Examining the concept of modernity in the thought of Dariush Shayegan and Seyed Hossein Nasr
الموضوعات :Ehsan Ayoobi 1 , Fereshteh Sadat Etefagh Far 2 , Amir Dabiri Mehr 3
1 - Department of Political Science, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
2 - Department of History, Yadegar Emam Branch, Islamic Azad University, Shahre-Rey, Iran
3 - Department of Political Science, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
الکلمات المفتاحية: Modernity, Tradition, West, Dariush Shayegan, Seyed Hossein Nasr,
ملخص المقالة :
The contrast between tradition and modernity has always been criticized throughout the histo-ry of political thought, and many thinkers have presented their views in this field in the West-ern and Islamic worlds. Meanwhile, the concept of modernity in the thought of Dariush Shayegan as a free thinker and Seyed Hossein Nasr as a traditional thinker and theorist is ex-amined in this research. The theoretical framework of the research is a combination of Carl Gustav Jung's collective psychoanalysis and other hermeneutics theories. This research aims to answer the question, what is the approach of Dariush Shayegan and Seyed Hossein Nasr in facing modernity? The findings of the research also indicate that Dariush Shayegan as an Ira-nian thinker and intellectual underwent important changes during his intellectual life, and for this reason, his early views have very significant differences with his later opinions. On the other hand, Seyed Hossein Nasr, like Shayegan, is an ardent critic and opponent of modernity, and he believes that reforming religion leads to the deconstruction of religion and that there is no end except secularism and anti-religion. But his full-length defense of religious pluralism makes it difficult to make a final judgment about his thoughts. The method of descriptive an-alytical research and the method of collecting data is documentary.
Abedi, Hassan, Rastegar, Abbas Ali, (2016). the emergence of spirituality in or-ganizations; Concepts, definitions, presuppositions, conceptual model, Iranian Management Sciences Quar-terly, Q2, No. 5: 99-121
Boroujerdi, Mehrzad, (1998). Iranian intel-lectuals and the West, translated by Jamshid Shirazi, Tehran, Farzan Rooz Publishing.
Ershad, Mohammad Reza, April 4, (2020). searching for efficient thought in the life and works of Dariush Shaye-gan
Ferasat khah, Maqsood, 23 June (2019). Ta-briz, commemoration ceremony of Dariush Shayegan
Haqdar, Ali Asghar, (2006). Dariush Shaye-gan and the Crisis of Traditional Spirituality, Tehran, Kavir, second edition
Hashemzadeh, Soroush, August (2006). This Satanic Modernity/ A Look at Dr. Seyed Hossein Nasr's Thoughts on Tradition and Traditionalism, Kheradnameh Hamshahri, No. 5, Tehran
Hodashtian, Atta, (2001). Modernity; Glob-alization and Iran, Tehran, Chapakhsh
Javadi, Shohreh, (2013). Rereading the theo-ries of Orientalism in search of the identity of the East, Quarterly Jour-nal of Art and Civilization of the East, 1st year, 1st issue of Fall 2013, 3-8
Jung, Carl Gustav, (1989). Four Examples, translated by Parvin Faramarzi, Mashhad, Astan Qods Razavi Pub-lishing House
Jung, Carl Gustav. (1960). The Archetype and the collective unconscious. New York: Princeton University
Kaji, Hossein, (1999). Who we are from the point of view of Iranian intellectu-als, Tehran, Rozaneh Publishing House
Kiafar's Ali, conversation with Dariush, Shayegan, (2018). Taisheghar Bour-geoisie, Tehran, Sharq newspaper
Mahdavi, Mansour, (2012). Sunnah, evalua-tion of the school of traditionalism based on the thoughts of Seyyed Hossein Nasr, Qom, Ishraq Hikmat
Mesbahian, Hossein (2018). "Possibility of Philosophical Criticism of Shaye-gan's Thoughts" Iran Newspaper, No. 6749, April 18.
Modernity and Modernism, (2004). Hozeh information base, quoted from Mis-sionaries magazine, July 2004, No. 55, Qom.
Mohammadi, Abdallah, (2012). Nasr, Tradi-tion, Modernity of Seyyed Hossein Nasr's Life and Thoughts, Tehran, Andishe Jovan Center
Mohammadi, Abdullah, March (2001). The Basics of Criticism of Modernity in Seyyed Hossein Nasr's Thought, Marefat Magazine, No. 159, Philo-sophical Visa: 123 to 130
Nasr, Seyed Hossein, (2007). Traditional Is-lam in the Modern World, translated by Mohammad Salehi, Tehran, Sohrevardi Research and Publishing Office
Nasr, Seyyed Hossein, (2003). Need for Holy Science, translated by Hassan Mi-andari, Qom, Taha Publishing House
Nasr, Seyyed Hossein, (2013). modern sci-ence has removed God from the world stage, the monthly specialized information review of the book of the month, 15th year, 171, Decem-ber.
Nozari, Hossein Ali, (2001). Modernity and Modernism (a collection of essays by 15 Western theorists), second edi-tion, Naqsh Jahan Publications
Qezelsofla, Mohammad Taghi, (2017). Ide-ology - power, intellectuals and poli-tics in Iran, Tehran, Omid Saba
Sadatinejad, Seyed Mehdi, & et al. (2017). Analyzing the concept of tradition from the perspective of Iranian thinkers; Review of the thoughts of Dariush Shayegan and Seyed Hosse-in Nasr, Political Quarterly, Journal of the Faculty of Law and Politics, Volume 47, Number 2, Summer 2017: pp. 410-393
Shayegan, Dariush, (1976). mental idols and eternal memory, Tehran, Amir Kabir
Shayegan, Dariush, (1977). Asia against the West, Tehran, Iranian Center for the Study of Cultures, Amir Kabir
Shayegan, Dariush, (1995). Under the skies of the world, a conversation with Ramin Jahanbeglu, translated by Nazi Azima, Tehran, Farzan Roz publishing house
Shayegan, Dariush, (2001). The new disen-chantment of Chel Tike identity and mobile thinking, translated by Fatemeh Valiani, Tehran, Farzan Rooz Publishing
Shayegan, Dariush, (2010). Mixing horizons, selection and editing by Mohammad Mansour Hashemi, Tehran, Farzan Rooz
Shayegan, Dariush, (2013). Henry Carbon: Horizons of Spiritual Thought in Iranian Islam, translated by Baqer Parham, Tehran, Farzan Rooz
