Determination of Arsenic and Trace Elements Exposure in Commercial Fishes on the Iran Market: Health Risk Assessment
Subject Areas : Journal of Chemical Health Risks
Asma Afshari
1
,
Faeze Behyad
2
,
Ghazaleh Monazami Tehrani
3
,
Seyedeh Belin Tavakoly Sany
4
1 - Medical Toxicology Research Center, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran
2 - Faculty of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran
3 - Faculty of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran
4 - Department of Health, Safety, Environment Management, School of Health, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad 13131-99137, Iran
Keywords: Heavy metals, Environmental pollution, Health risk as-sessment, Public pealth, Food safety,
Abstract :
Consuming food contaminated with toxic heavy metals is a main exposure rout of these substances entering the human body and is a serious threat to the health of communities. The present study aimed to estimate human health risk when exposed to arsenic and heavy metals due to the consumption of commercial fish in Iranian market. Nine species of commercial fishes were supplied from the public market in the city of Mashhad, Iran. Ninety samples were randomly selected from nine each species, and then concentration of heavy metals was measured. The concentration of heavy metals was measured with an inductively coupled plasma emission spectrometer. The health risk assessment-based EPA model was used to explore carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic risks. Hazard Quotient (THQ) in all species was less than 1 for adults, but the hazard index of all species was higher than 1, with a mean value of 2.09 ± 0.33 ranging between 1.3 and 2.86. The hazard quotient for children was higher than 1 in two metals, lead, and zinc. The hazard index for all was higher than 1, with a mean value of 6.39 ± 1.60 ranging between 4.21 and 8.77. Cancer risk (CR) assessment showed that in adults, the three metals arsenic, cadmium, and lead were within the safe range (CR ≥1×10-4)and only chromium was in the borderline of CR. Among children, the CR for cadmium and lead was in the safe range (CR ≥1×10-4)and for arsenic and chromium was in the borderline. There are potential carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic risks associated with consuming the fish commonly sold in Iranian market. The presence of heavy metals in aquatic products consumed in Mashhad can affect consumers’ health. The results of this monitoring can facilitate health decision-making and improve human health.
1. Jansen L., Roodenburg AJ., 2016. The use of food composition data in the Choices International Programme. Food Chemistry. 193(5), 196-202.
2. Torchi M., Seyedain Ardabili M., Azizi Nejad R., Nematollahi F., 2016. Assessing the effect of baking methods on the levels of heavy metals in Iranian traditional breads. Journal of Food Technology and Nutrition. 14(1), 5-12.
3. Dadgar S., Salehi H., Hajimirrahimi SD., Teimoori M., 2014. Measuring of per capita fish consumption and assessing barriers and development strategies for con-sumption in Markazi Province. Iranian Scientific Fisheries Journal. 10(2), 135-141.
4. Harlioglu M., Farhadi A., 2017. Iranian fisheries status: an update (2004-2014). Fish Aqua Journal. 8(2), 11-24.
5. Heshmati A., Karami-Momtaz J., Nili-Ahmadabadi A., Ghadimi S., 2017. Dietary exposure to toxic and essential trace elements by consumption of wild and farmed carp (Cyprinus carpio) and Caspian kutum (Rutilus frisii kutum) in Iran. Chemosphere. 173(6), 207-15.
6. Toppe J., Albrektsen S., Hope B., Aksnes A., 2007. Chemical composition, mineral content and amino acid and lipid profiles in bones from various fish species. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology Part B: Bio-chemistry and Molecular Biology. 146(3), 395-401.
7. Dekamin M., Veisi H., Safari E., Liaghati H., Khoshbakht K., Dekamin MG., 2015. Life cycle assess-ment for rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) produc-tion systems: a case study for Iran. Journal of Cleaner Production. 91(4), 43-55.
8. Bergman Å., Heindel JJ., Jobling S., Kidd K., Zoeller TR., 2013. State of the science of endocrine disrupting chemicals. World Health Organization. 11(1), 41-53.
9. Radkhah A.R., 2019. Prevalence of parasitic diseases as a serious threat to the ornamental fish industry: A study on the prevalence of Argulus parasites in ornamental fishes of Iran. J Orname Aqua. 6(3), 13-22.
10. Jyothi NR., 2020. Heavy metal sources and their effects on human health. Environ Imp and Mit. 20, 34-39.
11. Di Loreto G., Sacco A., Felicioli G., 2010. Radon in workplaces, a review. G Ital Di Med Lav Ed Ergon. 32(4), 251-259.
12. USEPA., 2005. Guidelines for carcinogen risk as-sessment. Risk Assessment Forum. US Environmental Protection Agency Washington, DC. 3 (2), 12-23.
13. USEPA., 2000. Draft Exposure and Human Health Reassessment of 2, 3, 7, 8-Tetrachlorodibenzo-p-Dioxin (TCDD) and Related Compounds. EPA/600/P-00/001Bd, 2000. 11(1), 239-245.
14. USEPA., 2000. Methodology for deriving ambient water quality criteria for the protection of human health. USEPA, Office of Water Washington DC. 2, 5-11.
15. Santonicola S., De Felice A., Cobellis L., Passariello N., Peluso A., Murru N., 2017. Comparative study on the occurrence of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in breast milk and infant formula and risk assessment. Chemo-sphere.175(4), 383-390.
16. Varol M., Sünbül MRJEr., 2020. Macroelements and toxic trace elements in muscle and liver of fish species from the largest three reservoirs in Turkey and human risk assessment based on the worst-case scenarios. 184(4),109298.
17. USEPA., 2002. Supplemental guidance for developing soil screening levels for superfund sites. 12(1), 1-187.
18. RaSenio y L., Smith r., lexicologis Ph., 2000. EPA Region EQRisk-Based Concentration Table. Background Information Development of Risk-Based Concentrations. 3, 112-119.
19. Sobhanardakani S., Tayebi L., Farmany A., Cheraghi M., 2012. Analysis of trace elements (Cu, Cd, and Zn) in the muscle, gill, and liver tissues of some fish species using anodic stripping voltammetry. Environ monit and assess. 184(2), 6607-6612.
20. Milošković A., Dojčinović B., Kovačević S., Ra-dojković N., Radenković M., Milošević D., 2017. Spatial monitoring of heavy metals in the inland waters of Serbia: a multispecies approach based on commercial fish. Environ Sci and Poll Res. 23(6), 918-933.
21. Shah AI., 2017. Heavy metal impact on aquatic life and human health–an overview. Proceedings of 37th Annual Conference of the International Association for Impact Assessment, IA’s Contribution in Addressing Climate Change. Stockholm, Sweden, June 10-13Teeri, pp. 112-123.
22. Ni H., Chan S., Wang W-XJC., 2005. Influences of salinity on the biokinetics of Cd, Se, and Zn in the inter-tidal mudskipper. Periophthalmus cantonensis. 61(11), 1607-1703.
23. Nasrollahzadeh Saravi H., Pourgholam R., Pourang N., Rezaei M., Makhlough A., 2013. Heavy metal con-centrations in edible tissue of Cyprinus carpio and its target hazard quotients in the Southern Iranian Caspian Sea Coastal. Unesipour. 23(103), 33-44.
24. Bandani GA., Khoshbavar Rostami H., Yelghi S., Shokrzadeh M., Nazari H., 2011. Concentration of heavy metals (Cd, Cr, Zn, and Pb) in muscle and liver tissues of common carp (Cyprinus carpio L., 1758) from coastal waters of Golestan Province. J Health Environ. 6(2), 267-278.
25. Agah H., Leermakers M., Elskens M., Fatemi S.M.R., Baeyens W.J.E.m., 2009. Accumulation of trace metals in the muscle and liver tissues of five fish species from the Persian Gulf. Assessment. 157(3), 499-514.
26. Türkmen A., Türkmen M., Tepe Y., Akyurt İ., 2005. Heavy metals in three commercially valuable fish species from Iskenderun Bay, Northern East Mediterranean Sea, Turkey. Food Chem. 91(1), 167-72.
27. Fabris G., Turoczy NJ., Stagnitti F., 2006.Trace metal concentrations in edible tissue of snapper, flathead, lobster, and abalone from coastal waters of Victoria, Australia. Ecotoxicol and Environment Safety. 63(2), 286-92.
28. Radkhah AR., Eagderi S., Sadeghinejad Masouleh E., 2023. Accumulation of Heavy Metals in Fish: A Serious Threat to Food Security and Public Health. Journal of Marine Medicine. 3(4), 236-45.
29. Agah H., Leermakers M., Elskens M., Fatemi SMR., Baeyens W., 2009. Accumulation of trace metals in the muscle and liver tissues of five fish species from the Persian Gulf. Environ monit and assess. 157(3), 499-514.
30. Adam MA., Maftuch M., Kilawati Y., Risjani Y., 2019. The effect of cadmium exposure on the cytoskeleton and morphology of the gill chloride cells in juvenile mosquito fish (Gambusia affinis). J Environ and Health. 45(4), 337-43.
31. Rajeshkumar S, Li X., 2018. Bioaccumulation of heavy metals in fish species from the Meiliang Bay, Taihu Lake, China. Toxicology reports. 5(1), 288-95.
32. Ormaza-González F.I., Ponce V, Pin G.M., 2020. Low mercury, cadmium and lead concentrations in tuna products from the eastern Pacific. J Environ and Health. 6(7), e04576.
33. Orangi M.A., Rahmani A., Mohaddesi A., Koosej N.J., 2021. Evaluation of heavy metal levels of lead, nickel, zinc, iron and copper in the muscle tissue of liza klunzingeri and the risk of its consumption in the islands (Qeshm, Hengam and Hormoz), Hormozgan Province. 30(1), 1-12.
34. Tariq J., Jaffar M., Ashraf M., Moazzam M.J., 1993. Heavy metal concentrations in fish, shrimp, seaweed, sediment, and water from the Arabian Sea, Pakistan. Marine Poll Bull. 26(11), 644-717.
35. Koller M., Hosam M.S., 2018. Introductory chapter: Introducing heavy metals. Heavy Metals. 1, 3-11.
36. Hadiani M.R., Dezfooli-Manesh S., Shoeibi S., Ziarati P., Mousavi C.P., 2015. Trace elements and heavy metals in mineral and bottled drinking waters on the Iranian market. Food Addit Contam Part B Surveill. 8(1), 18-24.
37. Chowdhury S., Mazumder M.J., Al-Attas O., Husain E., 2016. Heavy metals in drinking water: occurrences, implications, and future needs in developing countries. Sci of Total Environ. 569(7), 476-88.
38. Järup L., 2003. Hazards of heavy metal contamination. British Medical Bulletin. 68(3), 134-151.
39. Albaji A., Ziarati P., Shiralipour R.J., Sci A., 2013. Mercury and Lead contamination study of drinking water in Ahvaz, Iran. International Journal of Farming and Allied Sciences. 2(3), 751-853.
40. Cobbina S.J., Duwiejuah A.B., Quansah R., Obiri S., Bakobie N.J., 2015. Comparative assessment of heavy metals in drinking water sources in two small-scale mining communities in northern Ghana. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 12(9), 10620-34.
41. Safari Y., Delavar M.G., 2019. The influence of soil pollution by heavy metals on the land suitability for irri-gated wheat farming in Zanjan region, northwest Iran. Arabian Journal of Geosciences. 12(5), 1-10.
42. Jiang H., Qin D., Chen Z., Tang S., Bai S., Mou Zl., 2016. Heavy metal levels in fish from Heilongjiang River and potential health risk assessment. Bulletin of Environ Contamin and Toxicol. 97(3), 536-542.
43. Adegbola I.P., Aborisade B.A., Adetutu A.J., 2021. Health risk assessment and heavy metal accumulation in fish species (Clarias gariepinus and Sarotherodon mel-anotheron) from industrially polluted Ogun and Eleyele Rivers, Nigeria. Toxicol Rep. 8 (6), 1445-1460.
44. Hassanpour M., Rajaei G., SinkaKarimi M., Ferdosian F., Maghsoudloorad MS., 2014. Determination of heavy metals (Pb, Cd, Zn and Cu) in Caspian kutum (Rutilus frisii kutum) from Miankaleh international wetland and human health risk. J Mazandaran Univ Med Sci. 24(113), 163-170.
45. Panahandae M., Mansori N., Khorasani N., Karbasi A., Riyazi B., 2013. Estimate of exposure and potential hazard to consumption of, esox lucius, cyprinus carpio, chaleaiburnus chaleoide containing lead, cadmium and chromium in the indian bordering of anzali lagoon. J of Wet Ecobio. 2(1), 145-162.
46. Taweel A., Shuhaimi M., Ahmad A.J., safety E., 2013. Assessment of heavy metals in tilapia fish (Oreo-chromis niloticus) from the Langat River and Engineering Lake in Bangi, Malaysia, and evaluation of the health risk from tilapia consumption. Ecotox and Environ Safety. 93:45-51.
47. Mortazavi M., Sharifian Sr., 2011. Mercury bioac-cumulation in some commercially valuable marine or-ganisms from Mosa Bay, Persian Gulf. Int J Environ Scie. 5(3), 757-62.
48. Rafeipoor A., Dehghan R., Nejadsajdi H.S., 2019. Concentration measurement of heavy metals mercury, lead and cadmium in fish muscle Tuna, Tap and tilapia in the city of Jiroft. J Res Environ Health. 5(1), 21-30.
49. Mortazavi M., Sharifian S., Aghajari N., 2013. Risk estimation of heavy metals from consumption of silver pomfret and tiger tooth croaker in Hormozagan Province. Iranian Fisheries Science Research Institute. 4(4), 119-126.
50. Solgi E., 2015. Risk assessment of non-carcinogenic effects of lead, cadmium, and zinc in Cyprinus carpio from Zarivar wetlan. Journal of Health in the Field. 5(2), 76-82.
51. USEPE.,1989. Risk Assessment Guidance for Super-fund: pt. A. Human health evaluation manual: Office of Emergency and Remedial Response, US Environmental Protection Agency. 2, 1298-1293.
52. Mesdaghinia A., Nasseri S., Hadi M.J., 2016. As-sessment of carcinogenic risk and non-carcinogenic hazard quotient of chromium in bottled drinking waters in Iran. Environment. 9(3), 347-58.
53. Rajaei Q., Pourkhabbaz A., Hesari M.S., 2012. As-sessment of heavy metals health risk of groundwater in Ali Abad Katoul Plian. Journal of North Khorasan Uni-versity of Medical Sciences. 4(2), 155-62.
54. Rahman M.S., Molla A.H., Saha N., Rahman F.C., 2012. Study on heavy metals levels and its risk assess-ment in some edible fishes from Bangshi River, Savar, Dhaka, Bangladesh. Food Chemistry. 134(4), 1847-1854.