Dilemma in two game structures for a closed-loop supply chain under the influence of government incentives

محورهای موضوعی : Mathematical Optimization

Subrata Saha ¹ ( Department of Materials and Production, Aalborg University, 9220, Aalborg East, Denmark )
Izabela Ewa Nielsen ² ( Department of Materials and Production, Aalborg University, 9220, Aalborg East, Denmark )
Sani Majumder ³ ( Department of Mathematics, Betberia High School, Nadia, India )

تاریخ دریافت : 1399/07/18 تاریخ پذیرش : 1399/07/18 تاریخ انتشار : 1399/03/12

کلید واژه: Remanufacturing, Stackelberg game, Closed, loop supply chain, Government incentives,

چکیده مقاله :

The government organizations grant incentives to promote green product consumption, improve green product quality, boost remanufacturing activities, etc. through various policies. The objective of this study is to highlight pros and cons of two incentive policies, namely (1) incentive on manufacturer’s R&D investment and (2) direct incentive to consumer based on greening level of the product on the optimal pricing and investment decisions in improving used product return and greening level decisions in a closed-loop supply chain (CLSC). Optimal decisions are derived under manufacturer and retailer-Stackelberg games, and results are compared to explore characteristics of optimal decisions, consumer surplus, and environmental improvement under two marketing strategies of a manufacturer. It is found that the greening level and used product return rate in a CLSC are always higher under retailer-Stackelberg game. If the manufacturer sets a target for greening level, the CLSC members may receive higher profits if consumer receives incentive because of higher consumer surplus. However, environmental improvement may be lower. If the manufacturer sets a product return goal, then CLSC members may compromise with consumer surplus or environmental improvement for receiving higher profits. In the presence of direct incentive to consumers, CLSC members can trade with product at lower greening level for higher profits. Moreover, investment in improving used product return is always less compared to the investment in improving greening level.

منابع و مأخذ:

Alamdar SF, Rabbani M, Heydari J (2018) Pricing, collection, and effort decisions with coordination contracts in a fuzzy, threelevel closed-loop supply chain. Expert Syst Appl 104:261–276
Atasu A, Toktay LB, Van Wassenhove LN (2013) How collection cost structure drives a manufacturer’s reverse channel choice. Prod Oper Manag 22:1089–1102
Basiri Z, Heydari J (2017) A mathematical model for green supply chain coordination with substitutable products. J Clean Prod 145:232–249
Chen JM, Chang CI (2012) The co-opetitive strategy of a closed-loop supply chain with remanufacturing. Transp Res Part E Logist Transp Rev 48(2):387–400
Chu W, Baumann C, Hamin H, Hoadley S (2018) Adoption of environment-friendly cars: direct vis-a-vis mediated effects of
government incentives and consumers’ environmental concern across global car markets. J Glob Market 31(4):282–291
Dai R, Zhang J, Tang W (2017) Cartelization or cost-sharing? comparison of cooperation modes in a green supply chain.
J Clean Prod 156:159–173
De Giovanni P, Zaccour G (2014) A two-period game of a closedloop supply chain. Eur J Oper Res 232(1):22–40
Dey K, Roy S, Saha S (2018) The impact of strategic inventory and procurement strategies on green product design in a two-period supply chain. Int J Prod Res. https://doi.org/10.1080/00207543.2018.1511071
Dey K, Saha S (2018) Influence of procurement decisions in twoperiod green supply chain. J Clean Prod 190:388–402
Ferrer G, Swaminathan JM (2010) Managing new and differentiated remanufactured products. Eur J Oper Res 203(2):370–379
Gao J, Han H, Hou L, Wang H (2016) Pricing and effort decisions in a closed-loop supply chain under different channel power structures. J Clean Prod 112:2043–2057
Genc TS, Giovanni De (2017) Trade-in and save: a two-period closed-loop supply chain game with price and technology
dependent returns. Int J Prod Econ 183:514–527
Ghezavati VR, Beigi M (2016) Solving a bi-objective mathematical model for location-routing problem with time windows in multiechelon reverse logistics using metaheuristic procedure. J Ind Eng Int 12:469–83
Ghosh D, Shah J (2012) A comparative analysis of greening policies across supply chain structures. Int J Prod Econ 135:568–583
Ghosh D, Shah J (2015) Supply chain analysis under green sensitive consumer demand and cost sharing contract. Int J Prod Econ 164:319–329
Ghosh D, Swami S, Shah J (2018) Product greening and pricing strategies of firms under green sensitive consumer demand and environmental regulations. Ann Oper Res. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10479-018-2903-2
Govindan K, Shankar KM, Kannan D (2016) Application of fuzzy analytic network process for barrier evaluation in automotive parts remanufacturing towards cleaner production e a study in an Indian scenario. J Clean Prod 114:199–213
Govindan K, Soleimani H, Kannan D (2015) Reverse logistics and closed-loop supply chain: a comprehensive review to explore the future. Eur J Oper Res 240(3):603–626
Guo J, Gao Y (2015) Optimal strategies for manufacturing/remanufacturing system with the consideration of recycled products. Comput Ind Eng 89:226–234
Guo J, He L, Gen M (2018) Optimal strategies for the closed-loop supply chain with the consideration of supply disruption and subsidy policy. Comput Ind Eng. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cie.2018.10.029
Harder A, Beard E (2016) Energy efficient lighting. www.ncsl.org/research/energy/energy-efficient-lighting.aspx
Heydari J, Govindan K, Jafari A (2017) Reverse and closed loop supply chain coordination by considering government role.
Transp Res Part D Transp Environ 52:379–398
Hong Z, Guo X (2018) Green product supply chain contracts considering environmental responsibilities. Omega. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.omega.2018.02.010
Hong X, Wang Z, Wang D, Zhang H (2013) Decision models of closed-loop supply chain with remanufacturing under hybrid dual-channel collection. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 68:1851–1865 

Houde S, Aldy JE (2014) Belt and suspenders and more: the incremental impact of energy efficiency subsidies in the presence of existing policy instruments. https://heep.hks.harvard.edu/
Huang M, Song M, Lee L, Ching WK (2013) Analysis for strategy of closed-loop supply chain with dual recycling channel. Int J Prod Econ 144:510–520
Iino F, Lim A (2010) Developing Asias competitive advantage in green products: Learning from the Japanese experience. ADBI Working Paper 228. Tokyo: Asian Development Bank Institute. www.adbi.org/workingpaper/2010/07/09/3934.asia.advantage.green.prod.japan.experience/
Jabbour JC, Jabbour A, Govindan K, Freitas T, Soubihia D, Kannan D, Latan H (2016) Barriers to the adoption of green operational practices at Brazilian companies: effects on green and operational performance. Int J Prod Res 54(10):3042–3058
Jamali MB, Rasti-Barzoki M (2018) A game theoretic approach for green and non-green product pricing in chain-to-chain competitive sustainable and regular dual-channel supply chains. J Clean Prod 170:1029–1043
Jayaraman V (2006) Production planning for closed-loop supply chains with product recovery and reuse: an analytical approach. Int J Prod Res 44(5):981–998
Jena SK, Sarmah SP, Padhi SS (2018) Impact of government incentive on price competition of closed-loop supply chain
systems. INFOR: Inf Syst Oper Res 56(2):192–224
Kumar S, Putnam V (2008) Cradle to cradle: reverse logistics strategies and opportunities across three industry sectors. Int J Prod Econ 115(2):305–315
Li B, Zhu M, Jiang Y, Li Z (2016) Pricing policies of a competitive dual-channel green supply chain. J Clean Prod
112:2029–2042
Liu C, Xia G (2018) Research on the dynamic interrelationship among R&D investment, technological innovation and economic growth in China. Sustainability 10(11):4260
Lu J (2017) Comparing U.S. and Chinese electric vehicle policies. Environmental and Energy Study Institute. www.eesi.org/
articles/view/comparing-u.s.-and-chinese-electric-vehiclepolicies

Ma WM, Zhao Z, Ke H (2013) Dual-channel closed-loop supply chain with government consumption-subsidy. Eur J Oper Res 226:221–227
Mannberg A, Jansson J, Pettersson T, Brnnlund R, Lindgren U (2014) Do tax incentives affect households’ adoption of ‘green’ cars? A panel study of the Stockholm congestion tax. Energy Policy.
74:286–299
Martin E (2019) 14 companies that recycle their own products. www.goodhousekeeping.com/uk/consumer-advice/consumer-rights/a25915660/brands-that-recycle-products/. Accessed 6 Sept 2019
Mitra S, Webster S (2008) Competition in remanufacturing and the effects of government subsidies. Int J Prod Econ 111:287–298
Modak NM, Panda S, Sana SS (2016) Two-echelon supply chain coordination among manufacturer and duopolies retailers with recycling facility. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 87:1531–1546
Nam CW (2012) Corporate tax incentives for R&D investment in OECD countries. Int Econ J 26(1):69–84
Nielsen I, Majumder S, Saha S (2019a) Exploring the intervention of intermediary in a green supply chain. J Clean Prod
233:1525–1544
Nielsen I, Majumder S, Sana SS, Saha S (2019b) Comparative analysis of government incentives and game structures on single and two-period green supply chain. J Clean Prod 235(20):1371–1398
Patra P (2018) Distribution of profit in a smart phone supply chain under Green sensitive consumer demand. J Clean Prod
192:608–620
Rezaee MJ, Yousefi S, Hayati J (2017) A multi-objective model for closed-loop supply chain optimization and efficient supplier selection in a competitive environment considering quantity discount policy. J Ind Eng Int 13:199–213
Saha S, Sarmah SP, Moon I (2016) Dual channel closed-loop supply chain coordination with a reward-driven remanufacturing policy. Int J Prod Res 54(5):1503–1517
Savaskan RC, Bhattacharya S, Van Wassenhove LN (2004) Closedloop supply chain models with product remanufacturing. Manage Sci 50(2):239–252
Shishebori D, Babadi AY (2018) Designing a capacitated multiconfiguration logistics network under disturbances and parameter uncertainty: a real-world case of a drug supply chain. J Ind Eng Int 14:65–85
Shu T, Peng Z, Chen S, Wang S, Lai KK, Yang H (2017) Government Subsidy for remanufacturing or carbon tax rebate: which is better for firms and a low-carbon economy. Sustainability 9:156. https://doi.org/10.3390/su9010156
Sinayi M, Rasti-Barzoki M (2018) A game theoretic approach for pricing, greening, and social welfare policies in a supply chain with government intervention. J Clean Prod 196(2018):1443–1458
Song H, Gao X (2018) Green supply chain game model and analysis under revenue-sharing contract. J Clean Prod 170:183–192 
Swami S, Shah J (2013) Channel coordination in green supply chain management. J Oper Res Soc 64:336–351
Taleizadeh AA, Alizadeh-Basban N, Niaki ATA (2019) A closedloop supply chain considering carbon reduction, quality
improvement effort, and return policy under two remanufacturing scenarios. J Clean Prod 232:1230–1250
Taleizadeh AA, Sane-Zerang E, Choi TM (2016) The effect of marketing effort on dual-channel closed-loop supply chain
systems. IEEE Trans Syst Man Cybern Syst 99:1–12
Taleizadeh AA, Moshtagh MS, Moon I (2018) Pricing, product quality, and collection optimization in a decentralized closedloop supply chain with different channel structures: game theoretical approach. J Clean Prod 189:406–431
Tighazoui A, Turki S, Sauvey C (2019) Optimal design of a manufacturing-remanufacturing-transport system within a
reverse logistics chain. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 101(5–8):1773–1791
Vozza S (2018) Sustainability in retail: what it looks like and why it matters for your business. www.shopify.com/retail/sustainability-in-retail-what-it-looks-like-and-why-it-matters

Wang Y, Chang X, Chen Z, Zhong Y, Fan T (2014) Impact of subsidy policies on recycling and remanufacturing using system dynamics methodology: a case of auto parts in China. J Clean Prod 74:161–171
Wang W, Ding J, Sun H (2018) Reward-penalty mechanism for a two-period closed-loop supply Chain. J Clean Prod
203:898–917
Wei S, Cheng D, Sundin E, Tang O (2015) Motives and barriers of the remanufacturing industry in China. J Clean Prod 94:340–351
Xie G (2016) Cooperative strategies for sustainability in a decentralized supply chain with competing suppliers. J Clean Prod 113:807–821
Yang D, Xiao T (2017) Pricing and green level decisions of a green supply chain with governmental interventions under fuzzy uncertainties. J Clean Prod 149:1174–1187
Yang Z, Slowik P, Lutsey N, Searle S (2016) Principles for effective electric vehicle incentive design. https://theicct.org/sites/default/files/publications/ICCT_IZEV-incentives-comp_201606.pdf
Yuan KF, Gao Y (2010) Inventory decision-making models for a closed-loop supply chain system. Int J Prod Res
48(20):6155–6187

Yu JJ, Tang CS, Shen M (2018) Improving consumer welfare and manufacturer profit via government subsidy programs: subsidizing consumers or manufacturers? Manuf Serv Oper Manag 20(4):752–766
Zheng X, Lin H, Liu Z, Li D, Llopis-Albert C, Zeng S (2018) Manufacturing decisions and government subsidies for electric
vehicles in china: a maximal social welfare perspective. Sustainability. 10:672. https://doi.org/10.3390/su10030672