Analysis of Water Governance in Zayandeh-Rud River Basin Using the Grounded Theory Method; a Case Study of Isfahan Province

محورهای موضوعی :

Esmaeel Zakeri Mahabadi ¹ , Mohammad Reza Yazdani Zazerani ² , Hannaneh Mohammadi Kangarani ³

1 - Department of Political Science, Isfahan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Iran
2 - Department of Political Science, Isfahan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Ira
3 - Department of Political Science, Isfahan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Iran

تاریخ دریافت : 1403/08/20 تاریخ پذیرش : 1403/09/30 تاریخ انتشار : 1404/06/16

کلید واژه: Policy Making, Zayandeh-Rud River Basin, Water Governance, Grounded Theory,

چکیده مقاله :

Water scarcity and its impact on other socio-environmental aspects has become an undeniable issue which emphasizes the need to water resources management. One of the basins that have been se-verely affected by water governance issues is Zayandeh-Rud River Basin and Isfahan Province. The present study has been conducted as a qualitative study, with emphasis on the concept of govern-ance and with the aim of identifying the causes and dimensions of the crisis in the Basin and in Isfa-han province. To achieve this, the grounded theory method has been used in data analysis. Accord-ingly, have been interviewed in order to reach the theoretical saturation stage, 74 activists and stakeholders of this basin in 12 townships of Isfahan province (located in Upstream to the down-stream of Zayandeh-Rud). Participants in this study are a diverse range of actors, including mem-bers of parliament, judicial officials, executive directors, security-law enforcement officials, reli-gious-scientific figures, farmers, environmental and agricultural and natural resources experts, con-sultants, contractors and craftsmen. With open coding, 56 basic concepts have been identified and from these concepts, obtained 11 main categories which are mismanagement, increase of harvest, legal conditions, living conditions, trans-basin stations, technical view dominance, climate change, cyberspace, cultural factors, dominance Security look, strategies. Data analysis showed that from the perspective of research participants, due to shortcomings and weaknesses in governance, the policies pursued in this basin, lacked the necessary efficiency. And this inefficiency has led to a reduction in the legitimacy of the adoption and implementation of government policies, as the larg-est and most powerful actor in the Zayandeh-Rud River basin.

چکیده انگلیسی:

Water scarcity and its impact on other socio-environmental aspects has become an undeniable issue which emphasizes the need to water resources management. One of the basins that have been se-verely affected by water governance issues is Zayandeh-Rud River Basin and Isfahan Province. The present study has been conducted as a qualitative study, with emphasis on the concept of govern-ance and with the aim of identifying the causes and dimensions of the crisis in the Basin and in Isfa-han province. To achieve this, the grounded theory method has been used in data analysis. Accord-ingly, have been interviewed in order to reach the theoretical saturation stage, 74 activists and stakeholders of this basin in 12 townships of Isfahan province (located in Upstream to the down-stream of Zayandeh-Rud). Participants in this study are a diverse range of actors, including mem-bers of parliament, judicial officials, executive directors, security-law enforcement officials, reli-gious-scientific figures, farmers, environmental and agricultural and natural resources experts, con-sultants, contractors and craftsmen. With open coding, 56 basic concepts have been identified and from these concepts, obtained 11 main categories which are mismanagement, increase of harvest, legal conditions, living conditions, trans-basin stations, technical view dominance, climate change, cyberspace, cultural factors, dominance Security look, strategies. Data analysis showed that from the perspective of research participants, due to shortcomings and weaknesses in governance, the policies pursued in this basin, lacked the necessary efficiency. And this inefficiency has led to a reduction in the legitimacy of the adoption and implementation of government policies, as the larg-est and most powerful actor in the Zayandeh-Rud River basin.

منابع و مأخذ:

Akbari, Ghazanfar (2016), "Social Capital and Urban Governance", Geograph-ical Research Quarterly, Year 23, Is-sue 1, Spring.
Bazi, khodarahm and Khosravi, Somayeh and Javadi, Masoumeh and Hossein Nejad, Mojtaba. (2009), Water crisis in the Middle East (challenges and solutions), Proceedings of the 4th International Congress of Geogra-phers of the Islamic World, Sistan and Baluchistan, University of Sis-tan and Baluchistan, April 25-26, accessible at https://civilica.com/doc /82839
Creswell, J. W. (2005), Educational Re-search: Planning, Conducting, and Evaluating Quantitative and Quali-tative Research (2nd edition).
Danaei Fard, Hossein and Emami, Seyed Mojtaba. (2016), "Qualitative re-search strategies: a reflection on da-ta-based theorizing", Management Thought Quarterly, first year, sec-ond issue, fall and winter, pp. 69-97.
Esmaeili Fard, Maryam and Kaveh Firouz, Hossein. (2015), "Pathology of water policy in Iran", Social Strategy Quar-terly, 5th year, Vol. 21, Winter, pp. 169-197.
Esmaeili ,Mohammad Mahdi. (2020), "Water Supply Crisis in Zayandeh-Rud Ba-sin; Social Issues and Solutions to Manage it (Demonstrations of 2010 to 2013), Quarterly of Social Studies and Research in Iran, Vol. 9, No. 3, Autumn, pp. 567-585.
Etemad al-Saltaneh, Mohammad Hasan Khan. (1364), Merat ol-Boldan, by Parto Nouri Alaa, Vol. 2, Tehran, Afshar.
Gall, M. D., Gall, J. P., & Borg, W. R. (2003). Educational research: An in-troduction (7th ed.). Boston: Allyn & Bacon, available at: https://www.scirp.org/(S(351jmbntvnsjt1aadkposzje))/reference/ReferencesPapers.aspx?ReferenceID=713316), [access at 25 jan 2022].
Gol-karami, Abed. Kaviani Rad, Murad. (2016), "Effect of water resource limitation on hydrolytic stresses (case example: Central Iran catch-ment with emphasis on Zayandeh River catchment)", Geography and Environmental Planning Quarterly, year 28, series 65, number 1, Spring, pp. 134 -112
Hasrati, Mostafa. (2016), "An introduction to the qualitative method of theoriz-ing foundational data", Language and Linguistics Quarterly, second period, spring and summer, number 3, pp. 75-86.
Hatami, Abbas and Nurbakhsh, Susan. (2018), "Semantic reconstruction of the water crisis in the east of Isfahan based on contextual theory", Applied Sociology Quarterly, 30th year, seri-al number 73, number 1, Spring, pp. 123-146
Hosseini Abari, Seyyed Hasan. (2008), "The relationship between Sheikh Baha'i's scroll and the traditional division of the water of the Zayandeh River?", Geography and Environmental Stud-ies Quarterly, Department of Geog-raphy, first year, pre-issue-2, winter, pp. 5-14.
Hosseini Abri, Seyyed Hasan. (1377), "Tradi-tional water management of Za-yandehroud, a discussion on Iranian indigenous knowledge", scientific research journal of Isfahan Universi-ty Faculty of Literature and Human Sciences, second volume, number 15, winter, pp. 101-120.
Islamic Council Research Center. (2016), "Investigation of the water crisis and its consequences in the country", written by Mehdi Mazaheri and Nar-jes Al-Sadat Abdul Manafi, subject code 250, serial number 15608, ac-cessible at: https://rc.majlis.ir/fa/report/show /1040201
Mardani Karani, Saeed. (1375), "Research on the history of civilization and cul-ture of Chaharmahal and Bakhtiari", Shahrekord, Il Shahrekord.
Masah Bavani, Alireza and Morid, Saeed. (1384), "Effects of climate change on water resources and production of agricultural products, case study: Zayandeh river basin of Isfahan", Iran water resources research jour-nal, year 1, number 1, spring, pp. 40-47.https://www.inter3.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Downloads/Flyer_usw/download_IWRM-farsi.pdf
Ministry of Energy. (2016), "Integrated management of Zayandeh River wa-ter resources, Iranian-German re-search and development cooperation for a better future", translated by Seyed Khalil Aghili, accessible at: https://www.inter3.de/fileadmin/user_upload /Downloads/Flyer_usw/download_IWRM-farsi.pdf
Miremadi, Tahereh. (2016), "The Future of Critical Research on Water Govern-ance in Iran", Public Policy Quarter-ly, Volume 3, Issue 4, Winter, pp. 105-124.
Mirnezami, Seyed Jalaluddin and Bagheri, Ali. (2016), "Evaluation of water governance system in the process of protecting Iran's underground water resources", Iranian Water Resources Research Quarterly, Year 13, Num-ber 2, Summer, pp. 32-55.
Moghimi Benhangi, Saman and Bagheri, Ali and Abolhasani, Leily. (2017), "Evaluation of Iran's official water institution corresponding to the mechanisms governing the for-mation of water demand in the agri-cultural sector from the perspective of social learning framework", Irani-an Water Resources Research Quar-terly, Year 14, Number 1, Spring, pp. 140-159.
Mohammadjani, Ismaeil and Yazdanian, Nazanin. (2013), "Analysis of the country's water crisis and its man-agement requirements", Trend Quar-terly, 21 (65-66), 117-144.
Moradi Tadi, Mohammadreza. (2016). "Wa-ter and politics; A look at the pro-cess of politicization of water", Quarterly Journal of Interdiscipli-nary Studies in Human Sciences, 9(4), Fall, pp. 71-90.
Niakooyi, Alireza and Zibaei, Mansour. (2017), "Management of water re-sources and food security in the Za-yandeh River basin: application of the integrated analysis method of the river catchment", Journal of Ag-ricultural Economics and Develop-ment (Agricultural Sciences and In-dustries), Volume 26, Number 3, Autumn, pp. 183-196
Nooryan, Ali. (2018), "Explanation and analysis of the role of agricultural and land tenure system in the fall of Safavid dynasty (from 1000 to 1135 AH)", doctoral thesis, faculty of humanities, Islamic Azad Universi-ty, Najaf Abad branch.
Rezapour Nasrabad, Rafat. (2016), Validity and Reliability Criteria in Qualita-tive Research, Journal of Qualitative Research in Health Sciences, Year 6, Number 4, Winter, pp. 499-493.
Rogers, P. Hall, A, W. (2003), Effective wa-ter governance. Global Water Part-nership Stockholm, (available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/42765754_Effective_Water_Governance), [access at 25 jan 2022].
Sadevand, Zahra and Jandaghi, Gholamreza and Fathi, Mohammadreza and Azar, Adel. (1400), design and ex-planation of supply chain agility model of official statistics based on public value approach, Business Re-search Quarterly, No. 99, Summer, pp. 267-233.
Talebi SomeeSaraei, Mahshid and Zokaei, Mohammad Saeed and Fazli, Mo-hammad and Jomehpour, Moham-mad. (2018), "Sociology of a crisis; Social Pathology of Water Crisis in Zayandeh River Basin", Quarterly Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies in Human Sciences, 11(4), 44 series, Fall, 133-165.
Tan Asai, Alireza and Yuri, Mohammadreza and Jamshidi, Hossein and Barzali, Mohsen. (2016), "Water governance (integrated management of water re-sources)", paper presented in the second national conference on water resource management in coastal are-as, Sari, University of Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources, Oc-tober 2016.
Tayebi Abolhasani, Seyed Amir Hossein. (2018), An Introduction to Research Methodology: Standard Procedures for Qualitative Data Analysis, Sci-ence and Technology Policy Quar-terly, Volume 9, Number 3, Sum-mer, pp. 67-95.
Un. (2021), Climate change, water and fu-ture cooperation and development in the Euphrates-Tigris basin, By An-dré Mueller, Adrien Detges, Benja-min Pohl, Michelle Helene Reuter, Luca Rochowski, Jan Volkholz, and Eckart Woertz, (available at : https://www.researchgate.net/publication/356612083_Climate_change_water_and_future_cooperation_and_development_in_the_Euphrates-Tigris_basin), [access at: 20 Feb 2021]
Un. (2020), Water and climate change facts and figures, available at : https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000372876.locale=en [access at 20 Feb 2022]
Vahid, Majid and Akhavan, Saeed. (2016), "A comparative study of the perfor-mance of the 8th and 9th govern-ments in the Islamic Republic of Iran with an emphasis on water re-sources policy: case study: water re-sources crisis in Isfahan province", Public Policy Quarterly, Volume 3, Number 2, Summer, pp. 193-216
Yadegari, Ameneh and Yousefi, Ali and Amini, Amir Mozafar. (2017), Insti-tutional analysis of water govern-ance structure in Iran: study of Za-yandeh-Rud Basin, Iran Water Re-sources Research Journal, 14th year, No. 1, Spring, pp. 184-197.
Yazdani Zazerani, Mohammad Reza. (2012), "Investigation of the Conceptual Re-lationship and the Impact of Gov-ernance on Public Policy Making", International Relations Research Quarterly, Volume 1, Vol. 4, Sum-mer, pp. 109-142