Investigating the Long-term effect of dust on Health in order to prevent Its Impacts in Future Planning Case Study: Khuzestan Province

Subject Areas : Regional Planning

parisa ahadi ¹ , shahriar Khaledi ² , Mahmoud Ahmadi ³

1 - Faculty of Earth Sciences,Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran
2 - Professor of Climatology in Shahid Beheshti University, Faculty of Earth Sciences,Tehran, Iran
3 - Associate Professor of Climatology in Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran

Received: 2019-10-29 Accepted : 2020-01-10 Published : 2020-10-22

Keywords: Khuzestan, Dust, PLS, cardiopulmonary mortality, ANOVA,

Abstract :

         According to the studies conducted in this field exposure to dust particles can increase the heart disease and respiratory problems, particularly among vulnerable groups including children and the elderly. Being located in the dust belt of West Asian region, Khuzestan province in southwestern Iran has been facing severe dust problems since 2001. According to the necessity to further investigate the effects of this phenomenon, the present study was conducted to investigate the statistical relationship between the dust level and cardiopulmonary mortality in Khuzestan province during 2006-2016. The research results, conducted using Pearson Correlation test, one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Variance-Based Structural Equations (PLS), showed that there is a positive and significant relationship between dust and cardiopulmonary mortality. Also, dust and cardiac mortality showed the highest correlation with eight months delay. According to the ANOVA test results, all significant at 0.01 level, under the same dusty conditions, there is a significant difference between cardiopulmonary mortality in age groups below 10 and over 65 years with other groups. According to the path coefficient values and t-statistic calculated by structural equation method, it can be found that men are more vulnerable to dust than women. It is predicted that a 1% increase in monthly dust can cause a 0.31% and 0.28% increase in cardiac mortality and also a 0.41% and 0.30% increase in respiratory mortality in vulnerable and less vulnerable groups, respectively. These findings indicate the need for urgent planning to address the dust problem, as well as training and culturalization in dealing with this dangerous phenomenon. Extended abstract Introduction:          Dust phenomena, as one of the major environmental concerns caused by human interference and unreasonable use of natural resources, has been prevalent in recent years. Dust refers to a mass of sedimentary solid particles smaller than 50 microns in diameter that disperses into the atmosphere, resulting in a 1-2 km decrease in horizontal view. Dust storms are events which naturally occur in arid and semi-arid areas, especially in subtropical latitudes. One of the most known sources of dust is the west of Asia, including Arabian Peninsula, Syria, Iraq, and southwest of Iran. Studies suggests that different sectors different sectors, including agriculture, civil infrastructure, industry, economy, tourism, and healthcare can be affected by the dust phenomenon. According to new findings, dust particles are more dangerous to public health compared to what was previously thought. Infiltration of these particles into the airbags by breathing polluted air increases the likelihood of respiratory disorders, cardiovascular disorders, eye inflammation, skin rashes, meningococcal meningitis, hepatic and cerebral necrosis, and abortion. In Iran, 29 provinces have been affected by the dust phenomenon in recent years. Being located in the dust belt in the West Asian region, Khuzestan province in southwestern Iran has been facing severe dust problems since 2001. Also, a 2011 World Health Organization report identifies Ahwaz as the world's most polluted city in terms of particles with an annual average of 372 micrograms per cubic meter PM10. Hence, more attention needs to be paid by researchers to the effects of this phenomenon in the field of health. Accordingly, the present study was conducted to investigate the statistical relationship between the dust events and cardiopulmonary mortality by sex and in sensitive and non-sensitive age groups in Khuzestan province during 2006-2016. Methodology:       Two categories of data were used for the purpose of this research: A)     Dust data: including monitoring and horizontal view codes in Khuzestan province for the period of 2004-2016 which were obtained hourly from the Meteorological Organization and filtered and separated based on eleven dust codes of World Meteorological Organization (including 06, 07, 08, 09, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, and 98). Then, the frequency of dust events was classified on a monthly scale based on the data available in three main groups including local dust, trans-local dust and dust storms. B)     Mortality data related to Khuzestan province during the period of 2004-2016, collected monthly from the National Organization for Civil Registration. The cardiac and respiratory mortality data were categorized into two groups of vulnerable (age group lower than 10 years and upper than 60 years old) and less vulnerable. Then, they were studied for each female and male groups, separately. C)       The Pearson Correlation test was used to reveal the relationship between monthly dust data and cardiopulmonary mortality. The One-Way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was used to compare the effect of dust between the two vulnerable and less vulnerable groups. Also according to the research structure, which is based on the formative model, the variance-based structural equation techniques(Partial Least Square), including indices unidimensionality, Structural Reliability, Convergent Validity,  coefficient of determination R2, Cohen effect size (F2) and path coefficient were used. Results and discussion:           According to the results of correlation test, dust and respiratory mortality have a strong (r = 0.698) and significant (at 99% confidence level) correlation. Respiratory mortality is higher in the first months after a dust storm, but its correlation gradually declines. The correlation between cardiac mortality in the early months after the dust event is weak, but has a strong and significant correlation after a delay of more than 6 months, with the highest correlation of r = .551 in 99% confidence level after an eight-month delay. According to the results of one-way analysis of variance between vulnerable and less vulnerable groups, inter-group dispersion was higher than intra-group dispersion and as a result, there was a significant difference between vulnerable and less vulnerable groups when facing with dust. These results are significant at 99% confidence level. According to the results of variance-based structural equations (PLS), all factor loadings are greater than 0.4 and, therefore, the indices unidimensionality is confirmed. Structural reliability and convergent validity coefficients for all variables are greater than 0.6 and 0.5, respectively, and as a result, the measurement pattern is confirmed. Based on the path coefficient values ​​and t-statistic calculated in the model for the vulnerable groups, all path coefficients were positive and greater than 0.1 for all variables except for female cardiac mortality. Accordingly, all path coefficients, except for the dust path coefficient and female cardiac mortality, have a clear effect at the 5% significance level, and the sign of all path coefficients is positive with the values ​​more than 0.1, except for dust and female cardiopulmonary mortality in the less vulnerable groups. Also, the t-statistic is greater than 1.96 for all variables except for female cardiopulmonary mortality. Conclusion           According to the results, there is a positive and significant relationship between dust and cardiopulmonary mortality. Also, dust and cardiac mortality showed the highest correlation with eight months delay. The results also show that there is a significant difference between cardiopulmonary mortality in age groups below 10 and over 65 years with other groups in the same dusty conditions. Also, in similar situations, men are more vulnerable to dust than women, and it is predicted that a 1% increase in monthly dust can cause a 0.31% and 0.28% increase in cardiac mortality and also a 0.41% and 0.30% increase in respiratory mortality in vulnerable and less vulnerable groups, respectively in Khuzestan province. These findings indicate the need for urgent planning to address the dust problem, as well as training and culturalization in dealing with this dangerous phenomenon.

References:

1. Achilleos, S, Al-Ozairi, E, Alahmad, B, Garshick, E, Neophytou, A. M., Bouhamra, W & Koutrakis, P (2019): Acute effects of air pollution on mortality: A 17-year analysis in Kuwait. Environment international, 126, pp: 476-483.


2. Al-Hemoud. A, Al-Dousari.A, Al-Shatti.A, Al-Khayat. A, Behbehani. W, & Malak, M. (2018): Health impact assessment associated with exposure to PM10 and dust storms in Kuwait. Atmosphere, 9(1), pp: 1- 6.


3. Alijani, B (2013): Iranian Climate, Payam Noor University Press, Twelfth Edition, Tehran.


4. Amani.J ,Himan.KH ,Hojat .M (2012): Introduction to Structural Equation Modeling Using Partial Least Squares (PLS-PM) and its Applications in Behavioral Research ,Journal of Psychological Knowledge, 1(1)pp: 41-51.


5. Arami, S.A, Onagh.A, Mohammadiyan.A, Akbari .M, Zarasvandi.A (2018): Analysis of dust hazard studies in the southwest of Iran in the 22-Year Period 1996-2017. Journal of Spatial Analysis of Environmental Hazards, 1(5), pp: 39-66


6. Barati. J (2019): Investigating the Regional convergence of tourism and the role of tourism infrastructure in Iranian Provinces. Journal of Regional Planning, 35(9), pp: 1-12


7. Boloorani, A. D, Nabavi, S. O, Azizi, R, & Bahrami. H (2013): Characterization of dust storm sources in western Iran using a synthetic approach. In Advances in meteorology, climatology and atmospheric physics, Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, pp: 415-420.


8. Chien, L. C, Yang, C. H, & Yu, H. L (2012): Estimated effects of Asian dust storms on spatiotemporal distributions of clinic visits for respiratory diseases in Taipei children (Taiwan). Environmental health perspectives, 120(8), pp: 1215-1220


9. De Longueville, F, Hountondji, Y. C, Henry, S, & Ozer, P (2010): What do we know about effects of desert dust on air quality and human health in West Africa compared to other regions, Science of the Total Environment, 409(1), pp: 1-8.


10. Delangizan.S, Gafari. Z (2012): Investigation of the effect of aerosol on hospitalization and mortality rate of cardiac and respiratory patients (case study: Kermanshah), first six months of 2010-2011, Journal of Health and Environment. 1(6), pp: 65-76


11. Allahyari. S, Molaei Hashjin.N, Amari T (2019): Explaining the effects of relocation of rural settlements in the dams of Khuzestan with emphasis on human risks, Regional Planning Research Journal, 35(9), pp: 27-38


12. Gerivandi, H, Lashkaripour, G. R, Ghafoori, M, & Jalali, N (2011):The source of dust storm in Iran (a case study based on geological information and rainfall data).Journal of Earth and Environmental Sciences, 6, pp: 297-308


13. Goudarzi, G, Shirmardi, M, Naimabadi, A, Ghadiri, A, & Sajedifar, J (2019): Chemical and organic characteristics of PM2. 5 particles and their in-vitro cytotoxic effects on lung cells: The Middle East dust storms in Ahvaz, Iran. Science of the Total Environment, 655, pp: 434-445.


14. Goudie, A. S (2014). Desert dust and human health disorders. Environment international, 63, pp:  101-113.


15. Gross, J.E, Carlos, W.G, Dela Cruz, C.S, Harber, P, & Jamil, S (2018): Sand and dust storms: Acute exposure and threats to respiratory health. American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine, 198(7), pp: 13-20


16. Iran Statistics Center (2016): Report of detailed results of Khuzestan population and housing census, 2006-2016.


17. Jin, Q, Wei, J, & Yang, Z. L (2014): Positive response of Indian summer rainfall to Middle East dust. Geophysical Research Letters, 41(11), pp: 68-74.


18. Kang, J.H, Keller, J. J, Chen, C.S, & Lin, H. C (2012): Asian dust storm events are associated with an acute increase in pneumonia hospitalization. Annals of epidemiology, 22(4), pp: 257-263.


19. Karimi, M, Yazdani, M. H, & Naderi, A (2013): The effect of 120-day winds on the safety of Sistan region. Geography and Environmental Planning, 24(2), pp: 25-27


20. Khaledi.K (2013): Economic Impacts of dust storms on Iran's western provinces, Economic Modeling, 7(23), PP: 105-135.


21. Khaniabadi, Y. O, Daryanoosh, S. M, Amrane, A, Polosa, R, Hopke, P. K, Goudarzi, G, & Armin, H (2017): Impact of Middle Eastern Dust storms on human health. Atmospheric pollution research, 8(4), pp: 606-613.


22. Kim, K.H, Kabir, E, & Kabir, S (2015): Human health impact of airborne particulate matter. Environment international, 74, pp: 136-143.


23. Mesbahzadeh, T, Alipour N (2018): Evaluating the impact of drought on the frequency of dust occurrence using SPI, PNI and ZSI indices, Natural Resources, 2(71), pp:505-515


24. Mousavi, Z, OmIdian.M, Mapar, M, Yaghoubi, R. Shohani. S (2013): Comparison of the number of referees with skin disarders to dermatologic clinics before and after dust stoum in Ahvaz, Jientashapir, 3(4), pp: 103-113


25. Nourizadeh.H, Bahrami.H (2015): Investigation of the relationship between aerosol concentration with surface moisture and soil particle size distribution and the use of removable wind erosion simulator in west desert areas in Khuzestan province, Journal of Geographical Exploration of Desert Areas, 5(1), pp: 167-183.


26. Reed, L, & Nugent, K (2018): The health effects of dust storms in the Southwest United States. The Southwest Respiratory and Critical Care Chronicles, 6(22), pp: 42-46.


27. Sabzalipour, S, Nourzadeh Haddad, M, Zallaghi,E (2016): A Survey of Cardiovascular and Respiratory Diseases Attributable to PM10 pollutant in the western Half of Iran (Ahwaz, Bushehr and Kermanshah Provinces) with Use of AIRQ Model. Der Pharmacia Letter. 8 (11), pp: 17-23


28. Sadeghi, H, Khaksar.S (2014): Short Term Forecasting of Ahwaz Suspended Particle Contamination Using Neural Networks, Journal of Environmental Research, 9(5), pp: 177-186


29. Schweitzer, M.D, Calzadilla, A. S, Salamo, O, Sharifi, A, Kumar, N, Holt, G (2018): Lung health in era of climate change and dust storms. Environmental research, 163, pp: 36-42


30. Shahsavani, A, Yarahmadi, M, Jafarzadeh,N, Naeemabadi, A, Mahmoudian, M.A , Saki.H, Solati, M.H, Soleymani.Z,Nadafi. K (2010): The Effects of Dust Storms on Health and the Environment. Journal of North Khorasan University of Medical Sciences, 4(2).pp:45-56


31. Shahsavani, A., Tobías, A., Querol, X., Stafoggia, M., Abdolshahnejad, M., Mayvaneh, F., & Namvar, Z. (2020): Short-term effects of particulate matter during desert and non-desert dust days on mortality in Iran. Environment international, 134, 105299.


32. Teng, J. C. Y, Chan, Y. S, Peng, Y. I, & Liu, T. C (2016): Influence of A sian dust storms on daily acute myocardial infarction hospital admissions. Public Health Nursing, 33(2), pp: 118-128.


33. Vali. A, Roustaei.F (2016): Evaluation of wind erosion trends in central Iran using dust storm index in the last fifty years. Journal of Soil and Water Sciences, 4(21), pp: 139-200.


34. Wang, Y. C, & Lin, Y. K (2015):  Mortality associated with particulate concentration and Asian dust storms in Metropolitan Taipei. Atmospheric Environment, 117, pp: 32-40.


35. Yu, H. L, & Chien, L. C (2016): Short-term population-based non-linear concentration–response associations between fine particulate matter and respiratory diseases in Taipei (Taiwan): a spatiotemporal analysis. Journal of Exposure Science and Environmental Epidemiology, 26(2), pp: 180- 197.


36. Zallaghi, E, Goudarzi, G, Geravandi, S, & Mohammadi, M. J (2014): Epidemiological indexes attributed to particulates with less than 10 micrometers in the air of Ahvaz City during 2010 to 2013. Health Scope, 3(4), pp: 1-15


37. Zarasvandi. A, Heydari. M (2015) Iranian dust storms from geological Perspective, Shahid Chamran University Press, Second Edition, Ahvaz.