ارزیابی استقرار صنایع کشاورزی استان کرمانشاه بر مبنای نشانگرهای پدافند غیر عامل

محورهای موضوعی : فصلنامه علمی برنامه ریزی منطقه ای

فارس عبدی ¹ , امیرحسین علی بیگی ²

1 - دانشجوی دکتری توسعه کشاورزی دانشگاه رازی، کرمانشاه، ایران
2 - دانشیار گروه ترویج و آموزش کشاورزی، دانشگاه رازی، کرمانشاه، ایران.

تاریخ دریافت : 1400/07/28 تاریخ پذیرش : 1400/10/27 تاریخ انتشار : 1402/12/01

کلید واژه: استان کرمانشاه, پدافند غیرعامل, صنعت کشاورزی, مدل سوارا,

چکیده مقاله :

چکیده
استقرار بهینه و نحوه پراکنش مناسب صنایع وابسته به کشاورزی به مثابه ی بنیادی ترین صنعت غذایی جامعه با ملاحظات پدافند غیرعامل می تواند سبب اجتناب از آسیب پذیری آن ها در مقابل بلایای طبیعی و تهدیدهای انسان ساز شود و به تحقق توسعه پایدار با رویکرد کمترین خطرزایی و خطرپذیری کمک نماید.با توجه به این مهم پژوهش کمی حاضر با هدف ارزیابی استقرار صنایع کشاورزی استان کرمانشاه بر مبنای نشانگرهای پدافند غیرعامل به صورت توصیفی- تحلیلی انجام گرفت. جامعه آماری پژوهش، 25 نفر از اعضای هیئت علمی، متخصصان و کارشناسان مرتبط با موضوع تحقیق در محدوده مورد مطالعه بودند. روش گردآوری داده ها به دو صورت اسنادی و پیمایشی بود. نظر به تعدد نشانگرهای پدافند غیرعامل مؤثر بر ارزیابی استقرار صنایع کشاورزی از روش های تصمیم گیری چندشاخصه و مدل سوارا استفاده شد. بدین منظور، در ابتدا با بررسی پیشینه، 30 نشانگر مربوط به معیارهای سازگاری( 17 نشانگر)‏، ایمنی( 9 نشانگر)‏ وافاپ ( 4 نشانگر) برای ارزیابی استقرار صنایع کشاورزی استخراج شد و پس از نهایی شدن معیارها، وزن دهی با نظر خبرگان انجام گرفت. تجزیه وتحلیل داده ها با استفاده از مدل SWARA و VIKOR در رویکردی تلفیقی با سیستم اطلاعات جغرافیایی (GIS) انجام شد. نتایج نشان داد که از منظر ملاحظات پدافند غیرعامل، در وضع موجود واحدهای صنعتی کشاورزی قند بیستون، روژین تاک، روغن نباتی نازگل و خوراک دام و طیور روانسردر وضعیت مناسب، واحدهای صنعتی کشاورزی لبنیاتی بیستون و مانیزان اسلام آباد در وضعیت نامناسب و کارخانه قند اسلام آباد غرب در وضعیت متوسط به سر می برند. پیشنهاد می‌شود متناسب با نتایج پژوهش به منظور اجتناب از آسیب‌پذیری احتمالی صنایعی که از منظر پدافند غیر عامل در وضعیت نامناسب قرار دارند، تمهیدات و تدابیر مناسب اتخاذ گردد..

چکیده انگلیسی:

Abstract
The food of the community with passive defense considerations can prevent them from vulnerability to natural disasters and threatening threats and contribute to the realization of sustainable development with the approach of the least risk of angiogenesis. Given this important aim of the present studyto evaluate the establishment of agricultural industries in Kermanshah province based on passive defense indicators. The research population consisted of 114 members of faculty members, experts and experts in the study area. Data collection method was survey and survey. Considering the multiplicity of passive defense markers affecting the assessment of the establishment of agricultural industries, multi - criteria decision making methods and SWARA model were used. For this purpose, firstly, by reviewing the literature, the indicators related to the criteria of adaptation (17 indicator), safety (9 indicator ) and afap (4 indicator) were extracted to evaluate the establishment of agricultural industries and after finalizing the criteria, weighting was carried out by experts. Data were analyzed using vikor and SWARA model in integrated approach with geographical information system (GIS).
from the perspective of passive defense considerations , in the existing position of agriculture industrial units bistoun Sugar,Rojin tak,Nazgool vegetable oil, and Ravansar feed ambush, the appropriate status , the industrial units of Bisotun and Manisan Islamabad are in poor condition and the West Islamabad sugar plant in the middle condition. in order to avoid the potential bias of industries that are in unsuitable position from the aspect of passive defense factor, the appropriate arrangements and measures are taken.
 
Extended Abstract
Introduction
The strategic decisions of I .R. of Iran has influenced in view of military threats presuppositions because of country's strategically situation in the Middle East, abundant oil & gas reserves, rich and diverse mines, conflict, threat and unrest in the recent decades in global arena, also existence of bases and crisis-oriented centers in the region, widespread pressure of United States and Israel upon Iran, imposed sanctions at various times and the urbanization of the battlefield. 31 crises from 48 known global crises have been observed due to country's geo strategic and geo economic position, geographical situation and natural disasters in Iran. One of the important aspects in development planning is applied considerations of passive defense and safety principles in view of reducing destructive and unintended effects of natural and human crises, threats, vulnerabilities, accidents and hazards in the optimal location and vicinity of industries specially agricultural industry, as well as avoiding from financial damage to facilities, municipal equipment and relevant buildings and theirs accessories. Agricultural industries as part of the national capital and important assets of our country need to continuing of infrastructure activities, facilities, equipment, arteries and removing obstacles to inappropriate placement and preparedness against natural disasters, external threats, and reducing vulnerability, make them immunize, safe and desensitize. Implementation of passive defense principles provide safety and stability of environment industrial activity against natural and unnatural disasters and human threat. Passive defense has significant role in the sense of special strategic position of Kermanshah province, different industries & theirs spaces characteristics, as well as existing of its potential threats, such as: earthquake, flooding, climate fluctuations, non-strict observance of construction laws, obsolescence of facilities, and etc., consequently negligence of conjunction between agricultural industry and the countless capabilities of agricultural development. Therefore, applying of passive defense principles and its operational strategies is an inevitable necessary in the Kermanshah province, the present study reply this question: What’s result of assessing the establishment of agricultural industries based on passive defense principles in Kermanshah Province?
 
Methodology
This quantitative research was aimed to evaluate the establishment of agricultural industries in terms of passive defense indicators by method of descriptive-analytical in Kermanshah province. The statistical population of this study was 25 faculty members, specialists and experts in the area of research topic. Data gathering method was documentary and survey. Multi criteria decision making models as Vikor and Swara utilized in order to evaluating the establishment of agricultural industries in view of multiplicity indicators on passive defense.For this purpose, initially passive defense indicators (30) were extracted which affective on evaluating establishment of agricultural industries by reviewing of the literature such Compatibility, safety and afap (17, 9, 4) respectively, and after finally the criteria determining and weighting by experts. Data were analyzed by using of Vikor & Swara techniques and geographical information system (GIS).
 
Results and Discussion
According to the results of Swara technique, the weights of the main criteria were 0.2664 for compatibility, 0.1788 for safety and 0.1027 for afap, respectively. GIS software capabilities were used to integrate and overlap the maps after weighing the effective layers in industrial location based on using of Swara & Vickor models. Semivariogram raster maps indicated that based on the standards defined degree of desirability or desirability of the place of agricultural industries establishment in the current situation, the agricultural industrial units of the sugar factory (Biston), Rojin Tak tomato paste (Kermanshah- Sarableh), Nazgol vegetable oil (Kermanshah-Mahidasht), and livestock and poultry feed (Ravansar) are in good condition, Islamabad sugar factory is in medium condition and dairy industrial units (Biston) and (Islamabad) are in poor condition.
Finding indicated: Compatibility was the first criterion for evaluating establishment of agricultural industries in favor of passive defense in Kermanshah province. The notable advantages were in accordance to passive defense standards, proximity to infrastructures such as water transmission lines, electricity, gas, transportation network, roads, raw material supply sites, rural and urban population centers, etc. in locating industrial areas. Certainly a region will have higher priority than other regions that has all facilities and equipment. The first and last priority of compatibility determined as Agro-Industrial Complex of Rojin Tak with 0.833 Si, 0.249 RI, and Qi 0.921 and Islamabad’s cooperative 121- Bahar Dalahou Manizan (dairy) with Si 5.018, RI 0.66, and Qi 0.302 respectively.
 
Conclusion
Optimal establishment determining of agricultural industries based on passive defense approach is very important, because reduce the effects of damages and vulnerabilities: natural disasters and man-made threats, prevention of possible environmental crises, as well as proper and sustainable utility of all facilities in the land area  in recent years. A suitable location for industries establishment depended on a wide range of criteria and both economic and social benefits further environmental sustainability. Continuation of agricultural large industries is considerable in favor of efficiency and profitability and theirs infrastructure existence in the productive activities. The quality of these infrastructures is affected. Proper execution of passive defense supplied economic benefits in the industries, moreover reducing the effects of the incompatible proximity of these utilities on the environment.

منابع و مأخذ:

References

1. Abdollahzadeh Fard, Alireza. (2020). a study on the role and position of urban security in passive defense (Case: Shiraz). Journal of Urban Research and Planning, Year 11, Issue 40, spring, pp.189- 200.


2. Ahdenjad, Mohsen; Zolfi, Ali; Nowruzi, Mohammad Javad. (2014). an analysis of land location for the establishment of industries using AHP and VIKOR methods (Case study: the central part of the Aras Free Zone). Environmental Planning Quarterly, No. 24.


3. Alavi, Seyed Ali; RamaZan Nejad, Yaser. (2015). Assessing the principles of proximity of special uses from the perspective of passive urbandefense Study of the proximity of hospitals in the city of Ahvaz. Human Geography Research, 49(2), pp. 259-272.


4. Amanpour, Saeed: Mohammadi Deh Cheshmeh, Mostafa; Parvizian, Alireza.(2018). Assessment of passive defense requirements in the vicinity of case studies industries: Ahvaz metropolis. Geography and urban planning - regional. 8(26). pp 217- 244.


5. Amiri, Sajjad; Ravanshadnia, Mehdi; Chalouk, Gholamreza. (2016). Pathology of Petrochemical Industries Infrastructure from the Perspective of Passive Defense and Providing Necessary Measures to Reduce Vulnerability and Sustainable Development. National Conference on Passive Defense and Sustainable Development, Ministry of Interior, 12 and 13 October.


6. Ataei, Mohammad. (2010).Multi-Criteria Decision Making", First Edition, Shahroud University of Technology Press.


7. Ayaseh, Ali; Shahbazi, Fariborz. (2018). Conference to introduce investment opportunities and capabilities of Kermanshah province. Economic Deputy of Kermanshah General Department of Economic Affairs and Finance, Kermanshah Publisher.


8. Banbury, C.M; Mitchel, W. (2007). The Effect of Introdusing Important Incremental Innovation on Market Share and Business Survival, Sterategic Management Journal.16 (2).PP.161-182.


9. Biranvand, Mustafa; Mo'meni, Kourosh. (2012). Zoning of residential areas with passive defense approach in the direction of citizens' safety in the environment (GIS) studied: Dezful city, Journal of Disciplinary Geography, 7(25), pp. 1– 2.


10. Borna, Zahra; Bashiri khozestani, Fakhrolsadat.(2016). Factors Affecting the Location of Industrial Estates According to Sustainable Development Indicators and Prioritizing Them Using Triangular PhaseNumbers". Economic growth and development research. 2(7).pp. 117-139.


11. Considerations of urban defense and passive defense approach with emphasis on cellularization of cities. Journal of Urban Management, No. 38, spring, pp. 371-390.


12. Environmental Planning Quarterly, No. 34, pp. 130-109.


13. Esfandiari Dar Abad, Fariba; Piroozi, Elnaz; Amini, Zahra. (2018), An Analysis on the Location of Optimal Directions of Physical Development of Shiraz City Using Victor Method, Journal of Geographical Planning, Golestan University Quarterly, 6 (20), pp.116-99.


14. Eskandari Hamid (2011: A). Familiarity with the basics of passive defense. Tehran, Hamid Park Esfandiaridarabad, Fariba; Jedi, Soghari.


15. Eskandari, Hamid. (2011: b). Passive Defense Knowledge Special for General Level 2. Tehran, Bustan Hamid.


16. Fathullah, Jamal. (2018).Abstract of Kermanshah province planning studies, Razi University of Kermanshah and Kermanshah Management and Planning Organization.


17. Fattahi, Ahadollah; Khalife, Ibrahim. (2016). spatial zoning of rural settlements exposed to environmental hazards using Vickor multi-criteria decision making technique (Case study: Talesh city). Regional Planning Quarterly, 5 (20).pp. 125-136.


18. Fazli, Safar; Tafti Reyhaneh, Group. (2016). Multi-criteria decision processing Processing using data mining (Case study: Selecting third party logistics in outsourcing the warranty services of an electronics manufacturing company). New research in decision making. 2(3). pp. 239-215.


19. Ghaffari, Hamideh; Mohammadvali Samani, Jamal. (2020). Application and effectiveness of passive defense in water resources planning in Iran.


20. Ghanbari, Sirus; Mohammadi, Hassan; Mirki Anari, Hossein. (2016). Location of conversion and complementary industries in the agricultural sector of Khanmirza and Lordegan. Quarterly Journal of Space Economics and Rural Development, 6(4). Pp.194-177.


21. Ghasemieh, Rahim; Jamali, Gholamreza; Asl Karimi, Elham. (2015). Analysis of Dimensions of Large Supply Chain Management Approach in Cement Industry by Integrating Multi-Criteria Decision Making Technique. Industrial Management, 7(4). Pp.65-90.


22. Ghorbanpour, Mehdi; Iraqizadeh, Mojtaba; Ali Al-Hesabi, Mehran. (2021). Pattern of Explaining Passive Defense Indicators in Reducing Urban Vulnerability Case Study: Sanandaj City, Bi-Quarterly Journal of Crisis Management, 14(3).pp.114-138.


23. Hashemi Fesharaki, Javad; Shakibamanesh, Amir. (2011). Urban design from the perspective of passive defense. Tehran, Bustan Hamid Publications.


24. Hekmatpanah, Massoud; Nasri, Massoud; Qudus, Hamid; Hosseini; Amini, Hassan. (2016). Evaluation of the structure of industrial estates with a passive defense approach, Isfahan Industrial Park. Journal of Geography, 14(50). pp. 327 - 344.


25. Hosseini Amini, Hassan; Parizadi, Taher. (2010). Basic Concepts in Passive Defense with Emphasis on the City and District, First Edition, Institute of Archaic Thought.


26. Hosseini, Milad, (2017). Passive Defense in Electrical Systems of Persian Gulf Star Oil Refinery. Islamic Azad University, Shahroud Branch", Faculty of Engineering, Department of Electrical Engineering, Thesis for Master's Degree, Field: Power Electricity, Supervisor: Dr. Mohammad Hosseini Abardeh.


27. Hosseinzadeh, Hamed; Aghadadi, Abolfazl. (2008).The role of passive defense in risk management of national and strategic projects". The First International Conference on Strategic Project Management, Tehran, Sharif University of Technology, Shahid Rezaei Research Institute Imani, Bahram;Yazdani, Mohammad Hassan.


28. Imani, Bahram; Yazdani, Mohammad Hassan; Roohipour, Soolmaz. (2018). Feasibility study of estabilishing industries in Ardabil city. Journal of urban and Regional Development planning. 3(4). pp, 183-207.\


29. Imani, Ehsan; Khodakarami, Vahid; Afsar, Amir. (2018). Evaluation of the establishment of agricultural industries". Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Industrial Engineering. Babolsar, Mazandaran University of Science and Technology.


30. Jafarizadeh, Omid; Hamzeh, Farhad. (2019). Component of passive urban defense in the face of future threats. Journal of Strategic Knowledge Interdisciplinary Studies, 9 (36), pp.216-189.


31. Jamali, Gholamreza. (2014). Predicting market share and the probability of retaining and relocatingcustomers of Bushehr banks: An analytical comparison of the results of Markov and Savara chain methods. Journal of Operations Research in its Applications. Eleventh year. Fourteenth issue (43consecutive). pp. 87-75.


32. Karimi, Elias. (2019).The plan to develop existing conversion production units and create new production units is on the agenda of the Jihad Agricultural Organization of the province. Director of Transformation Industries of Kermanshah Agricultural Jihad Organization Wednesday, Provincial Group of Anna News Agency. Hyperlink:"http://ana.ir/i"http://ana.ir/i.


33. Kazemi, Shahrbanoo; Tabrizi, Nazanin. (2016). assessing the safety of urban space with emphasis on passive defense indicators (Case study: Amol city). Quarterly Journal of Urban Planning Studies,


34. Kermanshah Governorate (2015). Statistical yearbook of Kermanshah province.


35. Khorramabadi, Mohammad; Sattarikhah, Ali. (2011). Passive defense considerations in the design of cities. International Conference on Civil Engineering, Architecture and Sustainable Urban Development, Tabriz: Islamic Azad University, Tabriz Branch, Hyperlink "http://www.civilica.com/Paper" http://www.civilica.com/Paper.


36. Maleki, Kiomars. (2012). Assessment and analysis of vulnerabilities of sensitive land uses in the city of Tabriz from the perspective of passive defense with emphasis on earthquake crisis using GIS, research project of the Defense Department of the Geographical Organization of the Armed Forces.


37. Maleki, Kiomars; Brandcom, Farhad (2013). Urban defense and security from the perspective of passive defense and the creation of defensible spaces based on safe cities from the past to the present. Sepehr Magazine, Geographical Organization of the Armed Forces.


38. Maleki, Saeed; Zarifi, Kokab. (2011). Passive Defense Analysis, Proceedings of the Third NationalConference on Passive Defense.


39. Maroofi, Ayub; Sajjadi, Jila; Rostami, Hossein. (2019). Assessing the Spatial Vulnerability of the Infrastructure of West Azerbaijan Province with a Passive Defense Approach. Scientific Journal of Passive Defense, 10(1).pp.87-106.


40. Ministry of Jihad Agriculture (2005). Report of the Office of Conversion and Complementary Industries of the Agricultural Sector. Ministry of Jihad Agriculture, Tehran.


41. Mir ahmadi, Ali; Yadegarzadeh, Hssein. (2010). investigating the vulnerability of the form of cities from the perspective of passive defense and solutions: reducing it. City Construction Quarterly.14.


42. Mohammadi Deh Cheshmeh, Mostafa; Firoozi, Mohammad Ali; Nazarpour Dezaki, Reza. (2017b).


43. Mohammadi Deh Cheshmeh, Mostafa; Heidarinia, Saeed; Shojaeian, Ali. (2017a). Assessing thepattern of deployment of critical land uses from the perspective of passive defense in the metropolis of Ahvaz, Human Geography Research, 49(4), pp. 733-753.


44. Mohammadi, Ali: Khalili, Farid; Latifi, Ahmad; Shahbazi, Fariborz; Rashidi, Tayebeh. (2018), Benefits and Investment Incentives of Kermanshah Province, Publisher: General Department of Economic Affairs and Finance of Kermanshah Province, First Edition.


45. Mohammadi, Alireza; Ghaffari Gilande, Atta; Nouri, Sepid. (2019). Determining suitable location


46. Mohammadpour, Ali; Zarghami, Amir Hamzeh; Zarghami, Saeed. (2017). Investigation and analysis of vulnerable zones and elements of the city from the perspective of passive defense, case study: Sanandaj city. Journal of Geographical Information. 26(102). Pp.190-175.


47. Pour Mohammadi, Mohammad Reza; Brandcom Farhad; Maliki Kiomars; Shafaee, Arezoo. (2013).


48. Rahmani Fazli Abdolreza, Saeedi Rad Majid, Amini Sama (2015). Assessing the safety of ruralurban spaces with emphasis on passive defense indicators; Village - City of Ashtrinan.


49. Romina, Ebrahim; Hosseini, Mehdi. (2018).Study of passive defense criteria in locating industrial activities (Case study: Industries of Qom province). Journal of Strategic Knowledge Interdisciplinary Studies, 9(34), pp. 163-183.


50. Sajjadian Nahid; Alizadeh, Mehdi; Parvizian, Alireza. (2017). Assessing the establishment of Ahwazmetropolitan hospitals based on the principles of passive defense. Journal of Spatial Planning, Golestan University Scientific-Research Quarterly. Seventh year. Twenty-fourth serial number. Summer.


51. Salehi, Hassan; Akbari, Ehsan. (2019). Presenting Architectural Patterns for Designing Hidden Buildings in the Face of Military Threats, using the built-in camouflage method. Journal of Passive Defense. 10(2).PP. 83 – 95.


52. Sarvestan, Rasoul; Maleki, Saeed. (2017) Assessing the safety of Ilam city and presenting defense solutions from the perspective of passive defense. Passive Defense Quarterly.7 (3).pp. 47- 56.


53. Shahsavari, Hamed; Ghorbani, Vahid; Rabiee, Bahareh (2015). Explain the principles and


54. Urban planning in proportion to passive defense with emphasis on evaluation and optimal planning of urban land use. (Case study: Sanandaj city. 21(83).


55. Vulnerability in urban worn-out structures based on passive defense considerations (case study of worn-out tissue of Abkooh Castle, Mashhad). , Quarterly Journal of Greater Khorasan Research: 6(19). Pp.77-93.


56. Wood Industries cluster in Ardabil province. 2(23). Journal of Urban Studies. Pp, 69 – 86.


57. Yahya Pour, Mohammad Sadegh; Moghli, Marziyeh; Sedeghi, Abolfazl; Hosseini Amini, Hassan. (2016), Planning and locating from the perspective of passive defense, Tehran Fiqh al-Sadegh.


58. Yasouri, Majid. (2013).Study of the establishment of industries and location of industrial towns in Mashhad. Journal of Land Management. 5 (2).pp. 55 -74.


59. Ziari, Keramatullah. (2008). New Cities Planning, Samat Publications, Tehran


60. Zones for "industrial clusters" using multi-criteria decision models in GIS environment Case study: