-country-planning-act-70th-anniversary/1947-act-winners-losers (Accessed April 25, 2020).
Tunnicliffe, S. (2017) ‘70th Anniversary of the 1947 Town and Country Planning Act’. Historic England, Heritage Online Debate, (3). https://historicengland.org.uk/whats new/debate/recent/townand-country-planning-act-70th-anniversary (Accessed April 22, 2020).
UK government (2018) Principles of Selection for listed buildings, Department for Digital, Culture, Media & Sport, London https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5beef3c9e5274a2b0b4267e0/Revised_Principles_of_Selection_2018.pdf (Accessed October 18, 2024).
UK government (1990) UK public general acts, Planning (Listed buildings and conservation areas) Act 1990, https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1990/9/contents
Unesco (1985) Spanish Historical Heritage Law. 16/1985. Official State Gazette, No. 155. https://www.eui.eu/Projects/InternationalArtHeritageLaw/Documents/NationalLegislation/Spain/law16of1985.pdf (Accessed August 30, 2020).