Two modes of assessment: the case of academicians' writing

Subject Areas : Journal of Teaching English Language Studies

Siroos  Arefi Rad ¹ (Islamic Azad University, Takestan Branch)

Received: 2012-11-19 Accepted : 2012-12-22 Published : 2013-02-01

Keywords: writing skill, error, self-assessment, linguistic problems, expert- assessment,

Abstract :

This study attempted to investigate writing problems and the relationship between expert-assessment and self-assessment of writing problems. Participants were thirty four non-English faculty members of Tehran and Guilan universities. The instruments were writing an essay on the topic "What teaching strategies do you use in your classes?" in twenty five lines and filling the questionnaire of writing problems including fourteen items (word choice, verb form, missing subject, verb tense, preposition, word order, article, plural "s", spelling, subject-verb agreement, missing verb, passive voice, conditional sentences, and capitalization).The researcher investigated these fourteen areas both in their essays and their questionnaires of self-assessment. The data analysis showed there was no positive relationship between expert-assessment and self-assessment and the participants underestimated themselves in the questionnaire. Furthermore, the writing problems based on expert-assessment were: verb form, word choice, article, preposition, plural "s", capitalization, spelling, subject-verb agreement, word order, passive voice, verb tense, missing subject, missing verb, and conditional sentences. The findings revealed the main factors causing these problems are L1 interference, lack of grammar knowledge, vocabulary weakness, and poor spelling. The participants can write accurately if they learn basic grammar, increase vocabulary, ways of error correction, and awareness of L1 interference.

References:

Al-Fraidan, A. (2005). Direct and indirect assessment of writing with special reference 

     to the department of foreign languages at King Fasial university in Saudia

     Arabia. Unpublished master’s thesis, University of Essex, England.

Al- Hazmi, S, H, & Scholfield, Ph. (2007). Enforced revision with checklist and peer

     feedback in EFL writing: The example of Saudi university students. Scientific

    Journal of King  Faisal University, 8(3), 237-267.

Al-Jarf, R.. (2008). Sources of spelling errors in EFL Arab college students. Retrieved   

     November 15, 2008, from  http://faculty. ksu.edu.sa/aljarf/Publications/ Papers     

     /Sources%20of%20spelling %Errors %20 in%20EFL%20College%20Students%20-

     %20paper.pdf.

______ . (2009). Phonological and orthographical problems in EFL college spellers. 

     Proceedins of TELLIS Conference, Azad Izlamic University, Rudehen, Iran.

     Retrieved August 15, 2010, from http://repository.ksu.edu.sa/jspui/ handle/ 

     123456789/5618.pdf

______. (2010). Spelling error corpora in EFL. Sino-US English Teaching, 7(1), 1-15.

Allen, V.F. (1983). Techniques in teaching vocabulary. Oxford: Oxford University 

     Press.

Al-Mezeini, H, S. (2009). Does teaching spelling rules make a difference?. Retrieved

     July 8, 2011, from www.moe.gov.om/portal/sitesbuilder/ Sites/Arabic/ IPS/ Importa/ 

     tesol/3.

Al-Yahyai, Sh. Kh. (2004). Spelling difficulties in grade 4. Retrieved May 9, 2010,

      From www.moe.gov.om/portal/site builder/sites/Eps/Arabic/IPS/Importa /tesol/3/5. 

      pdf

Amo, E., & Jareno, F. (2011). Self, peer, and teacher assessment as academic learning 

      methods. Research Journal of International Studies, 18, 41-47.

Han, N., Chodorow, M., & Leacock, C. (2006). Detecting errors in English article

     usage by non-native speakers. Natural Language Engineering, 12(2), 115-129.

Hashemi, M. R., Khodadadi, E., & Yazdanmehr, E. (2009), Learners’ evaluation of EFL

      writing tasks in Iran’s ESOL exam preparation courses. Journal of English teaching

      and learning, 212, 76-106.    

Hayati, A. M., & Kalanzadeh, Gh. (1998). A contrastive study of English and Persian 

      linking verb comprehension. Paper presented at the university of Shahid Chamran,

      Ahvaz, Iran. Retrieved September 18, 2011, from http://bibliotecavirtualut.suagm. 

      edu/glossa2/journal/dec2008/A%20Contrastive%20Study%20of%20 english.pdf.      

Hedge, T. (2005). Writing. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Heidari, M. (2008). Classroom based evaluation. Roshd FLT, 22(86), 18-24.

Hermet, M., & Desilets, A. (2009). Using first and second language models to correct 

     prepositions errors in second language authoring. Proceedings of the 22^nd

     International Conference on Computational Linguistics, (PP. 149-152).

Koffler, S. L. (1984). Assessing students’ writing skills: A composition of direct &

     indirect methods. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American educational 

     research association. Retrieved October 12, 2011, from www.eric.ed.gov/ ERICWeb 

     Portal/recordDetail?accno=ED242771.

Lado, R. (1957). Linguistics across cultures. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

Llach, M. P. A. (2005). The relationship of lexical errors and their types to the quality

     of ESL composition: an Empirical study . Porta Linguarum, 3, 45-57.        

Lott, D. (1983). Analysing and counteracting interference errors. ELT Journal, 37(3), 

     256-261.

Lyon, J. (1981). Language and linguistics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

MacArthur, F. (1993). EFL writing tasks within a university degree in English. Revista 

      Alicantina de Estudios Ingleses, 6, 99-107.

Muangsamai, P. (2003). EFL learning / writing development in the internet

      Environment: A case study from pre-medical students' perspectives. Unpublished 

     doctoral dissertation, State University of Ohio-USA.

Murphy, S. (2008). Some consequences of writing assessment. In A. Havnes & L.

     McDowell (Eds.), Balancing dilemmas in assessment and learning in contemporary

     education. Routledge: London, England.

Nicol, D. J., & Macfarlane-Dick, B. (2006). Formative assessment and self-regulated 

      learning: A model and seven principles of good feedback practice. Studies in Higher 

      Education, 31(12), 199-218.

Noonan, B., & Duncan, C. R. (2005). Peer and self-assessment in highschools.

      Partial Assessment Research & Evaluation, 10(17), 1-8.

Noor, C. A. (2009). Analysis of linguistic problems in composing English paragraph 

      faced by students of writing 3 classes of English department at university of

      Muhammadiyah Malange. Unpublished master’s thesis, University of 

     Muhammadiyah Malang, Indonesia.

O’Farrell, C. (2004). Enhancing student learning through assessment. Paper presented

      at the university of Dublin, Trinity college, Ireland. Retrieved September 12, 2011,

      from http:// www.learningandteaching.dit.ie.documents/assessmenttoolkitv41f.pdf.

Rimka, M. (2004). Strategies for improving the writing process implications for design

     of support tools. Unpublished master’s thesis, University of Stockholm, Sweden.

Ross, J. A. (2006). The reliability, validity, and utility of self-assessment. Practical 

      Assessment, Research & Evaluation, 11(10), 1-13.

Sadler, D. R. (1998). Formative assessment: Revising the territory. Assessment in 

     Education, 5(1), 77-84.

 Schweers, C. W. (1999). He use square shirt: First language transfer in the writing

     of Hispanic ESL learners. Milenio: Revista de Artes y Ciencios, 3, 140-175.

Shaw , P,.& Liu, E. T. (1998). What develops in the development of second language

      writing? Applied linguistics, 19(2), 225-254.

Shen, M. Y. (2009). Reading-writing connection for EFL college learners’ literacy

     development. Asian EFL Journal, 11(5), 87-106.

Srimavin, W., & Darasawang. P. (2004). Developing self-assessment through journal

      writing. Proceedings of the Independent Learning Conference 2003. Retrieved

      November 15, 2011, form http://www.independentlearning.org/ila03/ila03-

     srimavin-and-pornapit.pdf.

Stapa, S. H., & Izahar, M. M. (2010). Analysis of errors in subject-verb agreement

     among Malaysian ESL learners. 3L The Shoutheast Asian Journal of English

     Lanaguage Studies, 16(1), 56-73.

Sundstrom, A. (2005). Self-assessment of knowledge and abilities- a literature study.

     Paper presented at the university of Umea, Sweden. Retrieved October 14, 2011,

     from www.edusci.umu.se/digitalAssets/60/60577_em541.pdf

Surgenor, P. (2010). Summative and formative assessment. Retrieved August 16, 2011, 

     from www.ucd.ie/t4cms/ucdlt0029.pdf

Tabibi, K. ( 2008). English grammar. Tehran: Pouran-e-Pazhoohesh.

Tahaineh, Y. Sh. (2010). Arab EFL university students’ errors in the use of preposition.  

     MJAL, 2(1), 76-112.

Tamjid, N. H., & Birjandi, P. (2011). Fostering learner autonomy through self- and

      peer-assessment. International Journal of Academic Research, 13(5), 245-254.

White, E. M. (1994). Issues and problems in writing assessment. Assessing in Writing, 

     1(1), 11-27.

Wu, W. (2006). Language transfer in Chinese EFL writing. Sino-US English Teaching, 

     3(5), 1-6.     

Yan, Y. (2010). Towards an eclectic framework for teaching EFL writing in a Chinese 

     text. US-China Education Review, 7(3), 29-33.

Yang, J., Ch., Ko, H. W., & Chung, I. L. (2005). Web-based interactive writing

      environment: Development and evaluation. Educational Technology and Society,

     8(2), 214-222.

Yazdanmehr, E. (2009). Learners’ evaluation of EFL writing tasks in Iran’s ESOL exam 

     preparation courses. Journal of English Language Teaching and Learning, 212, 76-

     106.

Yu-wen, W. (2007). Evaluating writing strategies instruction in a Chinese EFL

     university context. Sino-US English Teaching, 4(2), 11-17.

Yue, V. W. Y. (2010). Investigating ESL students’ grammar in writing. US-China

     foreign Language, 8(1), 22-31.