Human Behaviors against COVID-19: A game theory approach and a case study of Iran
Subject Areas :
Mansour Abedian
1
*
,
Maryam Hejazi
2
,
Sayyed Mohammad Reza Davoodi
3
1 - Department of Management, Financial Position, Najafabad Branch, Islamic Azad University , Najafabad, Iran
2 - Department of Industrial Engineering, Najafabad Branch, Islamic Azad University, Najafabad, Iran
3 - Associate Professor, Department of Management, Dehaghan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Dehaghan, Iran
Keywords: COVID-19, Quarantine, Social-distancing, mask, Human behavior, Game theory,
Abstract :
Human choices and prevention and control measures during the outbreaks of infectious diseases play an important role in mitigating the spread and burden of the diseases and the negative impact of such phenomenon on societies. In this study, we developed a static game theoretical approach to assess the impact of human responses to the personal protection strategies of vaccination, self-quarantine, wearing face masks and social distancing on the evolution of the COVID-19 pandemic burden. The model was set up such that an individual can choose multiple strategies to strike a balance between reducing the burden of the pandemic and not overrunning down their economies. A kind of static game analytics approach has been developed for this issue, and the proposed model has been implemented to design optimal intervention strategies for a sample of Iranian people in two critical phases in a serious battle against the COVID-19 pandemic. The results revealed that social distancing of exposed, susceptible, and recovered humans, self-quarantine of susceptible and infectious humans, and vaccination of exposed and recovered humans were more effective in mitigating the burden of the COVID-19 pandemic and limiting the transmission rate.
References
Bacharach, Michael. 2019. Economics and the Theory of Games. CRC Press.
Bazerman, Max H., Jared R. Curhan, Don A. Moore, and Kathleen L. Valley. 2000. “Negotiation.” Annual Review of Psychology 51(1):279–314.
Beutels, Philippe, Na Jia, Qing‐Yi Zhou, Richard Smith, Wu‐Chun Cao, and Sake J. De Vlas. 2009. “The Economic Impact of SARS in Beijing, China.” Tropical Medicine & International Health 14:85–91.
Byun, Hong-Seok and Seok-Hee Lee. 2017. “Design of a Piston Forging Process Using a Hybrid Taguchi Method and Multiple Criteria Decision-Making.” Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology 31(4):1869–76.
Chang, Hua-Cheng and Hung-Yuan Chen. 2014. “Optimizing Product Form Attractiveness Using Taguchi Method and TOPSIS Algorithm: A Case Study Involving a Passenger Car.” Concurrent Engineering 22(2):135–47.
Chang, Sheryl L., Nathan Harding, Cameron Zachreson, Oliver M. Cliff, and Mikhail Prokopenko. 2020. “Modelling Transmission and Control of the COVID-19 Pandemic in Australia.” Nature Communications 11(1):1–13.
Choi, Wongyeong and Eunha Shim. 2020. “Optimal Strategies for Vaccination and Social Distancing in a Game-Theoretic Epidemiologic Model.” Journal of Theoretical Biology 505:110422.
d’Onofrio, Alberto and Piero Manfredi. 2020. “The Interplay between Voluntary Vaccination and Reduction of Risky Behavior: A General Behavior-Implicit SIR Model for Vaccine Preventable Infections.” Pp. 185–203 in Current Trends in Dynamical Systems in Biology and Natural Sciences. Springer.
Dickens, Borame L., Joel R. Koo, Annelies Wilder-Smith, and Alex R. Cook. 2020. “Institutional, Not Home-Based, Isolation Could Contain the COVID-19 Outbreak.” The Lancet 395(10236):1541–42.
Dong, Ensheng, Hongru Du, and Lauren Gardner. 2020. “An Interactive Web-Based Dashboard to Track COVID-19 in Real Time.” The Lancet Infectious Diseases 20(5):533–34.
Eskafi, S., Emad Roghanian, and Meisam Jafari-Eskandari. 2015. “Designing a Performance Measurement System for Supply Chain Using Balanced Scorecard, Path Analysis, Cooperative Game Theory and Evolutionary Game Theory: A Case Study.” International Journal of Industrial Engineering Computations 6(2):157–72.
Ferguson, Neil, Daniel Laydon, Gemma Nedjati Gilani, Natsuko Imai, Kylie Ainslie, Marc Baguelin, Sangeeta Bhatia, Adhiratha Boonyasiri, ZULMA Cucunuba Perez, and Gina Cuomo-Dannenburg. 2020. “Report 9: Impact of Non-Pharmaceutical Interventions (NPIs) to Reduce COVID19 Mortality and Healthcare Demand.”
Flaxman, Seth, Swapnil Mishra, Axel Gandy, H. Juliette T. Unwin, Helen Coupland, Thomas A. Mellan, Harrison Zhu, Tresnia Berah, Jeffrey W. Eaton, and Pablo N. P. Guzman. 2020. “Estimating the Number of Infections and the Impact of Non-Pharmaceutical Interventions on COVID-19 in European Countries: Technical Description Update.” ArXiv Preprint ArXiv:2004.11342.
Froschauer, Josef, Max Arends, Doron Goldfarb, and Dieter Merkl. 2012. “A Serious Heritage Game for Art History: Design and Evaluation of ThIATRO.” Pp. 283–90 in 2012 18th International Conference on Virtual Systems and Multimedia. IEEE.
Funk, Sebastian, Marcel Salathé, and Vincent A. A. Jansen. 2010. “Modelling the Influence of Human Behaviour on the Spread of Infectious Diseases: A Review.” Journal of the Royal Society Interface 7(50):1247–56.
Gianchandani, Neha, Aayush Jaiswal, Dilbag Singh, Vijay Kumar, and Manjit Kaur. 2020. “Rapid COVID-19 Diagnosis Using Ensemble Deep Transfer Learning Models from Chest Radiographic Images.” Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing 1–13.
Gibbons, Robert S. 1992. Game Theory for Applied Economists. Princeton University Press.
Gumel, Abba B., Enahoro A. Iboi, Calistus N. Ngonghala, and Elamin H. Elbasha. 2021. “A Primer on Using Mathematics to Understand COVID-19 Dynamics: Modeling, Analysis and Simulations.” Infectious Disease Modelling 6:148–68.
Harsanyi, John C. 1982. “Solutions for Some Bargaining Games under the Harsanyi-Selten Solution Theory, Part II: Analysis of Specific Bargaining Games.” Mathematical Social Sciences 3(3):259–79.
Hellewell, Joel, Sam Abbott, Amy Gimma, Nikos I. Bosse, Christopher I. Jarvis, Timothy W. Russell, James D. Munday, Adam J. Kucharski, W. John Edmunds, and Fiona Sun. 2020. “Feasibility of Controlling COVID-19 Outbreaks by Isolation of Cases and Contacts.” The Lancet Global Health 8(4):e488–96.
Ho, Li-Hsing, Shu-Yun Feng, and Tieh-Min Yen. 2014. “A New Methodology for Customer Satisfaction Analysis: Taguchi’s Signal-to-Noise Ratio Approach.” Journal of Service Science and Management 2014.
Iboi, Enahoro A., Oluwaseun O. Sharomi, Calistus N. Ngonghala, and Abba B. Gumel. 2020. “Mathematical Modeling and Analysis of COVID-19 Pandemic in Nigeria.” MedRxiv.
Ivanov, Dmitry. 2020. “Predicting the Impacts of Epidemic Outbreaks on Global Supply Chains: A Simulation-Based Analysis on the Coronavirus Outbreak (COVID-19/SARS-CoV-2) Case.” Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review 136:101922.
Jones, James Holland and Marcel Salathe. 2009. “Early Assessment of Anxiety and Behavioral Response to Novel Swine-Origin Influenza A (H1N1).” PLoS One 4(12):e8032.
Kabir, K. M. Ariful and Jun Tanimoto. 2020. “Evolutionary Game Theory Modelling to Represent the Behavioural Dynamics of Economic Shutdowns and Shield Immunity in the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Royal Society Open Science 7(9):201095.
Kumar, N., M. Gupta, D. Gupta, and S. Tiwari. 2021. “Novel Deep Transfer Learning Model for COVID-19 Patient Detection Using X-Ray Chest Images.” Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing 1–10.
Laraki, Rida, Jérôme Renault, and Sylvain Sorin. 2019. Mathematical Foundations of Game Theory. Springer.
Lau, Susanna K. P., Patrick C. Y. Woo, Ami M. Y. Fung, King-man Chan, Gibson K. S. Woo, and Kwok-yung Yuen. 2004. “Anaerobic, Non-Sporulating, Gram-Positive Bacilli Bacteraemia Characterized by 16S RRNA Gene Sequencing.” Journal of Medical Microbiology 53(12):1247–53.
Lucas, William F. 1972. “An Overview of the Mathematical Theory of Games.” Management Science 18(5-part-2):3–19.
Manfredi, Simone and Thomas H. Christensen. 2009. “Environmental Assessment of Solid Waste Landfilling Technologies by Means of LCA-Modeling.” Waste Management 29(1):32–43.
Mansour, Nehal A., Ahmed I. Saleh, Mahmoud Badawy, and Hesham A. Ali. 2021. “Accurate Detection of Covid-19 Patients Based on Feature Correlated Naïve Bayes (FCNB) Classification Strategy.” Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing 1–33.
Martonosi, Susan E., Banafsheh Behzad, and Kayla Cummings. 2021. “Pricing the COVID-19 Vaccine: A Mathematical Approach.” Omega 102451.
Mehrotra, Ateev, Kristin Ray, Diane M. Brockmeyer, Michael L. Barnett, and Jessica Anne Bender. 2020. “Rapidly Converting to ‘Virtual Practices’: Outpatient Care in the Era of Covid-19.” NEJM Catalyst Innovations in Care Delivery 1(2).
Montgomery, Douglas C. 2017. Design and Analysis of Experiments. John wiley & sons.
Murnighan, J. Keith. 2015. “Attitudinal Structuring and Game Theory.” Negot. J. 31:361.
Murugan, R. and Tripti Goel. 2021. “E-DiCoNet: Extreme Learning Machine Based Classifier for Diagnosis of COVID-19 Using Deep Convolutional Network.” Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing 1–12.
Nagurney, Anna, Mojtaba Salarpour, June Dong, and Pritha Dutta. 2021. “Competition for Medical Supplies under Stochastic Demand in the Covid-19 Pandemic: A Generalized Nash Equilibrium Framework.” Nonlinear Analysis and Global Optimization 331–56.
Naini, Seyed Gholamreza Jalali, Ali Reza Aliahmadi, and Meisam Jafari-Eskandari. 2011. “Designing a Mixed Performance Measurement System for Environmental Supply Chain Management Using Evolutionary Game Theory and Balanced Scorecard: A Case Study of an Auto Industry Supply Chain.” Resources, Conservation and Recycling 55(6):593–603.
Nash, John. 1951. “Non-Cooperative Games.” Annals of Mathematics 286–95.
Neslin, Scott A. and Leonard Greenhalgh. 1983. “Nash’s Theory of Cooperative Games as a Predictor of the Outcomes of Buyer-Seller Negotiations: An Experiment in Media Purchasing.” Journal of Marketing Research 20(4):368–79.
Von Neumann, John and Osker Morgenstern. 1944. “Theory of Games and Economic Behavior, Princeton, 1944.” On Decision-Making under Uncertainty 285.
Ngonghala, Calistus N., Palak Goel, Daniel Kutor, and Samit Bhattacharyya. 2021. “Human Choice to Self-Isolate in the Face of the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Game Dynamic Modelling Approach.” Journal of Theoretical Biology 521:110692.
Ngonghala, Calistus N., Enahoro Iboi, Steffen Eikenberry, Matthew Scotch, Chandini Raina MacIntyre, Matthew H. Bonds, and Abba B. Gumel. 2020. “Mathematical Assessment of the Impact of Non-Pharmaceutical Interventions on Curtailing the 2019 Novel Coronavirus.” Mathematical Biosciences 325:108364.
Omrani, Hashem, Arash Alizadeh, and Ali Emrouznejad. 2018. “Finding the Optimal Combination of Power Plants Alternatives: A Multi Response Taguchi-Neural Network Using TOPSIS and Fuzzy Best-Worst Method.” Journal of Cleaner Production 203:210–23.
Onofrio, Roberto. 2016. “Physics of Our Days: Cooling and Thermometry of Atomic Fermi Gases.” Physics-Uspekhi 59(11):1129.
Pandey, Rupesh Kumar and S. S. Panda. 2015. “Multi-Performance Optimization of Bone Drilling Using Taguchi Method Based on Membership Function.” Measurement 59:9–13.
Rosenstrom, Erik, Buse Oruc Aglar, Julie S. Ivy, Pinar Keskinocak, Maria Mayorga, and Julie L. Swann. 2020. “High-Quality Masks Can Reduce Infections and Deaths in the US.” MedRxiv.
Rubin, Claire B. 2009. “Long Term Recovery from Disasters--The Neglected Component of Emergency Management.” Journal of Homeland Security and Emergency Management 6(1).
Saad, Waleed, Wafaa A. Shalaby, Mona Shokair, Fathi Abd El-Samie, Moawad Dessouky, and Essam Abdellatef. 2021. “COVID-19 Classification Using Deep Feature Concatenation Technique.” Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing 1–19.
Sharma, Mahak and Rajat Sehrawat. 2020. “Quantifying SWOT Analysis for Cloud Adoption Using FAHP-DEMATEL Approach: Evidence from the Manufacturing Sector.” Journal of Enterprise Information Management.
Shim, Eunha, Amna Tariq, Wongyeong Choi, Yiseul Lee, and Gerardo Chowell. 2020. “Transmission Potential and Severity of COVID-19 in South Korea.” International Journal of Infectious Diseases 93:339–44.
Shojaei, Payam, Seyed Amin Seyed Haeri, and Sahar Mohammadi. 2018. “Airports Evaluation and Ranking Model Using Taguchi Loss Function, Best-Worst Method and VIKOR Technique.” Journal of Air Transport Management 68:4–13.
Singh, Manjari. 2020. “Jordan after COVID-19: From Crisis Adjustment to Crisis Management.” The Washington Institute. April 15.
Sohrabi, Mohammad Karim and Hossein Azgomi. 2020. “A Survey on the Combined Use of Optimization Methods and Game Theory.” Archives of Computational Methods in Engineering 27(1):59–80.
Sutono, Sugoro Bhakti, Salwa Hanim Abdul-Rashid, Hideki Aoyama, and Zahari Taha. 2016. “Fuzzy-Based Taguchi Method for Multi-Response Optimization of Product Form Design in Kansei Engineering: A Case Study on Car Form Design.” Journal of Advanced Mechanical Design, Systems, and Manufacturing 10(9):JAMDSM0108–JAMDSM0108.
Tang, Miao, Tie-Dan Wang, and Ding-Hong Peng. 2020. “An Improved Taguchi Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Method Based on the Hesitant Fuzzy Correlation Coefficient and Its Application in Quality Evaluation.” Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing 1–14.
Torres, Javier A. Sánchez, Julián A. Rivera González, and Lambert de Maestrich Jorba. 2018. “What Kind of E-Mail Information Is More Effective in Communicating with the Client? Application of Game Theory.” Harvard Deusto Business Research 7(1):2–18.
Tuite, Ashleigh R., Isaac I. Bogoch, Ryan Sherbo, Alexander Watts, David Fisman, and Kamran Khan. 2020. “Estimation of Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) Burden and Potential for International Dissemination of Infection from Iran.” Annals of Internal Medicine 172(10):699–701.
Wang, Quan, Zhen Wang, Mukesh Kumar Awasthi, Yahui Jiang, Ronghua Li, Xiuna Ren, Junchao Zhao, Feng Shen, Meijing Wang, and Zengqiang Zhang. 2016. “Evaluation of Medical Stone Amendment for the Reduction of Nitrogen Loss and Bioavailability of Heavy Metals during Pig Manure Composting.” Bioresource Technology 220:297–304.
Yang, Taho, Yuan-Feng Wen, and Fang-Fang Wang. 2011. “Evaluation of Robustness of Supply Chain Information-Sharing Strategies Using a Hybrid Taguchi and Multiple Criteria Decision-Making Method.” International Journal of Production Economics 134(2):458–66.