Assessments of Residues of Pesticide in Cattle and Cattle Products and Associated Public Health Challenges in North Central, Nigeria

Subject Areas : Journal of Chemical Health Risks

Aliyu Evuti Haruna Evuti Haruna ^{1 *} , Nma Bida Alhaji ² , John Yisa Adama ³ , Onakpa Michael Monday ⁴ , Hadiza Lami Muhammed ⁵ , Hussaini Anthony Makun ⁶

1 - Africa Centre of Excellence for Mycotoxins and Food Safety Federal University of Technology, Minna, Niger State, Nigeria
2 - Africa Centre of Excellence for Mycotoxins and Food Safety Federal University of Technology, Minna, Niger State, Nigeria
3 - Africa Centre of Excellence for Mycotoxins and Food Safety Federal University of Technology, Minna, Niger State, Nigeria
4 - Africa Centre of Excellence for Mycotoxins and Food Safety Federal University of Technology, Minna, Niger State, Nigeria
5 - Africa Centre of Excellence for Mycotoxins and Food Safety Federal University of Technology, Minna, Niger State, Nigeria
6 - Africa Centre of Excellence for Mycotoxins and Food Safety Federal University of Technology, Minna, Niger State, Nigeria

Received: 2023-04-08 Accepted : 2025-01-29 Published : 2025-01-19

Keywords: Pesticide, Aldrin, Food Safety, Tissues, Public Health,

Abstract :

Residues of pesticide in animal tissues are an increasing concern due to their potential harm to human health. To assess the associated risks, pesticide concentrations were analyzed in five edible bovine tissues: muscle, liver, kidney, and tongue. Health risk estimates were calculated using the Estimated Daily Intake (EDI), Hazard Quotient (HQ), and Hazard Index (HI) for two age and weight groups: children aged 1–11 years with an average weight of 30 kg, and adults weighing 70 kg. Pesticide residues were detected in the following ranges: 2.38–3.87 g kg^-1 in muscle, 3.59–6.4 g kg^-1 in liver, 1.88–4.55 g kg^-1 in kidney, and 2.55–4.36 g kg^-1 in tongue. The order of pesticide residue quantity across the tissues was: Liver > Tongue > Muscle > Kidney. All pesticide levels measured in the tissues were below the established maximum residue limits (MRLs). However, the HQ values for heptachlor epoxide, aldrin, and dieldrin, along with HI values for organochlorines, exceeded 1. This suggests a potential for non-carcinogenic health risks, particularly for infant, from consuming contaminated bovine tissues.

References:

1.Adesehinwa A., 2024. Pig production in Africa: Current status, challenges, prospects, and opportunities. Animal Bioscience. 37(4), 730–741.
2. Barański M., Średnicka-Tober D., Rempelos L., Hasanaliyeva G., Gromadzka-Ostrowska J., Skwarło-Sońta K., Leifert C., 2021. Feed composition differences resulting from organic and conventional farming practices affect physiological parameters in Wistar rats Results from a factorial, two-generation dietary intervention trial. Nutrients. 13(2), 377.
3. Chia S., Tanga C., Osuga I., Cheseto X., Ekesi S., Dicke M., van Loon J., 2020. Nutritional composition of black soldier fly larvae feeding on agro-industrial by-products. Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata. 168(6–7) 472–481.
4. Dipa M., 2023. Biomarkers for the assessment of pesticide toxicity in fish. International Journal of Zoology and Investigations. 9(1), 184–194.
5. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). 2004. FAOSTAT on-line statistical service. FAO, Rome. Available online:
6. Fuhrimann S., Wan C., Blouzard E., Veludo A., Holtman Z., Chetty-Mhlanga S., Rother H., 2021. Pesticide research on environmental and human exposure and risks in Sub-Saharan Africa: A systematic literature review. International Journal of Environmental Research & Public Health. 19(1), 259.
7. Haggblade S., Diarra A., Traoré, A. 2021. Regulating agricultural intensification: Lessons from West Africa’s rapidly growing pesticide markets. Development Policy Review. 40(1) 22-24
8. Isgren E., Andersson E., 2020. An environmental justice perspective on smallholder pesticide use in Sub-Saharan Africa. Journal of Environment & Development. 30(1), 68–97.
9. Jiang W., 2023. Collection of data on pesticides in maize and tomato in Africa: Protocol for Africa pesticide residue survey study. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology. 110(2) 23-26
10. Kipkoech C., Jaster-Keller J., Gottschalk C., Wesonga J., Maul R., 2023. African traditional use of edible insects and challenges towards the future trends of food and feed. Journal of Insects as Food and Feed. 9(8), 965–988.
11. Lorusso V., 2021. Parasitology and One Health Perspectives on Africa and beyond. Pathogens. 10(11), 1437.
12. Mahmound A.F.A., Darwish W., Morshdy A.M.A., Eldaly E.A., Ikenaka Y., Ishizuka M., 2013. Determination of organochlorine pesticides (OCPs) in edible offals of Egyptian buffalo. Japanese Journal of Veterinary Research. 61(2), S58–S63.
13. Mbosso C., Boulay B., Padulosi S., Meldrum G., Mohamadou Y., Niang A., Sidibé A., 2020. Fonio and Bambara groundnut value chains in Mali: Issues, needs, and opportunities for their sustainable promotion. Sustainability. 12(11), 4766.
14. Muhammad F., Akhtar M., Rahman Z.U., Farooq H.U., Khaliq T., Anwar M., 2010. Multi-residue determination of pesticides in the meat of cattle in Faisalabad-Pakistan. Egyptian Academic Journal of Biological Sciences. 2, 19–28.
15. Newman M.C., 2010. Fundamentals of ecotoxicology (3rd ed.). Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
16. Fuhrimann S., Wan C., Blouzard E., Veludo A., Holtman Z., Chetty-Mhlanga S., Rother H., 2021. Pesticide research on environmental and human exposure and risks in Sub-Saharan Africa: A systematic literature review. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 19(1), 259
17.Haggblade S., Diarra A., Traoré A., 2021. Regulating agricultural intensification: Lessons from West Africa’s rapidly growing pesticide markets. Development Policy Review. 40(1). 45-47
18. Isgren E., Andersson E., 2020. An environmental justice perspective on smallholder pesticide use in Sub-Saharan Africa. Journal of Environment and Development. 30(1), 68–97.
19. Jiang W., 2023. Collection of data on pesticides in maize and tomato in Africa: Protocol for Africa pesticide residue survey study. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology. 110(2). 33-36
20.Kipkoech C., Jaster-Keller J., Gottschalk C., Wesonga J., Maul R., 2023. African traditional use of edible insects and challenges towards the future trends of food and feed. Journal of Insects as Food and Feed. 9(8), 965–988.
21.Cox C., 1991. Glyphosate. Journal of Pesticide Reform. 11(2), 35–38.
22.Japan Food Chemical Research Foundation (JFCRF). 2006. Positive list system for agricultural chemical residues in food. Japan.
23.Ahmad I., 2011. Monitoring of pesticide residues in food animals. Journal of Environmental Sciences. 78(2), 35–37.
24.Fardous A., 2010. Pesticide residues in animal tissues: A public health concern. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology.
25. Nwude D.O., 2011. Metal quantification in cattle. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health Sciences. 75(2), 35–38.
26. Pardio V., 2011. Human health risk of dietary intake of organochlorine pesticide residues. Food Chemistry, 135, 1873–1893.
27. Thrusfield M., 2009. Veterinary epidemiology (3rd ed.). Oxford: Blackwell Science Ltd 78(2), 2528.
28. Schmidt W. F., Bilboulian S., Rice C. P., Fettinger C., McConnell L. L., Hapeman C. J. 2013. Structure and asymmetry in the isomeric conversion of beta-to-alpha-endosulfan. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 49(11), 5372–5376.
29.Schmidt W.F., Hapeman J.C., Fettinger C.J., Rice C.P., Bilboulian S., 1997. Thermodynamic, spectroscopic, and computational evidence of irreversible conversion of beta-to-alpha-endosulfan. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 45(4), 1023–1026.
30. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). 1993. Re-registration eligibility document: Glyphosate. Office of Prevention, Pesticides and Toxic Substances, EPA: Washington, DC.
31.Van Der Hoff G. R., Van Beuzekom A. C., Brinkman U. A., Baumann R. A., Van Zoonen P., 2010. Determination of organochlorine compounds in fatty matrices Application of rapid off-line normal-phase liquid chromatographic clean-up. Journal of Chromatography A. 754, 487.
32. Vijay J. J., Vikas S. W., 2019. Public health implications of pesticide residues in meat. Veterinary World. 4(4), 178–182.
33.Blankson-Arthur S., Tutu A. O., Fosu P., Mensah H. K., Denutsul D., Palm L.P., Atiemo S. M., Kwofie A. B., 2019. Concentration of organochlorine pesticide residue in game meat from the Gomoa East District of Ghana. Elixir Pollution. 49, 9739–9742.
34.Blankson-Arthur S., Yeboah P.O., Golow A. Tutu A.O., Denutsul D., 2012. Levels of organochlorine pesticide residues in grasscutter (Thryonomys swinderianus) tissues. Research Journal of Environmental and Earth Sciences. 34, 350–357.
35. Ezemonye L.I.N., Tongo I., 2009. Lethal and sublethal effects of atrazine to amphibian larvae. Jordan Journal of Biological Sciences. 1, 29–36.
36. Food and Agriculture Organization/World Health Organization (FAO/WHO). 1995. Pesticide residues in food 1994: Report of the Joint Meeting of the FAO Panel of Experts on Pesticide Residues in Food and the Environment and WHO Toxicological and Environmental Core Assessment Groups (FAO Plant Production and Protection Paper 127). Rome.
37.Food and Agriculture Organization/World Health Organization (FAO/WHO). 1992. Pesticide residues in food—1991: Evaluations—1991, Part II. Toxicology (WHO/PCS/92.52). Geneva.
38.Mahmoud A.F.A., Darwish W.S., Morshdy A.M.A., Eldaly E.A., Ikenaka Y., Ishizuka M., 2021. Determination of organochlorine pesticides (OCPs) in edible offals of Egyptian buffalo. Japanese Journal of Veterinary Research, 61, S58–S63.
39.Morais S., Dias E., Pereira M., 2012. The impact of pesticides. Academic Publishing Organization. 21–38.
40.Shahzadi N., Imran M., Sarwa M., Hashmi A., Wasim M., 2015. Identification of pesticide residues in different samples of milk. Journal of Agroalimentary Processes International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC). 2008. Overall evaluations of carcinogenicity to humans, update 2008.
41.Amaraeni S.R., Pillale R.R., 2000. Concentration of pesticide residues in tissues of fish from Koller Lake in India. Environmental Toxicology. 16(6), 550–556.
42. Cox C., 1999. Glyphosate. Journal of Pesticide Reform. 11(2), 35–38.
43. Japan Food Chemical Research Foundation (JFCRF). 2006. Positive list system for agricultural chemical residues in food. Japan.
44. Ahmad I., 2020. Monitoring of pesticide residues in food animals. Journal of Environmental Sciences. 347(2), 31–33.
45. Bradman A., Eskenazi B., Castorina R., 1999. Exposures of children to organophosphate pesticides and their potential adverse health effects. Environmental Health Perspectives. 107, 409.
46.Fardous A., 2020. Pesticide residues in animal tissues: A public health concern. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology. 78(2), 35–38.
47. Cox C., 1994. Glyphosate. Journal of Pesticide Reform. 11(2), 35–38.
48. Japan Food Chemical Research Foundation (JFCRF). 2006. Positive list system for agricultural chemical residues in food. Japan. Available at: www.ffcr.or.jp.
49. Ahmad I., 2011. Monitoring of pesticide residues in food animals. Journal of Environmental Sciences. 29(2), 24-26.
50. Fardous A., 2020. Pesticide residues in animal tissues: A public health concern. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology. 68(2), 45–48.
51. Nwude D. O. 2013. Metal quantification in cattle. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health Sciences. 11(2), 35–38.
52.Pardio V. 2012. Human health risk of dietary intake of organochlorine pesticide residues. Food Chemistry, 135, 1873–1893.
53.Thrusfield M. 2009. Veterinary epidemiology (3rd ed.). Oxford: Blackwell Science Ltd. 68(2), 44–41.
54. Adesehinwa A., 2023. Pig production in Africa: Current status, challenges, prospects, and opportunities. Animal Bioscience, 37(4), 730–741.
55.Barański M., Średnicka-Tober D., Rempelos L., Hasanaliyeva G., Gromadzka-Ostrowska J., Skwarło-Sońta K., Leifert C. 2023. Feed composition differences resulting from organic and conventional farming practices affect physiological parameters in Wistar rats Results from a factorial, two-generation dietary intervention trial. Nutrients. 13(2), 377.
56. Chia S., Tanga C., Osuga I., Cheseto X., Ekesi S., Dicke M., van Loon J. 2021. Nutritional composition of black soldier fly larvae feeding on agro-industrial by-products. Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata. 168(6–7), 472–481.
57.Dipa M. 2023. Biomarkers for the assessment of pesticide toxicity in fish. International Journal of Zoological Investigations, 9(1), 184–194.
58. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). 2004. FAOSTAT on-line statistical service. FAO, Rome.
59. Fuhrimann S., Wan C., Blouzard E., Veludo A., Holtman Z., Chetty-Mhlanga S., Rother H., 2022. Pesticide research on environmental and human exposure and risks in Sub-Saharan Africa: A systematic literature review. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 19(1), 259.
60. Haggblade S., Diarra A., Traoré A. 2021. Regulating agricultural intensification: Lessons from West Africa’s rapidly growing pesticide markets. Development Policy Review. 40(1), e12545. 10.1111/dpr.12545
61.Isgren E., Andersson E. 2022. An environmental justice perspective on smallholder pesticide use in Sub-Saharan Africa. Journal of Environment and Development. 30(1), 68–97.
62. Jiang W., 2023. Collection of data on pesticides in maize and tomato in Africa: Protocol for Africa pesticide residue survey study. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology. 110(2),45. 0.1007/s00128-023-03692-x.
63. Kipkoech C., Jaster-Keller J., Gottschalk C., Wesonga J., Maul R. 2023. African traditional use of edible insects and challenges towards the future trends of food and feed. Journal of Insects as Food and Feed. 9(8), 965–988.
64. Lorusso V. 2021. Parasitology and One Health Perspectives on Africa and beyond. Pathogens. 10(11), 1437.
65. Mahmoud A.F.A., Darwish W., Morshd A.M.A., Eldaly E.A., Ikenaka Y., Ishizuka M., 2013. Determination of organochlorine pesticides (OCPs) in edible offals of Egyptian buffalo. Japanese Journal of Veterinary Research. 61, S58–S63