A review of theoretical literature and identification of factors and criteria effective on urban, regional, global and national competitiveness with a meta-analytical approach
Subject Areas :
غلامرضا مرادی
1
,
مهسا دهقانیان
2
,
الهام کاظمی نژاد
3
*
1 - استادیار گروه مهندسی شهرسازی، دانشگاه سلمان فارسی، کازرون، ایران
2 - دانشجوی دکتری شهرسازی، دانشگاه یزد، یزد، ایران
3 - کارشناسی ارشد برنامه ریزی شهری، دانشگاه هنر، تهران
Keywords: Competitiveness, meta-analysis approach, Sandelowski and Baros seven-stage model.,
Abstract :
Introduction: Nowadays, the new concept of GDP of common regions, the purpose of this study is to reveal the concept of urban competitiveness and identify approaches and factors and effective criteria of urban competitiveness in Iran using meta-analysis method. In recent years, the concept of competitiveness has become a common term in urban, regional and national economic analyzes and policies. Globalization and economy based on information knowledge, by removing the border between countries, has gradually reduced the geographical position of territorial competitions from national to regional scale.
Materials and Methods: Descriptive-analytical research, in terms of purpose; It is functional and. In this study, a 7-stage model of Sandlowski and Barros meta-analysis was used and the approach of the present study was content analysis. By collecting the required information and reviewing the titles, content, method and results, 18 articles were selected and the basic criteria of these articles were extracted. Meta-analysis is a type of qualitative study that examines the information and findings extracted from other qualitative studies with a related and similar topic. As a result, the target sample for meta-analysis consists of selected qualitative studies based on their relationship with the research question. Meta-analysis, integrated review of qualitative literature is not the target.
Results and Discussion: The results show that in all competitiveness, the economic factor has the greatest impact and cities, regions and the whole world should strengthen this factor in order to increase competitiveness, which in this regard can be strengthened economic ties inside and outside cities and Regions, promotion and use of inter-regional and urban advantages, improving the quality of the labor market, etc. or in line with social factors in the region, we can mention the promotion of spatial exchange, improving the level of human capital.
Conclusion: Based on the results categorized above, the economic factor has been the most discussed factor in all urban competitiveness respectively. The effective factors and criteria of urban competitiveness include economic, social, environmental, tourism, infrastructural, political institutional and quality of life factors. According to the reviewed articles, the economic factor had the greatest impact on urban competitiveness, and after the economic factor, as it was said before, the social factor It has a significant effect on urban competitiveness and the quality of life is the least influencing factor on urban competitiveness.
Abbasi, M & Mahmoudi Meymand, M & Amini, M & Rahimi Klor, H. (2012). Analysis of Relationships between Factors Affecting Competitiveness Components Using Focal Correlation Technique (Case Study: Headquarters Units of Tehran Insurance Companies), Journal of Transformation Management Research, No. 7, pp:1-20. (In persian)
Abbasi, M.R. & RahimiKoloor, H (2010). The requirements of competitiveness in the sectors of industry and commerce‚ Journal of Political Economic Information, III (IV), Pp 248-255. (In persian)
Afsah Hoseini, F & Zabihi, H & Jahanshahlo,L. (2017). Position, dimensions and realization of urban competitiveness in urban management, Journal of Urban Management Studies, No. 34, pp: 77-91. (In persian)
Afsah Hoseini, F & Zabihi, H & Jahanshahlo,L. (2018). Analysis of urban spatial competitiveness rank of provincial centers of Iran based on principal component analysis (PCA), Journal of Urban Management, Volume 16, Number 49, pp: 387-407. (In persian)
Aghazadeh, H & Stiri, M. & Osanloo, B (2007). Investigating the components affecting the competitiveness of firms in Iran, Journal of Economic Research, pp: 37-58. (In persian)
Aghazadeh, H & Tabibi, M. (2007). The Nature of Competitiveness: A Multidimensional Look, Journal of Spring Management Knowledge, No. 76, pp:139-159. (In persian)
Ali Akbari, I & Akbari, M & Ansari, M & Bustan Ahmadi, V. (2019). Measuring and Analyzing Competitiveness Indicators in West Asian Countries with Emphasis on Iran, Journal of Regional Planning, No. 33, pp:1-14. (In persian)
Ali Akbari, I & Khodadadkashi, F & Comasy, H. (2018). Evaluation of Economic Competitiveness of Iranian Metropolises, Journal of Regional Planning, Volume 8, Number 29, pp:13-26. (In persian)
Ambashta, A.‚ & Momaya, K (2004), Competitiveness of Firms: Review of theory, frameworks and models, Singapore Management Review, Vol 26, No 1‚ First half 2004, Pp 45-61.
Anholt, S (2007). Competitive Identity the New Brand Management for Nations, Cities and Regions. Palgrave Macmillan, Hampshire, Palgrave Macmilan Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010.
Bahmanpour Khalesi, H & Nourian, F. (2017). Identifying regionally competitive sectors in Fars province, Journal of Fine Arts - Architecture and Urban Planning, Volume 22, Number 3, pp:33-44. (In persian)
Begg, I (1999). Cities and competitiveness, Urban Studies. 36(5/6), 795-809.
Begg, I. (Ed.) (2002). Urban Competitiveness: Policies for Dynamic Cities, Bristol: Policy Press.
Bench, Suzanne; & Day, Tina (2010). The user experience of critical care discharge: a metasynthesis of qualitative research. International journal of nursing studies, 47(4), 467-411.
Bristow, G (2005). Everyone’s a ‘winner’: problematising the discourse of regional competitiveness, Journal of Economic Geography, 285-304.
Cagacan Deger, Nese Kumral and Burcu Turka (2000). Competitiveness, Productivity and Growth in European Union and Turkey.
Camagni,R (2002). On the concept of Territorial competitveness: sound of Misleading? Journal of urban studies, vol.39,2395-2411.
Chang, Y. C. Chen, M. H. Lin, Y. P. & GAO, Y. S (2012). Measuring Regional Innovation and Entrepreneurship Capabilities, Journal of the Knowledge Economy, 3(2), 90-108.
Dadashpour, H & Ahmadi, F. (2009). Articles: Regional Competitiveness as a New Approach in Regional Development, Journal of Development Strategy, No. 22, pp. 49-80. (In persian)
Dadashpour, H & Ahmadi, F. (2010). Regional Competitiveness as a New Approach in Regional Development, Yas Strategy Quarterly, No. 22, pp:81-51. (In persian)
Dadashpour, H & Ahmadipour, Z & Moarefi, A. (2014). The Role of Industrial Clusters on Regional Competitiveness (Case Study: Khuzestan Oil, Gas and Petrochemical Equipment Cluster), Journal of Industrial Management (Sanandaj Azad), Volume 10, Number 31, pp:63-72. (In persian)
Dadashpour, H & Dedehjani, M. (2014). Identifying and prioritizing the effective root factors in promoting regional competitiveness (Case study: Kurdistan Province), Regional Planning Quarterly, Fifth Year, No. 19, pp:42-27. (In persian)
Dc (2001). Destination competitiveness: development of a model with application to Australia and the republic of korea. An Australian Govt report, October.
Dick, M. (2013). Urban Management from Theory to Practice, Administration of Cities in Developing Countries, Translated by Gholamreza Kazemian and Hamed Rastegar, Tehran, Tisa (Original Language Publishing Date, 2006).
Dijkstra, L. Annoni, P. & Kozovska, K (2011). A new regional competitiveness index: Theory, methods and findings. European Commission.
Divandari A. Aghazadeh, H. & Nikoukar, G. H (2009). Market orientation and business Competitiveness Identity-Based Case Study: Urmia City, Scientific Quarterly of Strategic Studies of Public Policy, Volume 9, Number 32, pp:128-155. (In persian)
Doloreux,D.Shearmur,R.Figueiredo,D.(2016).Québec’CoastalMaritimeCluster: Its Impact on.
Eskandari, M & Pile var, A & Rezaei nasab, A. (2017). Assessment of Affective Factors on The Regional Competitiveness Towards Sustainable Development (Case study: North Khorasan Province), Journal of Geography and Urban-Regional Planning, Vol 7, No 24, PP: 57-70. (In persian)
Esko Lange, F (2009). Urban governance, an essential determinant of city development. World vision institute for research and development, Bonn: University of Bonn.
Gorbani, R & Kazemi Zad, Sh. (2019). An Analysis of the Factors Affecting Urban Competitiveness Based on Scenario Writing Method (Case Study: Tabriz), Quarterly Journal of Geography and Urban-Regional Planning, Volume 9, Number 30, pp:19-38. (In persian)
Hall GM. (2003). How to write a paper. 3th ed. London: BMJ publishing group. p.92-98.
Hong, Jacky F.L (2015). knowledge development through co-opetition. Journal of world Business, 50(2015) 769-780.in the field of Islamic management with a meta-integrated approach, Public Management Perspective, pp:9-24.
Jahnny, Siavash (2011). Explaining and analyzing competitiveness in the countries under the document of Iran's vision and priorities in promoting competitiveness, Journal of Planning and Budget, No. 113, pp: 147-176. (In persian)
Jamali, F & Rostaie, Sh & Y, M. (2018). Evaluation of the causal model of criteria affecting urban competitiveness with fuzzy Dimtel approach, Journal of Urban Economics and Management, Year 6, No. 23, pp:33-35. (In persian)
Johnny, S. (2011). Factors Affecting Competitiveness in Iran and Southwest Asian Countries, Journal of Economic Research and Policy, No. 58, pp. 159-188.
Kargari Samani, A & Kurdish, A & Khodadad Hosseini, S.H & Mousavi Shafaei, S M. (2013). The Impact of Urban Competitiveness on National Competitiveness, Business Management Perspectives, No. 53, pp:123-139. (In persian)
Khazraei Sholayifar, M & Karkabadi, Z & Kamyabi, S. (2019). Evaluation of strategies to increase the competitiveness of Iranian metropolises based on Coopetition strategy Case study: Tehran, Mashhad, Tabriz, Ahvaz and Zahedan, Journal of Geographical Sciences, No. 30, pp:102-119. (In persian)
Khazraei Sholayifar, M & Karkabadi, Z. (2018). Investigating the Factors Affecting Urban Competitiveness Based on Saez. (In persian)
Kostianinen, J (2002). learning and the ba in development network of an urban region, European planning studies 10. (In persian)
Kresl, P.K (2007). planning cities for the future: the successes and failures of urban economic strategies in Europe, Edward elgar publishing,171.
Krugman, P (2005). Second winds for industrial regions? In D. Coyle, W. Alexander, & B. Ashcroft, New Wealth for Old Nations.
Laszlo S. & Ulbert, J (2009). The examination of the competitiveness in the hungarian sme sector: a firm level analysis. Faculty of business and economics, university of pecs.
Lengyel, I (2007). Economic growth and competitiveness of Hungarian regions, 2nd Central European Conference in Regional Science, 587-608.
Lengyel, I (2009). Bottom-up Regional Economic Development: Competition, Competitiveness and Clusters, In Z. Bajmócy, I. Lengyel, & (eds), Regional Competitiveness, Innovation and Environment (pp. 13-38, JATEPress), Szeged.
Lengyel, I (2016). Competitiveness of Metropolitan Regions in Visegrad Counties. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 223, 357–362.
Man, T. W. Y. Lau, T. & Chan, K. F (2002). The competitiveness of small and medium enterprises: a conceptualization with focus on entrepreneurial competencies. Journal of Business Venturing, 17, 123-142.
Martin, R. L (2004). A study on the factors of regional competitiveness. Cambridge: University of Cambridge.
Mirzaei, H. (2014). Planning based on regional planning (for the realization of resistance economy), Guilan Management and Planning Organization, Training and Research Center for Development and Futurism. (In persian)
Molaei, A. (2019). Analysis of Urban and Regional Competitiveness Capabilities (Case Study of Tabriz), Journal of Spatial Planning (Geography), No. 35, pp:137-109. (In persian)
Molaei, A. (2019). Recognizing the Capacities of Urban and Regional pattern of regional development through activity clusters in Tehran province with emphasis on competitiveness, Land Management Journal, No. 21, pp:235-262. (In persian)
Morphet, Janice (2008). Modern local government, London, Sage. performance in iran. Journal of Management, I, 39-54 (In persian).
Mushfeghi, V & Mohammadi, H. (2020). Adaptability Analysis of Creative and Competitive Areas of Iran, Journal of Land Management, No. 23, pp:595-620. (In persian)
Nazmfar, H & Eshghi Chaharborj, A & Alawi, S. (2014). Spatial Analysis of Competitiveness of Urban Settlements in Iranian Provinces, Journal of Spatial Planning, Volume 7, Number 24, pp:153-167. (In persian)
Nazmfar, Hussein; Eshghi Chaharborj, Ali; Alawi, S. (2016). Investigating the Economic Competitiveness of Iranian Cities, Quarterly Journal of Urban Economics and Management, pp:23-38. (In persian)
Porter, M. E (1990). The competitive advantage of nations. The free press: New York.
Poursafavi, S.M & Jafari, Sh. (2017). Evaluation of regional competitiveness in functional urban areas of Mazandaran province using cluster analysis, Journal of Human Geography Research, Volume 49, Number 4, pp:807-820. (In persian)
Rabieh, M & Khajoui, M. (2012). Explaining Competitiveness Strategies in Tehran, Journal of Strategic Management Studies, Volume 4, Number 15, pp:37-56. (In persian)
Richard, H. (2015). Sustainability and competitiveness in Australian cities. University of Canberra.
Ron Martin, James,S (2008) The theoretical bases of urban competitiveness: does proximity matter? Department of Geography. Cambridge university. Pp 333-351.
Sabuni, S & Behzadfar, M & Saremi, H. (2019). Prioritization of factors affecting the competitiveness of Parand city, Journal of Urban and Rural Management, No. 56, pp:161-143. (In persian)
Sabuni, S & Behzadfar, M & Saremi, H. (2020). Competitiveness of New Cities (Study Sample: Parand New City), Scientific Modeling Economic Quarterly, Volume 14, Number 52, pp:114-121. (In persian)
Saleh Nejad, S.A & Darwish, H & Ahmadi, A.A & Forouzandeh, L. (2018). Transformation of Staff Dignity Studies in Iran, Journal of Human Resource Management Research, Volume 10, Number 2 (32), pp:75-96. (In persian)
Sandelowski, Margarete; & Barroso, Julie (2007) Handbook for synthesizing qualitative research. New York and London: Springer.
Sasanpour, F & Hatami, A & Babaei, Sh. (2017). Competitiveness analysis of the quality of life in Tehran metropolis at the global level, Journal of Geography, No. 55, pp:398-377. (In persian)
Serrano, F.A (2003) City Competitiveness and Attractiveness: A New Approach to Evaluate Economic Development in Mexican Cities. (Doctoral dissertation). University of Glasgow, United Kingdom. Retrieved from http://theses.gla.ac.uk/982/1/2003 serranophd.pdf.
Sharifi, Sh & Norouzi, H & Mania, E. (2014). Evaluation of urban tourism with emphasis on Tourism infrastructure development and urban competitiveness; Case study: Tehran metropolis, Journal of Urban Management, No. 39, pp:369-392. (In persian)
Sharifzadegan, M & Nedayi Tusi, S. (2014). Spatial Development Framework of Regional Competitiveness in Iran, Case Study: 30 Provinces, Journal of Fine Arts - Architecture and Urban Planning, Volume 20, Number 3, pp:5-20. (In persian)
Sharifzadegan, M & Nedayi Tusi, S. (2015). Assessing the appropriateness of using the components of regional development competitiveness success in Iran, Journal of Human Geography Research, Volume 48, Number 1, pp:124-105. (In persian)
Shirmohammadi, Sh & Matlabi, Q & Haydari, Sh. (2014). A Reading of the Status and Role of Architectural Branding on Urban Competitiveness in Global Cities, Urban Management, No. 40, pp:206-177. (In persian)
Shorts, J & Hyun Kim, J. (2004). Globalization and the City, translated by Ahmad Poor Ahmad, and Shayan (official) Rastami, Academic Jihad, Date of Publication of the Original Language 1999.
Sinkiene, J (2009) Copmpetitivenessrji n lithuania,vifa olitica i esoctors of city i administravima 29:47-53.
Sohrabi, B & Azami, Amirvizdani, H. (2011). Pathology of researches conducted Proposed Model Based on the Concept of Coopetition (Case Study: Tehran), Journal of New Attitudes in Human Geography, No. 41, pp:111-130. (In persian)
Storper, M (1997) the regional world:territorial development in a global economy,guilford press new York.
Tabatabai, S & Saeedeh Zarabadi, Z & Ziari, Y & Majidi, H. (2018). Explaining the pattern of regional development through activity clusters in Tehran province with emphasis on competitiveness, Land Management Journal, Volume 11, Number 2 (21 consecutive), pp. 235 – 262. (In persian)
Taylor, P (2004). Regional competitiveness: An Elusive yet key concept. Regional studies, VOL. 38.9, pp. 991 – 999.
Thornley, A (1999). urban planning and competitive advantage.
Turk, I (2004). Cities, Regions and Competitiveness. Regional Studies, Vol 38, pp1069-1083.
Wang, Y. Niue, W (2008). Study on the City-scale Network Competitiveness. Urban Development Studies,2008,15(2):99-103.
Webster, D. and Muller, L (2000) Urban competitiveness assessment in developing country urban regions the road forward, paper prepared for urban group. INFUD, Washington D.C.
Yaghfori, H & Eskandari Thani, M & Akbari, F. (2014). The role of historical context in promoting the components of urban competitiveness studied: Birjand, Journal of Spatial Planning (Geography), No. 26, pp:84-63. (In persian)