Comparison of the Relationship between Freedom and Development in the Thought of Ayatollah Mesbah Yazdi and Amartya Sen
محورهای موضوعی : مجله بین المللی علوم اجتماعی
Ebrahim Kazemi
1
,
Mohammad Mahdi Naderi
2
,
Rahmatollah Amirahmadi
3
1 - Ph.D. Student in Contemporary Philosophy, Sabzevar Branch, Islamic Azad University, Sabzevar, Iran
2 - Department of Philosophy, AZ.C., Islamic Azad University, Azadshahr, Iran
3 - Department of Sociology, AZ.C., Islamic Azad University, Azadshahr, Iran
کلید واژه: Freedom, Development, Ayatollah Mesbah Yazdi, Amartya Sen,
چکیده مقاله :
This study, with the aim of comparing the relationship between freedom and development in the thought of Ayatollah Mesbah Yazdi and Amartya Sen, was conducted using a descriptive-analytical method. The findings indicated that in the thought of Mesbah Yazdi and Amartya Sen, freedom and development are interconnected, yet in their perspectives this connection is accompanied by different emphases and interpretations. Mesbah regards freedom essentially as liberation from servitude to tyrants and worship of other than God; thus, he does not accept freedom in the Western liberal sense, but acknowledges it within the framework of the Islamic system. He considers freedom as an important value, but not an ultimate goal, and believes that it must be defined within the framework of ethics and religious teachings. For Mesbah, development is also seen as a means to achieve transcendent and spiritual goals, such as human felicity and perfection. However, Amartya Sen considers development as a process in which individuals’ real freedoms are expanded, and more opportunities and capabilities for choice and participation in life are provided. He believes that freedom is both a tool and an end of development. In other words, development is a process through which people gain greater freedoms in choosing, living, acting, and participating in society. Sen also holds that overcoming developmental challenges requires the formal recognition of individual freedoms. For him, development is essentially the expansion of freedoms, and its ultimate aim is the removal of unfreedoms and the increase of human choice.
This study, with the aim of comparing the relationship between freedom and development in the thought of Ayatollah Mesbah Yazdi and Amartya Sen, was conducted using a descriptive-analytical method. The findings indicated that in the thought of Mesbah Yazdi and Amartya Sen, freedom and development are interconnected, yet in their perspectives this connection is accompanied by different emphases and interpretations. Mesbah regards freedom essentially as liberation from servitude to tyrants and worship of other than God; thus, he does not accept freedom in the Western liberal sense, but acknowledges it within the framework of the Islamic system. He considers freedom as an important value, but not an ultimate goal, and believes that it must be defined within the framework of ethics and religious teachings. For Mesbah, development is also seen as a means to achieve transcendent and spiritual goals, such as human felicity and perfection. However, Amartya Sen considers development as a process in which individuals’ real freedoms are expanded, and more opportunities and capabilities for choice and participation in life are provided. He believes that freedom is both a tool and an end of development. In other words, development is a process through which people gain greater freedoms in choosing, living, acting, and participating in society. Sen also holds that overcoming developmental challenges requires the formal recognition of individual freedoms. For him, development is essentially the expansion of freedoms, and its ultimate aim is the removal of unfreedoms and the increase of human choice.
Aghajani, N. (2000). “Islam and Development”. Ma’refat, Winter, Issue 39.
Mesbah Yazdi, M.T. & Nedayi, H. (1993). “A Series of Dialogues on Fundamental Issues in Human Sciences.” Mesbah, Winter, Issue 8.
Akhtarshehr, A. (2008). “Development in the West and Islam: Results and Consequences.” Ma’refat, Spring, Issue 92.
Azkia, M. & Ghaffari, Gh.R. (2008). Sociology of Development. Tehran: Keyhan (7th edition).
Urban Economics (2010). “Amartya Sen: The Economist and Advocate of Social Justice”, Issue 8.
Bagheri Dowlatabadi, M.T. & Nouri, N. (2015). “The Influence of Anthropology on Interpreting the Concept of Freedom in the Thought of Ayatollah Mohammad-Taqi Mesbah Yazdi and Mohammad Mojtahed Shabestari”. Issue 28.
Berlin, I. (1989). Four Essays on Liberty. Translated by Mohammad Ali Movahed, Bahman, Tehran: Khwarazmi Publishing Company.
Beshirieh, Hossein (2001). History of Political Thought in the Twentieth Century, Vol. 2 (Liberalism and Conservatism). Tehran: Nashr-e Ney, 3rd edition.
Todaro, M. (2008). Economic Development in the Third World. Translated by Gholamali Farjami. Tehran: Kohsar.
Hosseini, A. (2012). “Freedom from the Perspective of Transcendent Political Wisdom.” Fourth Session of Strategic Thought.
Hosseini, S. A. & Masoudi, S. E. (2018). “Analysis and Critique of Amartya Sen’s Thoughts on Development.” Critical Research Journal on Texts and Programs in Humanities, Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies.
Khalili Tirtashi, N. (2001). “Human Development from the Islamic Perspective.” Ma’refat, Winter, Issue 49.
Roshan, A. & Shafiei Seifabadi, M. (2010-2011). “Interpretation of Religion and Its Influence on the Concept of Freedom in the Thought of Mohammad Mojtahed Shabestari”, Issue 9.
Zarneshnas, Sh. (2014). Political and Cultural Dictionary, 1 vol., Qom: Ma’aref Publishing (affiliated with the Supreme Leader’s Office in Universities), 1st edition.
Taheri, M. (2021). “Findings in Jurisprudence and Epistemology”, Semiannual, No. 2, Tehran, Iran.
Mesbah Yazdi, M.T. (2009). Lecture, 11th Cultural Research Office Conference.
Mesbah Yazdi, M.T. (2012a). Political Theory of Islam. Edited by Karim Sobhani. Qom: Imam Khomeini Educational and Research Institute, Vol. 1.
Mesbah Yazdi, M.T. (2012b). Questions and Answers. Qom: Imam Khomeini Educational and Research Institute.
Mesbah Yazdi, M.T. (2012c). Response of the Teacher to Inquiring Youth. Qom: Imam Khomeini Educational and Research Institute.
Mesbah Yazdi, M.T.; Larijani, Mohammad-Javad & Mesbahi, Gholamreza (1994). “Roundtable: Religion and Development.” Ma’refat, Spring, Issue 15.
Alkire, Sabina(2010) “Development: A Misconceived Theory Can Kill”, in: Amartya Sen, Christopher W. Morris (ed.), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
- Christopher W. Morris (ed.), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
-Goulet, D. (1997). “Development Ethics: a New Discipline”, International Journal of Social Economics, 24(11), P.1160-1171.
- Marangos, John and Astroulakis, Nikos, (2009), the institutional foundation of development ethics”, Journal of Economic Issues, XLIII (2): 381-388.
- Sen, Amartya(1999):“Development as Freedom”, Oxford, Oxford University Press
