The Position of Sustainable Regional Development Policymaking in the Fourth Economic, Social and Cultural Development Plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran
محورهای موضوعی :
Fereydoon Hasanvand
1
,
Garineh Keshishyan Siraki
2
,
Ataullah Sinaei
3
,
Khodayar Mortazavi Asl
4
1 - Department of Political Science, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
2 - Department of Political Science, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran & Member of the Western Studies Research Institute
3 - Department of Political Science, Payame Noor University, Tehran, Iran
4 - Department of Political Science, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
کلید واژه: Islamic Republic of Iran, policymaking, sustainable regional development, Fourth Development Plan, pathology,
چکیده مقاله :
In recent decades, the concept of sustainable regional development has become one of the funda-mental axes of policymaking at regional levels in the Islamic Republic of Iran. In this regard, with the design and implementation of five-year medium-term plans such as the Fourth Development Plan, greater coherence and alignment between policies and executive actions emerged, and the de-cision-making system became more systematic. This research, using library tools for data collection and descriptive-analytical methods and qualitative content analysis, as well as utilizing the theory of social and spatial justice, sought to answer the question: What position has sustainable regional development policymaking had in the Fourth Economic, Social and Cultural Development Plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran? The results indicate that although the Fourth Development Plan, in terms of formulating laws and designing policies, has a progressive, comprehensive, and innovative approach and has attempted to integrate various dimensions of regional development indicators into a coherent and justice-oriented framework with a holistic and integrated view, it has encountered a serious gap between goals and field realities in the implementation and practice stage. Weak institu-tional coordination, lack of executive guarantees, and the dominance of political views over plan-ning logic have led to the achievement of goals being pursued in an unstable and unbalanced man-ner. Excessive reliance on unstable financial resources and inability to build effective institutions have hindered the operationalization of key concepts such as land planning and spatial justice. As a result, instead of realizing an integrated development model, this plan has become a manifestation of the disconnect between ideal planning and inefficient implementation.
In recent decades, the concept of sustainable regional development has become one of the funda-mental axes of policymaking at regional levels in the Islamic Republic of Iran. In this regard, with the design and implementation of five-year medium-term plans such as the Fourth Development Plan, greater coherence and alignment between policies and executive actions emerged, and the de-cision-making system became more systematic. This research, using library tools for data collection and descriptive-analytical methods and qualitative content analysis, as well as utilizing the theory of social and spatial justice, sought to answer the question: What position has sustainable regional development policymaking had in the Fourth Economic, Social and Cultural Development Plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran? The results indicate that although the Fourth Development Plan, in terms of formulating laws and designing policies, has a progressive, comprehensive, and innovative approach and has attempted to integrate various dimensions of regional development indicators into a coherent and justice-oriented framework with a holistic and integrated view, it has encountered a serious gap between goals and field realities in the implementation and practice stage. Weak institu-tional coordination, lack of executive guarantees, and the dominance of political views over plan-ning logic have led to the achievement of goals being pursued in an unstable and unbalanced man-ner. Excessive reliance on unstable financial resources and inability to build effective institutions have hindered the operationalization of key concepts such as land planning and spatial justice. As a result, instead of realizing an integrated development model, this plan has become a manifestation of the disconnect between ideal planning and inefficient implementation.
Abbasi Tolli, Javad (2023). “The Concept of Social Justice and Its Relationship with Human Rights.” Available at: https://www.human-rights-iran.org/hri/archives/646
Alipouri, Ehsan and Ashofteh, Seyed Alireza (2021). Regional Development Poli-cy-Making, Tehran: University Pub-lications.
Allameh, Seyyed Ali Asghar (2014). “An Investigation of the Role of the Government in the Failure of the Fourth Development Plan.” Master’s thesis, Islamic Azad University, Tehran Central Branch, Faculty of Political Science.
Amirhajloo, Elham (2022). Rethinking Re-gional Development Policy in Iran (Approaches, Experiences, and Strat-egies), Tehran: Center for Develop-ment and Foresight Research.
Azkia, Mostafa (2005). Sociology of Devel-opment, Tehran: Keyhan Publica-tions.
Barry B. (1989). Theories of Justice, Har-vester-Wheat sheaf.
Clair, M.P. (2023). Sustainable Regional De-velopment: Revitalizing Regions through Innovation (1st ed.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003404750.
Ghadiri Hojjat, Mostafa and Hafeznia, Mo-hammadreza (2018). “Strategies for Achieving Spatial Justice in Iran.” Political Geography Research Jour-nal, 3(1), pp. 25–57.
Ghaffari Fard, Mohammad; Hosseini, Fatemeh; and Hosseini Mazari, Sey-yed Esmaeil (2023). “Mechanisms for Promoting Governance and Re-gional Development Policy-Making in Iran.” Public Sector Economics Studies Quarterly, 2(1), pp. 37–58.
Gholami Nejat Amiri, Saeed; Mehralitabar, Morteza (2022). A Collection of Sev-enty Years of Development Planning Studies in Iran: Land Use Planning and Regional Planning, Tehran: Plan and Budget Organization Publica-tions, Center for Development and Foresight Research.
Goharkhah, Fatemeh and Yadgar, Ali (2020). Regional Development of Smart Metropolises: Spatial and Economic Design Strategies, Volume 1, Tehran: Zarnashr Publications.
Heydari, Ali Akbar and Dizi Jani, Maryam (2018). “Analysis of Factors Affect-ing Urban Neighborhood Develop-ment from the Perspective of Spatial Justice (Case Study: Comparative Study of Eram and Abivardi Neigh-borhoods in Shiraz).” Regional Plan-ning Quarterly, 8(29), pp. 191–202.
Javan, Jafar and Abdollahi, Abdollah (2008). “Spatial Justice in Urban Dual Spac-es; A Geopolitical Explanation of In-equality Patterns in the Suburbs of Mashhad Metropolis.” Geopolitics Quarterly, 4(2), pp. 131–156.
Kamali, Yahya (2023). “Identifying and Ranking the Challenges of Evaluat-ing Development Policies in Iran (Five-Year Development Plans).” Majles and Strategy Quarterly, 30(115), pp. 91–125.
Karchi, Mohammadreza (2025). The Role of Governments in the Formation of De-velopment Plans: From the First to the Fifth Plans, Tehran: Sales Publi-cations.
Laurent, E. (2011). Issues in environmental justice within the European Union, Ecological Economics, No. 70 ,1846–1853.
Liu, Y. (2022). Regional sustainable devel-opment strategy based on the coor-dination between ecology and econ-omy, Ecological Indicators, Volume 134, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolind.2021.108445.
Lotfi, Sedigheh; Manouchehri Miyandoab, Ayoub; and Ahar, Hassan (2013). “City and Social Justice: An Analy-sis of Neighborhood Inequalities – Case Study: Neighborhoods of Ma-ragheh.” Geographical Research Quarterly, 28(109), pp. 69–92.
Mahmoudian, Morteza (2019). Tourism Planning and Its Impact on Regional Development, Tehran: Pazhoheshgar Bartar Publications.
Management and Planning Organization (2005). The Law of the Fourth Eco-nomic, Political, and Cultural Devel-opment Plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Tehran: Publications of the Management and Planning Organi-zation.
Mansour, Jahangir (2009). The Law of the Fourth Economic, Social and Cultur-al Development Plan, Tehran: Doran Publications.
Martínez, J. (2009). The use of GIS and in-dicators to monitor intra-urban ine-qualities. A case study in Rosario, Argentina. Journal of Habitat Inter-national, 33(4), 387-396, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.habitatint.2008.12.003.
Mir, Mohammad; Hooshmandyar, Nader; Khosravi, Mohammad Ali and Taheri, Abolghasem (2025). “Pa-thology of Government Policies in the Fourth and Fifth Economic De-velopment Plans and Their Impact on Regional Policies.” Geography Quarterly (Regional Planning), 14(54), pp. 32–49.
Mirzaei, Hojatullah; Nasiri Aghdam, Ali; and Alavi, Seyyed Houman (2023). Unbalanced Regional Development in Iran in the 2010s, Tehran: Economic Affairs Research Institute Publica-tions.
Mitchel, D. (2003). The right to the city–social justice and the fight for public space. Guilford Press.
Momtaz, Gholamhossein (2015). A Sociolog-ical Examination of the Concept of Development. International Confer-ence on Humanities, Psychology and Social Sciences, Tehran: IRIB Inter-national Conference Center.
Mosalla Nejad, Abbas (2021). Pathology of Iran’s Economic Development (First to Fourth Economic, Social, and Cul-tural Development Plans of the Is-lamic Republic of Iran), Tehran: Akhtaran Publications.
Mostafavi Sani, Ali and Nemati, Mohammad (2019). “A Pathological Analysis of Balanced Regional Development in the Country's Development Plans.” Fiscal and Economic Policies Quar-terly, 7(26), pp. 31–69.
Motahari, Morteza (1973). Divine Justice, Second Edition, Tehran: Sadra Pub-lications.
Omidali, Esmaeil (2022). The Role of Me-tropolises in Regional Development, Tehran: Shahr Sazi Publications.
Pourya Mehr, Reza (2021). Regional Devel-opment and the Role of Intermediate Cities, Tehran: Raz Nehan Publica-tions.
Rahimpour Asl, Iraj and Abdollahzadeh, Asieh Sadat (2020). Sustainable Re-gional Development and Globaliza-tion, Tehran: Arya Naghsh Publica-tions.
Sojoodi, Maryam; Ziyari, Keramatollah; Pour Ahmad, Ahmad and Yasouri, Majid (2025). “A Review of the Po-sition of Regional Planning and De-velopment in Pre- and Post-Revolution Development Plans.” Po-litical Spatial Planning Quarterly, 6(3), pp. 9–19.
Seventh Development Plan Law (2025). Available at: https://srm.acecr.ac.ir/fa/page/9510
Shojaei Nasab, Abdolreza (2017). The Devel-opment Process in the Fourth Socio-Economic Plan in Iran's Provinces, Tehran: Minoufar Publications.
Stimmes, Robert John; Stough, Roger and Salazar, Maria (2018). Endogenous Regional Development: Leadership and Institutions, translated by Hosse-in Sharifzadegan and Behzad Malek-pour Asl, Tehran: Ney Publishing.
Stohr, W. (1975). Regional development experiences and prospects in Latin America. Mouton Publishing, Uni-versity of Texas.
Todaro, Michael (1994). Economic Develop-ment in the Third World, translated by Gholamali Farjadi, Tehran: High-er Institute for Research in Planning and Development.
Yasouri, Majid and Sojoodi, Maryam (2021). An Introduction to Regional Devel-opment Strategy, Tehran: Noor Elm Publications.
Zali, Nader (2017). Strategic Foresight in Regional Planning and Development, Tehran: Center for Strategic Studies.
Ziyari, Keramatollah and Mohammadi, Ali-reza (2017). Regional Development Management with Emphasis on Iran, Tehran: University of Tehran Press.
