Explaining and examining the dimensions of distinguishing between philosophical counselling and psychological counselling

Subject Areas : Philosophy of psychology

Seyed Hesam  Hosaini ¹ (Department of Philosophy of Education, Faculty Educational Sciences, University of Shahed, Tehran, Iran.)
Seyed Salar   Hosseini ² (A graduate of Public Administration, Payam Noor University, Saqqez Center)
Akbar  Rahnama ³ (Professor, Department of Philosophy of Education, Faculty of Educational Sciences, University of Shahed, Tehran, Iran)

Received: 2024-04-06 Accepted : 2024-05-09 Published : 2024-05-10

Keywords: philosophical counseling, Psychological counseling, Differences, World view,

Abstract :

Improving the problems of life in ancient times was a unique role of philosophy. This central role was forgotten due to the dominance of science in the modern era. But in the contemporary era, philosophy has come to its senses and is trying to revive its position in life through practical activities such as philosophical counselling. Achieving this goal requires clarifying the boundaries of differentiation between this emerging approach and other forms of psychological counselling. Therefore, this research was done with the aim of explaining the differences between philosophical counselling and psychological counselling. The type of research is applied in terms of purpose and qualitative in terms of approach, and conceptual analysis method and interpretive method were used to explain the purpose. Based on the findings of the research, the differences between these two areas can be explained in terms of the difference in definition, therapeutic role, topic, task and role, skills, goals and the relationship between client and consultant. The results of the research showed that these two areas can support each other as a complement and consider the worldview and mental state of the clients together.

References:

# Achenbach G.B. (1997). “On Wisdom in Philosophical Practice”. Inquiry: Critical Thinking Across the Disciplines, Vol. XVII, No 3, primavera. #
# Bagheri Noaparast Kh. (1389). An Introduction to the Philosophy of Education in the Islamic Republic of Iran, first volume, Tehran: Scientific and Cultural Publications. [in Persian] #
# Barrientos J. (2005). Introduction to Counseling and Philosophical Orientation. Santa Cruz de Tenerife: Idea. #
# Boele, D. (1995). The Training of a Philosophical Counselor. In R. Lahav & M. #
# Bohm, D. (1996) On Dialogue. London: Routledge. #
# Cohen, E. D. (1995). Philosophical Counseling: Some Roles of Critical Thinking, Essays on Philosophical Counseling University Press of America.:121-131 #
# Deurzen Van E. (2001). Speech is Silver, Silence is Golden: Psychotherapy and Philosophical Consultancy, Thinking Through Dialogue: Essays on Philosophy in Practice, Surrey, Practical Philosophy Press. #
# Dogan S. (2000). A Contemporary approach to School Guidance and Counseling, Comprehensive Guidance Program model, 2(13), 56-64. #
# Gerber W. (1995). Philosophical Practice, Pastoral Work and Suicide Survivors, en Essays on Philosophical Counseling, New York: University Press of America: 153-158. #
# Gerebers, Will. (1995). Philosophical Practice, Pastoral Work and Suicide Survivors, en Essays on Philosophical Counseling: 154-157. #
# Gutknecht Thomas (2006) Philosophical Counseling in Germany, Hamburg, Psychological Researching. #
# Jongsma I. ([1996). Philosophical Counseling in Holland: History and Open Questions, in Essays on Philosophical Counseling, New York: University Press of America. #
# Lahav R. & M. Tillmans (1995). A Conceptual Framework for Philosophical Counseling: Worldview Interpretation., Essays in Philosophical Counseling University Press of America. pp. 3-24. #
# Lahav R. (1996a). “What is Philosophical in Philosophical Counselling?”, Journal of Applied Philosophy, Vol. 13, No. 3, 259-278. https://www. jstor .org /stable/24353958 #
# Lahav R. (1997). “Philosophical Counseling and Existential Therapy: On the Possibility of a Dialogue between the Fields”, Journal of the Society For Existential Analysis, No. 9, pp. 129-145. #
# Lahav R. (1996b). “Philosophical Counseling and Taoism: Wisdom and Lived Philosophical Understanding”, Journal for Chinese Philosophy, No. 23, pp. 259-276. #
# Lebon Tim. (1999). Socrates, Philosophical Counseling and Thinking Through Dialogue, enThinking Through Dialogue: 31-42. https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=2ahUKEwjNtMPbkraCAxVQtqQKHfhhDyMQFnoECBgQAQ&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.timlebon.com%2FWas%2520Socrates%2520a%2520Philosophical%2520Counsellor%2520LeBon.pdf&usg=AOvVaw1597VMpEnzq2DWwaDu1Fnd&opi=89978449 #
# MacIntyre Alisdair (1977). “Epistemological Crises, Dramatic Narrative and the Philosophy of Science”. The Monist, 60(4), pp. 453-472. #
# Marinoff L. (2005). Philosophical Therapy. Istanbul: Gendas Culture. #
# Martin W.M. (2001). “Ethics as Therapy: Philosophical Counseling and Psychological Healthy”. Journal of Applied Philosophy. www.aspcp.org/ijpp/html/vol1no1.html #
# Mijuskovic B. (2021). “Philosophical Counseling and Loneliness: An Interdisciplinary Approach, Interdisciplinary Research in Counseling”, Ethics and Philosophy, 1(1), pp.28-37. https://www.ceeol.com/search/article-detail?id=994752 #
# Mills Jon. (2001). “Philosophical Counseling as Psychotherapy”, International Journal of philosophical Practice, 1(1), pp. 1-28. #
# Prins-Bakker A. (1995). Philosophy in Marriage Counseling. In: LAHAV, R.; TILLMANNS, M.V. Essays on Philosophical Counseling. New York: University Press of America, Inc. pp: 135-152. #
# Raabe P. (2001). Philosophical Counseling: Theory and Practice, Westport: Prager. #
# Raabe P. (2002). Issues Philosophical Counseling. NewYork: Prager Torrey Publishers. #
# Raabe P.B. (1999). Philosophy of Philosophical Counseling. Thesis (PhD in Philosophy) – Faculty of Graduate Studies, University of British Columbia, Vancouver. Available at: http://hdl.handle.net/2429/9926. #
# Romero J. (2010). “Philosophical advice in the international and Ibero American. Historiographic note”. HASER. International Journal of Applied Philosophy, No.1, pp.149-162. #
# Russel J. (2001). “Philosophical Counseling is not a Distinct Field: Reflections of A Philosophical Practitioner”. International Journal of Philosophical Practice, 1(1), pp.4-35. #
# Savage P. (1997). “Philosophical Counseling”. Nursing Ethics Dergisi, 4(1), pp. 32-49. #
# Schefczyk M. (1995). “Philosophical Counseling as a Critical Examination of Life-Directing Conceptions”, en Essays on Philosophical Counseling. #
# Schuster C.S. (1999a). Philosophy Practice: an alternative to Counseling and Psychotherapy. Westport, Prager. #
# Schuster C.S. (2005). Philosophical Counseling Not Personal New Age Terapy. Radical Psychology. Vol.4. www.radpsynet.org/journal/vol1-2/phillc1.html. #
# Schuster S.C. (1999b). “Philosophy Practices as Alternative Ways to Well-being”. Journal of Radical Psychology, 1(1). Available online: http://www.radpsynet.org/journal/vol1-1/Schuster.html. #
# Segal S. (2007). Disrupted Conventions or Diseased Selves: The relationship between philosophical and psychotherapeutic forms of questioning, Publisher Taylor & Francis Group: 41-55. https://doi.org/10.1080/17428170600900624 #
# Tillmanns M. (2018). “The Early Days of the Philosophical Practice Movement”, Practical Philosophy, 3(13), pp. 5-14. http://philopractice.org/web/history-maria-tillmanns. #
# Tuedio J.A. (1998). Philosophical Counseling as a Window on the Abstract Realities of Everyday Life. Department of Philosophy, California State University, Stanislaus. #