The Position and Role of the Government in Development from the Perspective of Hossein Azimi, Fariborz Reiis Dana and Masoud Nili
محورهای موضوعی :Ostad Rostam Rostami 1 , Reza Shirzad 2 , HosseinAli Nowzari 3
1 - Department of Political Science, Karaj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Karaj, Iran
2 - Department of Political Science, Karaj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Karaj, Iran
3 - Department of Political Science, Karaj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Karaj, Iran
کلید واژه: Growth and Development, Government, Hossein Azimi, Fariborz Reiis Dana, Masoud Nili.,
چکیده مقاله :
One of the most important issues in the economy is the role of government in the process of eco-nomic growth and development. Production is a complex and social activity that requires all its con-texts and resources to achieve proper production for society. Therefore, the issue of importance is the manner and quality of government intervention in matters related to the economy and the wel-fare of the people, not the extent of this intervention. In Iran, there is always disagreement among thinkers on which institution is responsible for development. For some, the government has a duty to take the lead in development and to push it forward, but for others, the government is not a good institution to promote development. These groups play a minimal role for the government. This study, by comprehensively examining these two different approaches, examines the views and ideas of three prominent scientists and experts in the field of political economy and focuses on the role of government in development. Azimi introduced development in a more general way and believed that complete development is not possible without the development of all structures. According to him, in the developed world, structural guidance (structuring in the presence of technical domi-nance) is unnecessary and short-term guidance is necessary. The importance of the government in the development process is so great in the idea that the main and most important institution of de-velopment is the "government based on democracy"; And he puts the judiciary and the media in the next ranks. Reiis Dana considers the state to be class in nature and does not examine the state sepa-rately from the global relations of capitalism. This lack of attention has always caused development in a fragmented, unbalanced and unsuccessful country. According to Reiis Dana, development in Iran is due to the development of capitalism, because capitalist development in the world is growing unevenly. Nili believes that government intervention in development, in addition to inefficiency, deprives people of their freedoms. Therefore, Nili looks at the issue from another angle and defends government restrictions on the economy and development by prioritizing freedom over social jus-tice.
One of the most important issues in the economy is the role of government in the process of eco-nomic growth and development. Production is a complex and social activity that requires all its con-texts and resources to achieve proper production for society. Therefore, the issue of importance is the manner and quality of government intervention in matters related to the economy and the wel-fare of the people, not the extent of this intervention. In Iran, there is always disagreement among thinkers on which institution is responsible for development. For some, the government has a duty to take the lead in development and to push it forward, but for others, the government is not a good institution to promote development. These groups play a minimal role for the government. This study, by comprehensively examining these two different approaches, examines the views and ideas of three prominent scientists and experts in the field of political economy and focuses on the role of government in development. Azimi introduced development in a more general way and believed that complete development is not possible without the development of all structures. According to him, in the developed world, structural guidance (structuring in the presence of technical domi-nance) is unnecessary and short-term guidance is necessary. The importance of the government in the development process is so great in the idea that the main and most important institution of de-velopment is the "government based on democracy"; And he puts the judiciary and the media in the next ranks. Reiis Dana considers the state to be class in nature and does not examine the state sepa-rately from the global relations of capitalism. This lack of attention has always caused development in a fragmented, unbalanced and unsuccessful country. According to Reiis Dana, development in Iran is due to the development of capitalism, because capitalist development in the world is growing unevenly. Nili believes that government intervention in development, in addition to inefficiency, deprives people of their freedoms. Therefore, Nili looks at the issue from another angle and defends government restrictions on the economy and development by prioritizing freedom over social jus-tice.
Alam, Abdolrahman (2005), Foundations of Political Science, Tehran, Ney Pub-lishing, 13th edition.
Azimi, Hossein (1987), Structural issues and problems of the Iranian economy, Kayhan, 6/20/1366.
Azimi, Hossein (2004), Iran Today in the Mirror of Development Issues (What can be done to solve the short- and long-term economic crises of the country?), Tehran: Islamic Culture Publishing Office.
Azimi, Hossein (2004), The path of our de-velopment passes through the chan-nels of Iranian culture, Asr-e-Eqtesad Magazine, 2/23/2004.
Baghestani, Massoud, Miri, Ashraf al-Sadat and Reza Samadi Boroujeni (2015), The need for government interven-tion in the regulation and supervi-sion of financial markets, Economic Journal, No. 7 and 8, October and November 2015, pp. 43-58.
Darabi, Majid, (2005), Analysis of the effect of strengthening the internal con-trols of companies listed on the stock exchange on the audit reports of the auditing organization, Master Thesis, Islamic Azad University, Central Tehran Branch.
Eftekhari, Roknuddin (1999), Theories of Rural Development (unpublished pamphlet); Tarbiyat Modarres Uni-versity, Tehran.
Evans, Peter (2001), Development or Plun-der: The Role of Government in In-dustrial Transformation, translated by Abbas Zandbaf, Abbas Mokhber, Tehran: Tarheno.
Foroughi, Mohammad Ali (2008), Principles of the Science of Wealth of Nations (the first book of economics in Iran), Tehran: Farzan Rooz Publications.
Ghavam, Abdolali (2015), Principles of For-eign Policy and International Policy, Tehran, Samat.
H. Hirst, Paul (2002), Political Corruption, translated by Mohammad Taheri, Tehran: Institute for Strategic Stud-ies Publications.
Heydarifar, Mohammad Raouf (2010); The Role and Position of the Territory in the Field of International Relations, Foreign Policy Quarterly, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Volume 24, Number 3, Fall 2010, Pages 817-846.
Hosseini, Hassan (2008), Development and Human Resources Development In-dex and its Situation in Iran, Peak Noor - Humanities, Volume 6, Number 1 (Management 2), Spring 2008, pp. 146-159.
Jomehpour, Mahmoud (2003), The main factors in the process of sustainable development: people, resources, spaces and the role of public partici-pation in it, Social Sciences Quarter-ly, Volume 10, Number 22, Summer 2003, pp. 103-130.
Khalilian, Sadegh (1999), Economics of Natural Resources, Tehran: Forests and Rangelands Research Institute.
Khezri, Mohsen, Sahabi, Bahram, Yavari, Kazem and Hassan Heidari (2015), The effect of trade returns on infla-tion in the Iranian economy, Quar-terly Journal of Economic Research, Volume 15, Number 57, Summer 2015, pp. 193-228.
Khishchehreh, Mohammad (2003); Examin-ing the scope of government inter-ventions in the development pro-cess; general culture; No. 34, pp. 12-28.
Mirdal, Gunnar (1996), Asian Drama, Pov-erty of Nations, translated by Amiri, Amir Kabir.
Naseri, Mehdi (2010), Optimal control of private investment and consumption based on monetary and financial in-struments in the framework of the objectives of the Fourth Develop-ment Plan, Economic Research, Volume 46, Number 1, Spring 2011, pp. 175-206.
Nili, Massoud (2011), Mechanisms for the realization of social justice in Iran, International Market, Volume 3, Number 13, July and August 2011, pp. 26-29.
Nili, Massoud (2011), Mechanisms for the realization of social justice in Iran, International Bazaar Monthly, Year 3, Issue 13 July - August 2011, Pag-es: 283-292.
Nili, Massoud (2014), Massoud Nili's analy-sis of the obstacles facing the Irani-an economy, Center for Strategic Studies and Studies, Nokt-e Rooz, No. 14, 6/18/2014.
Nili, Massoud and Alireza Saedi (2005), The Experience of Industrial Develop-ment in the World, Tehran: Scien-tific Publications of Sharif Universi-ty of Technology.
Nili, Massoud and Alireza Saedi (2014), Bar-riers to Industrial Development in Iran, Sharif University Graduation Conference.
Nili, Massoud, (2019), Barriers to Iran's eco-nomic growth as narrated by Mas-soud Nili, Eghtesad News, 7/11/1398, news code: 305836.
Nili, Massoud, Saberi, Ali Akbar, Nili, Far-had, Kordbacheh, Mohammad Has-san Dargahi, Ahmad Doust Hosseini (2014), Government and Economic Growth in Iran, Tehran: Ney Pub-lishing.
Pajooyan, Jamshid and Tanya Khosravi (2012), The Impact of Inflation on Private Sector Investment, Quarterly Journal of Private Sector Investment Knowledge, Volume 1, Number 4, Pages 1-22.
Rastegarjoo, Hossein (2017), Culture and Social Justice and its Role in the Economic Development of the Country, 10th International Confer-ence on Economics and Manage-ment, Rasht, Islamic Azad Universi-ty, Rasht Branch.
Reiis Dana, Fariborz (1998), Education, So-cio-Economic Development and Democracy, November 1998, No. 2, pp. 45-48.
Reiis Dana, Fariborz (2000), Economic, so-cial development and cultural ups and downs, the trick of the new pe-riod of February 2000 No. 1 (121 consecutive).
Reiis Dana, Fariborz (2002), A Speech on Development and Social Justice, Parliament and Research, Ninth Year, Spring 2002, No. 33, pp. 13-26.
Reiis Dana, Fariborz (2002), The Disaster of Exhaustion, Kalk, October 2002, No. 134, pp. 11-14.
Reiis Dana, Fariborz (2006), Dependence and Development, Journal of Devel-opment Culture, Nos. 33 and 34, pp. 64-67.
Reiis Dana, Fariborz (2007), Economic Growth and Social Justice, Market or Program? Social Welfare Quarter-ly, Volume 6, Number 24, Pages 31-53.
Shahabadi, Abolfazl (2007), The effect of government economic activities and policies on the growth of non-oil GDP (Case study of Iranian econo-my). Economic Research Journal, Volume 7, Number 26, Fall 2007, Pages 181-211.
Sharif Al-Nasbi, Morteza (1996), Research Report: Development Cycle: A Guide to the Accelerated Growth of Economic-Industrial Development in Southeast countries, Tehran, Pub-lisher of Rasa Cultural Services In-stitute.
Sokhanvar, Hossein (2011), Development does not have the same definition and meaning, Aftab newspaper, 12/4/1390.
Taheri, Shahnam (1997), Economic Devel-opment and Planning, Tehran, Azmoun Publishing.
Vincent, Andrew (2018), Theories of Gov-ernment; Translated by Hossein Bashiriyeh, Tehran, Ney Publishing, first edition.
