ارزیابی سیاستگذاری های شورای اسلامی شهرها در توسعه کالبدی- فضایی محیطهای شهری (نمونه موردی: شهر شیراز)

محورهای موضوعی : سیاستگذاری شهری

عبدالجلیل شریفی ¹ , محمد علی شهریاری ² , نفیسه واعظ ³

1 - گروه علوم سیاسی، واحد شهرضا، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، شهرضا، ایران
2 - گروه علوم سیاسی، واحد بوشهر، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، بوشهر، ایران
3 - گروه علوم سیاسی ، واحد شهرضا، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، شهرضا، ایران

تاریخ دریافت : 1402/01/18 تاریخ پذیرش : 1402/05/01 تاریخ انتشار : 1402/08/01

کلید واژه: توسعه پایدار, شهرسازی و معماری, شورای اسلامی شهر شیراز, سیاستگذاری شهری,

چکیده مقاله :

شوراها به عنوان نهادی که مشروعیت و مقبولیت خود را از مردم می‌گیرند، می‌توانند نقش مهمی را بر اثر بخشی سیاست‌گذاری‌های شهری داشته باشند. بخشی از این سیاستگذاری در حوزه کالبد شهر به ویژه حوزه شهرسازی و معماری است. تحقیق حاضر با هدف ارزیابی سیاستگذاری های شهری شورای اسلامی شهر شیراز در حوزه شهرسازی و معماری از منظر توسعه پایدار انجام شده است. روش تحقیق توصیفی- پیمایشی با استفاده از ابزار پرسشنامه است. جامعه‌ی آماری این پژوهش مدیران و سرپرستان بخش‌های مختلف شهرداری شیراز (خبرگان اجرایی) و اساتید دانشگاهی آشنا به موضوع تحقیق (خبرگان دانشگاهی) بوده است. حجم نمونه از طریق جدول مورگان 113 نفر محاسبه شد. روایی و پایایی بازار پرسش نامه تایید شد. یافته های تحقیق نشان داد که برای ارزیابی سیاستگذاری های شهری شورای اسلامی، می توان از الگوی مراحل هاگوود و گان (1984) مشتمل بر 5 بعد تشخیص مسایل،تدوین سیاست،تصمیم گیری،اجرای سیاست و ارزشیابی سیاست بهره گرفت که برای سنجش ابعاد مزبور از 19 مولفه بنا به نظر خبرگان دانشگاهی و اجرایی حوزه شهری استفاده گردید. نتایج نشان داد در سطح کمتر از 05/0، ابعاد و مولفه های مرتبط با سیاستگذاری شهری معنادار بوده اند. جهت معناداری نشان داد که وضعیت ابعاد و مولفه های سیاستگذاری شورای اسلامی، متوسط ارزیابی می شود. نتیجه آزمون فریدمن جهت رتبه بندی ابعاد و مولفه های سیاستگذاری نشان داد که در میان ابعاد، بعد تشخیص مسائل و در میان مولفه ها نیز میزان تفویض قدرت و منابع به اعضای شورای اسلامی شهر، بیشترین رتبه را کسب نموده اند. همچنین نتیجه آزمون تی تک نمونه از عملکرد شورای اسلامی ازنظر سیاستگذاری های حوزه شهرسازی و معماری در سطح کمتر از 05/0 اشاره دارد. در حوزه شهرسازی بهترین عملکرد شورای اسلامی مربوط به شاخص مشورت و اعمال نظارت قانونی بر معاونت شهرسازی و واحدهای وابسته به آن با مقدار 803/0 و در حوزه معماری نیز شاخص مشورت و تصویب مقررات و مصوبات حوزه معماری با مقدار 705/3 بوده است.

چکیده انگلیسی:

Councils, as institutions that derive their legitimacy and popularity from the people, can play an important role in urban policy-making through their decisions regarding urban form, especially in the fields of urban planning and architecture. The present study aimed to evaluate the urban policies of the Islamic City Council of Shiraz in the field of urban planning and architecture from the perspective of sustainable development. The research method was descriptive-survey, using a questionnaire tool. The statistical population of this study consisted of managers and heads of various departments of Shiraz municipality (executive experts) and university professors familiar with the research topic (academic experts). The sample size was calculated to be 113 individuals using Morgan's table. The validity and reliability of the questionnaire were confirmed. The study's findings indicated that for evaluating the urban policies of the Islamic Council, the Hagoort and Gunn model (1984) consisting of 5 dimensions of issue identification, policy formulation, decision-making, policy implementation, and policy evaluation can be used. To measure these dimensions, 19 components related to urban policy-making were identified based on the opinions of academic and executive experts in the field of urban planning. The results showed that at a significance level of less than 0.05, the dimensions and components related to urban policy-making were significant. The results also indicated that the status of the dimensions and components of the Islamic Council's urban policies was evaluated as average. The Friedman test results for ranking the dimensions and components of policy-making showed that among the dimensions, issue identification and among the components, the delegation of power and resources to the members of the Islamic Council obtained the highest rank. The results of the one-sample t-test also indicated that the performance of the Islamic Council in terms of urban planning and architecture policies was less than 0.05. In the field of urban planning, the best performance of the Islamic Council pertained to the consultation and legal supervision of the urban planning department and its affiliated units with a score of 0.803, and in the field of architecture, the best performance pertained to consultation and approval of regulations and decisions in the field of architecture with a score of 0.705.Extended AbstractIntroduction:In the current climate of urban expansion and urbanization, the Islamic city councils are important civil governance institutions that are responsible for realizing the rights of citizens in the urban area. The city council as a decision-making institution for urban development is more important today than ever before. The importance of councils in the administration of affairs is so great that in the decentralization system of governments where political and administrative power has been transferred to the provincial, urban, and rural levels, councils have significant importance (Tavakliniya and Noor Mohammadi, 2012). It is said that the main purpose of forming the Islamic City Council is to rapidly advance urban development programs through the cooperation and participation of the people, therefore, in Iran, councils find an existential philosophy as one of the institutions that supervise the performance of the public sector (Pirmozen, 2008). Islamic city councils are defined as the main guide of urban activities to realize the management of the urban unit. Therefore, according to the constitution and the approved law of Islamic councils dated (1375), the main task of urban management is assigned to the Islamic councils of the city, whose representatives are elected by the people (Nowrozi Far, 1380).Therefore, because of the aforementioned contents and the lack of research that evaluates the urban policy of the Islamic City Council from the perspective of sustainable development, and because sustainable development emphasizes qualitative and human criteria more than any other criterion, Therefore, to achieve a real stable situation in cities, it is necessary to develop policies to achieve sustainable cities. Therefore, this research seeks to evaluate the urban policies of the Shiraz Islamic Council (as a study) from the perspective of sustainable development, so that appropriate suggestions can be made from the results of such research to promote urban development.Methodology:This research is applied research in terms of nature and purpose. The descriptive-analytical research method and the research strategy used are quantitative. In this research, an attempt is made to use the positivist method in a theoretical framework and to analyze the research problem by using survey and field methods, considering the application of quantitative problems. The statistical population of the research consists of the managers and supervisors of various departments of Shiraz municipality (executive experts), which according to the available statistics include 138 people, as well as university professors familiar with the subject of the research (academic experts), of which 25 people were identified by the researcher. And as a result, the size of the statistical population reached 163 people. Random sampling method was used for sampling from the mentioned population and Morgan's table was used to determine the sample size, and the results showed that the required sample is 113 people. Also, the data collection tool of this research is a researcher-made questionnaire, the questions of which are designed and developed based on the components proposed in the research model (19 questions) and are used to collect data from the studied community after confirming validity and reliability.Results and discussion:After distributing 113 questionnaires among the members of the studied community, finally, 102 valid questionnaires (90% return rate) were obtained for analysis, and the information description of the received questionnaires showed: in terms of gender, nearly 57% (with a frequency of 58 people) of the answers The research respondents are women and about 43% (with a frequency of 44 people) of the respondents are men. Therefore, most of the research respondents are women. In terms of service history, the findings showed that 4.9% (with a frequency of 5 people) had less than 5 years, 41.1% (with a frequency of 42 people) between 5 and 10 years, 53.9% (with a frequency of 55 people ) have between 10 and 15 years of service experience. Therefore, most of the respondents have between 5 and 15 years of work experience (95%). Regarding the level of education, the results showed that 21.5% (with a frequency of 23 people) had a bachelor's degree and 78.4% (with a frequency of 80 people) had a master's degree or higher. Therefore, the absolute majority of respondents have a master's degree or higher. In terms of the type of employment, the results showed that 53.9% of the respondents have formal employment, 42% have contractual employment and the rest have contractual employment.Also, the result of the T-Tech exam indicates the performance of the Islamic Council in terms of policies in the field of urban planning and architecture at a level of less than 0.05. In the field of urban planning, the best performance of the Islamic Council was related to the index of consulting and exercising legal supervision over the deputy of urban planning and its affiliated units with a value of 0.803, and in the field of architecture, the index of consulting and approving regulations and approvals in the field of architecture was with a value of 3.705.Conclusion:The findings of the research showed that to evaluate the urban policies of the Islamic Council of Shiraz from the perspective of sustainable development, it is possible to use the Hogwood and Gann (1984) stage model consisting of 5 dimensions of problem identification, policy formulation, decision making, policy implementation, and policy evaluation. It was found that 19 components were used to measure the aforementioned dimensions according to the opinion of academic and executive experts in the urban area. Also, the results showed that at a significance level of 5%, 5 dimensions and 19 components related to them cannot be rejected. The ranking of the dimensions and components also indicated that among the dimensions that shape the evaluation of urban policies with emphasis on sustainable development, the highest rank is related to problem diagnosis and among the components that shape the evaluation of urban policies with emphasis on sustainable development, the highest ranks were respectively related to the components of the amount of delegation of power and resources to the members of the Islamic Council of the city and attention to urban diplomacy. The final result indicates the average policy situation of Shiraz Islamic Council. In this context, their policies and performance in the field of urban planning and architecture have also been significant.

منابع و مأخذ:

• Aghaei Heshchin, Manouchehr; Mozaffari, Payman; Moulai Heshchin, Fereshte (2013), investigating the role of Islamic city councils in urban management, a case study of Hashjin city Islamic council during 3 periods, the first specialized congress of urban management and city councils, Sari, Iran Development Conference Center.


• Ahad Nejad, Mohsen, Samia, Alipour, Samia, Mohammadi and Munirah Hosseini (2010). Evaluation of periodic approvals of city councils from the perspective of the council's role in urban management (case study: periodic approvals of Karaj City Council 1389-1990), the first regional conference on architecture and urban planning, Saqqez applied scientific higher education center.


• Amanpour, S; Hosseini Shahparian, N; Atashfroz, N; Farhamand, Gh.(2015) Investigating and analyzing the performance of councils in urban management (case example; Izeh city), Journal Research and Urban Planning, Vol 6, No 22, PP 95-110.


• Asadi, E; mahmoudi pati, F; abaszade soorami, M.(2020) Comparative analysis of city councils's tasks and functions in Iran: Based on findings from case study of Amol city council, Memari-Va-Shahrsazi, 24(3), 31-45.


• Azargun, Nasser; Mansouri, Seyyed Amir; Barati, Nasser, (2017), presenting indicators of measuring and evaluating sustainable urban development in strategic urban development plans (CDS) using the balanced scorecard model, Armanshahr Quarterly, Volume 11, Number 23.


• Beaker, J. and Jahan, F. (2017) Design guidelines for green roofs. Toronto: Environment Canada.


• Beall, J., Guha-Khasnobis, B., & Kanbur, R. (2010). Urbanization and development: multidisciplinary perspectives. Oxford University Press.‏


• Den Uyl, R. M., & Driessen, P. P. (2015). Evaluating governance for sustainable development–Insights from experiences in the Dutch fen landscape. Journal of environmental management, 163, 186-203.


• Fanni, Z; Ghorbani Sepehr,A; Soltan Mohammadi, Z. ()The role of local councils in sustainable development urban (Case Study: Amir Abad neighborhood, Tehran 6th District), Sustainable Development of Geographical Environment, 2(2), 99-117.


• Hall, P., & Pfeiffer, U.(2004), Urban Future 21, Spon Press: London.


• Hataminejad, Hossein and Faraji Melayi, Amin, (2018), Feasibility assessment of the implementation of urban development strategy plans in Iran, Regional studies and researches, second year, number eight, pp. 55-76.


• Hogwood, B, and Gunn, L (1984) Policy Analysis for Real World, Oxford, Oxford University Press.


• Hosseinzadeh Delir, Karim, Ghorbani, Rasul and Shukri Firouzjah, Pari, (2008), qualitative analysis and evaluation of urban sustainability metrics in Tabriz city, urban and regional studies and researches, 1(2), 1-18.


• Hutchison, R. (2010). Chicago school of urban sociology. Encyclopedia of urban studies, 127-131.


• Jabareen, Y.R., (2006). Sustainable Urban Form: Their Typologies, Models and concepts. Jurnal of planning Education and Research. No. 26, pp: 38-47.


• Jalili Qasim Agha, Amid, (2017), Policy Making: Concepts, Patterns and Processes, New Research Approaches in Management and Accounting, No. 4, Bahar.


• jamali haji hassan sofla, E; Nematollahi Bonab, S.(2021). Investigating and evaluating the role of citizens and their social participation in achieving sustainable urban development goals(case study: Tabriz city), Urban Environmental Policy, Vol 1, No 1, 95-112.


• Javadi, S., Amirkhani, A. (2022). Investigating the effective factors in urban development on urban management, case study: Qiyadasht municipality, the first conference on civil engineering, urban planning, architecture and environment, Tehran.


• Kazemian, G; Mirabedini, Z.(2011): Pathology of Integrated Urban Management for Tehran in view of Policy and Decision Making, Honar_ha-Ye- Ziba, 3(46), 27- 38.


• Kostka, G. (2014). Barriers to the implementation of environmental policies at the local level in China, s.l.: World Bank.


• Mahkouii, H; Bavir H. (2021): Urban Development with an Approach to the Role of Local Government in Iran, Journal of Urban Environmental Policy, Vol 1, No 1, PP 17- 26.


• Maleki, Saeed; Daman Bagh, Safia, (2012), evaluation of sustainable urban development indicators with emphasis on social, physical and urban service indicators, Urban Planning Studies Quarterly, 1(3), 29-54.


• Masnavi, Mohammadreza, (2012), a research on sustainable development and new paradigms of urban development, Environment, No. 21, 98-112.


• Moslami Mohni, Yusef, (2017), Urban policy making in Iran: presenting a practical model, Politics Quarterly, 48(1), 163-173.


• Mousaviyan, M. (2010), Principles and foundations in architecture and urban planning ,Azarakhsh. 75-78.


• Nasiri, Y; Bahraini, S H;  Daudpour, Z. (2021), Evaluation of the role and position of the Islamic Council of Cities in the urban planning system of Iran, New a theorys in human geography, 13(2), 890-909.


• Pirmouzhen, Kamaluddin, (2012), the ambiguous position of councils in urban management, Municipalities Monthly No. 38, 39-40.


• Pishgahi Fard, Zahra and Mehsa Vaezi, (2013), Challenges of the City Council in Tehran's Urban Management, 7th Congress of the Geopolitical Association of Iran (Political Geography of the City), Tehran, Geopolitical Association of Iran, Khwarazmi University.


• Pourramzan, E; Nabi Bidhandi, GH; Givehchi,S; Nami, M H.(2017) Examining the role of urban management components in the physical expansion of the city A case study of region 5 of Tehran, Geography (Regional Planing), 8(4), 427-434.


• Rabbani, Taha; Aftekhari, Abdolreza Ruknuddin; Mishkini, Abolfazl; Rafiyan, Mojtabi, (2017), Analysis of the future institutional obstacles of the sustainable development of Tehran metropolis, Spatial Planning and Design Quarterly, 22(1), 124-153.


• Rakhshaninasab, H R; karimi, T.(2020) Evaluating of the degree of citizens' satisfaction of the urban Islamic councils (Case study: Jiroft), Geography Environment Preparation, 12(47), 1-22.


• Saeedi nia. (2002), Urban Management, Publications of the Organization of Municipalities, Tehran, Vol 11, pp 15.


• Salari, Mohammad, (2016), the city's Islamic Council and its role in promoting citizens' rights, Geography Quarterly (Regional Planning), Volume 26, Number 1, pp. 287-305.


• Shamai, Ali; Abdolahi, Awat; Yusuf Feshki, Mohsen, (2014), an analysis on the development planning of Sardasht city with the approach of urban development strategy, Geographical Perspective in Human Studies, 9(27), 35-51.


• Solecki, W., Seto, K. C., & Marcotullio, P. J. (2013). It's time for an urbanization science. Environment: science and policy for sustainable development, 55(1), 12-17.‏


• Tavakolinia, Jamila; Noormohammadi, Mehdi, (2013), an attitude on the performance of city council in urban management, Municipalities Quarterly, 9(92): 72-78.


• Van Zeijl-Rozema, A., Cörvers, R., Kemp, R., & Martens, P. (2008). Governance for sustainable development: a framework. Sustainable Development, 16(6), 410-421.


• Walsh, Cormac (2010). "Strategic Spatial Planning at the Regional and Local Scales: A Case Study of the Dublin City-Region", 1(2), pp 20-21.


• Zaręba, A., Krzemińska, A., Kozik, R., Adynkiewicz-Piragas, M., & Kristiánová, K. (2022). Passive and Active Solar Systems in Eco-Architecture and Eco-Urban Planning. Applied Sciences, 12(6), 29-42.