Comparison of Yield and Some Forage Qualitative Characteristics of Corn, Sorghum and Amaranth in Response to Density and Sowing Date in Fars Province

Subject Areas : Journal of Crop Ecophysiology

Elham Moshaver ¹ , Yahya Emam ² , Hamid Madani ³ , Ghorban Nour Mohamadi ⁴ , Hossein Heidari Sharifabad ⁵

1 - Ph.D. Student of Agronomy, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
2 - Professor of Agronomy Department, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran
3 - Associte Professor of Agronomy Department, Arak Branch, Islamic Azad University, Arak, Iran
4 - Professor of Agronomy Department, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
5 - Professor of Agronomy Department, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

Received: 2015-08-08 Accepted : 2016-02-16 Published : 2016-03-20

Keywords: Forage quality, Protein percentage, Forage yield of amaranth, iron content,

Abstract :

Field studies were conducted  at  Marvdasht area of  Fars province in 2013 to investigate the effects of planting date and density on yield and some qualitative characteristics of three forage crops; corn, sorghum and amaranth . Split split plot experiments were conducted in a complete randomized block design with 3 replications at two locations. Treatments were plant species (forage corn 704, forage sorghum cultivar Speedfeed and a new forage crop: amaranth), plant density (66000, 83000 and 110000 plants per hectare) and planting date (June 22, July 6, July 21). Combined analysis of variance indicated that, plant species, planting density and date significantly affected hay yield, grain protein percentage, iron and zinc content, calcium percentage, fiber and crude protein content. Highest hay production (11279.70 g.m-2 ), grain protein percentage(14.85%), iron content ( 446 mg kg-1 dry matter), calcium percentage (3.66%), and the lowest fiber content (9.44%) were obtained from amaranth with density of 66000 plants per hectare planted on July the 6th. The highest content of zinc(113.50 mg kg-1 dry matter) was observed  with corn planted on June 22 with density of 66000 plants per hectare. The highest  content of crude protein was in corn planted on July 21 with density of 66000 plants per hectare( 1.69%) without significant difference against amaranth planted on July 6 (1.65%). Maximum fiber content (26.39%) belonged to sorghum plant. The results of this experiment showed that quality of 3 forage species were reduced with delaying planting date and increasing plant density. The results of this experiment, as a whole, showed that amaranth with density of 66000 plants per hectare at sowing date of July 6 can be recommended as appropriate and superior forage plant to Fars province based on the traits evaluated.

References:

Aghaalikhani, M. 1993. Evaluating of different nitrogen rates on yield, growth and qualitative and quantitative of forage Sorghum. Ms Thesis. University of Tehran. 183pp.

 Akinola, J.D., and J.H. Davies. 1978. Effects of sowing date on forage and seed production of 14 varieties of cowpea. Journal of Agriculture. 14:197-203.

 Alvarez – Jubetea, L., E.K. Arendtb, and E. Gallaghera. 2010. Nutritive value of pseudo cereals and their increasing use as functional gluten – free ingredients. Food Science and Technology. 21: 106-113.

 Ansari-Ardali, S., and M. Aghaalikhani. 2012. Effect of nitrogrn and density on qualitative and quantitative performance of forage Amaranth. Iranian Journal of Agronomy Science. 1: 35-44. (In Persian).

 Arnon, A. 1993. Agronomy in dry land. Translate: Koucheki, A. Jahade Daneshghai Mashhad Press. 202pp.

 Ayeneband, A., Aqasizadeh, V. and Meskarbashi, M. 2005. Evaluation of quantitative and qualitative charactereistics of Amaranth cultiuvars in different planting dates. Iranian Journal of Field Crops Research. 5(2): 221-228. .(In Persian).

 

 Barba de la Rosa, A.P., I.S. Fomsgaard, B. Larsen, A.G. Mortensen, and A. De Leon. 2009. Amaranth as an alternative crop for sustainable food production, phenolic acids and flavonoids with potential impact on its nutraceutical quality. Journal of Cereal Science. 49: 117-121.

 Bazi, M.., N. Nemati, H. Mokhtarpour, and S.A. Mosavat. 2005. Effects of plant density and tiller removal on quality and quantity of forage sweet corn. Iranian Journal of Agricultural Science. 2:38-46. (In Persian).

 

 Becker, R., E.L. Wheeler, K. Lorenz, A.E. Stafford, O.K. Gro – Sjean, and R.M. Saunders. 1981. A compositional study of amaranth grain. Journal of Food Science. 46: 1175-1180.

 Berghofer, E. and Schoenlechner, R. 2002. Grain Amaranth. In: Belton P. Taylor Journal. 219-260.

 Caselato – Sousa, V.M., and J. Amaya. 2012. State of Knowledge amaranth grain, a comprehensive review. Journal of Food Science. 4: 93-104.

 Cox, W.J., and D.J.R. Cherney. 2001. Row spacing, plant density and nitrogen effect on corn silage. Agronomy Journal. 93:597-602.

Curran, B., and J. Posch. 2000. Agronomic management of silage for yield and quality, silage cutting height. Crop Insights Journal. 10(2): 48-57.

Danik, M., and A. Richard. 2001. Amaranth as a Nutritional Supplement for the Modern Diet. The Official Newsletter of the Amaranth Institute. 15(1):2-5.

 Early, E.B., R.J. Miller, G.L. Reichert, R.H. Hageman, and R.D. Sief. 1966. Effects of shade on maize production under field conditions. Crop Science. 6:1-6.

Emami, A. 1996. The methods of plant analyse. Technical Bulletin. No 182. Vol 1. Institute of Soil and Water Research, Tehran.

 Eshghizadeh, H.R., A.H. Khoshgortarmanesh, A. Ashrafi, A.H. Moaalem, and A. Miladi. 2008. Evaluation of iron rate in some crops in vitro. Journal of Agriculturearl Science and Naturural Recources. 3:48-53. (In Persian).

 Fallah, S.A., and A. Tadayon. 2007. Effect of nitrogrn and density on yield, nitrat and protein of silage corn. Electronic Journal of Agriculture Crops Production. 1: 105-121. (In Persian).

 Fazaeli, H. 2007. Amaranth (Amaranthus hypochondriacus) a potential of good quality forage. First International Conference on Sustainable Animal -Agriculture in Developing Countries. Pp. 317-319. 27-29 Sept. Yunnan Agricultural University, Kunming, China.

 Feizbakhsh, M.T., H. Mokhtarpour, A. Mosavat, A. Mohajer and Gh. Shahi. 2008. Effect of swing date and plant density on forage yield and morphological characteristics of corn (Sc.704). Electronic Journal Agronomy Plant. 3:1:217-224. (In Persian).

 Gimplinger, D. M., G. Shulter, G. Dobos, H. P. Kaul. 2008. Optimum crop densities for potential yield and harvestable yield of grain amaranth are conflicting. Agronomy Journal. 28:119-125.

 Graybill, J.S., W.T. Cox, and D.J. Otis. 1991. Yield and quality of forage maize as influenced by hybrid, planting date and plant density. Agronomy Journal. 85:559-564.

 Gregorova, H., M. Babelove, and E. Durkova. 2001. Productivity and quality of amaranth above – ground biomass under row spacing and crop density. The 55^th Anniversary of the Slovak Agricultural University in Nitra.

 Grobelink Mlakar, S. 2006. The impact of sowing date, plant density and mineral nitrogen fertilization on grain yield and quality of Amaranthus Cruentus "G6". MSc thesis, Ljublijana, 88P.

 Hale, M.G., and D.M. Orcutt. 1987. The physiology of plants under stress. New York Press.

 Hanson, W.C. 1950. The photometric determination of phosphorus in fertilizers using the phosphor vanadomolybdate complex. Journal of Science in Food and Agriculture. 1: 172-173

Hanway, D.G. 1979. Corn planting date, population and row spacing. University of Nebraska, Lincoln, Bull. 79:138-147.

Henderson, T., B. Johnson, and A. Schneiter. 2000. Row spacing, plant population and cultivar effects on grain amaranth in the Northern Great Plains. Agronomy Journal. 92: 329-336.

 Ishizuka, Y. 1978. Nutrient deficiencies of crops. Food Technology Center Press. P:218.

 Javadi, H., M.H. Rashed – Mohassel, and A. Azari. 2005. Effect plant density on agronomy characteristics, chlorophyll content and steam remobilization of four grain sorghum cultivars. Iranian Journal of Field Crops Research. 5(2): 271-279. .(In Persian).

 

Jones, R., and G.L. Johnson. 1991. Row width and plant density effects on Texas high plains sorghum. Journal of Production of Agriculture. 4:613-621.

 Karimi, H. 2005. Agronomy and breeding of hay crops (Vol7). University Tehran Press. 414 pp.      

Lang, A.L., J.W. Pendekton, and G.H. Dungan. 1956. Effects of population and nitrogen levels on yield and protein and oil contents of nine corn hybrids. Agronomy Journal. 48: 284-289.

 Lauer, J. 1997. More mileage from corn silage: Selecting hybrids. Field crops, 28:429-433.

 Marschner, H. 1995. Mineral Nutrition of higher plants. Second edition. New York, Academic Press.

 Masaoka, Y., and N. Takano. 1985. Studies on the digestibility of forage crops. Effect of plant density on cell wall digestibility by cellulose using two sorghum cultivars of differing tillering. Jornal of Japan Grassland Science. 31:117-122.

 Mehrani, A., H. Fazaeili, and H. Asadi. 2012. Effect of harvest in different growth step on qualitative and quantitative of Forage amaranth and evaluation of economic. Journal of Plant and Seed. 28(2): 173-185. (In Persian).

 Mokhtarpour, H., S.A. Mosavat, M.T. Bazy, and A.R. Saberi. 2007. Effect of sowing date and plant density on quality and quantity characteristics of forage sweet corn. Iran Journal of Agricultural Science. 2: 38-46. (In Persian).

 

 Moll, R.H., and E.J. Kamparth. 1977. Effects of population density upon agronomic traits associated with genetic increases in yield of (Zea mays L.). Agronomy Journal. 69:81-84.

 Moshaver, E., Y. Emam, H. Madani, Gh. Nourmohamadi, and H. Heidari-Sharifabad. 2015. Comparison of qualitative and quantitative performance of forage crops Maize, Sorghum and Amaranth as affected by planting density and date. Trends in Life Sciences. 4(4): 97-105.

 Myers R.L. 1996. Amaranth: new crop opportunity. In Janick J. (ed.): Progress in New Crops. ASHS Press, Alexandria: 207-220.

 Niromand-Tomaj, A., M. Jamialahmadi, A. Reyasi, and Gh.R. Zamani. 2008. Response some qualitative characteristics of (Lathyrus sativus L.) to density and sowing date in Birjand. Iranian Journal of Agriculture Research. 9(4): 678-684. .(In Persian).

 Normohamadi, Gh., S. Syadat, and A. Kashani. 2001. Agronomy (cereal). Ahvaz University. P: 428.

 Paduano, D.C., R.M. Dixon, J.A. Doming, and J.H.G. Holmes. 1995. Lupin, cowpea and navy bean seeds as supplements for sheeps fed low quality roughage. Journal Animal Feed Science Technolgy. 53: 55-69.

 Pospisil, A., B. Varga, and Z. Sveenjak. 2006. Grain yield and protein concentration of two amaranth species as influenced by density. European Journal of Agronomy. 25: 250-253.

Putnam, D., E. Oplinger, J. Doll, and E. Schulte. 1989. Amaranth. Alternative field crops manual. Elctronic version issue. Univ. Wisconsion, Extension Service, Madison.

 Rabbani, H., S.A Mirhadi, H. Aliarabi, H. Fazaeli, and H.R. Mahjobi. 2011. Evaluating of silage and fresh protein of two variations of forage amaranth and comparision with forage corn by protein and carbohydrate Cernel system. 5^th Iranian Pasture Science Congress. University of Esfahan.

 Raei, Y., M. Jodaet, H. Moghadam, M.R. Chaeichi, and V. Vayasani. 2009. Effect of sowing date and density on qualitative and quantitative performance of two variations of forage sorghum under limitation of water. Journal of Agriculturearl Science and Naturural Recources. 92: 52-65. (In Persian).

 Rangarajan, A., B. Ingall, M. Orfanedes, and D. Wolf. 2002. In row spacing and cultivar affects ear yield and quality of early – planted sweet corn. Hortechnology Journal. 12: 410-415.

 Raut, M.S., and M. Ali. 1987. Productivity of forage sorghum as influenced due to nitrogen and phosphorus under rainfed condition on vertisol of Burdelkhand tract. Indian Journal of Agricultural Research. 21(3): 171-174.

 Sadeghi, H., and M.J. Bahrani. 1999. Effects of plant density and nitrogen rates on yield and yield components of corn. Iranian Journal Crop Science. 3:403-412. (In Persian).

 

 Singh chhidda, J. 1988. Modern Techniques of raising Field Crops. Oxford and IBH pub. p.523.

 Sleugh, B., K. Moore, E. Brummer, A. Knapp, J. Rvssell, and L. Gibson. 2001. Forage nutritive value of various amaranth species at different harvest dates. Crop Science. 41: 466-472.

 Stalknecht, G.F., and J.R. Schulz – Schaeffer. 1993. Amaranth rediscovered. New York Publish. P: 211-218.

 Tabatabaei, S., A. Razazi, A.H. Khoshgortarmanesh, N. Khodaeiyan, Z. Mehrabi, A. Askari, Sh. Fatheyan, and F. Ramezanzadeh. 2007. Effect of iron deficienvy on concentrated, absorption and transition of iron, zinc, manganese in some a griculture crops. Journal of Soil and Water. 25(4): 728-735. (In Persian).

 Tetio – Kagho, F., and F.P. Gardner. 1988. Response of maize to plant population density, canopy development, light relationship and vegetative growth. Agronomy Journal. 8: 930-935.

 Tosi, E.A., E.H. Lucero, and R. Masciatelli. 2001. Dietary fiber obtained from amaranth grain (Amaranthus Cruentus) by different milling. Journal of Food Chemistry. 73: 441-443.

 Ulger, A.C., H. Ibrikci, B. Cakin, and N. Guzel. 1997. Influence of nitrogen rates and row spacing on corn yield, protein content and other plant parameters. Journal of Plant Nutriant. 20: 1697-1709.

 Valcarcel – Yamani, B., and S. Caetano. 2012. Applications of quinoa and amaranth and their influence in the nutritional value of cereal based foods. Food and Public Health. 2: 265-275.

Valimohamadi, F., M. Tajbakhsh, and A. Saeid. 2008. Effect of density and sowing date on yield and yield components and some qualitative and morphology characteristics of pea. Journal of Agriculturearl Science and Naturural Recources. 46: 31-40. (In Persian).     

 Vansoest, P.J., and R.H. Wine. 1991 a. Determination of lignin and cellulose in acid detergent fiber with permanganate. Journal of the Association of Official Agricultural Chemists. 51:780.

 Vansoest, P.J., and R.H. Wine. 1991 b. Use of detergents in the analysis of fibrous feeds. IV. The determination of plant cell constituents. Journal of the Association of Official Agricultural Chemists. 50:50.

 Weber, L.E. 1987. Amaranth grain production guide. Rodale Research Center, Rodale Press Inc. Pennsylvania, USA. P: 178.

 Williams, J. and D. Brenner. 1995. Grain Amaranth. P: 129-186.

  Yin, X., and T.J. Vyn. 2005. Relationships of isoflavone, oil and protein in seed with yield of soybean. Agronomy Journal. 97: 1314-1321.