Comparative Study of the Concept of Justice in the Contemporary Political Philosophy of Islam and the West (With emphasis on Michael Sandel's votes)

Subject Areas : علوم سیاسی

Niloofar Chinichian ¹ , Malek Yahiya Salahi ² , Sadegh Zibakalam ³ , Abolghasem Taheri ⁴

1 -
2 -
3 -
4 -

Received: 2016-11-10 Accepted : 2017-07-12 Published : 2017-09-01

Keywords: Islam, justice, Constitutionalism, Priority to goodness,

Abstract :

The idea of Communitarianism with epistemic teachings, such as politics as virtue, the priority of good faith, respect for the cultural diversity of societies, is one of the most prominent intellectual currents of the present age. The hypothesis of this research is that based on the comparative analytical attitude of key societal teachings and the epistemic principles of Islam, one can find common ground in order to achieve another understanding of the challenging issues, especially the category of justice. The purpose of this study is to develop such a discourse to understand another and to live human beings in the field of opinion and practice. This research is a descriptive-analytic method based on the hermeneutic Quinton Skinner (text authoring). Many Islamic thinkers, especially Muslim ones, with regard to the great efficiency in understanding and interpreting texts, consider hermeneutic method. Nasr Hamed Abu Zayd, Mohammad MojtahedShabestari, Fazl-Rahman, and Argon are among the Muslim thinkers who based on hermeneutical knowledge of topics such as history, interpretation and understanding of religious texts, the interpreter's mentality, religious experience, the unlimited sense of meaning, and the lack of a single reading in the texts. They ask.

References:

A group of translators, (2007), socialists and liberalism, Qom, pajoheshgahOlomvaFarhangEslami Publication.

Abdollahi, Ali, (2012), Epicurean, Tehran, Mosque Publication

Abdurrahman, (2010), History of Western Political Philosophy, Tehran, DaftareSiyasivabeynolmelali.

Ahmadi, Babak, (1998), Modernity and Critical Thinking, Tehran, Markaz Publication.

Alem, Abdurrahman, (2010), History of Western Political Philosophy, Tehran, DaftareSiyasivabeynolmelale.

Alikhani, Ali Akbar et al. (2011), Political Thoughts of Muslim thinkers Tehran, PajuheshkadehMotale Tehran ate FarhangivaEjtemai Publication and Social Studies,

Alikhani, Ali Akbar, (2009), Investigating the political system of justice in Islam, Tehran, PajuheshkadehMotaleateFarhangivaEjtemai Publication

Aristotle, (1999), Nicomakhose Ethics, Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Tehran, Tarhe no Publication

Aristotle, (2011), Politics, Hamid Enayat, Tehran, Amir Kabir Publication

Babaei, Parviz, (2007), Philosophical Schools from Ancient to Today, Tehran Negah publication

Bashiriyeh, Hussein, (2003), Reason in Politics, Tehran, NegaheMoaser Publication

Beheshti, SeyedAlireza, (2016), Theoretical Foundetions of Politics in Multicultural Societies, Tehran, Nahid   Publication,

Beheshti, Seyyed Mohammad Hussein,( 1981 ), Review and analysis of Jihad, Justice, Liberalism and Imamate, Tehran, MarasemBargozariHaftomTir Publication.

             

28

Bloom, William, T, (1994) Theories of the Political System, Ahmad Tadaun, Tehran, Aran publication

 

 Crowe, Richard, (2015), Aristotle's Ethics, Maryam Khodadadi, Tehran, Ghoghnoos Publication

Durant, Will, (1993),  the history of civilization, Ahmad Aram .., Tehran ,Amir Kabir Publication

Enayat, Hamid, (2002), Foundation for Political Philosophy in the West, Tehran, Zemestan publication 

Faster, Michael, (1991), The Lord of Political Thought, Tehran, Amir Kabir Publication

Feirahi, Davood, (2015), AndishehEslah January, January, No. 4,

 Foolish Medina, Journal of Philosophy History,Year 5, No

Goldman, Lucien, (2006), Philosophy of Enlightenment, Shiva Kaviani, Tehran, Akhtaran Publication

Guy, Mary,(2012), Citizen in the History of Western Thought, Abbas Bagheri, Tehran, Fusan Publication

Habermas, J. C.Taylor, (2013), Multiculturalism, SaeedRezvani, Tehran, Rokhdad No Publication

Haghighat, Sadegh,Theorizing in Islam,WWW.fahimco.com:2017

Hajizadeh, Parviz, KalabasiAshtari Hussein, (2014), The Place of Justice in Plato's Utopia and Farabi's

J.L. Garcia,(2008), Modern Philosophy of Ethics and Macintyre Critique, RoohollahRamezani, Tehran, Tarjoman publication

Jones, etc, (1991), The People of Political Thought, Ali Ramin, Tehran Amir Kabir publication 

Khandozi, SeyyedEhsan, (2011), Reflections and Theories of Economic Justice in the Twentieth Century, MajlesVaRahbord Journal, No. 68

Legghozen, Mohammad,(2005), A critique of the ethics of originality, Mansour Nasiri, S Rahbord,     No. 35

Locke, John, (2008), a Treatise on the Rule, Hamid Azadanloo, Tehran, Ney Publication

Mohammad bin Ali al-Saduq, (1994), Ayoun al-Reza is, AliakbarGhafari , Tehran. Sadooq Publication

Mohammadi, Seyyed Ali, (1998), Freedom Theory in Political Philosophy of Hobbes and Locke, Tehran, PajoheshgaholomeEnsanivaMotaleateFarhangi Publication

Motahari, Morteza, (1995), Society and History, Vol. 5, Tehran, Sadra Publications

Motahari, Morteza, (2015), Man of Time needs, Vol. 1, Tehran, Sadra Publication

Nahj al-Balagheh

NejatiHosseini, Seyyed Mahmoud, (2009), Encyclopedia Danes name OlomEjtemai, Period 1, Number 1

 P00ladi, Kamal, (2013), to the head of Political Thought in the West from Socrates to Machiavelli, Tehran, Markaz Publishing

Price, Jones, (2012), Understanding the Philosophy of Thought in Ancient Times and Greek Period Mabbis, Reza Ali zadeh, Tehran, Rozaneh Publication.

Quran Karim

Rahman, fazlu, (1965), Islamic Methodology in History, Karachi: Central Institute for Islamic Research

 Rawls, John, (1993a), the Law of Peoples", Critical Inquiry, Vol. 20, No. 1.

Sahifeh Light, Vol. 6, Tehran, TanzimvaNashreAsare Imam Khomeini publication

Sahifeh-ye Imam, Vol 13, Tehran, TanzimvaNashreAsare Imam Khomeini publication

Sahifeh-ye Imam, Vol 21, Tehran, TanzimvaNashreAsare Imam Khomeini publication

Sandel, Michael, (2014), what cannot be bought with money, Hassan Afshar, Tehran, Markaz publication

Sandel, Michael, (2015), Liberalism and Its Limitations, Hassan Afshar, Tehran, Markaz publication

Sandel, Michael, a (2014), Justice - What is the right one? , Hassan Afshar, Tehran, Markaz publication

Sandel, Michel, (2004), The Case Against perfection, Harvard University press

Shariat, Farshad, (2010), Justice and Politics, Tehran, Imam Sadiq University publication

             

29

Shariati Ali, (1983), Collection of Works 26, Tehran, Niloofar Publication

 

Tak, Richard, (1997), Hobbes, HosseinBashiri
yeh, Tehran, Tarhe no Publication

Taylor, Charles, (2007), a Secular Age, Cambridge Belnap Press of Harvard University

Taylor, Charles, (2014), The Excellency of Life in the Secular Age, FarhangRajaee, , Tehran, Agah publication

Townshend, Jules, (2011), New Interpretations on Modern Philosophers, KhashayarDeihimi, Tehran, Ney publication

Vaezi, Ahmad, (2009), Review the Theory of Justice, Qom, MoaseseAmouzeshivapajouhesheyi Imam Khomeini Publication

Walzer, Michael, (1990), Socialist critique of liberalism, Ali AbediRenani, Tehran, Tarjoman Publication

Walzer, Michael, (2010), Areas of Justice, SalehNajafi, Tehran, Sales Publication